mybest
Cleansing Balms

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Beauty
  3. Cleansers
  4. 11 Best Cleansing Balms of 2024 [Tested and Reviewed]
11 Best Cleansing Balms of 2024 [Tested and Reviewed]

11 Best Cleansing Balms of 2024 [Tested and Reviewed]

Looking for a cleansing balm that offers a rich texture and a moisturizing finish? The skin-loving feel is a huge plus, but one of the biggest benefits is how effortlessly they remove makeup. However, choosing the right cleansing balm can be a struggle. With both classics like Clinique and trending Korean brands like Banila Co on the market, it's easy to wonder which will remove makeup most efficiently or leave your skin feeling hydrated.

We've compared 11 bestselling Cleansing Balms available online and put them to the test to recommend the best one for you.


We tested each product for the following:

  • Ease of Removal
  • Non-Tightening After Washing
  • Non-Sticky Finish
  • Texture


Which product ended up being the best of the best? We'll also tell you how to pick the best Cleansing Balms on your own in our buying guide, so read on for more shopping tips.

Last updated 03/05/2024
Natalie Cox
Expert
Cosmetic Chemist
Natalie Cox

Natalie Cox is a chemical engineer turned cosmetic chemist. Natalie has an expansive technical background in skin care, hair care, and personal care product formulation. Her curiosity and passion for creating products have also given her numerous opportunities to work with color cosmetics, pet care, and oral care products as a creative and research outlet. Natalie is exceptionally passionate about technical education and demystifying the personal care industry for brands, customers, and industry professionals alike.

Natalie Cox's Profile
…Continue reading
Yuri Hiraiwa
Guide
Head of Cosmetics and Beauty at mybest
Yuri Hiraiwa

She joined a Japanese beauty company as a new graduate and worked there for three and a half years. She counseled over 6,000 people annually and created personalized beauty regimens for each customer. She then joined mybest, where she has written articles covering everything from makeup to skincare. She is a cosmetics concierge, a specialist in cosmetic ingredients, and a certified image consultant.

Yuri Hiraiwa's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

Scroll to testing method
We gathered the 11 bestselling Cleansing Balms and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Effectiveness in Removing Makeup

    1
    Effectiveness in Removing Makeup

    First, we evaluated the most crucial aspect of a cleansing balm: how well it removes makeup.We applied makeup products to synthetic skin and used the cleansing balm to remove them. We measured the time it took for each makeup item to be completely removed and rated the speed on a scale of one to seven.Cosmetics Tested:Liquid FoundationLiquid ConcealerEyeshadow PencilWaterproof MascaraWaterproof EyelinerEyebrow PencilTest Conditions:1. Apply an appropriate amount of each item to artificial skin.2. Leave it on for three hours.3. Blend in the cleansing balm and rinse it off.

  2. Lack of Tightness After Washing

    2
    Lack of Tightness After Washing

    One of the strengths of cleansing balm is its ability to leave the skin feeling comfortable rather than taut after rinsing. For this test, five panelists used each product on their own skin and evaluated the following points on a scale of one to seven.Evaluation Points:Whether the skin feels dry immediately after rinsing with a strong desire to apply lotion right awayWhether there's a feeling of skin tightness or a taut sensation when touched

  3. Absence of Slipperiness After Washing

    3
    Absence of Slipperiness After Washing

    Even if the skin feels moisturized after washing, a slimy or sticky sensation can be uncomfortable. Our five testers used and evaluated each product based on the following points, rating them on a scale of one to seven.Evaluation Criteria:Whether rinsing off once felt insufficient Whether there was any stickiness left on the skin

  4. Texture

    4
    Texture

    Evaluation of Texture:The texture is crucial for continued comfortable use. Our five testers used and evaluated each product based on the following points, rating them on a scale of one to seven.Evaluation Criteria:Resistance to clumping when warmed in the handQuick transformation into a smooth texture when spreadEase of blending with makeup

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The products listed here are not guaranteed to have the effects or benefits described in the guide. Before making a purchase, be sure to assess the details and product descriptions of each item. 
The term "penetration" in this article refers to the penetration into the stratum corneum, the outermost layer of the skin.


The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

Benefits of Using Cleansing Balm and Ideal Users

Cleansing Balms Reduce Skin Irritation While Effortlessly Removing Makeup

Cleansing Balms Reduce Skin Irritation While Effortlessly Removing Makeup

One of the biggest perks of using a cleansing balm is its excellent makeup-removing abilities. Unlike micellar water, cleansing balms are rich in oils, making them especially good at breaking down the oils in makeup.


Additionally, the oil content helps preserve moisture, so your skin feels hydrated and less tight after rinsing. If you tend to experience dryness after using a cleanser, you should give balms a try. You'll be pleasantly surprised by how moisturized your skin feels afterward.


Moreover, the thick, creamy texture allows for gentle cleansing without excessive scrubbing, making it less likely to irritate your skin. This is why they're a great choice if you have sensitive skin or you're going through a phase of irritation.

Yuri Hiraiwa
Head of Cosmetics and Beauty at mybest
Yuri Hiraiwa

One downside is that you'll usually need to use a spatula to get the product out. While you can scoop it out directly with your fingers, a spatula is much more hygienic.

Perfect for Those With Dry Skin Who Wear Heavy Makeup

Perfect for Those With Dry Skin Who Wear Heavy Makeup

So, who should be using cleansing balm? Simply put, they're perfect for those with dry skin who wear heavy makeup.


As mentioned before, the main perks of using a cleansing balm are its effective makeup removal, moisturizing finish, and rich texture.


Those who often sport bold, party makeup or have to wear a full face of makeup every day for work (like flight attendants) will know that traditional water-based cleansers take a while to get the job done. A cleansing balm, however, quickly dissolves makeup and speeds up the process.


They're also a great option for those who struggle with skin tightness after washing or who simply enjoy a luxurious texture during their cleansing routine.

The Importance of Effective Cleansing in Skincare

The Importance of Effective Cleansing in Skincare

Many of us prioritize products like toners or emulsions to hydrate and balance our skin, but did you know that the cleansing step is just as crucial?


In daily life, not only makeup but also dust, bacteria, and sebum from your pores build up on your skin. If these aren't thoroughly washed away, even high-quality lotions and serums won't penetrate the skin well. Accumulated grime could also cause pimples or skin irritation.


If you're dealing with skin issues, focus on thoroughly removing impurities with your cleanser before investing in expensive toners or serums.

How to Choose a Cleansing Balm - Buying Guide

When choosing a cleansing balm, consider factors such as the cleansing power, consistency, and ingredients. Take a look at our buying guide for more details! 

1

Select Products That Remove Foundation or Heavy Eye Makeup As Needed

While cleansing balms tend to be more effective at removing makeup than water-based cleansers, their efficacy varies by product. To make sure you pick the right match for the makeup you wear, refer to the following sections.

Two Balms Stood Out for Effectively Removing Full Makeup

Two Balms Stood Out for Effectively Removing Full Makeup

At mybest, we purchased and tested several products to see how well they removed makeup. Only two products performed above average in terms of makeup removal speed.


Although no product completely removed liquid eyeliner, there was a significant difference in performance among the rest.


In particular, CeraVe's Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm and Glow Recipe's Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm stood out. They quickly bonded with foundation and concealer, setting them apart from the competition.


If you wear full makeup daily or often go for heavier makeup looks, these balms are highly recommended.

Options for Those Who Wear Light Eye Makeup With a Heavier Base

Options for Those Who Wear Light Eye Makeup With a Heavier Base

Although there's inconsistency in how well they remove eye makeup like eyeshadow and mascara, these two products quickly eliminated foundation.


For those who don't wear much eye makeup but apply a thick layer of foundation to cover skin imperfections, we highly recommend Naturium's Purple Ginseng Cleansing Balm and Yadah's Green Tea Pure Cleansing Balm 1.

Considerations for Those Focusing on Point Makeup With a Light Base

Considerations for Those Focusing on Point Makeup With a Light Base

Although our testers struggled to remove foundation and concealer with these two products, they swiftly took off eye makeup like eyeshadow and mascara.


If you prefer a lighter base to reduce skin stress but go all out with your eye makeup, these are the products for you.

2

Recommended Non-Tightening Products for Dry Skin

Broadening Options When Emphasizing Moisturization Over Makeup Removal

Broadening Options When Emphasizing Moisturization Over Makeup Removal

If you prioritize a moisturizing feel over makeup removal, you have a much wider selection of cleansing balms to choose from.


Cleansing balms typically leave your skin feeling less tight after washing. If you have dry skin and want a moisturizing finish, Physicians Formula The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm or Estee Lauder's Advanced Night Cleansing Balm are great options.


Ingredients with a higher oil content help retain moisture, so your skin is more likely to feel hydrated after rinsing off.

3

Choosing Based on Surfactant Types for a Fresh Finish

Over-Cleansing to Remove Residue Can Lead to Dry Skin

Over-Cleansing to Remove Residue Can Lead to Dry Skin

Ever felt that slippery sensation after rinsing and been tempted to wash again? Be careful as you might be washing away essential skin oils. Stripping your skin of its natural oils can make it prone to dryness.


Given that cleansing balms are oil-based, you might worry that they'll leave behind a greasy residue, especially when compared to water-based cleansers. Fortunately, our tests discovered several products that offer a surprisingly non-slimy, refreshing finish.


These products have a common trend in the surfactants that are included. Below, we'll go into more detail.

Balancing Surfactant HLB Values for Less Stickiness

Balancing Surfactant HLB Values for Less Stickiness

It's recommended to choose products that contain a variety of surfactants, both with low and high HLB (Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance) values. In particular, the combination of PEG-20 Glyceryl Triisostearate and PEG-10 Isostearate tends to be less sticky on the skin.


Essentially, the HLB value is an index that measures the solubility of a substance in water or oil. A lower number indicates higher oil solubility, while a higher number indicates higher water solubility. If both are included, the product can easily blend with oily makeup and also be easily rinsed off with water, reducing any residual slipperiness.

4

For a Creamy Texture, Look for Mainly Lipids and Solid Oils

Lipids for Gentle Contact and Solid Oils for Good Skin Compatibility

Lipids for Gentle Contact and Solid Oils for Good Skin Compatibility

The oil components mainly fall into three categories: ester oils, hydrocarbon oils, and lipids. Among these, lipids make the skin more supple, so they can help condition your skin to be soft and moist while removing makeup.


Furthermore, if solid oils like synthetic waxes or beeswax are included, the texture becomes richer, providing a luxurious, melting feel that gently envelops the skin.


Based on evaluations from our user trials, products containing lipids and solid oils received high ratings. For those who want to enjoy the unique experience of using a balm, consider these points when making your choice.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?
The products listed here are not guaranteed to have the effects or benefits described in the guide. Before making a purchase, be sure to assess the details and product descriptions of each item. 
The term "penetration" in this article refers to the penetration into the stratum corneum, the outermost layer of the skin.


11 Best Cleansing Balms Ranking

Here are the best Cleansing Balms we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
Superior makeup removal
Moisturizing
Prevents greasiness
Vegan-friendly
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Price
Key features
Ranking spec
Details
Makeup Removing Ability
Skin Tightness Prevention
Greasiness Prevention
Texture
Size
Main oil type
Surfactants used
Spatula applicator
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
1

Glow Recipe

Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm

Glow Recipe Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm 1
4.54

$33.00

High Mid

Effective Makeup Removal and Spreadable Texture

4.78
4.29
4.29
4.50

3.4 oz.

Seed Oil

unknown

2

YADAH

GREEN TEA PURE CLEANSING BALM 1

YADAH GREEN TEA PURE CLEANSING BALM 1 1
4.51

$21.00

Mid

Pleasant Texture and Quick Foundation Removal

4.47
4.50
4.50
4.72

3.4oz.

Lipids

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

3

CeraVe

Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm

CeraVe  Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm 1
4.42

$8.97

Low

Quick Makeup Adherence and Comprehensive Cleansing Power

4.83
4.07
4.00
4.15

1.3 oz.

Ester oil

unknown

unknown

unknown

3

Estee Lauder

Advanced Night Cleansing Balm

Estee Lauder Advanced Night Cleansing Balm 1
4.42

$48.00

High

Moisturized Finish and Pleasant Texture

4.38
4.57
4.22
4.43

2.37 oz.

Lipids

Sorbeth-30 Tetraoleate, Peg-5 Glyceryl Triisostearate

unknown

unknown

5

Naturium

Purple Ginseng Cleansing Balm

Naturium Purple Ginseng Cleansing Balm 1
4.27

$19.99

Low Mid

Easy Foundation and Mascara Removal, but Tends to Leave Residue

4.68
3.86
3.79
4.43

3 oz.

Ester oil

unknown

6

Then I Met You

LIVING CLEANSING BALM

Then I Met You LIVING CLEANSING BALM 1
4.19

$38.00

High Mid

Difficult to Remove Base Makeup but Smooth, Clump-Resistant Texture

3.93
4.43
4.57
4.65

3.17oz.

unknown

7

Physicians Formula

The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing BalmPF10986

Physicians Formula The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 1
4.08
Currently unavailable

Not Ideal for Heavy Makeup, but Balances Moisture and Freshness

3.75
4.57
4.43
4.29

8.5 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

8

Clinique Laboratories

Take The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm

Clinique Laboratories Take The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm 1
3.97

$23.95

Mid

Hard to Remove Base Makeup, but Melty Texture Is a Plus

3.79
4.15
4.15
4.36

3.8 oz.

Ester oil

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

9

JUNO

CLEAN 10 CLEANSING BALM

JUNO CLEAN 10 CLEANSING BALM 1
3.95

$14.99

Low Mid

Struggles to Remove Foundation but Nicely Moisturizing

3.54
4.57
4.36
4.50

3 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

10

FARMACY

GREEN CLEAN

FARMACY GREEN CLEAN 1
3.87

$36.00

High Mid

Recommended for Dry Skin With a Focus on Moisturizing Rather Than Makeup Removal

3.40
4.65
4.57
4.43

3.4 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Cleansing Balms

Glow RecipePapaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm

mybest Score
4.54
Makeup Removing Ability
4.78
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.29
Greasiness Prevention
4.29
Texture
4.50
View on Amazon
Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm 1
Lowest price
$33.00
High Mid
Lowest price
$33.00
High Mid
Main oil typeSeed Oil
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Effective Makeup Removal and Spreadable Texture

Glow Recipe's Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm includes papaya enzymes that provide exfoliation to not only thoroughly remove makeup and impurities but also smooth and refine the skin.


In the evaluation of its makeup-removal efficacy, Glow Recipe's offering received high marks for quickly removing all types of makeup except eyeliner, and at a faster-than-average speed. Notably, it managed to remove stubborn concealer in just 30 seconds, which is quite impressive. This makes it a perfect product for those who want to swiftly remove heavy makeup.


Furthermore, the product scored highly for leaving the skin feeling neither tight nor slimy after washing. Evaluators who actually used the product praised its moisturizing feel after rinsing and its ability to wash off quickly without leaving a residue. This suggests that even those who have dry skin and have experienced issues with other cleansing balms are likely to be satisfied.


Additionally, the texture of the product received favorable reviews, with comments like "easy to spread" being common. The smooth and rich texture is not only easy to work with, but it is soft and gentle on the skin.


This cleansing balm is a top pick that ticks all the boxes, including makeup removal efficiency, after-wash feel, and texture.

Size3.4 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2
No.1 in Texture

YADAHGREEN TEA PURE CLEANSING BALM 1

mybest Score
4.51
Makeup Removing Ability
4.47
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.50
Greasiness Prevention
4.50
Texture
4.72
Lowest price
$21.00
Mid
Main oil typeLipids
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Pleasant Texture and Quick Foundation Removal

The Yadah Green Tea Pure Cleansing Balm 1 is a sherbet-like cleansing balm that claims to remove makeup, sunscreen, and other impurities without stripping the skin of its natural moisture.


This product scored highly for its ability to quickly remove foundation but struggled to remove waterproof mascara, taking over a minute. However, removing regular mascara should not be an issue. You can also use a separate eye makeup remover first to speed up the process.


The finish after washing is neither too tight nor too slimy, resulting in a balanced texture. Even those with dry skin should be satisfied, as the product leaves the skin feeling moisturized while still rinsing away cleanly.


The biggest draw of this product is its gorgeous melting texture. While the brand describes the consistency as "sherbet-like," the actual experience is more smooth and velvety than it is grainy. Featuring a base of oils and incorporating solid beeswax, the product excels in skin comfort.


This cleansing balm is notable for its smooth, velvety texture that quickly and effectively removes foundation from the skin.

Size3.4oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-freeunknown
Paraben-freeunknown
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.3
No.1 in Makeup Removing Ability

CeraVe Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm

mybest Score
4.42
Makeup Removing Ability
4.83
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.07
Greasiness Prevention
4.00
Texture
4.15
Lowest price
$8.97
Low
Main oil typeEster oil
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Quick Makeup Adherence and Comprehensive Cleansing Power

The CeraVe Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm promises to effectively remove long-wearing makeup, dirt, and excess sebum from the skin, leaving it clean and moisturized after use.


In the makeup removal evaluation, this balm received high marks for quickly taking off all types of makeup except eyeliner. Notably, it excelled in removing foundation much faster than many other products. It also performed well with concealer and eye makeup. This is a great choice for those who want to quickly remove full-face makeup.


The balm received moderate ratings for skin tightness and residue after washing. Feedback from the testers was mixed, with some noting, "My skin felt moisturized after rinsing," and others saying, "I felt the need to hydrate immediately after use," "It left my skin feeling fresh," and "There was a residual oily feel." With that in mind, whether or not this product is suitable will depend on individual preference and how you like your skin to feel after cleansing.


The texture of the product didn't score exceptionally high, but it did receive favorable comments such as, "It warmed up quickly with the heat of my hands, making it easy to spread." Although it feels a bit hard when you first scoop it out, warming it up in your hands will make it easier to blend into your makeup.


The best features of this product are its ability to quickly blend with makeup and effectively remove a full face of makeup in one go.

Size1.3 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.3

Estee LauderAdvanced Night Cleansing Balm

mybest Score
4.42
Makeup Removing Ability
4.38
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.57
Greasiness Prevention
4.22
Texture
4.43
Lowest price
$48.00
High
Main oil typeLipids
Surfactants usedSorbeth-30 Tetraoleate, Peg-5 Glyceryl Triisostearate
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free

Moisturized Finish and Pleasant Texture

The Advanced Night Cleansing Balm by Estée Lauder claims to melt smoothly into the skin as you massage it, transforming into a liquid that is easy to rinse off for a healthy feel on the skin.


This product scored highly for its quick removal of point makeup like eyeshadow and mascara, boosting its overall rating. While it struggled a bit with removing concealer, it is an ideal choice for those looking to quickly take off eye makeup like eyeshadow and eyeliner. However, it was less effective with mascara, so if you usually wear waterproof formulas, it's best to use a specialized remover as well.


Testers who actually used the product gave favorable reviews about its lack of post-wash tightness on the skin. Comments like "I felt a moisturized feeling" and "My skin felt smooth after rinsing" were frequently mentioned. On the other hand, some may find a residual slippery feeling, making this product more suitable for those with dry skin who prefer a moisturizing finish.


The texture also received positive evaluations. Thick yet soft, it feels comfortable against the skin. Another plus point is that it doesn't form clumps easily, adding to its appeal.

Size2.37 oz.
Spatula applicator unknown
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.5

NaturiumPurple Ginseng Cleansing Balm

mybest Score
4.27
Makeup Removing Ability
4.68
Skin Tightness Prevention
3.86
Greasiness Prevention
3.79
Texture
4.43
Lowest price
$19.99
Low Mid
Main oil typeEster oil
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Easy Foundation and Mascara Removal, but Tends to Leave Residue

Naturium's Purple Ginseng Cleansing Balm is a product advertised to effortlessly blend into the skin, removing dirt, excess sebum, makeup, sunscreen, and other impurities.


In the test for makeup removal effectiveness, the product generally cleansed very well, particularly shining in its speed at removing foundation and mascara. Both came off in less than 30 seconds, suggesting that you could get away without using a separate mascara remover.


Upon touch, the balm is slightly sticky, likely due to the inclusion of synthetic waxes from solid oils. However, it quickly transforms into a smoother texture when it comes into contact with the skin, receiving high praise from testers for its ease of use.


On the other hand, the balm received moderate ratings for its post-wash feel, both in terms of skin tightness and residue. Some reviewers mentioned that it took time to wash off and felt oily, so this product may not be the best fit for those who aren't fond of a heavier, richer feel.

Size3 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.6
No.1 in Greasiness Prevention

Then I Met YouLIVING CLEANSING BALM

mybest Score
4.19
Makeup Removing Ability
3.93
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.43
Greasiness Prevention
4.57
Texture
4.65
Lowest price
$38.00
High Mid
Main oil type
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Difficult to Remove Base Makeup but Smooth, Clump-Resistant Texture

The Living Cleansing Balm by Then I Met You is designed to dissolve oil-based impurities like makeup, sunscreen, and excess sebum. It's formulated with skin-conditioning ingredients such as olive oil and vitamin E.


In tests for makeup removal effectiveness, the balm took off eyeshadow and eyebrow products in less than 30 seconds but struggled with other types of makeup. Specifically, it had difficulty removing foundation and concealer, making it less suitable for those who wear heavy base makeup.


On the flip side, it received high marks for its non-slimy finish and that it washed off quickly. It also scored well in how it left the skin post-rinse, with testers noting that there was no dryness or tightness. This product strikes a good balance between non-greasiness and a moisturizing feel.


One of the standout features of this product is undoubtedly its melt-on-your-skin texture. It's extremely smooth and less prone to forming clumps, which received high praise from testers. If you're looking for a product that feels gentle on the skin and is a joy to use, this cleansing balm comes highly recommended.

Size3.17oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.7

Physicians FormulaThe Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing BalmPF10986

mybest Score
4.08
Makeup Removing Ability
3.75
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.57
Greasiness Prevention
4.43
Texture
4.29
The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 1
The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 2
The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 3
The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 4
The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm 5
Currently unavailable
Main oil typeunknown
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Not Ideal for Heavy Makeup, but Balances Moisture and Freshness

The Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing Balm by Physicians Formula promises to dissolve makeup and impurities while providing moisture to the skin.


In tests for makeup removal, it underperformed in removing concealer, significantly affecting its overall ranking. It also took about a minute for eyeshadow and mascara to dissolve thoroughly, making it less suitable for those who use concealer or wear heavy eye makeup.


On the other hand, the balm received high marks for its non-tightening feel. Comments like "the skin felt smooth after washing" and "there was dryness or tightness" were commonly observed. Moreover, the balm was also praised for its non-slimy finish, making it a good option for those who have dry skin but still want a fresh feeling after cleansing.


The balm has a loose, drippy texture, which means it doesn't take much time to spread across the face. Testers who used the product rated this aspect highly, remarking that it was extremely soft and felt like an oil. For those who enjoy a melting, balm-like texture, this would be a good pick.

Size8.5 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-freeunknown
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
Currently unavailable
No.8

Clinique LaboratoriesTake The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm

mybest Score
3.97
Makeup Removing Ability
3.79
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.15
Greasiness Prevention
4.15
Texture
4.36
Lowest price
$23.95
Mid
Main oil typeEster oil
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Hard to Remove Base Makeup, but Melty Texture Is a Plus

Clinique's Take The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm is advertised as a product that gently melts makeup, thoroughly cleanses, and rinses off cleanly.


In our tests, this product was particularly effective at taking off eyeshadow and mascara, but it took some time to fully remove foundation and concealer. While the balm is well-suited for those who want to focus on removing eye makeup, it may not be the best choice if you wear heavy base makeup.


This product also did not receive high ratings for how it left the skin feeling after cleansing, affecting its overall ranking. Comments were divisive, with some saying "My skin felt a bit taut afterward" and others "My skin felt moisturized." Those who experience significant skin tightness after cleansing may not find this product to be a good match.


However, the product's texture received favorable reviews from testers for its quick transformation into a soft consistency when spread by hand. Although it may feel a bit hard when first scooped out, requiring a bit of force, it melted well from the warmth of the skin. This smooth, melting texture is one of the most appealing aspects of cleansing balms, and it seems that Clinique's offering did not disappoint in this regard.

Size3.8 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-freeunknown
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.9

JUNOCLEAN 10 CLEANSING BALM

mybest Score
3.95
Makeup Removing Ability
3.54
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.57
Greasiness Prevention
4.36
Texture
4.50
Lowest price
$14.99
Low Mid
Main oil typeunknown
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Struggles to Remove Foundation but Nicely Moisturizing

JUNOCO's Clean 10 Cleansing Balm is formulated with only 10 carefully selected ingredients to easily melt away makeup for all skin types.


In makeup removal tests, the product generally took a long time to completely clean the face, resulting in a low ranking. In particular, it took more than a minute and a half to remove foundation, making it unsuitable for those who wear heavy base makeup.


On the other hand, the product received high marks for not leaving any tightness after cleansing. Testers commented that their skin felt smooth and moisturized. Furthermore, this balm provided a non-greasy, refreshing finish.


Because synthetic waxes and solid oils are included in the formulation, the texture is on the harder side. However, the balm quickly transforms into a smooth texture that easily spreads across the face with the warmth of your hands. Testers noted that the thick texture reduced friction and allowed for a gentle cleansing experience. This product is recommended for those who prioritize how a cleansing balm feels during use.

Size3 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-freeunknown
Paraben-freeunknown
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.10
No.1 in Skin Tightness Prevention
No.1 in Greasiness Prevention

FARMACYGREEN CLEAN

mybest Score
3.87
Makeup Removing Ability
3.40
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.65
Greasiness Prevention
4.57
Texture
4.43
Lowest price
$36.00
High Mid
Main oil typeunknown
Surfactants usedunknown
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Recommended for Dry Skin With a Focus on Moisturizing Rather Than Makeup Removal

Farmacy's Green Clean is marketed as a product that quickly melts away all makeup, gently cleanses, and leaves the skin feeling silky smooth and hydrated.


In tests for makeup removal efficiency, the product received very low ratings for its inability to remove almost all types of makeup except for eyebrow products. This greatly affected its overall ranking. While the testing involved hard-to-remove items like waterproof makeup, it can be assumed that this product may only be effective for removing very light makeup.


On the plus side, it did not leave the skin feeling tight after cleansing. Testers rated it highly, commenting that their skin felt moisturized and hydrated. Additionally, both high and low hlb value surfactants are included in the formulation, resulting in a non-slimy feel. This product would be great for those who struggle with dryness after cleansing.


The soft texture received mixed reviews, although the majority of testers felt it was pleasant. One notable downside was its tendency to form lumps, which could cause discomfort when not fully dissolved. However, apart from this, the texture is smooth and easy to manage. Thoroughly blending the product into the skin with your hands before use should resolve any issues.

Size3.4 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-freeunknown
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all
No.11

F&COBanila CoClean It Zero Cleansing Balm Original

mybest Score
3.76
Makeup Removing Ability
3.40
Skin Tightness Prevention
4.22
Greasiness Prevention
4.36
Texture
4.36
Lowest price
$23.69
Mid
Main oil typeunknown
Surfactants usedPEG-20 Glyceryl Triisostearate, PEG-10 Isostearate,
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Takes Time to Completely Remove Makeup, but Leaves a Fresh Feel

Banila Co's Clean It Zero Cleansing Balm is formulated with all skin types in mind. It claims to thoroughly remove impurities while hydrating the skin.


In tests for makeup removal efficiency, the product received low ratings because it took more than one minute to fully take off most types of makeup. While it does eventually do the job, more time spent cleansing means more friction on the skin, which isn't ideal. This product may not be suitable for those who wear heavy makeup.


The product was close to receiving top marks for its ability to leave the skin feeling non-tight after cleansing. Looking at its ingredient composition, it's likely that the inclusion of surfactants with varying hlb values contributed to its non-greasy afterfeel, earning it high ratings in that regard. It's a good option for those who like a fresh feeling after cleansing.


The texture also received favorable reviews, with one tester commenting, "It quickly melted into a liquid form when warmed with the hands, making it easy to spread." Since it melts quickly, it easily blends with makeup and leaves the skin smooth.

Size6 oz.
Spatula applicator
Alcohol-free
Paraben-free
Double cleansing not required
Formulated with solid oils
View all

How We Tested the Cleansing Balms

Cleansing Balms Evaluation

For this comparison, we gathered 11 top-selling cleansing balms from stores like Amazon and Walmart and conducted a thorough evaluation to determine the most outstanding product. At mybest, we define an excellent cleansing balm as one that leaves no tightness after washing, has a smooth texture that doesn't cause skin friction, and is effective in thoroughly removing heavy makeup.


Taking into consideration the key points for selection, we identified the following four criteria for evaluation:
  • Effectiveness in Removing Makeup
  • Lack of Tightness After Washing
  • Absence of Slipperiness After Washing
  • Texture

Products we tested

  1. CeraVe Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm
  2. Clinique LaboratoriesTake The Day Off™ Cleansing Balm
  3. Estee LauderAdvanced Night Cleansing Balm
  4. F&COBanila CoClean It Zero Cleansing Balm Original
  5. FARMACYGREEN CLEAN
  6. Glow RecipePapaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm
  7. JUNOCLEAN 10 CLEANSING BALM
  8. NaturiumPurple Ginseng Cleansing Balm
  9. Physicians FormulaThe Perfect Matcha 3-in-1 Melting Cleansing BalmPF10986
  10. Then I Met YouLIVING CLEANSING BALM
  11. YADAHGREEN TEA PURE CLEANSING BALM 1
1

Effectiveness in Removing Makeup

Effectiveness in Removing Makeup
First, we evaluated the most crucial aspect of a cleansing balm: how well it removes makeup.

We applied makeup products to synthetic skin and used the cleansing balm to remove them. We measured the time it took for each makeup item to be completely removed and rated the speed on a scale of one to seven.

Cosmetics Tested:
  • Liquid Foundation
  • Liquid Concealer
  • Eyeshadow Pencil
  • Waterproof Mascara
  • Waterproof Eyeliner
  • Eyebrow Pencil

Test Conditions:
1. Apply an appropriate amount of each item to artificial skin.
2. Leave it on for three hours.
3. Blend in the cleansing balm and rinse it off.
2

Lack of Tightness After Washing

Lack of Tightness After Washing
One of the strengths of cleansing balm is its ability to leave the skin feeling comfortable rather than taut after rinsing. For this test, five panelists used each product on their own skin and evaluated the following points on a scale of one to seven.

Evaluation Points:
  • Whether the skin feels dry immediately after rinsing with a strong desire to apply lotion right away
  • Whether there's a feeling of skin tightness or a taut sensation when touched
3

Absence of Slipperiness After Washing

Absence of Slipperiness After Washing
Even if the skin feels moisturized after washing, a slimy or sticky sensation can be uncomfortable. Our five testers used and evaluated each product based on the following points, rating them on a scale of one to seven.

Evaluation Criteria:
  • Whether rinsing off once felt insufficient
  • Whether there was any stickiness left on the skin
4

Texture

Texture
Evaluation of Texture:
The texture is crucial for continued comfortable use. Our five testers used and evaluated each product based on the following points, rating them on a scale of one to seven.

Evaluation Criteria:
  • Resistance to clumping when warmed in the hand
  • Quick transformation into a smooth texture when spread
  • Ease of blending with makeup

Tips for Using a Cleansing Balm

A cleansing balm helps remove impurities and makeup effectively. If it's applied incorrectly, it might not be as effective. Check out our tips to learn how to appropriately use a cleansing balm! 

Apply an Appropriate Amount With Dry Hands

Apply an Appropriate Amount With Dry Hands

When applying your cleansing balm, make sure to use it with clean, dry hands. The moisture from wet hands might not blend well with the oil ingredients of the balm. Warm the balm up between the tips of your fingers and emulsify it a little before applying to your dry face. 


You should spend a little bit of time using your fingers to gently massage in circular motions. Start from your T-zone, which is known to be the oiliest area on your face, and move towards drier areas, such as your cheeks.


Massage the cleansing balm into your skin for around 30 seconds to two minutes, depending on how much makeup you wear. If you have eye makeup on, lightly massage around those areas with extra care so as not to get any product in them.  

Rinse Clean and Use a Soft Towel to Wipe Away the Day

Rinse Clean and Use a Soft Towel to Wipe Away the Day

After massaging your face, rinse your face thoroughly to ensure that no residue is left behind. Cleansing balms are a bit tougher to remove than other cleansers, so you should dampen a soft towel and gently wipe your face to remove it completely. Try not to scrub the product off your skin since it might cause irritation. 


For some products, the residue can act as a moisturizer, so it's okay to not completely wipe those balms away! To finish up, use a dry towel to remove any remaining water before using a water-based cleanser or applying other skincare products, like a moisturizer, serum, or night cream. 

More Ways to Remove Your Makeup Safely

If you're not up to using a cleansing balm every day, try alternating with some other reliable makeup removers. We've even tested out some of them in our Tokyo office!

Amazon's Best Selling Facial Cleansers

Not sure a cleansing balm is right for you? Take a look at what Amazon buyers like for removing makeup and washing your face.

Top 5 Cleansing Balms

No. 1: Glow RecipePapaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm

No. 2: YADAHGREEN TEA PURE CLEANSING BALM 1

No. 3: CeraVe Makeup Removing Cleanser Balm

No. 3: Estee LauderAdvanced Night Cleansing Balm

No. 5: NaturiumPurple Ginseng Cleansing Balm

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Beauty
  3. Cleansers
  4. 11 Best Cleansing Balms of 2024 [Tested and Reviewed]

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.