mybest
Pudding Mix

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Food and drinks
  3. Snacks and candies
  4. 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed)
  • 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed) 1
  • 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed) 2
  • 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed) 3
  • 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed) 4
  • 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed) 5

10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed)

If you're in the mood for dessert but don't want something that's difficult to make, pudding is your best bet! There are a ton of flavors to choose from, from classic vanilla and chocolate to tangy key lime and lemon. Plus, the wide variety of options means you can find a pudding for every diet, whether you're vegan or watching your sugar intake.


Among all the popular pudding mixes on the market, Jell-O's Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler is our favorite. This sampler has nine distinct flavors for you to enjoy, and all of them are crafted without any sugar. If you're curious about other pudding mixes on our 10 best instant pudding mixes list, keep reading! Also, for more information, check out our buying guide reviewed by a professional chef. 

Last updated 10/03/2023
Jim Quast
Expert
Executive R&D Chef
Jim Quast

Jim Quast (JQ) is a lifelong professional restaurant and corporate R&D chef who loves everything food-related and the tools, both big and small, to make those great food memories. He's a super huge BBQ, grill, and kitchen gadget fanatic. JQ has spent the last 30+ years trying to figure out what works to make your kitchen life easier and fun. If you can use it to slice it, dice it, cook it, smoke it, or store it, he's been there checking it out. Food = Life!

Jim Quast's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

How to Choose a Pudding Mix

If you need some extra help to make a decision, this buying guide will come in handy. Remember to take into consideration crucial factors such as the flavor of the mix, the ingredients, ease of preparation, and your dietary restrictions.

1

Pick a Flavor That Satisfies Your Cravings

Pick a Flavor That Satisfies Your Cravings
If you're in the mood for something simple, classic vanilla or tapioca pudding might be a great choice. Since they pair well with basically anything, try adding fruits, nuts, or spices to make this treat even more special.

If you're after something more decadent, pistachio or chocolate pudding is rich and delicious. If you're a chocoholic, opt for a chocolate fudge flavor for more indulgence. 


Fruity flavors can be good if you're looking for a taste that is more refreshing. Lemon, orange, or key lime pudding provides a tangy kick to surprise your taste buds, while banana is sweet and comforting. The flavor options are limitless, so follow your taste buds! 

2

Consider the Ease of Preparation

Consider the Ease of Preparation

Instant pudding mixes are convenient. Most products simply need you to add some milk and stir. This type of pudding will usually set in about five minutes. However, some may require beating the milk in using an electric or handheld mixer. Some people comment that they find instant pudding gritty if not mixed very well.


Another type to consider is the cook-and-serve kind. Some products can be prepared with a microwave, and other mixes can be cooked on the stove. These still may not take much time to cook, usually boiling for a few minutes is all that's needed; but they will require time to cool down. Chilling in the refrigerator for an hour or two is often recommended.

3

Check the Ingredient List

Check the Ingredient List

Pudding mixes help you easily whip up a yummy dessert, but they might not taste natural if they use artificial additives. A mix containing only natural, basic ingredients, such as cornstarch, sugar, and natural flavors like vanilla extract or cocoa won't have an off-putting aftertaste. 


You might also want to consider a certified organic mix. Organic products have been carefully inspected by a certification body and must meet stringent standards regarding manufacturing and safety. They don't contain artificial additives, so you know the taste will be natural.

4

Make Sure That the Mix Meets Your Dietary Restrictions

Make Sure That the Mix Meets Your Dietary Restrictions

If you have dietary restrictions, it's important to screen the ingredient list and "may contain" label to ensure that the mix doesn't contain anything that can trigger an allergic reaction or jeopardize your diet. 


Pudding mixes might contain allergens like egg, milk, or soy. You should also keep in mind that even if a product is made without your allergens, it might still be cross-contaminated from being processed in a shared facility. 


If you don't see any cross-contamination warnings on the packaging and want to be on the safe side, contact the manufacturer.  


If you are trying to limit your sugar intake, you can still enjoy pudding! Some mixes are sugar-free and sweetened with zero-calorie sweeteners such as aspartame or stevia extract. These products won't raise your blood glucose levels and are generally safe for those who are following a low-sugar diet, including people with diabetes.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Pudding Mixes

Here are our 10 best picks for pudding mixes. Our choices are influenced by flavor variety, ingredient quality, ease of preparation, and various dietary preferences or restrictions.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Jell-O

Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler

Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler 1枚目

Best Sugar-Free Flavor Variety

2

Simply Delish

70 Plus Vanilla Shake and Pudding Mix

Simply Delish 70 Plus Vanilla Shake and Pudding Mix  1枚目

Best for Natural Vanilla Flavor

3

Simply Delish

Natural Chocolate Instant Pudding

Simply Delish Natural Chocolate Instant Pudding 1枚目

Best Chocolate Pudding Free From Sugar and 8 Allergens

4

My-T-Fine

Lemon Pudding and Pie Filling

My-T-Fine  Lemon Pudding and Pie Filling 1枚目

Best for Tangy Lemon Flavor

5

Hawaii's Best

Luau Pudding Squares

Hawaii's Best Luau Pudding Squares 1枚目

Best for a Tropical Twist

6

Jell-O

Kraft Minute Tapioca

Jell-O Kraft Minute Tapioca 1枚目

Best for Tapioca Enthusiasts

7

Jell-O

Oreo Instant Pudding Mix

Jell-O Oreo Instant Pudding Mix 1枚目

Best for Oreo Cookie Lovers

8

Jell-O

Pistachio Instant Pudding Mix

Jell-O Pistachio Instant Pudding Mix 1枚目

Best for a Rich, Nutty Flavor

9

Jell-O

Banana Cream Instant Pudding Mix

Jell-O Banana Cream Instant Pudding Mix 1枚目

Best for a Creamy Banana Delight

10

Jell-O

Butterscotch Instant Pudding Mix

Jell-O Butterscotch Instant Pudding Mix 1枚目

Best Butterscotch Instant Pudding

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Jell-OSugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler

Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler Image 1
Source:amazon.com
Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler Image 2
Source:amazon.com
Sugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler Image 3
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$28.17
Reference price
$28.17

Best Sugar-Free Flavor Variety

Pros:

  • Nine distinct flavors
  • Sugar-free
  • Fat-free before preparation
  • 20 to 30 calories per serving
  • Easy to prepare and chill with milk or a non-dairy substitute
Cons:
  • One variety needs to be cooked on the stove


This instant pudding mix sampler is best for those who prefer sugar-free and low-calorie dessert options. This set comes with nine different flavors so you won't become bored and can satisfy the taste preferences of the whole household. The flavors include vanilla, chocolate, banana cream, butterscotch, pistachio, and cheesecake. 


Most reviewers liked the fantastic assortment of flavors that includes choices that are difficult to find in stores. Many others also appreciated that these treats allowed them to stay on track with their diets.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Simply Delish70 Plus Vanilla Shake and Pudding Mix

Reference price
$2.99

Best for Natural Vanilla Flavor

Pros:

  • Low-carb
  • Accommodates a variety of diets, including keto and sugar-free
  • Lactose-free for sensitive individuals
  • Compatible with non-dairy milk alternatives
Cons:
  • Stevia extract may produce a bitter aftertaste 

This instant pudding mix is best for individuals who love natural vanilla flavors and need lactose-free or non-dairy options. You can prepare the mix with oat milk or other non-dairy alternatives and the pudding will still set in the fridge. The mix does not contain any fat per serving before preparation.


A handful of reviewers mentioned they did not like the aftertaste or texture of the pudding. Nonetheless, many buyers appreciated that this pudding helped them manage their calories and weight. They also liked that it did not contain any sugars and had a smooth, vanilla taste to it. Some reviewers also mentioned the pudding was quick and easy to make. 

No.3

Simply DelishNatural Chocolate Instant Pudding

Reference price
$2.61

Best Chocolate Pudding Free From Sugar and 8 Allergens

Pros:

  • Instant mix; just add milk or non-dairy substitute
  • No sugar per serving
  • 25 calories per serving
  • Accommodates a variety of dietary restrictions including gluten-free, lactose-free and low-sugar
  • Natural flavors 
Cons:
  • May have a bitter aftertaste according to reviewers
  • Needs a mixer or handheld beater to prepare

This instant pudding mix is best for chocolate lovers who want to indulge and stick to a diet. Simply Delish uses zero-calorie sweeteners erythritol and stevia. The mix is also suitable for keto and gluten-free diets and is free from the eight major allergens. You can use almond, soy, or coconut milk instead of cow's milk if you prefer.


A few reviewers did not like the consistency and what they noticed as an aftertaste. However, this chocolate pudding mix was a go-to for various buyers, particularly those with dietary restrictions. Many hardly noticed that it was sugar-free thanks to its rich chocolate flavor. Some used this mix in smoothies and found it worked well. 

No.4

My-T-Fine Lemon Pudding and Pie Filling

Reference price
$1.48

Best for Tangy Lemon Flavor

Pros:

  • Lively citrus flavor 
  • Use for pudding or lemon meringue pie
  • Can be made in the microwave
  • Uses water, not milk

Cons:

  • Requires time for preparation and two hours chilling
  • Need to add sugar and egg yolks

This cook-and-serve pudding mix is best for those who love the taste of tangy fruit. It's made only with natural flavors, so you can enjoy a refreshing citrus taste without any artificial aftertaste. However, the mix does require work and preparation time to get it ready to eat.  


Buyers used this mix as a base for their lemon meringue pie and were impressed with the delicious results. For a tangier kick, people suggested substituting water with some fresh lemon juice. 

No.5

Hawaii's BestLuau Pudding Squares

Reference price
$8.86

Best for a Tropical Twist

Pros:

  • Can prepare using water; no milk needed
  • Refreshing coconut flavor
  • Made in Hawaii

Cons:

  • Needs to be boiled and cool down

This mix is for people who prefer tropical tastes and want to make authentic Hawaiian haupia squares. With a creamy texture and a light, refreshing flavor, this dessert is an excellent end to a meal or a fantastic quick snack. Just mix in some water, and you're good to go! Also, you can make a variety of desserts such as pudding pies. 


A few reviewers experienced difficulties with getting the mix to form into solid squares. However, various buyers thought this mix was essential for making authentic-tasting haupia. While the recipe only required water, reviewers suggested using coconut milk for extra creaminess or coconut water to make the texture and taste a bit more jelly-like. 

No.6

Jell-OKraft Minute Tapioca

Reference price
$1.24

Best for Tapioca Enthusiasts

Pros:

  • Classic, simple tapioca flavor
  • No high-fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners
  • No fat per serving before preparation

Cons:

  • Requires stovetop cooking to prepare
  • Not suitable for low or no sugar diets

This mix is best for those who prefer a blander, tapioca flavor. While you can customize your tapioca pudding with this mix, you will need to add skim milk if you want to keep it fat-free. However, this mix does make enough for an entire family and tapioca pudding enthusiasts who don't mind extra prep time.


A few reviewers weren't happy with the cooking directions or the way the pudding turned out. Many reviewers expressed their love for the taste of this pudding. They mentioned tapioca and the Jello-O brand as their favorites. Some even enjoyed the pudding as a warm treat soon after cooking the mix.  

    No.7

    Jell-OOreo Instant Pudding Mix

    Reference price
    $1.78

    Best for Oreo Cookie Lovers

    Pros:

    • Fun Oreo cookie flavor
    • Smooth pudding with a bit of texture from the cookie bits
    • Sets within five minutes

    Cons:

    • May not set with non-dairy milk alternatives

    This Oreo instant pudding mix from Jell-O is best for cookie lovers. It contains bits of Oreo cookies to serve as a dessert by itself, or use it in recipes for pie or cheesecake. This mix doesn't take long to prepare and you'll have a chilled dessert in minutes.


    Some reviewers were disappointed that the mix did not set with non-dairy milk alternatives. Yet, the majority of buyers loved the creamy texture and thought this pudding tasted excellent by itself or as an Oreo pie filling. They enjoyed the crumbled cookie pieces and flavors.  

    No.8

    Best for a Rich, Nutty Flavor

    Pros:

    • Rich pistachio flavor
    • Chunks of almond and pistachio
    • Sets within five minutes

    Cons:

    • May not set with non-dairy milk alternatives

    This pistachio instant pudding mix is a great flavor for individuals who prefer an indulgent nutty taste mixed with sweetness. While you can make this mix quickly, dairy or cow's milk is the best way to go. 


    Some buyers didn't like the texture of the nuts. But an overwhelming majority of reviewers appreciated the flavor and mentioned it was one of their favorites. A few buyers stated they also used this pistachio pudding in cakes and pies. Or, they enjoyed the pudding as a spring or summer dessert with pineapple and whipped cream. 

    No.9

    Jell-OBanana Cream Instant Pudding Mix

    Reference price
    $1.78

    Best for a Creamy Banana Delight

    Pros:

    • Just add milk and stir
    • Can be used as filling for banana cream pies
    • Try mixing it in waffle or pancake batter

    Cons:

    • May not set with non-dairy milk alternatives

    This instant pudding mix can work as chilled pudding in a bowl or as part of a banana cream pie. It's easy to prepare in less than 10 minutes. Try the classic serving method with sliced banana, vanilla wafer cookies, and whipped cream for a treat adults and kids alike will enjoy.


    Some reviewers experienced problems getting the pudding mix to set with almond milk and other non-dairy alternatives. However, most buyers found the flavor to be amazing and used it as part of their famous family recipes. Others noted they had luck with getting the pudding to set with lactose-free and skim milk

    No.10

    Jell-OButterscotch Instant Pudding Mix

    Reference price
    $1.71

    Best Butterscotch Instant Pudding

    Pros:

    • Just add milk; sets in five minutes
    • Rich butterscotch flavor pairs well with toppings

    Cons:

    • Using non-dairy milk alternatives may not work


    You can mix in milk and chill this instant butterscotch pudding in the refrigerator for a quick dessert or sweet snack. It also works great in recipes like cookies. However, you will want to stick with cow's milk when preparing it.


    While one reviewer said it came out grainy, many buyers appreciated the flavor. They enjoyed topping it with various things, from whipped cream to pretzels. Most reviewers also said they liked how the pudding only required milk to prepare. For some, it was the best pudding they had ever had. 

    Tips for Elevating Pudding Mix

    There are various ways to make your pudding mix taste more special. Curious? Check out our tips! 

    Experiment With Add-Ins

    Experiment With Add-Ins

    Want to make your pudding mix taste homemade so that no one knows it's store-bought? You can do so by adding a few extra ingredients.


    Let's talk about some potential additions that can enhance the flavor of your mix. Chopped nuts, fruits, or chocolate chips go well with many flavors and will make the texture of your pudding much more interesting. These additional ingredients will give your pudding more depth and complexity as well. 


    Spices like cinnamon or nutmeg are other great choices. They will take basic flavors, such as vanilla, to another level. However, be careful about putting in too much spice, as it might overpower the other flavors. If you want something fun, use sprinkles to add more color and sweetness to your pudding.


    If you're hosting a party, alcohol-infused puddings are likely to be a hit! Some popular options include Irish cream, vodka, and Kahlua. 

    Substitute the Required Ingredients

    Substitute the Required Ingredients

    Another tip that will help you elevate your pudding mix is to substitute some of the required ingredients. Most products will ask for water or milk, but to make your pudding more creamy and indulgent, try evaporated milk, half-and-half, or even heavy cream. 


    If you can't consume dairy, coconut milk and coconut cream helps thicken your pudding mix. Plus, they bring a delicious tropical twist to the main flavor. You might also try other non-dairy alternatives, such as almond or oat milk. 


    Keep in mind that some non-dairy alternatives such as almond, soy, and rice milk have a thinner consistency than cow's milk. Completely substituting the required amount of cow's milk in the recipe with a non-dairy product might make your pudding less thick or slightly runny.


    If you're using non-dairy milk, it's better only to use half the amount of milk stated in the instructions. Or, you might want to check reviewers' comments for some suggestions. 

    Looking for More Tasty Dessert Options?

    Want something rich and indulgent to satisfy your sweet tooth? We've got you covered. Check out our articles for more tasty treats! 

    Amazon's Best Selling Pudding Mixes

    If you need more ideas about which instant pudding mixes will fit your taste buds and lifestyle, you can check out Amazon's list of best sellers.  

    Top 5 Pudding Mix

    No. 1: Jell-OSugar-Free Instant Pudding Sampler

    No. 2: Simply Delish70 Plus Vanilla Shake and Pudding Mix

    No. 3: Simply DelishNatural Chocolate Instant Pudding

    No. 4: My-T-Fine Lemon Pudding and Pie Filling

    No. 5: Hawaii's BestLuau Pudding Squares

    View Full Ranking
    The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
    1. TOP
    2. Food and drinks
    3. Snacks and candies
    4. 10 Best Pudding Mixes of 2023 (Chef-Reviewed)

    Popular favlists

    Search by category

    mybest

    We connect users with the best tried and true products,
    tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

    Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.