mybest
Peanut Brittles

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Food and drinks
  3. Snacks and candies
  4. 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More)
  • 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More) 5

10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More)

Are you a peanut lover who also likes hard candy? Peanut brittles combine your affinity for nuts and sugar into one. These candies are a popular holiday treat, but you can enjoy them anytime! If peanut brittles are something you've never tried before, you're in for a treat with our top 10 list curated after careful research by staff at mybest. 


We chose See's Candies Peanut Brittle as our number one pick. Its classic recipe and high remarks from customers won us over. Along with nine other great options, be sure to also check out our buying guide so you'll know how to choose the perfect peanut brittle the next time you're at the candy store. Let's get started with a brief description of what peanut brittle is.  

Last updated 10/03/2023
mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

What Is Peanut Brittle?

What Is Peanut Brittle?

Legend has it that peanut brittle first emerged in the southern United States by accident. It is thought that someone added baking soda to a taffy recipe instead of cream of tartar. This mistake produced a hard candy instead of the soft, chewy texture of taffy. Peanuts may have been added as a way to salvage the result.


Peanut brittle is a popular Christmas gift and treat in the United States, although some people like to eat it year-round. It is a hard candy with rough, sometimes jagged edges that can be broken into smaller pieces. Some use the candy as a topping on sundaes and other desserts such as cakes.


Conventional peanut brittle recipes include peanuts, corn syrup, butter, sugar, baking soda, water, and salt. There are recipes that add other types of nuts, chocolate or caramel drizzles, and vegan substitutes for butter.

How to Choose a Peanut Brittle - Buying Guide

Choosing a peanut brittle that meets your preferences will depend on what type of flavors you enjoy and your nutritional needs. You might also want to consider peanut brittles that have been certified for meeting enhanced food safety and quality standards.

1

Know Your Flavor Options

Know Your Flavor Options

If you're looking for a classic flavor, look for peanut brittle with peanuts, corn syrup, and butter. Substitutes or added ingredients such as vegan butter, brown or cane sugar, almonds, cashews, and macadamia nuts can impact taste and texture.


If you want something with added richness or sweetness, look for brittles with chocolate, caramel, or vanilla. For those who enjoy spicy flavors, try peanut brittles with jalapeño or habanero flavoring. If you like to mix savory or smoked flavors with nuts and sugar, you might try bacon-flavored peanut brittles.  

2

Consider Your Dietary Needs and Restrictions

Consider Your Dietary Needs and Restrictions

Conventional peanut brittle recipes tend to be high in calories, fat and sugars. These recipes also contain ingredients that are not suitable for people with nut allergies, those who are diabetic or sensitive to sugars and carbs, and vegans. 


Vegans should watch out for butter, sugar or honey in the ingredients list. If you want to account for the calories, sugars, and fat in your daily totals, consider limiting the amounts from other food sources.


The American Heart Association recommends no more than 24 grams of sugar per day for women and no more than 36 grams per day for men. Recommendations for calorie and fat consumption vary based on height, biological sex, and activity levels.

3

Think About Storage if You Want to Buy Ahead

Think About Storage if You Want to Buy Ahead

If you buy large amounts of peanut brittle or want to buy early and keep it for the holiday season, you’ll be wondering the best way to keep it. If the packaging is see-through, find a place that doesn’t get any direct sunlight.


The worst enemy of peanut brittle once opened is moisture, so never put it in the refrigerator. If you want to store peanut brittle in your freezer, you’ll need a container that does not let in any air. Many store-bought peanut brittles can last unopened for six months in a cabinet if it's not too hot.

4

Look for Local Specialties

Look for Local Specialties

If you prefer to order from local stores and candy shops for peanut brittle rather than large online retailers, consider reviews and local awards. Some communities may have residents vote for the top local peanut brittles. You can also look through online reviews to get a sense of whether the recipe will meet your taste and quality preferences.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Peanut Brittles

Here's our list of the 10 best peanut brittles based on points in the buying guide below like recipes and flavors, in addition to customer reviews. You'll see we've also included some for individuals who prefer sugar-free and vegan options.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

See's Candies

Peanut Brittle

See's Candies Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Classic Peanut Brittle Flavor

2

Nuts.com

Peanut Brittle

Nuts.com Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Old-Fashioned Peanut Brittle

3

Sonoran Spice Company

Habanero Peanut Brittle

Sonoran Spice Company Habanero Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Peanut Brittle With a Kick

4

Jackie's Chocolate

Sugar-Free Peanut Brittle

Jackie's Chocolate Sugar-Free Peanut Brittle 1枚目

A Sugar-Free, Lower-Calorie Peanut Brittle

5

Sharay's Ghana Style Brittle

Peanut Brittle

Sharay's Ghana Style Brittle Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Simple, All-Natural Ingredients

6

Brittle Brothers

Bacon Peanut Brittle

Brittle Brothers Bacon Peanut Brittle 1枚目

A Peanut Brittle With Real Bacon

7

See's Candies

Sugar-Free Dark Peanut Brittle Bars

See's Candies Sugar-Free Dark Peanut Brittle Bars 1枚目

Combines Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate With Peanut Brittle

8

Andy Anand Chocolatier

Jalapeño Peanut Brittle

Andy Anand Chocolatier Jalapeño Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Great for Jalapeño Lovers

9

Its Delish

Peanut Brittle

Its Delish Peanut Brittle 1枚目

Made in the United States

10

SweetGourmet

Original Peanut Butter Squares Candy

SweetGourmet Original Peanut Butter Squares Candy 1枚目

Snack-Sized Squares Full of Peanuts

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

See's CandiesPeanut Brittle

Peanut Brittle Image 1
Source:sees.com
Peanut Brittle Image 2
Source:amazon.com
Peanut Brittle Image 3
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$35.00
Reference price
$35.00

Classic Peanut Brittle Flavor

See's Candies peanut brittle is made with a classic recipe that includes peanuts, butter, corn syrup, and vanilla. While this peanut brittle is certified kosher, it appeals to a wide variety of people due to its rich taste. The recipe is the original one from the founder Mary See. 


While there were a few reviewers that said it was crumbly, an overwhelming majority stated it was one of the best recipes they've tasted and complimented its buttery flavor. Most reviewers also liked the high number of peanuts in the candy. 

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Nuts.comPeanut Brittle

Peanut Brittle Image 1
Source:nuts.com
Reference price
$4.99
Reference price
$4.99

Old-Fashioned Peanut Brittle

This candy is available in a four-pound bag or a 12-pound case. Although it does not contain butter, this peanut brittle is still based on a classic recipe. It can be stored at room temperature for up to six months if unopened.


A small group of reviewers complained the peanut brittle did not contain enough nuts. Some people also found the candy to be too thick or sweet. A larger group of reviewers enjoyed the old-fashioned recipe. They found it to be addictive and hard to put down. 

No.3

Sonoran Spice CompanyHabanero Peanut Brittle

Reference price
$6.95

Peanut Brittle With a Kick

If you like a mix of spicy and sweet, you'll want to try this habanero-flavored peanut brittle. It's based on a classic peanut brittle recipe and does not contain any soy or dairy products. However, the habanero gives it a stand-out flavor that is for the adventurous


A few reviewers were disappointed in the texture and level of spice in the peanut brittle. Others loved the balance between sweet and spicy flavors.  

No.4

Jackie's ChocolateSugar-Free Peanut Brittle

Reference price
$24.95

A Sugar-Free, Lower-Calorie Peanut Brittle

This peanut brittle is a sugar-free option for those who need to limit their sugar intake. The brittle's flavor is based on the old-fashioned recipe. This candy is handmade and is delicate enough to crumble into a dessert topping. You can also buy it in two, three, and five-pound bags. 


A few reviewers wished the brittle had more peanuts in it. The majority of purchasers liked the old-time flavor and that they had a sugar-free way to enjoy it. 

No.5

Sharay's Ghana Style BrittlePeanut Brittle

Reference price
$7.49

Simple, All-Natural Ingredients

This peanut brittle contains four ingredients: peanuts, sugar, salt and water. It has peanuts throughout, instead of the typical whole nuts in hard candy you may be used to. Sharay's also claims it won't stick to your teeth!


Many reviewers confirmed that point. They also enjoyed the flavor, stating it was one of the best they'd had. Some reviewers also thought the peanut brittle had the right balance of sweetness. 

No.6

Brittle BrothersBacon Peanut Brittle

Bacon Peanut Brittle Image 1
Source:amazon.com
Bacon Peanut Brittle Image 2
Source:amazon.com
Bacon Peanut Brittle Image 3
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$7.99
Reference price
$7.99

A Peanut Brittle With Real Bacon

If you like the taste of bacon and sweetness mixed together, this peanut brittle from Brittle Brothers is for you. It has pieces of real, smoked bacon and peanuts. Brittle Brothers also says the brand uses more nuts in its recipe than other manufacturers. 


A smaller group of reviewers thought the bacon flavor was too weak, while others thought it tasted artificial. A larger group of reviewers enjoyed the mix of bacon and nuts. They thought the combined flavor was unique and interesting

No.7

See's CandiesSugar-Free Dark Peanut Brittle Bars

Sugar-Free Dark Peanut Brittle Bars Image 1
Source:sees.com
Reference price
$18.00
Reference price
$18.00

Combines Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate With Peanut Brittle

See's Candies makes this sugar-free peanut brittle for dark chocolate lovers. The sugar substitutes are sucralose and maltitol. This peanut brittle also includes a variety of nuts including almonds, walnut and pecan, in addition to peanuts. The entire bar of brittle is covered in dark chocolate. 


Multiple reviewers noted they were diabetic and really appreciated this flavor of peanut brittle. Most reviewers liked the taste and noted they bought additional boxes because of the flavor.  

No.8

Andy Anand ChocolatierJalapeño Peanut Brittle

Reference price
$21.84

Great for Jalapeño Lovers

Jalapeño peanut brittle is a unique flavor for those who like the pepper's heat. The vendor provides personalized gift messages with this candy if you know of someone who appreciates one-of-a-kind peanut brittle flavors. 


One reviewer noted the taste was a little off for them, although it had a good balance between spicy and sweet. Others thought it made a great gift for holidays and special occasions. 

No.9

Its DelishPeanut Brittle

Peanut Brittle Image 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$17.99
Reference price
$17.99

Made in the United States

It's Delish's peanut brittle states the candy is made in the United States and includes fresh-roasted peanuts. The manufacturer also states this peanut brittle is certified kosher. With two pounds of candy, you can assemble some in small gift baskets for others and keep some for yourself. 


Some reviewers expressed disappointment with the quality and texture of the brittle. They thought it was either too tough or appeared to be undercooked. The majority of reviewers liked that the peanut brittle came in uniform square shapes, so it did not need to be broken off. They also appreciated the mild taste of the candy. 

No.10

SweetGourmetOriginal Peanut Butter Squares Candy

Original Peanut Butter Squares Candy Image 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$17.69
Reference price
$17.69

Snack-Sized Squares Full of Peanuts

SweetGourmet's peanut brittle preserves the original flavor of the candy and adds butter for richness. The squares are bite-sized for easy snacking. Smaller sizes also make this peanut brittle easy to add as a topping to other desserts, including brownies and sundaes. 


A few reviewers found the candy too hard and difficult to chew. The majority of purchasers commented on the balance between a sweet and salty taste. They also noted the peanut brittle had a good number of peanuts in each bite and the texture was consistent. 

Need to Feed Your Sweet Tooth? Try These Yummy Treats!

Candy isn't just for kids! Enjoy the sweeter side of life and indulge once in a while. Here are some of our top suggestions for satisfying your sugar cravings. 

Top 5 Peanut Brittles

No. 1: See's CandiesPeanut Brittle

No. 2: Nuts.comPeanut Brittle

No. 3: Sonoran Spice CompanyHabanero Peanut Brittle

No. 4: Jackie's ChocolateSugar-Free Peanut Brittle

No. 5: Sharay's Ghana Style BrittlePeanut Brittle

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Food and drinks
  3. Snacks and candies
  4. 10 Best Peanut Brittles of 2023 (See's Candies, Jackie's Chocolate, and More)

Popular favlists

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.