mybest
Healthiest Mayonnaises

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Food and drinks
  3. Condiments
  4. 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed)
  • 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed) 1
  • 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed) 2
  • 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed) 3
  • 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed) 4
  • 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed) 5

6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed)

Gone are the days of low-fat everything. Full-fat products are back, and as a result, mayonnaise is having a bit of a moment. But we’re a little more conscious now when it comes to the mayonnaise that we’re eating. Luckily, a number of healthy options have risen to cater to our needs.

With so many options, though, it can be overwhelming to choose which to buy. We've done the research and curated a list of the 6 healthiest mayonnaises on the market. Our favorite was Sir Kensington's Organic Mayonnaise. Read on to find out why, as well as for a buying guide complete with additional advice from certified nutritionist Kara Swanson. 
Last updated 02/21/2024
Kara Swanson
Expert
Nutritionist
Kara Swanson

Kara Swanson is a certified nutritionist and the founder of Life Well Lived. She is married to her best friend and the proud mother of three. Her passion is to make nutrition simple+easy+delicious!

Kara Swanson's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

How to Choose a Healthy Mayonnaise – Buying Guide

There are a lot of mayonnaises that claim to be healthy, but few of them actually are. So here are a few hints to figuring out which ones you actually want to eat and what makes a mayonnaise better for you.
1

Always Look at the Ingredients List

At its base, mayonnaise is made from egg yolks, oil, and an acidic ingredient such as vinegar. But it's the types of oils that make healthy mayonnaise worth your money. We'll break down some key ingredients to be on the lookout for when shopping for the mayo you deserve.

Avoid Highly Processed Canola and Soybean Oils

Avoid Highly Processed Canola and Soybean Oils
The first thing you see when looking at the ingredient list of any mayonnaise is an oil. This is also where there’s the most variation in healthfulness

Most commonly found mayos are made with soybean oil or canola oil. While in their natural states both of these oils are high in healthy fats, they're also heavily processed which means they lose a lot of nutritional value


Canola oil and soybean oil are also high in omega-6 fatty acids. While you need some omega-6 in your system, too much can lead to chronic inflammation. That then introduces a host of health problems, including heart disease and arthritis.


Some good alternatives are avocado and coconut oils, which have lower omega-6 fatty acid ratios and are processed at lower temperatures than other commonly found oils like soybean or canola. That means they retain their heart-healthy properties while still delivering the rich flavor that makes mayonnaise so good. 


If you do decide to go with soybean or canola oil-based mayonnaise, make sure your choice is expeller-pressed, which means that the oil is extracted manually rather than chemically. This will ensure that there’s no external heat applied and will lessen any negative impacts.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

Don't judge a product by its label! Labels can be so deceiving and many people fall into the trap of thinking "organic" or "gluten-free" is automatically healthy when really that's not always the case. It's important to read the labels to see what oils are being used in your mayo. Avoid highly processed oils so you don't increase inflammation in your body.

Go for Real Eggs or None at All

Go for Real Eggs or None at All
When looking for a mayonnaise, look for one that actually uses real egg yolks and not egg powder or some other egg derivative. The less processed an ingredient is, the better it is for you. If possible, try to look for mayo that uses eggs from cage-free chickens.


But even if you’re not in the business of eating eggs, that doesn’t mean you’re left out of the mayo party! There are a number of egg-free, vegan-friendly mayonnaise options as well. Just pay extra attention to the ingredients, though, as manufacturers often need to add other ingredients and stabilizers to make up for the eggs and maintain texture.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

The less processed a product is the better it is, always! I recommend a vegan mayonnaise - one without eggs - to avoid the chance of getting a processed product, but if you choose to have one with eggs, make sure it's the real deal.

2

Don't Be Afraid of Full-Fat Mayo

Don't Be Afraid of Full-Fat Mayo

It's understandable that sometimes you don’t want all the calories that come along with full-fat mayonnaise, but we think you should reconsider. While lower-calorie mayo does exist, it isn’t necessarily the better option.


For one thing, some recipes work better with higher fat content mayo as fat increases flavor. Fat is also necessary for the absorption of certain vitamins.


The most important reason to avoid low-fat mayos, though, is the additives. In order to create the same texture and flavor with a lower fat content, additives, starches, stabilizers, and sugars need to be added.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

It's important to note that when something is fat-free if the manufacturer didn't add anything extra to it, it would taste pretty bad. So to make it taste good they add sugar, chemicals, and additives so that we actually want to eat it. 


Instead of picking a low-fat mayo, I advise simply grabbing a full-fat one and just using less of it. Using less is a simple way to cut down on some extra calories, too.

3

Sacrifice Longer Shelf Life to Avoid Potentially Harmful Chemicals

Sacrifice Longer Shelf Life to Avoid Potentially Harmful Chemicals
Most mayonnaise is made from unsaturated fats, which tend to go rancid fairly quickly. In order to combat that and prolong shelf life, manufacturers add a chemical called EDTA, which is known to cause a host of physical ailments. So try to look for a mayo without EDTA. You can even try making your own!


But as preservative-free mayo doesn't last longer than a few days, it's hard to avoid having preservatives in your store-bought mayo. But you can still see that you get the least preservatives possible by looking for a shelf life of no more than a few months. This may shorten the time in which you can safely eat your mayonnaise, but it will definitely keep you healthier.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

When you start to choose healthier food items like mayo, ketchup, or BBQ sauce, you will begin to realize that healthier, whole foods, don't last as long. Which, from a health standpoint, isn't a bad thing because that means there are fewer chemicals our body has to fight off. 


Choosing a healthier mayo means fewer chemicals so make sure you have a couple of recipes you can use it in to ensure you use it all.

4

Match the Flavor of the Mayo to Your Cooking

Match the Flavor of the Mayo to Your Cooking

If you find yourself using mayo in one capacity most of the time, such as in sandwiches or salad dressings, it might make sense to find a flavored mayo to spice things up. Like commercial mayonnaise brands, healthy mayonnaises also come in a variety of flavors. Some commonly found pre-flavored mayos include garlic, lemon, and chipotle.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

Finding a flavored mayo is fun if you use it for the same thing all the time. Or you could easily spice it up yourself and add some garlic, chili powder, or lemon. Get creative and try something new!

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

6 Healthiest Mayonnaises

Here are our 6 best picks for the healthiest mayonnaises. We made our choices based on the points listed in the buying guide as well as reviewer comments when available.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Sir Kensington’s

Organic Mayonnaise

Sir Kensington’s  Organic Mayonnaise 1枚目

Our Top Choice - Fully Organic, Smooth, and Flavorful

2

Primal Kitchen

Real Mayonnaise Made With Avocado Oil

Primal Kitchen  Real Mayonnaise Made With Avocado Oil 1枚目

Best Sugar-Free Creamy Mayonnaise

3

Chosen Foods

Avocado Oil-Based Vegan Mayonnaise

Chosen Foods  Avocado Oil-Based Vegan Mayonnaise 1枚目

Best Vegan Mayonnaise With a Smooth Spread

4

Truff

TRUFF MAYO COMBO PACK

Truff TRUFF MAYO COMBO PACK 1枚目

Best for a Gourmet Touch

5

BetterBody Foods

Avocado Oil Mayonnaise

BetterBody Foods Avocado Oil Mayonnaise 1枚目

Best for a Rich Avocado Flavor

6

Chosen Foods

Avocado Oil Traditional Mayo

Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Traditional Mayo 1枚目

Best Bold Mayonnaise With Cold-Pressed Oil

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise

Organic Mayonnaise Image 1
Source:thrivemarket.com
Reference price
$8.99
Reference price
$8.99

Our Top Choice - Fully Organic, Smooth, and Flavorful

It’s hard to find mayonnaise with a more wholesome ingredients list than Sir Kensington's. Fully organic and made with a base of sunflower oil and certified humane free-range eggs, this mayo has absolutely no artificial additives.

Some people who tried Sir Kensington's mayo found it to be a bit bland and not as texturally pleasing as the commercial mayonnaises they were used to. If you're set on the thick texture of commercial mayonnaise, this product might not be for you. 

Most who bought Sir Kensington's Organic Mayonnaise were thrilled with its silky consistency and bold flavors. Many said that while the different texture and taste took some getting used to at first, they found Sir Kensington's to be a quality replacement for commercial mayonnaise in sandwiches, salads, and other recipes. 

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Primal Kitchen Real Mayonnaise Made With Avocado Oil

Reference price
$8.74

Best Sugar-Free Creamy Mayonnaise

Primal Kitchen's mayonnaise is made from avocado oil, organic free-range eggs, and beet vinegar, all verified as non-GMO. It is one of the few commercially available mayonnaises that contain no sugar or sweeteners, making it a paleo diet and Whole 30-approved choice. It's also available in multiple flavors!

Some who purchased Primal Kitchen's mayo said its vinegar flavor was too powerful to enjoy. A few others had issues with ingredients separating due to colder temperatures, so if you want to buy this mayonnaise online, we recommend doing so only in warmer weather. 

However, reviewers were for the most part thrilled with Primal Kitchen Mayo's creamy, rich texture and healthy ingredients. Many with conditions like diabetes were happy to have a sugar-free option for mayonnaise and said that while the taste is slightly sourer than other commercial brands, the health perks and texture are well worth it. 

No.3

Chosen Foods Avocado Oil-Based Vegan Mayonnaise

Reference price
$11.99

Best Vegan Mayonnaise With a Smooth Spread

Chosen Foods' vegan mayonnaise is vegan, free of soy and canola, and organic. It also features aquafaba as a stabilizer, which is basically chickpea water that fluffs up the same way egg whites do. It does have a few additives to make up for the structure that eggs usually provide.

A few customers who purchased Chosen Foods' Vegan Mayo in the winter found that the oil separated from the rest of the mayonnaise, leaving it permanently runny.

Otherwise, reviewers seem very happy with this vegan mayonnaise. They say that, unlike other vegan mayonnaises, Chosen Foods's mayo doesn't leave an aftertaste. While a few report that its consistency is slightly thinner than other commercial brands, they add that it's smooth, flavorful, and tastes just as good on a sandwich.  

No.4

TruffTRUFF MAYO COMBO PACK

Reference price
$22.99

Best for a Gourmet Touch

Truff's double pack features a luxurious infusion of black winter truffles to the brand's healthy sunflower oil-based mayonnaise. One jar is Truff's original black truffle recipe, and the second adds a kick of red jalapeño pepper to the party. Both are organic and gluten-free.

 

One or two people who bought Truff's mayonnaise complained that the truffle flavor was a bit too rich for their preferences. If you aren't a fan of this admittedly niche taste, you may want to try a different healthy mayonnaise.  


Truffle lovers, however, came back with glowing reviews for these two mayonnaises. They said that the truffle flavor was clear and made an excellent addition to their food, especially sandwiches and chicken. Not only are these mayonnaises good for your body, but they're a unique flavor experience for truffle seekers as well. 

No.5

BetterBody FoodsAvocado Oil Mayonnaise

Reference price
$7.20

Best for a Rich Avocado Flavor

This mayonnaise is from the same company that produces PBfit, so you know it’s going to be good. It is made from avocado oil and cage-free eggs and contains no GMOs, canola, soy, or preservatives.

Some who bought Better Body Foods' mayo online warn that as it has a shorter shelf life than commercial mayonnaises, you might get your jar a little too close to the expiration date for comfort. While this may indeed mean that the mayo has few preservatives in it, we recommend finishing the jar off quickly after purchase. 

Other than that, reviewers rave about the rich flavor and smooth texture of this avocado mayonnaise. In fact, some people who typically hate avocados even enjoyed it! Many keto dieters report that this is the perfect spread if you're starting your keto journey, and some have even compared the flavor to standard Hellman's. 

No.6

Chosen FoodsAvocado Oil Traditional Mayo

Reference price
$11.99

Best Bold Mayonnaise With Cold-Pressed Oil

If you’re looking for quality ingredients, look no further than this mayonnaise. With a base of cold-pressed avocado oil, it is completely non-GMO, mostly organic, free of preservatives and stabilizers, and uses honey as a sweetener instead of sugar.

Because of its lack of chemicals, some purchasers warn that this mayo might separate with temperature changes. A few others were unhappy with the fact that the mayonnaise is sweetened with honey and therefore not keto-friendly

Most who tried Chosen Foods' Classic Mayo thoroughly enjoyed how creamy and boldly flavored it is. Some say it tastes as good as the mayonnaises they've made at home and far surpasses commercial mayonnaise brands. They add it has a satisfying zinginess to it that sets it apart from other brands. 

Extra Tips from Nutritionist Kara Swanson

Extra Tips from Nutritionist Kara Swanson

Mayonnaise is a pretty versatile ingredient that can be used for baking, in salads, or as a simple dressing for flavorful sandwiches. However, since it can be high in calories, Kara Swanson has a few more tips on how to make healthier choices when dealing with the condiment.

Kara Swanson
NutritionistKara Swanson

Less is best. Most mayo has 100 calories per one tablespoon, so cut down on extra calories by using less of it when you're making a chicken salad. If you're vegan one of my favorite recipes using mayonnaise is a chickpea salad. So many recipes call for a lot of mayo, but I've found I can easily cut down on it by half and it'll still be tasty!


If you're looking for a healthier substitute for mayo on your daily sandwich instead, then try adding hummus or mashed avocado. Both add a lot of flavor and healthy fats but offer fewer calories.

More Healthy Alternatives

Looking to keep things healthy? We've got you covered! Check out these lists below for more healthy alternatives to your favorites.

Top 5 Healthy Mayonnaise

No. 1: Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise

No. 2: Primal Kitchen Real Mayonnaise Made With Avocado Oil

No. 3: Chosen Foods Avocado Oil-Based Vegan Mayonnaise

No. 4: TruffTRUFF MAYO COMBO PACK

No. 5: BetterBody FoodsAvocado Oil Mayonnaise

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Food and drinks
  3. Condiments
  4. 6 Healthiest Mayonnaises of 2023 (Nutritionist-Reviewed)

Popular favlists

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.