mybest
Eyeshadow PaletteHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Eyeshadow PaletteHelping You Find the Best
16 Best Eyeshadow Palettes  [Tested and Reviewed]

16 Best Eyeshadow Palettes [Tested and Reviewed]

Eyeshadow palettes are a must-have product for makeup lovers. Offering multiple colors and textures in one complementary kit, they’re a great starting point for those new to the makeup scene. But with a wide variety available from almost every cosmetics brand, it’s difficult to decide which to go for.

We've compared 16 of the bestselling eyeshadow palettes available online and put them to the test to help you find your perfect match.


We tested each product for the following:

  • Pigment

  • Ease of Use

  • Color Selection

Last updated 07/25/2024
Miki Ishikura
Expert
Freelance Makeup Artist
Miki Ishikura

After graduating from Vert Rouge Beauty School in 2014, Miki Ishikura studied under a hair and makeup artist in Tokyo for two years. She then worked as a freelance makeup artist in Tokyo for a year before moving to New York in 2017. Still based in New York, she continues contributing to fashion magazine photoshoots and backstage at fashion weeks in New York, Milan, and Paris as a freelance makeup artist.

Miki Ishikura's Profile
…Continue reading
Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Guide
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

After Aisha Kanaya Yuson graduated from college, her interest in the beauty industry led her to complete a two-year program specializing in makeup. She moved to the U.S. by herself and settled in New York City, where she apprenticed under renowned makeup artists. She has expanded her field of activities by participating in fashion magazine shoots and assisting backstage at NYFW. She is currently affiliated with an artist agency in the U.S.

Aisha Kanaya Yuson's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

We gathered the 16 bestselling Eyeshadow Palettes and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Pigment

    1
    Pigment

    Having highly pigmented eyeshadow is essential to produce bold colors that enhance your eyes.Eyeshadows with a dull color won't give you the same effect and can cause your makeup to look off.We asked five women of different ethnicities to test each of the eyeshadow palettes and grade them based on the following points.Does the color apply uniformly?Does the color appear the same after application?

  2. Ease of Use

    2
    Ease of Use

    Eyeshadow palettes that let you apply the product intuitively and don't require a high level of technique allow both beginners and skilled makeup artists to create beautiful looks.We asked our five female testers to evaluate the following points regarding ease of use.Is it easy to blend?Does it have fallout?

  3. Color Selection

    3
    Color Selection

    The color scheme is a major factor to consider when purchasing an eyeshadow palette. Palettes with a carefully selected range of colors allow you to produce a wider variety of looks.We evaluated each palette's color selection based on the following points.Number of finishesNumber of colors

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

What's the Appeal of Eyeshadow Palettes?

Many people want to be more creative with their daily makeup, and eyeshadow palettes are an easy way to achieve that.


Eyeshadow palettes contain a set of colors meant to blend and complement each other. They are put together carefully by experts, so even beginners can confidently create natural and balanced looks simply by choosing and mixing colors within a single compact.


Whether you want to go natural or glam, the range of colors in a palette also gives you the chance to experiment and create your own unique look.


Eyeshadow palettes offer the best of both worlds: everything you need to confidently create a look that works while still allowing you to showcase your own style. 

How to Choose Eyeshadow Palettes

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Eyeshadow Palettes.

1

Pick Highly Pigmented Palettes for Vivid Colors That Blend Easily

Make Color Pop Regardless of Skin Tone

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

People often discover they can't match the effect they were going for when trying to recreate makeup looks they see on celebrities or images from Pinterest. Part of this stems from lower-quality eyeshadow with poor pigmentation.


Discovering that an eyeshadow isn't as vivid or has a more muted color than you expected after buying it can completely change the look you had planned.


While it's possible to use an eyeshadow base or a bright concealer to make the color appear more vibrant, it's much more satisfying to find a product that produces bright, bold coloring on its own.


Highly pigmented eyeshadows are also easier to blend with other colors. They create a smooth, seamless gradient, allowing you to get that pro makeup artist look. When applying eye color, nothing is more satisfying than having it show up exactly as you want.

After testing all of the products, we found that the softness of the formula resulted in different finishes.


To ensure an eyeshadow with rich color, look for those with a soft, powdery texture. Our testers rated these types highly after trying them out. Conversely, the team had a hard time getting the results they were looking for when using eyeshadows with a coarser texture.


Both beginners and experienced makeup artists will find that eyeshadows with a fine-grained formula are easier to work with and minimize mistakes.

2

Choose a Palette With Two or More Textures Plus a Base Color to Use for Any Look

More Colors and Finishes Make for Infinite Possibilities

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

One of the biggest appeals of eyeshadow palettes is that the shades are put together by experts, so they are complementary in both color and finish, as well as including a diverse color range.


The base color of an eyeshadow palette can be used to create a defined look. They are great for softening the harsh line of your eyeliner or creating a bold effect like a smokey eye. Having several finishes to choose from, such as shimmer, glitter, and matte, also allows you to play around and produce a wide range of looks.


Finding an eyeshadow palette that's right for you not only results in more flattering eye makeup but also gives you more options to work with. Plus, choosing one that accentuates your eyes will make the process of doing your makeup that much more enjoyable.


Using a single matte shade is great for everyday or work makeup. For an event or evening look, try applying colors with a shimmer or glitter finish to the inner corners of your eyes to make them pop.


Lastly, while more colors in a palette may seem appealing, it's more important to find one with the least amount of unnecessary colors possible.

We found that the majority of eyeshadow palettes contain a base shade. But when it came to finishes, some included several such as matte, shimmer, and glitter, while others only contained one, with every brand offering a different color variety.


If you aren't looking for one particular finish, it's safest to choose a palette with at least two formula options for compatibility with a wide range of looks.

3

Pick an Eyeshadow Palette Based on Your Undertone

Using Colors That Complement Your Undertone Brings Out Your Skin's Natural Beauty

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

Choosing an eyeshadow based on your skin's undertone rather than simply selecting a visually appealing color will do more to enhance the appearance of your skin and create an overall balanced look that complements your natural beauty.


For example, when choosing a neutral palette, colors like taupe and gray work well for cool undertones, while gold, bronze, and copper-toned shades complement warm undertones.


This method for choosing makeup colors can be used for not just eyeshadow but also lipstick, blush, and even hair dye to create a balanced look.

Undertone refers to the hue from under the surface of your skin. This differs from the surface color of the skin as it comes from deep beneath it, but it plays a major part in how your skin appears visually.


There are three types of undertones: cool, warm, and neutral.


People with cool undertones have blue, pink, or reddish hues in their skin color. Skin with warm undertones appears to have a peach, golden, or yellowish hue. Neutral undertones are characterized as a mixture of both cool and warm hues or falling outside both types.

4

Find Palettes That Include Tools for Convenience

Palettes With a Brush or Mirror Are Ideal for Travel and On-The-Go

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

Even a small mirror on a palette can be a lifesaver when you go out. It makes checking and touching up your makeup less of a hassle.


For larger eyeshadow palettes, choosing one that comes with a brush can save you time and space in your bag when traveling.


Looking for these extra features on a palette not only makes your bag lighter but can also help you maintain your makeup throughout the day more comfortably.

It's surprisingly common to find eyeshadow palettes that don’t include makeup tools, but choosing one that does can make all the difference, especially if you’re a beginner.


We have indicated whether each palette comes with a mirror and brush in the product details, so be sure to check before making your final decision.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

16 Best Eyeshadow Palettes Ranking

Here are the best Eyeshadow Palettes we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
Versatile palettes
With mirror
For warm tones
For cool tones
For on the go
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Main Score
Details
Pigment
Ease of Use
Color Selection
Shade range
Weight
Capacity
Applicator brush
Mirror
Textures
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Color tone
1

Urban Decay

Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette

Urban Decay Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette 1
5.00

Creates Diverse Looks, but Matte Colors Fall Short

5.00
5.00
5.00

12 colors

7.4 oz.

unknown

Matte, shimmer

Warm tones

2

Prism Makeup

Professional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

Prism Makeup Professional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette 1
4.84

40 Colors and Multiple Finishes but Difficult to Use

4.80
4.67
5.00

40 colors

6 oz.

unknown

Matte, shimmer, metallic, presto glitter

unknown

unknown

Warm tones, Cool tones

3

NATASHA DENONA

Glam Eyeshadow Palette

NATASHA DENONA Glam Eyeshadow Palette 1
4.83

Great for Skilled Looks but Overwhelming for Beginners

4.60
5.00
5.00

15 colors

8.5 oz.

0.679 oz.

unknown

Matte, metallic, pearl

unknown

Cool tones

4

Anastasia Beverly Hills

Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette

Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette 1
4.64

Seamless Blending Plus a Handy Brush and Mirror

5.00
4.34
4.50

14 colors

6.7 oz.

unknown

Matte, metallic

unknown

Warm tones

5

Charlotte Tilbury Beauty

Luxury Palette

Charlotte Tilbury Beauty Luxury Palette 1
4.53

A Compact Palette for Everyday Looks

4.20
4.50
5.00

4 colors

1.8 oz.

0.18 oz.

Matte, shimmer

unknown

unknown

Warm tones

6

PARFUMS CHRISTIAN DIOR

Backstage Eyeshadow Palette

PARFUMS CHRISTIAN DIOR Backstage Eyeshadow Palette 1
4.50

A Diverse Color Scheme, but Needs Multiple Applications

4.34
4.17
5.00

9 colors

2.8 oz.

unknown

Matte, metallic, pearlescent, glitter, holographic

unknown

unknown

Warm tones

6

Tom Ford

Tom Ford Eye Color Quad - De La Creme

Tom Ford Tom Ford Eye Color Quad - De La Creme 1
4.50

A Variety of Textures, Like Matte and Glitter, With Beautiful Pigmentation

4.38
4.10
5.00

4colors

unknown

unknown

shimmer、matte、sheer sparkle,、satin

unknown

unknown

Warm tones

8

MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette

 MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette 1
4.49

Variety of Glamorous Shimmery Colors, but Slightly Prone to Fallout

4.27
4.25
5.00

12colors

unknown

unknown

matte、metallic、shimmer

unknown

unknown

Warm tones

8

Revlon

ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow QuadAddictive (500)

Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow Quad 1
4.49

Creates Precise Lines, but Best Suited for Specific Skin Types

4.87
4.00
4.50

4 colors

1.4 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

Cool tones

10

HUDA BEAUTY

NUDE Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette

HUDA BEAUTY NUDE Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette 1
4.46

Plenty of Colors and Textures, but Pigmentation May Not Be Enough for Some

4.21
4.22
5.00

9colors

unknown

unknown

matte、metallic、shimmer

unknown

unknown

Warm tones

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Eyeshadow Palettes
No.1 in Pigment
No.1 in Ease of Use
No.1 in Color Selection

Urban Decay
Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette

mybest Score
5.00
Pigment
5.00
Ease of Use
5.00
Color Selection
5.00
View on Amazon
Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette 1
Lowest price
$59.00
High Mid
Lowest price
$59.00
High Mid
Shade range12 colors
TexturesMatte, shimmer
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Creates Diverse Looks, but Matte Colors Fall Short

What we loved

  • Vast collection of 12 shades
  • Minimal fallout
  • Blending is a breeze

What we didn't love

  • Matte shades don’t apply as evenly as others
  • Larger size isn’t ideal for on-the-go

Created by California-based brand Urban Decay, the Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette contains no parabens or sulfuric acids.


This palette's standout feature is its vast collection of 12 shades, including two distinct finishes. It also includes a brush and mirror, making it convenient for touch-ups. However, its size isn't ideal for carrying around every day, so it's probably more suitable for home use or longer trips.


Feedback from our testers included comments such as, "The shimmer shades applied uniformly and had vibrant pigmentation, while the deeper matte shades seemed uneven unless layered multiple times." On the plus side, it performed well in the ease-of-use category, with testers noting, "There was minimal fallout, and blending was a breeze." When working with matte shades, we recommend starting with a light layer and building up gradually for the best results.


With its delicate color spectrum, this eyeshadow palette will help you create elegant looks.

Weight7.4 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2
No.1 in Color Selection

Prism Makeup
Professional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

mybest Score
4.84
Pigment
4.80
Ease of Use
4.67
Color Selection
5.00
Lowest price
$9.98
Low Mid
Shade range40 colors
TexturesMatte, shimmer, metallic, presto glitter
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

40 Colors and Multiple Finishes but Difficult to Use

What we loved

  • Huge selection of shades and finishes
  • Multiple base color options for a range of looks

What we didn't love

  • Pigment strength varies across shades
  • Can be hard to blend, making it unsuitable for beginners

The Professional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette by Prism Makeup is designed to bring out the natural beauty in your eyes.


The standout feature of this palette lies in its expansive offering of 40 shades and multiple finishes, with four distinct textures and numerous options to use as a base color. This earned it high marks in the color selection category.


After applying, our testers observed, "The pigment quality varies noticeably across different shades." Opinions were also split regarding ease of use, with at least one reviewer noting that certain colors were more challenging to blend. You'll need advanced makeup skills to achieve the best results with this palette.


This is a great eyeshadow palette for those wanting a wide range of colors, but it isn't beginner-friendly.

Weight6 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones, Cool tones
No.3
No.1 in Ease of Use
No.1 in Color Selection

NATASHA DENONA
Glam Eyeshadow Palette

Lowest price
$69.00
High Mid
Shade range15 colors
TexturesMatte, metallic, pearl
Applicator brush
Mirror
unknown
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free

Great for Skilled Looks but Overwhelming for Beginners

What we loved

  • Customizable magnetic pans
  • Tons of colors and textures to experiment with
  • Smooth, even application

What we didn't love

  • Not all shades have good color payoff
  • Blending can be challenging
  • Best for experienced makeup artists

Natasha Denona's Glam Eyeshadow Palette has a cool, neutral-toned color scheme. It features customizable magnetic pans, so you can move the layout around based on your needs and skin tone.


This palette scored exceptionally high for its color selection. In addition to several base colors, it also offers three different finishes. On the downside, our team found that while the shadow applied evenly, specific colors retained their pigment better than others, making blending more challenging. Overall, this palette is better suited to those who are confident in their makeup skills.


Experienced makeup artists seeking a palette of cool-toned brown shades will find many possibilities with this one. However, it will likely be difficult to work with for beginners.

Weight8.5 oz.
Capacity0.679 oz.
Color toneCool tones
No.4
No.1 in Pigment

Anastasia Beverly Hills
Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette

mybest Score
4.64
Pigment
5.00
Ease of Use
4.34
Color Selection
4.50
Lowest price
$45.00
Mid
Shade range14 colors
TexturesMatte, metallic
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free

Seamless Blending Plus a Handy Brush and Mirror

What we loved

  • Wide variety of neutral tones makes it versatile
  • Smooth blending with no harsh lines
  • Colors are just as vibrant on the skin

What we didn't love

  • Darker matte shades are harder to blend
  • Slight fallout

Anastasia Beverly Hills' Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette promises a versatile, neutral selection of colors that look great for both daytime and evening looks.


During our ease-of-use tests, our reviewers were positive. They mentioned that sometimes there was fallout, but the eyeshadows blended smoothly with no harsh lines. The colors also stayed just as vibrant after application. However, we noticed that the darker matte shades did not result in a completely even finish. We suggest giving the brush a little shake to remove any extra product before application.


With 14 colors and two textures, this palette offers a wide range of options for creating various looks. The included brush and mirror are a welcome bonus.


Whether you prefer natural makeup or want something more glam, this eyeshadow palette has you covered.

Weight6.7 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
No.5
No.1 in Color Selection

Charlotte Tilbury Beauty
Luxury Palette

Lowest price
$28.00
Mid
Shade range4 colors
TexturesMatte, shimmer
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

A Compact Palette for Everyday Looks

What we loved

  • All the essentials for effortless looks
  • Simple yet beautiful shade selection
  • Compact size and mirror are ideal for on-the-go

What we didn't love

  • Some skin types may need to layer it for best results

Named after its London-born founder, Charlotte Tilbury, this cosmetics brand embodies her vision. The Luxury Palette is meticulously designed to meet your everyday makeup needs, delivering an effortless, feminine look.


After applying this eyeshadow, our team found they didn't need an extra makeup brush, and there was no fallout. As for pigmentation, one tester noted, "On my skin type, one application wasn't enough, but the color really popped after a second layer." Using a concealer or eyeshadow base could be worthwhile if you find that the pigmentation looks a little muted.


Although the palette features just four shades, all the essentials are there: a base color and two distinct finishes. Despite its simplicity, it allows you to create some really beautiful looks, so it's a good choice for beginners. The compact size and integrated mirror also make it ideal for on-the-go.

Weight1.8 oz.
Capacity0.18 oz.
Color toneWarm tones
No.6
No.1 in Color Selection

PARFUMS CHRISTIAN DIOR
Backstage Eyeshadow Palette

Lowest price
$52.00
High Mid
Shade range9 colors
TexturesMatte, metallic, pearlescent, glitter, holographic
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

A Diverse Color Scheme, but Needs Multiple Applications

What we loved

  • A diverse color palette for many looks
  • Similar shades blend together well

What we didn't love

  • Colors appear dull unless layered
  • Slight fallout

Dior's Backstage Eyeshadow Palette promises that its selection can create a diverse range of looks, from effortlessly natural to strikingly glam. The Backstage collection is designed to ignite the spirit of fashion and artistry through professional quality.


In terms of pigmentation, our testers shared comments such as, "A single application produced a duller color compared to how it looked in the palette, though a second layer enhanced the effect." Another tester noted, "Similar shades blended smoothly, but there was some fallout during the process."


On a positive note, this palette offers a beautiful array of nine colors, including a base color and more than two formulas, all within a compact design. This is great for those looking to play with different combinations and looks.


While this palette might not cater to those seeking intensely bold colors in a single application, it's still a good option if you're after a warm-toned selection in a compact kit.

Weight2.8 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
No.6
No.1 in Color Selection

Tom Ford
Tom Ford Eye Color Quad - De La Creme

Lowest price
$78.95
Shade range4colors
Texturesshimmer、matte、sheer sparkle,、satin
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

A Variety of Textures, Like Matte and Glitter, With Beautiful Pigmentation

What we loved

  • Enjoy various textures, including matte, shimmer, and glitter
  • Smooth application with vibrant colors
  • Compact size, easy to carry in a pouch

What we didn't love

  • Noticeable fallout

Tom Ford's Eye Color Quad - De La Creme is perfect for those who love experimenting with different eye makeup looks. Although it offers only four shades, it includes a variety of textures such as matte, shimmer, and glitter. It's ideal for those who want to match their sparkle to the occasion or mood. The compact size makes it convenient to carry in a pouch.


The pigmentation is almost there but not quite perfect. Some testers mentioned that "the coloring doesn't really stand out with just a single application, so you have to layer it." However, the texture is smooth, and the colors themselves are beautiful, so you can achieve a lovely finish with some layering.


As for ease of use, opinions were divided among testers. The combination of shades can create defined lines, making blending a little tricky. This palette is better suited for those who want to create strong contrasts rather than subtle gradients. Some users noted the fallout, so care is needed during application.


Despite this, the palette offers a range of textures in one compact package, making it versatile for both personal and professional scenes. It's worth considering if you're looking for an eyeshadow palette that can do it all.

Weightunknown
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
No.8
No.1 in Color Selection

MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette

mybest Score
4.49
Pigment
4.27
Ease of Use
4.25
Color Selection
5.00
Lowest price
$117.98
High
Shade range12colors
Texturesmatte、metallic、shimmer
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Variety of Glamorous Shimmery Colors, but Slightly Prone to Fallout

What we loved

  • Wide variety of colors for different eye makeup looks
  • Many shimmer shades for creating sparkling makeup
  • Colors apply true to what you see in the palette

What we didn't love

  • Notable shimmer fallout

Makeup by Mario's Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette is perfect for those who love sparkling eye makeup. This 12-color palette features five shimmer shades, offering plenty of options to match your mood or occasion. The variety of matte shades makes it suitable for more subdued office makeup.


The pigmentation is top-notch. Even with a single application, the colors appear vibrant and true to the palette. However, the darker shades can be tricky to adjust, so it's best to layer gradually.


This palette's 12 diverse colors allow for various eye makeup patterns. The smooth, blendable formula makes it easy to apply quickly, even on busy mornings. However, some testers mentioned that the shimmer fallout is a concern. To prevent this, an eyeshadow base is recommended.


With its rich colors and textures, this eyeshadow palette is versatile enough for office and party looks. It's an excellent choice for those who enjoy experimenting with different sparkling makeup styles.

Weightunknown
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
No.8

Revlon
ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow QuadAddictive (500)

Lowest price
$7.39
Low Mid
Shade range4 colors
Texturesunknown
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Creates Precise Lines, but Best Suited for Specific Skin Types

What we loved

  • Minimal fallout
  • Color and formula selection make it easy to create a defined look

What we didn't love

  • Blending requires some skill
  • Color payoff isn’t as strong on darker skin

Revlon's ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow Quad contains a special adherent oil, which is supposed to give it lasting power and prevent fading.


Some of our testers noted that applying this eyeshadow on a darker complexion caused the color to appear duller than it looks in the palette. Regarding ease of use, feedback highlighted that "Fallout is minimal, yet creating a graduation requires some technique." We suggest using a concealer or eyeshadow base to enhance the pigmentation, as the colors might not deliver optimal vibrancy on their own.

A positive aspect of this palette is its colors. It includes a base color and several textures, allowing you to create a well-defined look with just one small kit.


With its compact size and sponge applicator, this palette is easy to keep in your handbag for touching up your makeup in the evening.

Weight1.4 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneCool tones
No.10
No.1 in Color Selection

HUDA BEAUTY
NUDE Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette

Lowest price
$32.00
Mid
Shade range9colors
Texturesmatte、metallic、shimmer
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

Plenty of Colors and Textures, but Pigmentation May Not Be Enough for Some

What we loved

  • Includes nine shades with various textures like matte and glitter
  • Colors blend well with skin and have overall good pigmentation
  • Minimal fallout during use

What we didn't love

  • Some shades may be less pigmented

HUDA Beauty's Nude Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette is ideal for those who love to create diverse eye makeup looks. This nine-color palette includes a range of textures from matte to shimmer and glitter. Mix and match these different textures to create eye-catching looks for any occasion.


Testers praised the palette for its skin-friendly colors that appear true to the palette. However, some found that the more muted shades lacked pigmentation. Still, layering the colors can help achieve the desired effect.


In terms of usability, the palette performs well. The formula is smooth, with minimal fallout, making it easy to apply with a brush or sponge applicator. While opinions on blending varied among testers, trying the shades on the back of your hand first can help.


This eyeshadow palette offers a range of calm, skin-friendly tones combined with various textures, allowing for versatile makeup looks. This palette is worth considering if you're tired of the same daily makeup routine.

Weightunknown
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones

An Impressive Array of Colors but Low Staying Power

What we loved

  • Vibrant color that pops on all skin tones
  • Ample shades to experiment with
  • Consistent application with just one layer

What we didn't love

  • Extra effort required to minimize fallout and mess

The tartelette in Bloom Amazonian clay palette, created by tarte, includes a clay-based formulation to prevent smudging. Additionally, we noticed the product had a subtle, pleasant fragrance.


As for pigmentation, the colors maintained their vibrancy across different skin tones. Testers unanimously agreed that the application was consistent and the resulting color was striking, even with a single layer. With a diverse offering of two finishes and multiple base shades, this palette ensures ample options to achieve your desired look.


However, during our ease-of-use assessment, our testers had mixed opinions, mainly because of fallout. While blending the shadows was easy enough, we had to meticulously remove extra product from the brush to minimize how much fell onto the face. We'd recommend applying your eye makeup before your foundation when using this palette.


If you're looking for an eyeshadow palette with a varied color selection and excellent pigment and aren't too concerned about fallout, this could be a match for you.

Weight5.6 oz.
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones, Cool tones
No.12
No.1 in Ease of Use

E.L.F. Cosmetics
Bite-Size Eyeshadow

mybest Score
4.43
Pigment
4.20
Ease of Use
5.00
Color Selection
4.34
Lowest price
$3.00
Low
Shade range4 colors
Textures matte
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

A Matte-Only Palette for Subtle Looks Only

What we loved

  • Simple colors for creating subtle looks
  • Portable size for on-the-go
  • Minimal fallout

What we didn't love

  • Colors are softer once applied
  • Blending causes fading, needing multiple reapplications

The Bite-Size Eyeshadow palette hails from e.l.f. Cosmetics, a company renowned for its commitment to vegan and cruelty-free products. Its eyeshadow line promises striking pigmentation and effortless blending.


The "I Love You A Latte" palette only contains matte textures, but our testers liked its rich base color. This four-color palette is made with portability in mind, so if you're specifically after a brown eyeshadow kit for on-the-go, this could be a good option.


Despite its promises, our testers noted, "There was minimal fallout, but the colors appeared softer upon application" and "the colors faded once blended, which made multiple reapplications necessary."


This palette is not designed to create dramatic looks, but it will be useful for creating subtle ones.

Weight0.7 oz
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones

Plenty of Variety, but Glitter Shades Are Prone to Fallout

What we loved

  • Wide variety of textures, including matte, shimmer, and glitter
  • Range of shades from muted to vibrant
  • Colors apply evenly

What we didn't love

  • Glitter shades tend to have fallout
Colorpop's nude mood is perfect for those who want to create versatile eye makeup looks to match their outfit or occasion. This nine-color palette includes a range of textures, from matte to shimmer and glitter, and offers a variety of shades, from muted tones to vibrant colors.

The pigmentation delivers, with colors going on evenly across the eyelid, true to what you see in the palette. However, some testers noted that the glitter shades have larger particles and can be challenging to apply. When applying glitter shades, it's best to add them gradually to control the sparkle.


The palette is lightweight and compact, making it easy to carry in a pouch. The smooth formula allows for quick application, ideal for those who need to finish their eye makeup quickly. However, since glitter shades tend to have fallout, it's best to apply them last.


With a variety of colors and textures, this eyeshadow palette allows you to create a wide range of looks, from natural to girly. It's convenient for both at-home and on-the-go touch-ups, making it a versatile addition to your makeup collection.

Weightunknown
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones
No.14
No.1 in Color Selection

mac cosmetics CONNECT IN COLOUR EYE SHADOW PALETTE: UNFILTERED NUDES

Lowest price
$50.95
Shade range12colors
Texturesmatte、shimmer、satin
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

No Shortage of Colors and Textures, but Some May Find It Sheer

What we loved

  • Natural shades suitable for daily makeup
  • Sheer coverage allows for easy intensity control
  • Elegant packaging makes it a great gift option

What we didn't love

  • Sheer coverage may not provide strong pigmentation

MAC Cosmetics' Connect in Colour Eye Shadow Palette: Unfiltered Nudes is ideal for those seeking an eyeshadow palette that is easy to use at any age. With a range of textures, from matte to shiny, the palette features natural shades that are perfect for everyday makeup.


The pigmentation falls a bit short of top marks. Testers noted that "overall, its sheer colors don't provide strong pigmentation." However, this sheer quality makes it easier to control the intensity of the colors, making it suitable for those who prefer a natural look or are beginners in makeup.


The palette's usability received mixed reviews. Some testers mentioned that "the colors are difficult to blend, making it hard to create a gradient." To achieve a smooth gradient, try using face powder to blend the colors.


The palette's glamorous case design is perfect for those who want to have fun with their makeup routine. Its natural shades are also suitable for office makeup, making this palette a great gift.

Weightunknown
Capacityunknown
Color toneWarm tones、Cool tones
No.15

Wet n Wild
Color Icon 5 Pan Eye & Face PaletteWalking on Eggshells

mybest Score
4.11
Pigment
4.00
Ease of Use
3.84
Color Selection
4.50
Lowest price
$3.28
Shade range5 colors
TexturesMatte, shimmer, metallic, presto glitter
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free

Great Color Scheme for a Low Price, but the Pigment Is a Let-Down

What we loved

  • Versatile color and texture selection

What we didn't love

  • Colors are dull and do not apply evenly
  • Weak pigmentation makes it harder to blend

The Color Icon 5-Pan Palette by Wet n Wild touts its formula as delivering rich hues with a generous payoff, ensuring smooth application and blending.


We loved this palette's color selection, multiple finishes, and strong base color, which allow you to create both natural looks and bolder, smokey eyes.


Unfortunately, when asked about pigmentation, our testers reported that the colors appeared somewhat dull and were challenging to apply evenly. As for ease of use, feedback included statements like "The lackluster pigmentation made blending difficult," which could prevent you from achieving your desired look.


To get the most color payoff, we highly recommend using a bright concealer or eyeshadow base before doing your makeup with this palette.

Weight1.4 oz.
Capacity0.96 oz.
Color toneWarm tones
No.16

Morphe
Morphe 2 Ready in 5 Eyeshadow Palette

mybest Score
3.96
Pigment
3.47
Ease of Use
4.34
Color Selection
4.50
Shade range5 colors
TexturesShimmer, matte
Applicator brush
Mirror
Vegan-friendly
unknown
Cruelty-free
unknown

A Warm-Toned, Highly Pigmented Kit That Needs Blending

What we loved

  • Good base shades with strong pigment
  • Applies uniformly
  • Adheres well to the skin

What we didn't love

  • Requires some skill to blend properly

The Morphe 2 Ready in 5 Eyeshadow Palette comes from L.A.-based Morphe, renowned for its professional-quality makeup brushes and expansive eyeshadow sets. The design is meant to encapsulate the essence of a serene vacation getaway.


While still a very portable size, this palette impressed us with its thoughtful incorporation of a base color and a deep hue. Our team rated it well, finding that it applied uniformly, adhered well to the skin, and had excellent pigmentation.


But there was a tradeoff. One of our testers said, "Although the pigment is great, it requires some skill to blend properly." If you're applying it with a brush, make sure to shake off any excess to avoid using too much.


This could be the perfect match for those seeking a compact brown eyeshadow palette with inviting warm tones.

Weight1.8 oz
Capacity0.179 oz.
Color toneWarm tones

How We Tested the Eyeshadow Palettes

Eyeshadow Palettes Evaluation

We gathered the 16 bestselling eyeshadow palettes from online stores like Amazon and put them through rigorous testing. At mybest, we define the best eyeshadow palettes as those that include highly pigmented colors, are beginner friendly, and allow you to achieve a wide range of looks.


We kept the following three points in mind while evaluating each product:


  • Pigment

  • Ease of Use

  • Color Selection

Products we tested

  1. mac cosmetics CONNECT IN COLOUR EYE SHADOW PALETTE: UNFILTERED NUDES
  2. COLORPOP nude mood
  3. MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette
  4. Anastasia Beverly HillsSoft Glam Eyeshadow Palette
  5. Charlotte Tilbury BeautyLuxury Palette
  6. E.L.F. CosmeticsBite-Size Eyeshadow
  7. HUDA BEAUTYNUDE Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette
  8. MorpheMorphe 2 Ready in 5 Eyeshadow Palette
  9. NATASHA DENONAGlam Eyeshadow Palette
  10. PARFUMS CHRISTIAN DIORBackstage Eyeshadow Palette
  11. Prism MakeupProfessional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette
  12. RevlonColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow QuadAddictive (500)
  13. Tartetartelette in Bloom Amazonian clay palette
  14. Tom FordTom Ford Eye Color Quad - De La Creme
  15. Urban DecayNaked3 Eyeshadow Palette
  16. Wet n Wild Color Icon 5 Pan Eye & Face PaletteWalking on Eggshells
1

Pigment

Pigment

Having highly pigmented eyeshadow is essential to produce bold colors that enhance your eyes.


Eyeshadows with a dull color won't give you the same effect and can cause your makeup to look off.


We asked five women of different ethnicities to test each of the eyeshadow palettes and grade them based on the following points.


  • Does the color apply uniformly?

  • Does the color appear the same after application?

2

Ease of Use

Ease of Use

Eyeshadow palettes that let you apply the product intuitively and don't require a high level of technique allow both beginners and skilled makeup artists to create beautiful looks.


We asked our five female testers to evaluate the following points regarding ease of use.


  • Is it easy to blend?

  • Does it have fallout?

3

Color Selection

Color Selection

The color scheme is a major factor to consider when purchasing an eyeshadow palette. Palettes with a carefully selected range of colors allow you to produce a wider variety of looks.


We evaluated each palette's color selection based on the following points.


  • Number of finishes

  • Number of colors

For Parties and Events, Don’t Forget the Setting Spray

For Parties and Events, Don’t Forget the Setting Spray

When you need your makeup to stay on all day or night, it's best to use a setting spray.


A setting spray is the finishing touch to your final look, securing your makeup in place and extending its staying power over a longer period.


Applying it is as simple as spraying it over your face after you've finished your makeup. Some setting sprays can even double up for use as a primer. There are also setting sprays formulated with different needs and skin types in mind, so finding the right one can not only keep your makeup on for longer but offer extra skincare benefits too.

Top 5 Eyeshadow Palettes

No. 1: Urban DecayNaked3 Eyeshadow Palette

No. 2: Prism MakeupProfessional Neutral Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

No. 3: NATASHA DENONAGlam Eyeshadow Palette

No. 4: Anastasia Beverly HillsSoft Glam Eyeshadow Palette

No. 5: Charlotte Tilbury BeautyLuxury Palette

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Eyeshadow Palette

Eyeshadow Sticks

14 Best

Tested and Reviewed

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.