Drain cleaners can save the day when your shower or kitchen drain has slime and clogs. They can be separated into chemical-based and enzyme-based products and are sold by a variety of companies, including Green Gobbler, Bio-Clean, and Drano, who is known for their Max Gel Drain Clog Remover. They also come in gels, powders, tablets, and other forms, so it can be confusing to find the right product.
We've compared 12 bestselling drain cleaners available online and tested them to recommend the best drain cleaners for you.
We tested each product for the following:
Which product ended up being the best of the best? In our buying guide, we'll also tell you how to pick the best drain cleaners on your own, so read on for more shopping tips.
Kohei works on articles covering a variety of daily goods. Since joining mybest, he has mainly overseen men's fashion products, comparing more than 400 items. Currently, he is working on creating helpful content for users, expanding his scope from daily necessities such as detergents and fabric softeners to stationery and interior goods.
We started by testing how well each product dissolves clogs in the bathroom. We filled a graduated cylinder with water, added things that often cause clogging in the shower, and put in the drain cleaner. We waited the maximum time listed in the instruction manual and checked how well the cleaner dissolved the contaminants. For products that need to sit for more than a day, we interpreted that as waiting overnight and let all such products sit for eight hours. We used the following things that cause shower clogging.HairButter (to simulate grease or oils)ShampooConditioner
We then tested how well each product dissolves clogs in the kitchen. We filled a graduated cylinder with water, added common culprits of kitchen sink clogs, and put in the drain cleaner. We waited the maximum time listed in the instruction manual and checked how well the cleaner dissolved the debris. For products that need to sit for more than a day, we interpreted that as waiting overnight and let all such products sit for eight hours.We used the following things that cause kitchen sink clogging.ButterFlourPastaEgg shells
If the cleaner adheres to the pipe walls, it can stick to debris easily as well, making it effective at clearing slime and clogs. We checked how well it adhered to the pipe walls by pouring it into a U-shaped pipe. For gels, we also measured how far it reached when poured into the pipe and checked the viscosity.
If you plan to use the cleaner for regular drain maintenance, you’ll want a product that is easy to use. We looked at the following things to test how easy each cleaner is to use.Whether or not it needs to be measuredIf it can pour out too fast or notHow easy it is to check how much is remainingWhether you have to take precautions during use
Cleaning the drain is a hassle and you want to get it done as quickly as possible, so we tested how long you need to let the cleaner sit. We evaluated based on the shortest time listed in the instruction manual, with shorter times being better.
All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest
Some people may want to try homemade drain cleaners for environmental reasons or to save money. However, these drain cleaners aren’t as effective as the ones on the market. The difference was readily apparent when we compared them, as commercial drain cleaners easily cleared hair from the pipes. This is your best bet if you want to clear your drain.
This article will show you which commercial drain cleaners clear drains the best. We recommend adding one of these products to your drain-cleaning arsenal.
Here are the points to remember when choosing the best drain cleaners.
As we mentioned earlier, drain cleaners are either chemical or enzyme based. Chemical cleaners use sodium hydroxide (lye), sodium hypochlorite (the main chemical in liquid bleach), or other substances. On the other hand, enzyme drain cleaners rely on organic compounds. However, we recommend using a chemical cleaner if your goal is to remove a clog.
When we tried an enzyme cleaner on a drain clogged with hair and food waste, which are common culprits behind clogs in your shower or kitchen sink respectively, they didn’t dissolve these clogs very well. Enzyme cleaners are very environmentally friendly, but if clearing clogs is your main priority, they aren’t the best option. Furthermore, some enzyme cleaners need to sit for eight hours or more, so it takes a long time to clean your drain.
Among chemical cleaners, those containing lye or bleach tend to be particularly effective. Lye, sodium hydroxide, breaks down oils and proteins, and bleach, or sodium hypochlorite, dissolves hair. In addition, most of these products only need to be left for 30 minutes or less, so they work quickly. Let’s take a look at which lye and bleach drain cleaners we found to be the best.
Our top recommendation is the drain opener by up & up. This product is unique for combining lye and bleach in one cleaner. It effectively dissolved hair, pasta, and flour that was clogging the drain in the shower or sink. It only took about 15 to 30 minutes to clear the drain, getting the job done fast.
It’s a liquid cleaner, so while you do need to measure out the right amount, unlike powders, you don’t need to worry about it creating dust or having to dissolve it in warm water, so it’s not much of a hassle to use. It strikes a good balance between powerful dissolving ability and ease of use, so if you’re having trouble picking a drain cleaner, give this product a shot.
Pipe cleaners come in four types: sticks, tablets, powders, and gels. We talked about which is best for clearing stubborn clogs above, but we recommend stick or tablet type products for preventing clogs and slime.
Many tablet and stick type drain cleaners are designed with regular use in mind, such as once a month or twice a week. They’re easy to use because you don’t need to do any measuring.
They don’t have as much dissolving power as liquid and powder products, so we don’t recommend them for clearing stubborn clogs, but they’re great for drain maintenance to prevent slime and blockages. However, they can only be used with pipes that trap water, such as P traps and S traps.
Liquid or gel and powder cleaners need to be measured each time, making them more of a hassle to use than tablets and sticks, which don’t need to be measured. Many powders need to be dissolved in warm water, so it can be tiring to use them on a regular basis. We don’t recommend using powder cleaners for regular maintenance.
Different products can be used in different places. Make sure to check the instruction manual to see if the product can be used where you want to use it before making your purchase. In general, many products can be used in showers, kitchen sinks, and garbage disposals, but there aren’t many that can be used in toilets. If you’re looking for a product you can use for your toilet, we recommend Green Gobbler Main Line Opener, which was our highest reviewed product for use in toilets.
Products | Image | mybest Score | Click to purchase | Key features | Main Score | Details | |||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clog-dissolving power (bathroom drains) | Clog-dissolving power (kitchen drains) | Adherence to pipe walls | Ease of use | Fast-working | Amount | Type | pH level | Ingredients | Purpose | Percentage of lye | Amount needed to clear a clog | Amount needed to clear slime | Number of times needed to dissolve sludge | Minimum amount of time needed to sit | Precautions | ||||||
1 | up & up Clog Clearing Gel | ![]() | 4.43 | Currently unavailable | mybest's Top Choice! Clears Stubborn Clogs in Both the Shower and the Kitchen Quickly | 4.65 | 4.29 | 4.00 | 3.93 | 5.00 | 80 fl. oz. | Gel | Alkaline | Sodium hypochlorite, sodium hydroxide, surfactants | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, garbage disposal, septic tank | 1-3% | 16-40 fl. oz. | - | 1-2 | 15-30 mins. | See full precautions and directions for use on the product. DANGER: CAUSES BURNS TO EYES, SKIN, AND MUCOUS MEMBRANES. HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED. Avoid contact with skin, eyes, and clothing. Wear safety glasses and rubber gloves when handling this product. Wash skin thoroughly with soap and water after handling. Do not ingest, taste or swallow. Use with adequate ventilation and avoid breathing vapors. DO NOT use or mix with other household chemicals. Do not use in toilets |
2 | Liquid-Plumr Pro Strength Clog Destroyer Gel | ![]() | 4.29 | Lacks Viscosity and Doesn’t Adhere Well to Pipe Walls, but Destroys Clogs With Ease | 4.29 | 4.29 | 4.00 | 3.93 | 5.00 | 80 fl. oz. | Gel | Alkaline | Sodium hypochlorite, sodium chloride, sodium hydroxide, cetyl betaine, sodium xylene sulfonate, sodium orthosilicate, sodium carbonate | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, septic tank | 1-5% | 16 fl. oz. | - | - | 7-15 mins. | Keep out of reach of children. Harmful if swallowed. Avoid splashing. Injures eyes, skin and mucous membranes on contact. Do not use with ammonia, toilet bowl cleaners or non–Liquid-Plumr® clog removers, as splashing or the release of hazardous gases may occur. Clean up any spillage immediately. | |
3 | XionLab Safer Drain Opener | ![]() | 4.23 | Doesn’t Dissolve Food Waste but Great for Hair Clogs | 4.65 | 3.93 | 4.00 | 4.29 | 3.93 | 32 fl. oz. | Gel | Alkaline | Xanthan gum, alcohol ethoxylate, modified magnesium silicate | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, septic tank | 16 fl. oz. | - | - | 6-8 hrs. | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Immediately call a poison center or doctor/physician. IF ON SKIN (or hair): Remove/Take off immediately all contaminated clothing. Rinse skin with water/shower and wash with soap and water. Wash contaminated clothing before reuse. IF INHALED: Remove victim to fresh air and keep at rest in a position comfortable for breathing. If still irritated call a poison center or doctor/physician. IF SWALLOWED: Rinse mouth. Do NOT induce vomiting. | ||
4 | Green Gobbler Main Line Opener | ![]() | 4.17 | Excellent for Clearing Bathroom Drains Quickly | 4.29 | 3.93 | 4.22 | 3.93 | 4.95 | 1 gal. | Gel | Alkaline | Caustic replacement 5-10%, lauramine oxide 1-5% | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, toilet, garbage disposal, septic tank | 0% | Residential main lines: entire bottle, sinks and tubs: one-half quart to one-quart. | - | - | 30 mins. to overnight | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. Hazard statements: May be corrosive to metals. Causes skin irritation. Causes serious eye damage. Keep only in original container. Wash hands thoroughly after handling. Wear protective gloves, eye protection. If on skin: Wash with plenty of water. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Immediately call a poison center or doctor. | |
5 | Drano Max Gel | ![]() | 4.16 | Currently unavailable | Effective Against Hair but Not User-Friendly | 4.29 | 3.93 | 4.07 | 3.93 | 4.95 | 80 fl. oz. | Gel | Alkaline | Bleach, lye | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, garbage disposal | - | 16-32 fl. oz. | - | - | 15-30 mins. | WARNINGS: DANGER: KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN. HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED. MAY BURN EYES, SKIN, AND MUCOUS MEMBRANES ON CONTACT. Do not use or mix DRANO MAX GEL with any other cleaners or chemicals, as hazardous fumes or a violent reaction may result. If gases are released, leave area immediately-ventilate if possible. Keep container tightly closed and store in locked cabinet. FIRST AID: GIVE IMMEDIATELY. EYES: Rinse immediately with water. Remove contact lenses, then flush eyes with water for 15 minutes. IF SWALLOWED: Rinse mouth. Drink a cup of milk or water. Do not induce vomiting. IF ON SKIN: Remove affected clothing. Flush skin with water for 15 minutes. IN ALL CASES, CALL POISON CONTROL CENTER OR PHYSICIAN. Contains sodium hydroxide, sodium hypochlorite, and sodium silicate. |
6 | Glisten Garbage Disposer Cleaner | ![]() | 3.75 | Good for Weekly Maintenance to Prevent Slime and Odors | 3.22 | 3.93 | 5.00 | 5.00 | 5.00 | 4 packets | Packet | Acidic | Alcohols, malic acid, sodium lauryl sulfate, sulfonic acids, alkyl, sodium salts | Garbage disposal, septic tank | 0% | N/A | 1 packet | - | 2 mins. | IF ON SKIN: Wash with plenty of water. If skin irritation occurs: Get medical attention. Specific treatment (see information on this label). Take off contaminated clothing and wash it before reuse. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. If eye irritation persists: Get medical attention. | |
7 | Plink Fizzy Drain Freshener | ![]() | 3.71 | Doesn’t Need to Be Measured, but Will Only Prevent Slime, Not Clear Clogs | 3.22 | 3.93 | 3.93 | 5.00 | 4.98 | 6 tablets | Tablets | Neutral to slightly acidic | D-limonene, paraffin, lanolin, yellow dye, citral, blue dye | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, toilet, septic tank | 0% | N/A | 1 tablet | - | 20 secs. | Wash thoroughly after handling. Wear eye protection. Response IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. If eye irritation persists: Get medical attention. | |
8 | Rockwell Labs InVade Bio Drain | ![]() | 3.40 | Container Design Makes It Easy to Use, but Lacks Dissolving Power | 3.00 | 3.57 | 4.65 | 4.65 | 3.93 | 32 fl. oz. | Gel | Neutral | Bacillus bacteria | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, toilet, garbage disposal, septic tank | 0% | 4 fl. oz. every other day | - | - | - | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. If more than an incidental amount is swallowed, seek medical attention immediately. Give one glass of water and do not induce vomiting. Wash hands well water for 15 minutes. Seek medical attention for any persistent irritation. | |
9 | Green Gobbler Drain Clog Remover | ![]() | 3.37 | You Won't Have to Measure, but It Falls Short Against Clogs | 3.22 | 3.00 | 5.00 | 5.00 | 5.00 | 5 packets | Packets | Strong acid | Sulfuric acid, sodium salt | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, toilet, garbage disposal, septic tank | 0% | 1-2 packets | - | 1-2 | 15-30 mins. | See full precautions and directions for use on the product. Causes serious eye damage Wear eye protection, protective gloves. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. Immediately call a poison center or doctor. | |
10 | Earthworm Drain Cleaner & Buildup Remover | ![]() | 3.35 | Needs to Be Reapplied for 3 to 5 Nights and Struggles to Clear Clogs | 3.00 | 3.57 | 4.00 | 3.93 | 3.93 | 64 fl. oz. | Gel | unknown | Decyl glucoside, fragrance, phenoxyethanol, viable culture blend, benzisothiazolinone, sodium hydroxide, propylene glycol, glycerin | Kitchen drain, bathtub or shower drain, bathroom sink drain, laundry standpipe, overflow drain, toilet, garbage disposal, septic tank | - | 6-8 fl. oz. | - | 3 times | Overnight for 3 nights | If accidentally ingested drink large quantities of milk or water and seek medical attention. Avoid direct contact with eyes. |
Amount | 80 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Sodium hypochlorite, sodium hydroxide, surfactants |
This is a chemical drain cleaner that combines lye and bleach. In addition to the bathroom and the kitchen, it can be used in a variety of places including overflow drains, and with septic tanks. This drain cleaner has superb dissolving power, almost completely breaking down hair, flour, and pasta, so it’s very useful for unclogging kitchen sinks and shower drains. In addition, it only needs to sit for 15 to 30 minutes.
pH level | Alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 1-3% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 16-40 fl. oz. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 15-30 mins. |
Precautions | See full precautions and directions for use on the product. DANGER: CAUSES BURNS TO EYES, SKIN, AND MUCOUS MEMBRANES. HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED. Avoid contact with skin, eyes, and clothing. Wear safety glasses and rubber gloves when handling this product. Wash skin thoroughly with soap and water after handling. Do not ingest, taste or swallow. Use with adequate ventilation and avoid breathing vapors. DO NOT use or mix with other household chemicals. Do not use in toilets |
Amount | 80 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Sodium hypochlorite, sodium chloride, sodium hydroxide, cetyl betaine, sodium xylene sulfonate, sodium orthosilicate, sodium carbonate |
This is a chemical drain cleaner that combines both lye and bleach. It can be used with any septic system, PVC, plastic, steel, and old pipes, and garbage disposals. It destroyed the clog of flour and butter we used in our tests and mostly dissolved the pasta as well. It was relatively effective against hair, too, so we think it can be used in the bathroom and kitchen alike. In addition, it gets the job done in seven to 15 minutes, so it works very quickly.
However, it lacks viscosity, which prevents it from cleaning off debris that clings to the pipe walls. We didn’t find it very user-friendly, as it needs to be measured, it’s difficult to check how much is remaining, and it has a wide mouth, which makes it likely to come gushing out if you’re not careful.
pH level | Alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 1-5% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 16 fl. oz. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 7-15 mins. |
Precautions | Keep out of reach of children. Harmful if swallowed. Avoid splashing. Injures eyes, skin and mucous membranes on contact. Do not use with ammonia, toilet bowl cleaners or non–Liquid-Plumr® clog removers, as splashing or the release of hazardous gases may occur. Clean up any spillage immediately. |
Amount | 32 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Xanthan gum, alcohol ethoxylate, modified magnesium silicate |
This product comes in a recycled plastic container and is very environmentally friendly. They claim it’s less dangerous to humans than chemical drain cleaners because it doesn’t contain bleach or lye. It has to be measured out, but the container is translucent, making it easy to see how much is left, so we gave it a good rating for ease of use.
In addition, it also performed well in the bathroom clog-clearing test, as it took out all the hair and is perfect for unclogging the shower drain. However, it’s not very effective at dissolving things that cause clogs in the kitchen sink. It also takes six to eight hours to work, so it’s not ideal for people looking for a fast-acting product. In addition, it’s not very viscous, so it struggles to remove debris adhered to the pipe walls.
pH level | Alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 16 fl. oz. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 6-8 hrs. |
Precautions | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Immediately call a poison center or doctor/physician. IF ON SKIN (or hair): Remove/Take off immediately all contaminated clothing. Rinse skin with water/shower and wash with soap and water. Wash contaminated clothing before reuse. IF INHALED: Remove victim to fresh air and keep at rest in a position comfortable for breathing. If still irritated call a poison center or doctor/physician. IF SWALLOWED: Rinse mouth. Do NOT induce vomiting. |
Amount | 1 gal. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Caustic replacement 5-10%, lauramine oxide 1-5% |
Green Gobbler Main Line Opener can be used with septic tanks and for a wide range of drains, including kitchen sinks, showers, garbage disposals and toilets. It comes in a one-gallon jug, which is about 10 uses. It dissolves hair very effectively, so it’s ideal for clearing shower drains. It only takes 30 minutes to work, so you can clear your drain quickly.
However, it doesn’t dissolve food waste very well, so we don’t recommend using it in the kitchen. In addition, it’s not very viscous and struggles to clean the pipe walls. The wide mouth causes the liquid to gush out at times and it’s difficult to tell how much is left in the container.
pH level | Alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | Residential main lines: entire bottle, sinks and tubs: one-half quart to one-quart. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 30 mins. to overnight |
Precautions | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. Hazard statements: May be corrosive to metals. Causes skin irritation. Causes serious eye damage. Keep only in original container. Wash hands thoroughly after handling. Wear protective gloves, eye protection. If on skin: Wash with plenty of water. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Immediately call a poison center or doctor. |
Amount | 80 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Bleach, lye |
The Drano Max Gel Drain Clog Remover is a chemical drain cleaner. In addition to the 80-ounce size we tested for this article, it also comes in a smaller 32-ounce size. It only takes between 15 and 30 minutes to clear the drain, so it’s a fast-acting cleaner. It dissolved most of the clogged hair in our test, so we found that it’s very effective for bathrooms.
On the other hand, it wasn’t effective against kitchen clogs other than flour, so it’s not the best product for that job. It’s also not particularly viscous, so it isn’t the best product for clearing debris off the pipe walls. You need to measure it out when you use it and can’t check how much is left easily, so it’s not exactly user-friendly.
pH level | Alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | - |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 16-32 fl. oz. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 15-30 mins. |
Precautions | WARNINGS: DANGER: KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN. HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED. MAY BURN EYES, SKIN, AND MUCOUS MEMBRANES ON CONTACT. Do not use or mix DRANO MAX GEL with any other cleaners or chemicals, as hazardous fumes or a violent reaction may result. If gases are released, leave area immediately-ventilate if possible. Keep container tightly closed and store in locked cabinet. FIRST AID: GIVE IMMEDIATELY. EYES: Rinse immediately with water. Remove contact lenses, then flush eyes with water for 15 minutes. IF SWALLOWED: Rinse mouth. Drink a cup of milk or water. Do not induce vomiting. IF ON SKIN: Remove affected clothing. Flush skin with water for 15 minutes. IN ALL CASES, CALL POISON CONTROL CENTER OR PHYSICIAN. Contains sodium hydroxide, sodium hypochlorite, and sodium silicate. |
Amount | 4 packets |
---|---|
Type | Packet |
Ingredients | Alcohols, malic acid, sodium lauryl sulfate, sulfonic acids, alkyl, sodium salts |
This product is separately packaged in the exact amount you need for each use. It’s recommended that you use it once a week, and it comes in a pack of four, or about a month’s supply. You don’t need to measure it out and you only have to wait for the bubbles to dissipate, which takes just one to two minutes. It contains ingredients that foam easily, so by pouring hot water down the drain, you can give it volume that helps it adhere to the pipe walls and clear off debris.
However, it struggled to dissolve hair and food waste, so we don’t expect it to clear stubborn clogs and we don’t recommend it for that, but it’s great for weekly maintenance to prevent slime and odors.
pH level | Acidic |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | N/A |
Amount needed to clear slime | 1 packet |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 2 mins. |
Precautions | IF ON SKIN: Wash with plenty of water. If skin irritation occurs: Get medical attention. Specific treatment (see information on this label). Take off contaminated clothing and wash it before reuse. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. If eye irritation persists: Get medical attention. |
Amount | 6 tablets |
---|---|
Type | Tablets |
Ingredients | D-limonene, paraffin, lanolin, yellow dye, citral, blue dye |
This is a tablet-type drain cleaner that gives off a gentle lemon scent when used. It only takes 20 minutes to work and all you have to do is place the tablet in the drain, so it’s very easy to use.
However, it completely failed to dissolve hair and barely dissolved food waste, so we don’t think it will do a good job clearing stubborn clogs. Also, because it’s a tablet, it doesn’t adhere to pipe walls and clean them off. While it’s easy to use, don’t expect it to clear difficult clogs. This product is better off being used for maintenance twice a week to prevent slime and odors.
pH level | Neutral to slightly acidic |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | N/A |
Amount needed to clear slime | 1 tablet |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 20 secs. |
Precautions | Wash thoroughly after handling. Wear eye protection. Response IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. If eye irritation persists: Get medical attention. |
Amount | 32 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Bacillus bacteria |
This product uses microbes that eat debris clogging your drain and contains citrus oil, giving it a pleasant fragrance. It’s a highly viscous liquid, helping it adhere to pipe walls and clean them. While you do need to measure out the correct amount to use, its translucent container lets you easily see how much is left. It also has a small-mouth opening, making it easy to avoid pouring more than you want.
However, it couldn’t dissolve hair or butter at all and left most of the food waste as well, so it’s not ideal for tackling tough clogs. It also needs to be left overnight, which isn’t ideal.
pH level | Neutral |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 4 fl. oz. every other day |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | - |
Precautions | *See full precautions and directions for use on the product. If more than an incidental amount is swallowed, seek medical attention immediately. Give one glass of water and do not induce vomiting. Wash hands well water for 15 minutes. Seek medical attention for any persistent irritation. |
Amount | 5 packets |
---|---|
Type | Packets |
Ingredients | Sulfuric acid, sodium salt |
This drain cleaner comes in individually wrapped tablets and can be used in the bathroom, kitchen, and even the toilet. As such, you don’t need to go through the hassle of measuring how much you need. It bubbles up quickly, helping it stick to the walls of the pipe and take down grime stuck to them. On top of all that, it only takes 15 to 30 minutes to work.
However, it can’t break down hair or food waste well, so it doesn’t seem very effective against stubborn clogs. It’s hard to evaluate a drain cleaner highly when it struggles to perform its main job.
pH level | Strong acid |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 1-2 packets |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 15-30 mins. |
Precautions | See full precautions and directions for use on the product. Causes serious eye damage Wear eye protection, protective gloves. IF IN EYES: Rinse cautiously with water for several minutes. Remove contact lenses, if present and easy to do. Continue rinsing. Immediately call a poison center or doctor. |
Amount | 64 fl. oz. |
---|---|
Type | Gel |
Ingredients | Decyl glucoside, fragrance, phenoxyethanol, viable culture blend, benzisothiazolinone, sodium hydroxide, propylene glycol, glycerin |
Earthworm Drain Cleaner & Buildup Remover is characterized by its citrus and sage scent. It uses natural enzymes instead of lye or bleach, making it better for the environment. It wasn’t able to break down hair or food waste very effectively in our test, so we don’t expect it to clear clogged drains.
It isn’t very viscous, so it doesn’t adhere to the pipe walls very well, either. We didn’t find it very user-friendly, as it needs to be measured and the container has a wide mouth, meaning you run the risk of having the liquid come gushing out. You also need to keep adding more for three to five consecutive nights, making cleaning your drain a very long chore.
pH level | unknown |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | - |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 6-8 fl. oz. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | Overnight for 3 nights |
Precautions | If accidentally ingested drink large quantities of milk or water and seek medical attention. Avoid direct contact with eyes. |
Amount | 2 lbs. |
---|---|
Type | Powder |
Ingredients | Amylase, cellulase, lipase and protease enzymes, non-pathogenic bacteria |
Bio-Clean uses their own unique blend of natural bacteria and four kinds of enzymes that they claim eliminates waste from pipes and sewage treatment systems. When we actually tested the product, it didn’t break down hair, oils, or food waste very thoroughly and didn’t seem capable of clearing stubborn clogs in either the kitchen or bathroom.
It’s also not very easy to use, as you need to measure it out and mix the powder with water first. In addition, it has low viscosity and doesn’t stick to the pipe walls, so it struggles to remove dirt and grime from them. While it is environmentally friendly, it doesn’t have much dissolving power and has to sit for six to eight hours.
pH level | unknown |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | 1-3 tbsp. |
Amount needed to clear slime | - |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | 6-8 hrs. |
Precautions | May cause eye irritation, 2B. If in eyes: Rinse with water |
Amount | 12 sticks |
---|---|
Type | Stick |
Ingredients | Sulfuric acid, calcium salt, sodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate, cellulose, 2-hydroxyethyl ether, lipase, triacylglycerol |
These strips are meant to be used for clearing clogs and eliminating odors. They come in a pack of 12 and should be used once a month, meaning you use one pack per year. It comes in the form of a stick, so you don’t need to measure it out. However, we observed that most of the hair, oils, and food waste were still present even after eight hours, so this isn’t the best bet against tough clogs. It also doesn’t clean the pipe walls very well.
This product is meant to be used once a month, so it’s not great for clearing clogs and you’re better off using it to protect your drain from slime.
pH level | Slightly alkaline |
---|---|
Percentage of lye | 0% |
Amount needed to clear a clog | N/A |
Amount needed to clear slime | unknown |
Minimum amount of time needed to sit | Dissolves over 1 week |
Precautions | Hazard statements (GHS US): Causes skin irritation, wear protective gloves and eye protection |
We took some of the top-selling drain cleaners from Amazon, Walmart, and other sites, and tested them to find the best one. Here at mybest, we define that as one with great dissolving power that adheres well to the pipe walls, is easy to use, and works fast.
We tested the drain cleaners for the following things.
Products we tested
We started by testing how well each product dissolves clogs in the bathroom. We filled a graduated cylinder with water, added things that often cause clogging in the shower, and put in the drain cleaner. We waited the maximum time listed in the instruction manual and checked how well the cleaner dissolved the contaminants. For products that need to sit for more than a day, we interpreted that as waiting overnight and let all such products sit for eight hours.
We used the following things that cause shower clogging.
We then tested how well each product dissolves clogs in the kitchen. We filled a graduated cylinder with water, added common culprits of kitchen sink clogs, and put in the drain cleaner. We waited the maximum time listed in the instruction manual and checked how well the cleaner dissolved the debris. For products that need to sit for more than a day, we interpreted that as waiting overnight and let all such products sit for eight hours.
We used the following things that cause kitchen sink clogging.
If the cleaner adheres to the pipe walls, it can stick to debris easily as well, making it effective at clearing slime and clogs. We checked how well it adhered to the pipe walls by pouring it into a U-shaped pipe. For gels, we also measured how far it reached when poured into the pipe and checked the viscosity.
If you plan to use the cleaner for regular drain maintenance, you’ll want a product that is easy to use. We looked at the following things to test how easy each cleaner is to use.
Cleaning the drain is a hassle and you want to get it done as quickly as possible, so we tested how long you need to let the cleaner sit. We evaluated based on the shortest time listed in the instruction manual, with shorter times being better.
While homemade cleaners can’t measure up to commercial products in terms of effectiveness, they are cheaper and more environmentally friendly, so a lot of people want to try using them. If you want to give one a shot, we’ll tell you how to make a simple drain cleaner at home.
All you need is baking soda and vinegar. Mix together a half cup of baking soda and a half cup of vinegar and pour it in the drain. Let it sit for one hour and then pour boiling water down the drain.
No. 1: up & up|Clog Clearing Gel
No. 2: Liquid-Plumr Pro Strength|Clog Destroyer Gel
No. 3: XionLab|Safer Drain Opener
No. 4: Green Gobbler|Main Line Opener
No. 5: Drano|Max Gel
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Health
Beauty
Home goods
Home electronics
PC
Camera
Food and drinks
Kitchen
Fashion
Accessories
Kids and baby
Interior
Hobbies
Outdoor
Home, garden, and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Media
Games
Apps
Automotive
Gifts
Mobile devices