15 Best Toilet Plungers in 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

The Korky BEEHIVE Max fits both old low-flow toilets and new toilets with oblong openings and sports a unique beehive-shaped cup that makes unclogging a breeze. In testing, we were able to clear the clog with just two plunges. The head is quite large and capable of storing a considerable amount of water, allowing it to force a high quantity of water into the pipe with each push and earning it a high rating.

The rubber of the beehive-shaped head is designed with a thick upper part and a thin, flexible bottom part that allows it to easily create an airtight seal. In addition, the hard upper part prevents it from warping when pushed. We felt that the power applied transferred completely to the head. You don't need to use much force, so it doesn't cause water to splash out of the bowl.

Regarding the handle, we found its T-shaped design appealing, as it allows you to hold it with both hands. The matte finish makes it easy to grasp and it's fairly slim, making it comfortable to hold even for those with small hands. It's made from a material that isn't stained by dirty water, so wiping it off after washing is enough. On the other hand, it's enormous and weighs a considerable one pound six ounces, making it hard to carry.

However, this plunger can't be beaten when it comes to easily clearing blockages, which is the most important property of a plunger. For those with sanitary concerns, it would be a good idea to buy the plunger holder that supports this product, too.

One thing that sticks out when looking at the Clorox toilet plunger is its 15-and-a-half-inch ergonomic handle. It comes with a caddy that hides the rubber head, so you can keep your bathroom looking sleek and clean. When we tried removing a clog with this product, it got the job done with just four plunges and minimal effort, resulting in a stress-free experience. It can create an airtight seal around the pipe, so you don't need to use much strength with this plunger. Thus, it doesn't cause much splashing, allowing you to wipe the floor down after use.

The top of the handle is a broad, triangular tip, so it doesn't dig into your hand when plunging. On the other hand, it's made from a slippery material, so it lost some points on ease of handling.

Regarding sanitation, this product received high marks for its included self-opening and -closing caddy that includes a drip tray inside. Due to its excellent ventilation, the head can be dried efficiently and stored without getting the floor wet. It's extremely easy to use, as it opens automatically when the plunger is lifted and closes automatically when it is placed back in. On the other hand, it makes a loud noise when closing, which is a negative. You should definitely consider this product if you're looking for a plunger with a sanitary design that clears clogs easily.

NEIKO's toilet plunger has a four-step level suction cup and claims to create a seal around almost any toilet drain opening. The handle is made of aluminum, which is easy to use and gives it a stylish modern look. In our test, it was able to break up the toilet paper blockage in just five plunges.

It lived up to its claim by creating a tight seal around the toilet drain. We could feel water being pushed out with each plunge and didn't need to apply much force. This led to very minimal splashing, which is a plus. Regarding the handle, it's the perfect size for gripping and is appropriate for any hand size. On the other hand, the hook on the tip dug into our hands when plunging, causing pain and disrupting the process. Moreover, there's no rubber grip to prevent it from slipping, making it hard to grip.

It doesn't come with a caddy, so it loses points in sanitation. However, we gave it points for using aluminum, which is resistant to rust, mold, and household bacteria, for the handle. For those with sanitary concerns, consider buying a caddy with an attached toilet brush. If you're worried about whether the plunger will fit your toilet, we recommend this product. This is also an excellent option for those who want to store their plunger by hanging it by a hook.

In our test, the Yanxus plunger took 11 pumps to clear the blockage, which wasn't the best result. Still, the hard rubber head creates a powerful seal, so you don't need to exert a lot of strength to use it. This makes plunging 11 times not so stressful.

It boasts an ergonomically designed handle, and its rounded tip makes it decently easy to use. We didn't feel any pain from the handle digging into our hands. However, at one pound two ounces, it is a little heavy when cleaning or moving the plunger. Regarding the design, we really liked the self-opening and -closing caddy, which opens when the plunger is lifted and closes when it's placed back. It also has a ventilation slot to improve airflow in the drip tray installed in the caddy.

The Mainstays three-piece toilet set comes with a tough toilet brush equipped with polyester bristles. The good thing about this set is that you can store your essential bathroom items together without taking up much space. As for unclogging the toilet, this plunger performed well, clearing the blockage in just eight plunges. We felt that the cup created a tight seal around the drain.

The handle is robust and fits nicely in the hands, so it doesn't require a lot of strength to use. However, we noticed a considerable amount of splashing when using this plunger, so it's important to take the proper preventative steps. As for the handle, it has a matte finish and feels nice to hold. However, the tip is a bit narrow, and we felt some pain when it pushed into our palms.

The caddy that allows you to store it with a toilet brush earned it a good evaluation. It's very easy to use, as you only have to place the plunger in the caddy. It's not designed to hide the head, though, so this may not be the right product for someone aiming for a stylish bathroom. That being said, if you're looking to store your brush and plunger together, this is a good option.

The Good Grips toilet plunger by OXO was created with the concept of universal design in mind. Its rubber head is designed to work on all toilets, including low-flush models. It wasn't the most effective in our test, as it took 11 plunges to clear the blockage. But the handle's rounded tip made it easy and stress-free to use, and the surface of the shaft is easy to grip.

On the other hand, it weighs in at one pound, and 2.4 ounces, making it difficult to handle. This product performed poorly in splash resistance because it forced the water to overflow. It's important to cover the floor with rags or newspaper when using this product. However, the handle was long enough to prevent dirty water from splashing on our hands.

It comes with a self-opening and -closing holder. Inside the holder is a drip tray with excellent ventilation, which helps evaporate water. That being said, it takes a lot of work to clear blockages and causes a lot of splashing, so it's a step below the top-ranked products.

The Simplehuman toilet plunger sports a handle made from corrosion-resistant stainless steel. The included caddy has a magnet that attaches to the plunger, allowing it to be stored in style. It took a lot of work to remove the toilet paper clog; in fact, 12 plunges. The cup was a little too small to cover the drain hole of the toilet we used, so we found it hard to establish an airtight seal. On top of that, it took a lot of force to create the seal, leading to significant splashing.

The substantial tip at the end of the handle is fantastic. Moreover, the narrow part makes it easy to grasp, so we have no complaints there. On the other hand, it weighs a whopping one pound and seven ounces. Despite the weight, after attaching the magnet to the plunger, you can pick them up together, which is convenient when cleaning the floor. The ability to hide the rubber head is another good point. This isn't a bad choice if you're looking for a sanitary and stylish design.

The Rocky Mountain Goods plunger is compact, with a handle length of just nine inches. It can also be used for sinks, bathtubs, and shower drains. In our test, it took 10 plunges to unclog the pipe. Since it fits snugly to the drain on the bottom of the toilet bowl, it generated a decent amount of power when pushing water. However, a major downside of this plunger when using it on a toilet is its short handle, which causes dirty water to get on your hands. This plunger should only be used on toilets with a shallow bottom.

Despite not causing a lot of splashing, the wooden handle gets soaked with dirty water, making it unsanitary. On top of that, it's hard to grip and push because it's made of wood. Even still, it's extremely light at only five ounces, making it very easy to carry. If you want to use it mainly for the sink or shower, you might want to consider this plunger.

The Kendik toilet plunger is from a tire recycling company and is characterized by its head made of high-quality rubber and a wooden handle. It did not perform so well in the unclogging test, as it took 11 plunges to clear the blockage.

This was caused by the shape of the rubber, which does not fit well with the complex shape of the toilet bowl. It struggles to create an airtight seal, so you need to exert a lot of strength when plunging. The handle is hard to grip and not well finished, and we noticed wood splinters on it. On the plus side, splashing was practically non-existent.

Luigi's toilet plunger claims to clear pipes by blasting them with water rather than air. It's characterized by its bellows-like design, which reaches deep into the drain. In actuality, we were unable to unclog the pipe even after 15 pumps. Blasting the water didn't require much strength, but on the downside, we noticed a considerable amount of splashing.

We felt that the wide tip of the handle made it easy to use, but the joint was weak and bent easily. The included caddy earned a good score. However, the caddy is deep and doesn't have a drip tray, so make sure to keep it clean.

The toilet plunger and brush combo by MR.SIGA has an all-black design that helps give your bathroom a chic look and keeps your toilet items in one place. This product failed to unclog the pipe in our test, though, only moving the blockage two inches after 15 plunges. This may be due to the small size of the cup and its inability to create a tight seal.

We also had concerns about the thin tip of the handle, which digs into your hand and makes it hard to use. Regarding splashing, a lot of water overflowed out of the bowl due to the need for vigorous plunging. It seems to have a sanitary design with the included caddy, but it doesn't include a drip tray.

The Get Bats Out toilet plunger is a heavy-duty mid-sized plunger. With a total length of 21 inches, they claim it can fit in almost any cabinet or under most sinks. This product performed poorly in our test, as the clog only moved a mere inch after 15 plunges. We didn't feel that it created much of a seal around the drain.

In addition, even after pushing out the flange, it went back in after making contact with the drain. You have to touch the rubber cup, which is covered in dirty water, in order to fix this, which is very unhygienic.

Water gushes out of the bowl with each plunge, so we also evaluated it poorly in terms of splash reduction. There is a hook on the end of the handle, so you can't push down there while plunging, requiring you to squeeze the shaft. While the matte finish gives it a good grip, it's very slim and not ideal for those with large hands.

The DEFLECTAIR is an accordion-type plunger that claims to be able to push out a large amount of water. On the plus side, the handle and head can be disassembled, making it easy to clean. Unfortunately, the toilet paper blockage moved only three-quarters of an inch after 15 plunges.

In addition, the accordion-type head stores a lot of water inside and requires a lot of force to push, causing a large amount of water to spill from the bowl. In terms of sanitation, it's easy to clean because it's made of plastic and can be disassembled. However, it does not come with a caddy, so you have to place it directly on the floor.

The JS Jackson plunger, which can also be used for kitchen sinks, comes in six different colors to suit your style. When it comes to unclogging a toilet, it performed poorly, as it didn't move the blockage at all. To make matters worse, it requires a lot of strength with each push and causes a lot of splashing off of the accordion head.

The tip of the handle is of sufficient width for plunging, but the joint between the handle and the cup is very fragile and bends easily. While its weight of just eight and a half ounces makes it easy to carry, the plastic it's made from makes it feel like a toy and it is unfortunately difficult to grip.

The PWWDADA plunger comes in the classic design of a red rubber cup attached to a long wooden handle. Aside from toilets, it can also be used on various other types of drains. When actually used to unclog a toilet, we did not observe any hint of movement of the blockage after 15 plunges. When using this product on something with a complex shape like a toilet, the rubber head caves in, and fixing it is extremely stressful.

The lack of a tight seal made the water splash easily, and the area around the toilet got significantly wet. The handle is made of wood, which is not ideal from a hygiene perspective. The product we purchased also was cracked, so we weren't able to handle it with ease.