mybest
ErasersHelping You Find the Best
mybest
ErasersHelping You Find the Best
  • Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More) 1
  • Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More) 2
  • Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More) 3
  • Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More) 4
  • Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More) 5

Best Erasers of 2024 (Staedtler, Paper Mate, and More)

If you work at a desk with paper and pencil, a dependable eraser is essential in your arsenal of stationary implements. There are various brands and types of erasers such as plastic, rubber, and kneaded erasers—some of which are better suited to erase pencil or pen.

In this article, we’re going to help you decide which eraser you need and recommend you the 10 best erasers on the online marketplace. We loved the erasers from Paper Mate and Ticonderoga for their versatility. Check out our list for more!
Last updated 09/01/2024

Quick List - Top Erasers

1

Paper Mate

Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser12 count
Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser

Tried and Trusted Schoolyard Rubber Eraser

2

Ticonderoga

Classic Pink Erasers
Classic Pink Erasers

Precision Erasing, Perfect Results

3

Pentel

Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small
Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small

Small, Soft, and High-Quality PVC Erasers

4

Amazon

Amazon BasicsAmazon Basics Block White Eraser
Amazon Basics Block White Eraser

Efficient Eraser for Clean Corrections

5

Staedtler

Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser
Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser

Phthalate-Free, Latex-Free, and Long Lasting

mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

How To Choose an Eraser – Buying Guide

If you’re in the market for a new eraser, what qualities should you be looking out for? There are several important factors, such as eraser material, design, and grip. We'll go through some points to consider when buying an eraser here.

1

Choose Your Material Depending on Application

What are you using this eraser for? Are you erasing pen, pencil, or something else? There are roughly four categories of erasers, and the answer to the aforementioned questions will guide you to the right choice. Here they are.

Vinyl Eraser Are Trendy and Durable

Vinyl Eraser Are Trendy and Durable

Also known as plastic erasers, these are made from vinyl chloride and work pretty well. Vinyl erasers are able to erase pencil and ink with ease. In addition, the leftover residue from the eraser tends to bunch together, leaving you with little mess to clean up.


Vinyl erasers are hard and rigid, and can therefore tear the paper without much force. They also shrink at an alarming rate, so you will need to use them with caution. However, if you’re allergic to rubber, vinyl is a great option.

The Familiar and Nostalgic Rubber Eraser

The Familiar and Nostalgic Rubber Eraser

When you think of an eraser, you probably envision the pink and rubbery eraser shown above. Rubber erasers are ubiquitous in schools all around the United States and can come in a variety of colors other than pink. They were the first type of eraser invented and are still reliably used to this day.


The latex harvested from the rubber tree is used to make these erasers. Synthetic alternatives exist, though they are cheaper and not as effective as natural rubber.


Rubber erasers are sturdy and don’t run out too fast. They, however, do not erase ink and, unless you exert some force, aren't always great with pencil, either. But be careful not to apply too much pressure on a rubber eraser, as they’re known to break in half. They also harden after being exposed to too many ultraviolet rays, so get something you can use up quickly.

Gum Erasers Are Pliable and Better for Large Areas

Gum Erasers Are Pliable and Better for Large Areas
Gum erasers are very soft and are normally used to erase large areas of paper. They’re actually made of rubber, but are much more pliable. Because their soft composition won’t tear up the paper as much as a vinyl or traditional rubber eraser would, they’re often used by artists.


Additionally, their rectangular shape allows you to choose between using a small (the corner) or large (the face) surface area when you’re erasing. For artists, the ability to go small allows for a more precise erase. That means a better drawing or picture.

Kneaded Erasers are Malleable and Leave No Mess

Kneaded Erasers are Malleable and Leave No Mess

Kneaded erasers are almost primarily used by artists, and they don’t just erase—they can also function as a type of highlighter. They are malleable and can be shaped, or kneaded, into whatever form works best for the artist. 


Unlike other eraser options, kneaded rubber ones actually pull the graphite from the paper and essentially absorbs it, leaving no shavings behind. However, the eraser will eventually darken from all the graphite.


Most kneaded erasers can absorb chalk, pastels, charcoal, and, sometimes, colored pencils. Be careful not to leave them in hot environments for too long, as they’re likely to lose their shape and become unusable.

2

Get an Eraser That Doesn't Require Effort to Work

Get an Eraser That Doesn't Require Effort to Work

If your eraser doesn’t erase well, you’ll spend more time erasing and less time writing. So if you want an efficient eraser, get something that’ll erase without you grinding it into the paper. This isn’t something you’ll figure out by just staring at the eraser, though, so read through the customer reviews.

3

Prevent Breakage by Buying a Stiff Eraser

Prevent Breakage by Buying a Stiff Eraser

Unfortunately, erasers do break. If you’re concerned about this happening, opt for a stiff and dense eraser that can withstand your elbow grease.


Note that the sleeve that's wrapped around an eraser is also an important factor. If the little sash of cardboard around your eraser has the corners cut out, it means your eraser is going to have a hard time snapping. 


When you press down on your eraser, you’re actually digging the sleeve into it. If the corners are notched, the sleeve’ll actually open up a bit, easing up pressure on your eraser and preventing it from easily breaking.

4

Choose an Eraser That's Easier to Clean Up

Choose an Eraser That's Easier to Clean Up

When using an eraser, you’ll often end up with shavings all over your lap, your desk, or your rug. In order to prevent this, get an eraser whose shavings clump together neatly or roll into a ball. You can check out reviews or look at the descriptions for erasers to check out how erasers function when they erase.


In addition, shavings from white erasers can be hard to see. It’s a good idea to get a colored eraser so the shavings stick out.

5

Check the Shape of the Eraser for Practical Purposes

Check the Shape of the Eraser for Practical Purposes

You might be an artist and have artistic inclinations to choose an eraser depending on how it looks. However, what’s more important is your ability to actually keep your eraser for an extended amount of time. 


Choose an eraser that’s easy to fit in your pen case and one that actually works for what you want to erase in order to get the most out of your product. Practicality is everything.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Erasers

Contrary to what most people think, an eraser isn't just a rectangular piece of plastic you use to get rid of marks. There are so many types, including ones that are kneaded or made out of rubber, vinyl, or gum.
Popularity
Filter
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
Details
Material
Ease of Use
Stiffness
Malleable
Eraser Shavings
Shape
Paper Tear
1

Paper Mate

Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser12 count

Paper Mate Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser 1

Tried and Trusted Schoolyard Rubber Eraser

Rubber

Wedge

2

Ticonderoga

Classic Pink Erasers

Ticonderoga Classic Pink Erasers 1

Precision Erasing, Perfect Results

Rubber

Wedge

3

Pentel

Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small

Pentel  Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small 1

Small, Soft, and High-Quality PVC Erasers

Plastic

Rectangle

4

Amazon

Amazon BasicsAmazon Basics Block White Eraser

Amazon Amazon Basics Block White Eraser 1

Efficient Eraser for Clean Corrections

Plastic

Rectangle

5

Staedtler

Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser

Staedtler  Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser 1

Phthalate-Free, Latex-Free, and Long Lasting

Vinyl

Rectangle

6

Faber-Castell

Kneaded Eraser, Grey

Faber-Castell  Kneaded Eraser, Grey 1

A Kneaded Option that Can Be Used to Lightly Erase

Plastic

Malleable

7

Tamaki

Large White Erasers for School, 6 Pack

Tamaki Large White Erasers for School, 6 Pack 1

Clean Erasing, Every Time.

unknown

Rectangle

8

Mr. Pen

Pink Pencil Erasers

Mr. Pen Pink Pencil Erasers 1

Designed by Teachers, Made for Excellence

Vinyl

Wedge

9

Tombow

MONO Sand Colored Pencil Eraser 2pk

Tombow MONO Sand Colored Pencil Eraser 2pk 1

Environmentally Friendly All-Encompassing Eraser

Rubber

Wedge

10

Prismacolor

Prismacolor Kneaded Rubber Eraser

Prismacolor Prismacolor Kneaded Rubber Eraser 1

Erase More Precisely With This Large Kneaded Rubber

Rubber

Malleable

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Paper Mate
Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser12 count

Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser 1
Source:amazon.com
Paper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser 2
Lowest price
$6.92
High Mid
Lowest price
$6.92
High Mid
MaterialRubber
Malleable

Tried and Trusted Schoolyard Rubber Eraser

You've likely used this eraser before in school. We’ll bet, however, that you didn’t know that the very concept of the pink eraser has been around since the late 1800s, and it all started with the Pink Pearl. It's both a nostalgic childhood staple and a simple, latex-free eraser.

Its flat surface and rounded edges offer you precise and general erasing capabilities. However, you’ll have a hard time erasing pen marks with this eraser, and doing so will likely tear the paper. It's best to use this eraser for any type of pencil writing, and it's especially good for children's' schoolwork.
Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeWedge
Paper Tear
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Ticonderoga
Classic Pink Erasers

Lowest price
$4.15
Low Mid
MaterialRubber
Malleable

Precision Erasing, Perfect Results

Ticonderoga Pink Erasers are designed for effective use at home, school, or the office. Featuring beveled edges, these erasers offer enhanced control, allowing for precise removal of black pencil marks without smudging or leaving excessive residue. They are soft, latex-free, and gentle on paper, minimizing the risk of tears.


These erasers are PMA certified non-toxic, ensuring they are safe for all users, including children. The combination of their high-quality material and practical design makes Ticonderoga Pink Erasers a reliable choice for anyone in need of clean and efficient corrections.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeWedge
Paper Tear
View all
No.3

Pentel
Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small

Lowest price
$2.19
Low
MaterialPlastic
Malleable

Small, Soft, and High-Quality PVC Erasers

Pentel's Hi-Polymer Block Erasers are latex-free and come in a pack of three. You don't need to put a lot of pressure on it when getting rid of stubborn marks and they don't smudge or ghost. Since they are made of hi-polymer, these erasers will stay soft for longer—always ready to get rid of stains. 

Each eraser in this pack comes with a sleeve that will help extend the eraser’s life. Though it does shed a lot, reports suggest that this eraser does a great job getting rid of charcoal and pastels. It also works well for your typical standardized testing bubble sheets.
Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeRectangle
Paper Tear
View all
No.4

Amazon
Amazon BasicsAmazon Basics Block White Eraser

Lowest price
$6.99
High Mid
MaterialPlastic
Malleable

Efficient Eraser for Clean Corrections

This eraser swiftly removes lead-pencil marks from paper without smudging, ensuring neat and precise corrections. Designed for minimal pressure, it maintains paper integrity while offering a secure, comfortable grip with its rectangular block shape


Made of quality white TPR, it guarantees reliable performance for erasing small mistakes or lines of text from various applications, from handwritten notes to math homework.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeRectangle
Paper Tear
View all
No.5

Staedtler
Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser

Lowest price
$6.38
High Mid
MaterialVinyl
Malleable

Phthalate-Free, Latex-Free, and Long Lasting

Staedtler is another long-loved German brand of stationery makers with a tried and trusted eraser. Their offering is phthalate- and latex-free, and also comes in a pack of four, so you won't need to be buying new ones any time soon. You can also feel good about making purchases from the company, as they support eco-friendly processes and sustainability.

One reviewer says that the erasers do smear when used, so they may not be the best option for creating artwork. Others were unhappy that they received only one eraser as opposed to the four that should have come in a pack.

Reviewers were happy that it was easy to use these erasers smoothly, without tearing the paper underneath. A lot of engineering students seem to like it and say it lasts a long time (up to 6 months to finish one eraser). 

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeRectangle
Paper Tear
View all
No.6

Faber-Castell
Kneaded Eraser, Grey

Lowest price
$3.56
Low Mid
MaterialPlastic
Malleable

A Kneaded Option that Can Be Used to Lightly Erase

If you’re an artist, you’re probably familiar with the company Faber Castell. They are one of the world’s oldest stationery and art supply companies based in Germany. Their offering is a kneaded eraser that can absorb pencil and charcoal. The advantage is that it can be morphed into whatever shape you desire.

This eraser is not recommended for erasing large drawings or papers. It also won’t pull all the graphite from your drawing if you don’t want it to. If you only want to lighten your drawing (or your essay), just apply light force and let the eraser do the trick. And though some reviewers mentioned that this kneaded eraser is particularly soft,  others liked that it was easy to mold.
Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeMalleable
Paper Tear
View all
No.7

Tamaki
Large White Erasers for School, 6 Pack

Lowest price
$4.99
Mid
Materialunknown
Malleable

Clean Erasing, Every Time.

These soft high-quality, latex-free erasers are designed for effortless pencil mark removal. Each eraser is individually wrapped and comes with a protective sleeve to keep both you and the eraser clean. 


Measuring 1.8 x 0.8 x 0.39 inches, these erasers erase cleanly without scratching the paper, remaining soft and ready to use for precise corrections. Enjoy the convenience and reliability of this 6-pack, perfect for home, school, or office use.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeRectangle
Paper Tear
View all
No.8

Mr. Pen
Pink Pencil Erasers

Lowest price
$4.99
Mid
MaterialVinyl
Malleable

Designed by Teachers, Made for Excellence

Crafted by educators with firsthand experience in challenging classrooms across the United States, the Mr. Pen Eraser is meticulously designed to meet the rigorous demands of daily use. Its efficient design swiftly removes lead-pencil marks from paper without smudging or smearing, ensuring clean, precise corrections. 


Made from high-quality white TPR, this eraser maintains a clean appearance and offers reliable performance, ideal for erasing small mistakes or lines of text from handwritten notes, math homework, and more. The rectangular block shape provides a secure, comfortable grip, requiring minimal pressure to preserve the integrity of your work.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeWedge
Paper Tear
View all
No.9

Tombow
MONO Sand Colored Pencil Eraser 2pk

Lowest price
$6.50
High Mid
MaterialRubber
Malleable

Environmentally Friendly All-Encompassing Eraser

Effortlessly remove colored pencil and ink marks, including ballpoint, rollerball, and some marker, with the MONO Natural Rubber Latex Ink Eraser. Crafted from natural rubber latex and silica grit, this environmentally friendly eraser is ideal for creating artwork highlights and ensuring clean, precise corrections. 


Each pack contains two erasers, providing reliable performance and sustainability in every use.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeWedge
Paper Tear
View all
No.10

Prismacolor
Prismacolor Kneaded Rubber Eraser

Lowest price
$4.69
Mid
MaterialRubber
Malleable

Erase More Precisely With This Large Kneaded Rubber

Prismacolor’s kneaded offering is big enough that it'll last you a long time. This eraser removes chalk, lightly used colored pencils, pastels, and charcoal. Because it’s kneaded, it’s not going to leave shavings—instead, it’s going to absorb the markings and eventually become discolored. It also takes some time before it becomes pliable, so make sure to use it a lot so you can shape it and make it more precise.

When a certain side of the eraser is too worn, simply fold it into itself and use another side of the eraser. No matter what you decide to use this eraser for, it will offer you a greater degree of control over your work.

Ease of Use
Stiffness
Eraser Shavings
ShapeMalleable
Paper Tear
View all

For More Erase Power, Check Out These Other Options

There’s alternatives to purchasing an eraser. If you’re feeling up to the challenge, you can actually make an eraser yourself! You can also buy correction tape to help you get rid of other marks and stains.

Make an Eraser With Eraser Clay

Make an Eraser With Eraser Clay
Visit your local craft store and look for eraser clay. Don’t be afraid to mix and match colors to make an eraser in your preferred style. Once you get the clay, simply mold and shape it to the form that you want.


Generally, a good eraser should be large in size and have a few sides so it’s easy to grip. Having a blocky (versus a round or amoebic) eraser give you the freedom to erase big or small. You probably already have tools in your kitchen that will help you cut and shape your eraser. Consider butter knives, dough rollers, and toothpicks for this purpose.


Once you've shaped and cut it, then you're ready to start using it! This is a simple way to make your own personalized eraser.

Equip Yourself With Correction Tape for Added Protection

Equip Yourself With Correction Tape for Added Protection
Remember that time you filled out a document with a ballpoint pen only to realize you made a mistake at the very beginning and now you have to redo everything? Sometimes, an eraser just won’t get rid of these marks—and sometimes you don't have enough room to rewrite that section in the blank space still available. 

Introduce correction tape into your arsenal of supplies, and there won’t be any error you can’t cover up. Once the white tape covers your mistake, simply write on top of it and no one will know the difference.

Top 5 Erasers

No. 1: Paper MatePaper Mate Pink Pearl Eraser12 count

No. 2: TiconderogaClassic Pink Erasers

No. 3: Pentel Hi-Polymer® Eraser, Small

No. 4: AmazonAmazon BasicsAmazon Basics Block White Eraser

No. 5: Staedtler Staedtler Plastic Vinyl Eraser

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Erasers

Folders for School

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.