Gel pens offer a comfortable grip that makes for a smooth writing experience. Pens with a fast-drying formula can even minimize smudging. They can be used for everything from taking notes in class to signing documents. But with so many available from brands like Pilot, uniball, Paper Mate, and Sharpie, it can be difficult to choose the right one.
We tested our gel pens based on the following criteria:
We rigorously tested 12 bestselling gel pens to recommend the best one for you. mybest defines the best gel pen as one that writes smoothly, doesn't smudge, and lasts for a long time. We ranked the top-performing models, and we'll help you choose the best one for you in our buying guide.
Fernanda, or fer_plans on Instagram, is a dedicated stationery enthusiast passionate about planners, journals, fountain pens, and inks. Her captivating content showcases her unwavering love for all things stationery, making her a valuable resource for fellow enthusiasts seeking advice and inspiration.
Kohei works on articles covering a variety of daily goods. Since joining mybest, he has mainly overseen men's fashion products, comparing more than 400 items. Currently, he is working on creating helpful content for users, expanding his scope from daily necessities such as detergents and fabric softeners to stationery and interior goods.
We searched for pens that write fluidly while producing a uniform amount of ink.
We tested for pens that fit comfortably in the user's hand with a balanced weight distribution.
We think most people would prefer to use a pen that doesn't bleed when highlighted, so we looked for smudge-resistant models.
To find gel pens whose ink dries immediately after writing and won't smudge when touched by hand, we used the following method to review each product.
We thoroughly tested how long each pen could hold up for long-lasting use.
All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.
Table of Contents
Gel pens offer an ergonomic and comfortable writing experience, ensuring clear and uniform lettering. While their ink takes slightly longer to dry, it's important to be mindful of potential smudging, especially when underlining or highlighting soon after writing. The gel ink's smooth and consistent flow requires minimal pressure, reducing hand fatigue during extended writing sessions. This makes them particularly suitable for lengthy note-taking or meetings.
Ballpoint pens, on the other hand, dry quickly and are less likely to smudge but may be uncomfortable to write with for long periods. There are also a limited number of color choices, with black being the most common color. While water-based ball pens offer a bit more comfort, they're more prone to smudging when highlighted or if the ink gets wet.
Gel pens combine the vibrant colors and smooth writing experience typical of water-based pens, along with the consistent reliability-in-writing of oil-based pens.
Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Gel Pens.
Writing with the Sarasa dry X1 results in clear lettering with no interruptions. The ink flow is also consistent, giving your writing a clean, professional look. Our testers generally agreed that it "wrote fluidly with no irregularities."
Other pens we tested weren't as consistent with the amount of ink produced and resulted in inconsistent line thickness. Taking into account that some weren't as comfortable to hold either, we recommend the Sarasa dry X1 if writing comfort is your top priority.
Gel pens with a rubber grip are less likely to slide around, making it even easier to write. Pens with only a plastic surface often slip, so it's hard to keep the tip steady. Another feature that makes gel pens more stable is their low center of gravity. You'll find that the balance transfers to your hand and results in a comfortable hold.
Pens with the right thickness will fit naturally between your fingers, which prevents strain and fatigue when writing for long periods. If you use a pen that's too thick or thin, you may end up unconsciously adding extra pressure while writing, making your hand sore.
The Sarasa dry X1 has a rubber grip to prevent slips. In contrast, our testers found that some of the lower-scoring pens either didn't stay in place or were too thick to hold comfortably. We rated products for comfort and the presence of non-slip grips to help you find the best pen.
Have you ever accidentally smeared ink on the page while writing or had it smudge after using a highlighter over it? A gel pen that's smudge-resistant and dries quickly is the perfect solution to these frustrating problems.
Not all gel pens are equal when it comes to smudge resistance and drying speed. Ones that dry as soon as you've written reduce the chance of smudging if you accidentally touch the page. This also helps readability when using a highlighter on top of it, as the ink doesn't smudge.
Fast-drying ink is particularly important for left-handed people, who are a lot more likely to touch the page as their hand moves across it. Using a gel pen with fast-drying ink is the most reliable way to prevent this.
Since every pen holds a different amount of ink, you should check beforehand to get an idea of how long it can be used. Even pens of the same length can hold a different amount of ink if the barrel is larger. When we tested each pen's capacity, we found that those with thicker barrels typically held more ink.
However, a pen that stores more ink is not always better. This is because the consistency of the ink also comes into play. If you're looking for a gel pen that lasts as long as possible, check the ink capacity scores in our ranking.
Products | Image | mybest Score | Click to purchase | Key features | Main Score | Details | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Writing comfort | Ease of holding | Resistance to smudging | Ink dry time | Ink capacity | Length | Maximum diameter | Weight | Grip material | Barrel material | Pen mechanism type | Nib Shape | Range of tip sizes | Refillable | Model number of refills | ||||||
1 | Zebra Pen SARASA dry X1 Gel Retractable | ![]() | 4.55 | mybest's Top Choice: Writes Smoothly and Consistently Without Smearing | 4.71 | 4.76 | 4.32 | 4.65 | 3.88 | 5.6 in. | 11.5 mm | 0.39 oz. | unknown | Plastic | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | unknown | unknown | |
2 | Pentel of America EnerGel RTX|BL77BPA | ![]() | 4.50 | Quick-Drying and Comfortable to Hold | 4.76 | 4.35 | 4.39 | 4.65 | 4.02 | 5.8 in. | 10.9 mm | 0.42 oz. | unknown | Recycled plastic, Stainless steel | Retractable | unknown | 0.7mm | unknown | ||
3 | Newell Brands Sharpie S-Gel|2096134 | ![]() | 4.46 | Good Smudge Resistance, Drying Speed, and Writing Comfort | 4.53 | 4.71 | 4.33 | 4.29 | 4.18 | 14.7 in. | 10.5 mm | 0.35 oz. | Rubber | Plastic | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | 2096168 | ||
4 | Mitsubishi Pencil Gel Pens 207|1791453 | ![]() | 4.25 | Solid, Consistent Writing but Grip Is Uncomfortable | 4.35 | 3.81 | 4.36 | 4.65 | 4.45 | 5.6 in. | 11.5 mm | 0.32 oz. | Rubber | Polyester | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | 170207 | ||
5 | BIC USA BIC Gel-ocity Quick Dry Gel Pens | ![]() | 4.23 | Currently unavailable | Fits Comfortably in Your Hand, but Takes Time to Dry | 4.29 | 4.47 | 4.33 | 3.93 | 3.84 | 5.8 in. | 12.0 mm | 0.39 oz. | unknown | unknown | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | unknown | |
6 | Newell Brands Paper Mate InkJoy Gel Pens|1951640 | ![]() | 4.19 | Some Writing Inconsistencies, but Smudge-Resistant and Quick-Drying | 4.11 | 3.93 | 4.45 | 4.65 | 4.25 | 5.7 in. | 10.5 mm | 0.39 oz. | unknown | unknown | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | unknown | unknown | |
7 | Pilot Corporation of America Dr. Grip | ![]() | 4.06 | Long-Lasting but Takes a Full 7 Seconds to Dry | 4.35 | 4.53 | 4.37 | 3.00 | 4.36 | 5.6 in. | 13.8 mm | 0.71 oz. | unknown | Metal | Retractable | unknown | 0.7mm | unknown | ||
8 | Zebra Pen G-750 Retractable Gel|49811 | ![]() | 4.04 | Dries in Only a Second, but Feels a Little Weighty | 4.47 | 3.46 | 4.42 | 5.00 | 3.22 | 5.6 in. | 9.5 mm | 1.06 oz. | Brass | Brass | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | 88112 | ||
9 | Pilot Corporation of America G2 Premium Gel Roller Pens | ![]() | 3.98 | Makes Up for Slow Drying Time with a Large Ink Capacity | 4.17 | 4.29 | 4.30 | 3.00 | 4.76 | 5.6 in. | 11.3 mm | 0.35 oz. | Rubber | Plastic | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | unknown | ||
10 | Shuttle Art Retractable Black Gel Pens | ![]() | 3.97 | Slip-Free, Easy to Hold, but Has Inconsistent Lines | 4.29 | 4.35 | 4.26 | 3.00 | 4.08 | 5.7 in. | 10.3 mm | 0.35 oz. | unknown | unknown | Retractable | Conical | 0.7mm | unknown |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
The only downside was the ink capacity, which was only just enough for a single notebook. You would have to replace it regularly, but considering the writing comfort, resistance to smudging, and ink-drying speed, this gel pen gets our highest recommendation.
Maximum diameter | 11.5 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Plastic |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | unknown |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
The ink from this pen dried after about 2 seconds, so even left-handed people shouldn't have to worry about smearing the ink if they accidentally touch it. While the lack of any bleeding was a plus, it also only holds enough ink to fill a single notebook, so you'll need to restock regularly.
Maximum diameter | 10.9 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Recycled plastic, Stainless steel |
Nib Shape | unknown |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | Rubber |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
For the most part, the ink didn't bleed after being highlighted and was fully dry after 3 seconds. It's unlikely for this ink to smudge even when you're taking notes quickly in class. Considering it can fill up just over one notebook, the ink capacity is average. It won't need to be replaced too frequently, but it's not particularly long-lasting either.
Maximum diameter | 10.5 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Plastic |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | 2096168 |
Grip material | Rubber |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
As for drying speed, the absence of ink bleeding or smearing was satisfactory. This gel pen is an excellent choice for taking notes in class. Since one pen contains enough ink to fill between 1 ½ to 2 notebooks, you won't need to repurchase frequently.
Maximum diameter | 11.5 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Polyester |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | 170207 |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
Maximum diameter | 12.0 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | unknown |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
Maximum diameter | 10.5 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | unknown |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | unknown |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
Maximum diameter | 13.8 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Metal |
Nib Shape | unknown |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | Brass |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
This pen only holds enough ink to fill about half a notebook, so you'll want to buy refill cartridges along with the pen itself. While it does write smoothly across the page without interruption, it's also noticeably heavy to the point where you may get tired of holding it after a while. We also found that the grip material sometimes causes the pen to slip from the hand.
Maximum diameter | 9.5 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Brass |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | 88112 |
Grip material | Rubber |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
Maximum diameter | 11.3 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Plastic |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | unknown |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
Maximum diameter | 10.3 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | unknown |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | Plastic, Renewable wheat straw |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
The U-Eco Gel Click Recycled Plastic Pens by UBrands are primarily made of recycled straw instead of plastic. The pen's ink showed no signs of bleeding, and we generally liked the brisk feeling when writing with it. However, there was some noticeable friction, so those who prefer pens with more fluidity might not enjoy it. The plastic material of the barrel also felt like it slipped around a bit. This pen's light weight didn't lend itself to a natural balance of gravity. The ink of this pen rarely smudged, but it needed a full 7 seconds to dry, so we wouldn't recommend them for jotting things down quickly. In terms of ink capacity, one pen couldn't fill up a single notebook, so it will need to be replaced frequently.
Maximum diameter | 10.0 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Plastic, Renewable wheat straw |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | unknown |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Grip material | Rubber |
---|---|
Range of tip sizes | 0.7mm |
What we loved
What we didn't love
While testing for smudge resistance, there was visible ink bleeding, so you won't be able to use a highlighter over the top. The ink capacity was enough to fill up about a single notebook, putting it around the mid-range. Also the ink required over 7 seconds to dry, so it won't be a good fit if you're left-handed or often draw pictures or charts.
Maximum diameter | 12.9 mm |
---|---|
Barrel material | Plastic |
Nib Shape | Conical |
Refillable | |
Model number of refills | unknown |
Products we tested
We searched for pens that write fluidly while producing a uniform amount of ink.
We asked 6 product testers (3 men and 3 women) to write with each pen and rate how likely they would be to recommend it.
We tested for pens that fit comfortably in the user's hand with a balanced weight distribution.
We asked 6 product testers (3 men and 3 women) to pick up and hold each pen and score how likely they would be to recommend it.
We think most people would prefer to use a pen that doesn't bleed when highlighted, so we looked for smudge-resistant models.
After writing with each pen and letting the ink dry for one minute, we wrote over them with a yellow highlighter and then used a lux meter to measure the brightness of the resulting color. Those whose ink didn't bleed and left the highlighter color unchanged received the highest scores.
To find gel pens whose ink dries immediately after writing and won't smudge when touched by hand, we used the following method to review each product.
We measured how long it took the ink to dry by touching it after writing and gave the best scores to those that dried the fastest.
We thoroughly tested how long each pen could hold up for long-lasting use.
After marking the spot where the ink filled up to, we used each pen to write the letters of the alphabet until the ink had decreased by 1mm. We then used this to measure how many notebooks could be filled with a single pen and used those numbers for scoring.
No. 1: Zebra Pen|SARASA dry X1 Gel Retractable
No. 2: Pentel of America|EnerGel RTX|BL77BPA
No. 3: Newell Brands|Sharpie S-Gel|2096134
No. 4: Mitsubishi Pencil|Gel Pens 207|1791453
No. 5: BIC USA|BIC Gel-ocity Quick Dry Gel Pens
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Health
Beauty
Home goods
Home electronics
PC
Camera
Food and drinks
Kitchen
Fashion
Accessories
Kids and baby
Interior
Hobbies
Outdoor
Home, garden, and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Media
Games
Apps
Automotive
Gifts
Mobile devices