mybest
Setting Sprays

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Beauty
  3. Makeup supplies
  4. 12 Best Setting Sprays of 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]
12 Best Setting Sprays of 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

12 Best Setting Sprays of 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

Setting sprays are essential in preventing makeup from breaking down due to sweat, sebum, and dryness. Also known as fixing sprays, they are recommended for special events or to simply extend the wear of makeup on a long day. However, with so many options on the market, it can be difficult to figure out which is the best one.

We've compared 12 bestselling Setting Sprays available online and put them to the test to recommend the best for you.

We tested each product for the following:

  • Performance
  • Prevents dryness
  • Fragrance
  • Sensation of mist

Which product ended up being the best of the best? We'll also tell you how to pick the best Setting Sprays on your own in our buying guide, so read on for more shopping tips.

Last updated 11/24/2023
Natalya Lowe
Expert
Professional Makeup Artist
Natalya Lowe

Natalya is a professional makeup artist based in Los Angeles and has been trying new products to find what is best for each individual's skin tone and type. She is self-taught but wanted to further her education, and she went to a makeup school in Los Angeles to learn the ins and outs of makeup. She has tried many makeup brands and products and can proudly say she has found some of the best and longest-wearing products. As a freelance makeup artist, she wants her clients not to worry about their makeup not lasting as long as they need it to.

Natalya Lowe's Profile
…Continue reading
Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Guide
Head of Makeup at mybest
Aisha Kanaya Yuson

After Aisha Kanaya Yuson graduated from college, her interest in the beauty industry led her to complete a two-year program specializing in makeup. She moved to the U.S. by herself and settled in New York City, where she apprenticed under renowned makeup artists. She has expanded her field of activities by participating in fashion magazine shoots and assisting backstage at NYFW. She is currently affiliated with an artist agency in the U.S.

Aisha Kanaya Yuson's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

Scroll to testing method
We gathered the 12 bestselling Setting Sprays and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Performance

    1
    Performance

    We define a good setting spray as one that prevents makeup from breaking down. We gathered testers that have prior experience with using setting sprays, and asked for their evaluation on how well the setting sprays kept their makeup in place, and conducted the test in the following ways.

  2. Prevents Dryness

    2
    Prevents Dryness

    To set the standard for a setting spray that is resistant to dryness we had our experienced testers rate products within the context of being less drying, and conducted the test in the following ways.

  3. Fragrance

    3
    Fragrance

    We consider a setting spray with a good fragrance to be one that was evaluated by experienced testers who understand the importance of a pleasant scent, and conducted the test in the following ways.

  4. Sensation of Mist

    4
    Sensation of Mist

    We deem a setting spray with a good mist sensation as one that has been highly rated by experienced testers who recognize the importance of an even distribution of the spray. They also evaluated if it feels comfortable when applied to the skin.

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
We do not guarantee any of the results or features explained in our buying guide. Please reference each product's official description when making your purchase.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

Are Setting Sprays Really Effective?

Absolutely. Not only can setting sprays improve the durability and appearance of makeup, they can also prevent shine and makeup from breaking down.

Absolutely. Not only can setting sprays improve the durability and appearance of makeup, they can also prevent shine and makeup from breaking down.

Have you ever put on makeup in the morning and it looked absolutely beautiful, but by the afternoon, the T-Zone and the areas around the nose have gotten super oily, and makeup have started to flake off from the cheeks and chin?


In that case, using a setting spray may help with those problems.


Here at mybest, we have tested the performance of several setting sprays. After eight hours of wear, we evaluated the condition of the makeup and found that most of the products were effective in keeping makeup in place. Several testers mentioned after using the sprays, "I noticed less shine than usual," and "My skin felt hydrated and I didn't notice any tightness."


Since a setting spray only requires a few spritzes after your makeup application, it is definitely a handy item to have.

Natalya Lowe
Professional Makeup ArtistNatalya Lowe

A setting spray is a liquid mist typically containing ingredients such as water and alcohol, forming a protective veil over the makeup to keep it in place. Think of setting spray as a hairspray but for the face.

How to Choose Setting Sprays

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Setting Sprays.

1

To Extend the Wear of Makeup, Choose a Spray That has Alcohol and Polymers

These Ingredients Control Sebum and Reduce Shine While Preventing Makeup from Breaking Down

These Ingredients Control Sebum and Reduce Shine While Preventing Makeup from Breaking Down

One of the most important points to look for in a setting spray is how well it keeps makeup in place. If your makeup ends up getting smudged and faded, it will result in a messy look, even if you took the time to meticulously apply it the first place. So, be sure to check that your makeup stays intact.


Through our testing, we discovered that compared to not using a setting spray at all, the use of a setting spray resulted in less shine and made makeup more budge-proof in the T-Zone and areas around the nose. This was especially true when setting sprays that contained alcohol and polymers were used.


Alcohol helps in faster drying times, while polymers protect the face from sebum and sweat by forming a thin film on the skin, making it more resistant to breakdown than alcohol-free products.


For those who find it difficult to decipher which ingredients are considered polymers, we have simplified that process for you, so be sure to check the product rankings below.

Natalya Lowe
Professional Makeup ArtistNatalya Lowe

If you use a setting spray with alcohol, be sure to prep the skin beforehand with hydration. Be mindful of your skin's specific needs.

2

For Those with Dry or Sensitive Skin, Choose a Spray That Has a Moisturizing Formula

Preventing Dryness Means No More Cakey Makeup

Preventing Dryness Means No More Cakey Makeup

While alcohol is an important component to keeping makeup in place, it may cause irritation to those with dry or sensitive skin.


In that case, we recommend a setting spray that is alcohol-free and includes moisturizing ingredients. These ingredients prevent foundation from caking and creasing.


As a result of our testing, many testers have commented that they did not notice any dryness or patchiness when using a moisturizing setting spray.


On the other hand, using a setting spray without moisturizing ingredients didn't garner better results than not using a setting spray at all. For those who want to prevent dryness and patchiness, or those with dry or sensitive skin that cannot tolerate alcohol, be sure to check for moisturizing ingredients when selecting a setting spray.

Natalya Lowe
Professional Makeup ArtistNatalya Lowe

Some setting sprays can be used throughout the day to freshen up your makeup. If you tend to feel parched on the skin, respraying the face later in the day can never hurt to add that glow back

3

For Those Who Value Ease of Use, Consider the Sensation of the Mist and Fragrance

There are numerous setting sprays available on the market, but if you are going to use one, it might be better to choose one that you enjoy, and even look forward, to using. Keeping that in mind, through testing we have curated a list of features and recommended products for you.

Choose a Spray That is Easy to Control and Distributes Mist Evenly

Choose a Spray That is Easy to Control and Distributes Mist Evenly
One of the key factors that determines the ease of use of a setting spray is whether the mist is applied evenly to the face.

If the mist does not cover a wide surface when sprayed, the areas that did not get covered could end up smudging.


Through our evaluation, we discovered it was easier to spray and apply the mist evenly when a light push was all that it took to release the product.


Those who are concerned with ease of use, please check out the "Sensation of Mist" aspect in the rankings below.

Natalya Lowe
Professional Makeup ArtistNatalya Lowe

You can also keep setting sprays in the fridge for a cooling effect on hot summer days.

Fruity and Refreshing Scents Make a More Pleasant Experience

Fruity and Refreshing Scents Make a More Pleasant Experience

Fruity and refreshing scents were rated highly by our testers.


Our testers gave positive comments, such as "The refreshing scent was pleasant" and "The fragrance wasn't too strong nor was it uncomfortable to have on the face."


On the other hand, sprays that smelled strongly of alcohol were rated negatively, which lead to comments, such as "It smelled like medicine" and "Too strong."


If fragrance is your biggest concern, please try using the ranking below to narrow down your choices.

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybestAisha Kanaya Yuson

Once you try using a setting spray, you might find yourself paying attention its fragrance.


A good fragrance alone can lift your spirits and refresh you, so we recommend that you try to find a scent that you like.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?
We do not guarantee any of the results or features explained in our buying guide. Please reference each product's official description when making your purchase.

12 Best Setting Sprays Ranking

Here are the best Setting Sprays we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
For dry or sensitive skin
Alcohol-free
Pleasant fragrance
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Ranking spec
Details
Performance
Prevents dryness
Fragrance
Sensation of mist
Amount
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Alcohol-free
Waterproof
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent
1

Benefit Cosmetics

The POREfessional Super Setter

Benefit Cosmetics The POREfessional Super Setter 1枚目
4.13

Lightweight yet Resistant to Breakdown, Alcohol-free and Sensitive Skin-Friendly

4.02
4.32
4.08
4.23

4 oz.

unknown

unknown

2

E.L.F. Cosmetics

Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

E.L.F. Cosmetics Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist 1枚目
4.11

Resistant to Breakdown From Dryness With an Incredibly Appealing Scent

4.02
4.26
4.14
4.14

2.7 fl. oz.

3

Milani

Make It Last Original

Milani Make It Last Original 1枚目
4.01

Prevents Breakdown and Dryness, but Lacks Ease of Use

4.11
4.23
3.60
3.52

2 fl. oz.

3

One Size

On 'Til Dawn

One Size On 'Til Dawn 1枚目
4.01

Setting Spray In a Can That Is Both Refreshing and Resistant to Dryness

4.17
4.02
3.56
3.81

3.4 fl. oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

5

Morphe

Continuous Setting Mist

Morphe Continuous Setting Mist 1枚目
3.97

Prevents Sebum, Dryness and Is Comfortable to Use

4.05
3.90
3.96
3.84

2.8 fl. oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

5

Tarte

Shape Tape Stay Spray

Tarte Shape Tape Stay Spray 1枚目
3.97

Pleasant Candy-Like Scent, but Delivers An Uneven Spray of Mist

4.02
4.05
4.02
3.56

4 oz.

7

MAC Cosmetics

Prep + Prime Fix+

MAC Cosmetics Prep + Prime Fix+ 1枚目
3.86

Good for Preventing Dryness, but Lacks Ease of Use

3.84
4.11
3.84
3.46

3.4 fl. oz.

unknown

unknown

8

CharlotteTilbury

Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray

CharlotteTilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray 1枚目
3.84

Gives a Pleasant Fragrance and Mist, but Lacks Sebum Control

3.72
3.93
4.14
3.93

3.3 fl. oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

9

Maybelline

Maybelline New YorkFacestudio Lasting Fix

Maybelline Facestudio Lasting Fix 1枚目
3.80

Keeps Shine and Dryness in Check, but Lacks Ease of Use

3.93
4.05
3.44
3.32

3.4 fl. oz.

unknown

10

Lancome

Fix It Forget It Setting Spray

Lancome Fix It Forget It Setting Spray 1枚目
3.77

Extremely Effective in Preventing Dryness, but Breaks Down Easily

3.63
4.17
3.60
3.69

3.4 fl. oz.

unknown

unknown

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Setting Sprays
No.1 in Prevents dryness
No.1 in Sensation of mist

Benefit CosmeticsThe POREfessional Super Setter

mybest Score
4.13
Performance
4.02
|
Prevents dryness
4.32
|
Fragrance
4.08
|
Sensation of mist
4.23
View on Amazon
The POREfessional Super Setter Image 1
Lowest price
$28.70
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Lightweight yet Resistant to Breakdown, Alcohol-free and Sensitive Skin-Friendly

Benefit Cosmetics' The POREfessional Setting Spray not only boasts a long-wearing makeup look, but can also blur pores, leaving the skin smooth and refreshed. It also comes in a mini size for maximum portability.


Many testers who used the product commented on how it reduced shine, felt lightweight and not tight on the skin. Furthermore, it is alcohol-free and suitable for those with sensitive skin, making it easy to use on an every day basis. For those who find their eyebrows or blush fading throughout the day, please give this a try.


It has a subtle sweet scent that even people who are sensitive to fragrance can use. The spray pump is also easy to push, allowing the mist to come out finely and evenly coats the entire face, which is definitely another one of its attractive features.


With its refreshing scent and ease of use, it is perfect for both new makeup users and those who want to incorporate it into their existing makeup routine.

Amount4 oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproof
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

E.L.F. CosmeticsStay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

mybest Score
4.11
Performance
4.02
|
Prevents dryness
4.26
|
Fragrance
4.14
|
Sensation of mist
4.14
Lowest price
$12.37
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Resistant to Breakdown From Dryness With an Incredibly Appealing Scent

E.L.F. Cosmetics' Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist is a setting spray that claims to prevent skin irritation with the inclusion of anti-inflammatory ingredients, such as cucumber fruit extract, aloe vera, and green tea leaf extract. It also features a micro-fine mist for easy application.


This product was highly rated by all testers for being effective in keeping makeup in place. One tester commented, "Even after the spray dried, my skin did not feel tight," suggesting it may be suitable for those with dry skin as well. It comes in a portable size, making it very easy to travel with.


It has a scent reminiscent to the mist on a summer morning by a forest lake, which was popular among the testers and had a wide appeal. The spray pump was also easy to press, allowing for a fine mist that feels good on the skin.


It is a product you can rely on when you have plans after work or even for special events.

Amount2.7 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Waterproof
No.3

MilaniMake It Last Original

mybest Score
4.01
Performance
4.11
|
Prevents dryness
4.23
|
Fragrance
3.60
|
Sensation of mist
3.52
Lowest price
$9.99
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Prevents Breakdown and Dryness, but Lacks Ease of Use

Milani's Make it Last Original claims to prevent makeup from fading or creasing, extending makeup longevity. It comes in a transparent bottle that makes it clear how much product is left with just a glance.


Many testers reported no signs of flaking or creasing due to dryness even after eight hours, rating the product highly on its resistance to dryness. In addition, it was well-received in terms of preventing makeup breakdown as testers didn't notice any more shine than usual in their T-Zone or areas around the nose. It is also a reliable product for those whose eyeshadow or eyebrows tend to smudge or fade easily.


On the other hand, there were mixed reviews when it came to the scent and sensation on the skin, with additional complaints on the stiffness of the spray pump, and how difficult it was to adjust the amount of mist. The slight scent of alcohol was also a concern.


Since this product does get the job done by preventing breakdown and dryness, it can be considered satisfactory as long as ease of use and comfort aren't the main concerns.

Amount2 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Waterproof
No.3
No.1 in Performance

One SizeOn 'Til Dawn

mybest Score
4.01
Performance
4.17
|
Prevents dryness
4.02
|
Fragrance
3.56
|
Sensation of mist
3.81
Lowest price
$48.81
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formulaunknown
Film-forming agent

Setting Spray In a Can That Is Both Refreshing and Resistant to Dryness

One/Size is a brand founded by beauty influencer Patrick Starrr. On 'Til Dawn Setting Spray claims to have ingredients that even out skin texture and absorb excess sebum, while also keeping makeup in place and reducing the appearance of pores.


Many testers felt that their makeup didn't breakdown easily, solidifying its effectiveness as a setting spray. It is refreshing to use, and even after eight hours, the skin didn't feel tight or dry, furthering its appeal. It is perfect for not only locking in makeup on a long day, but also during the hot summer months when you can enjoy a cool mist from the unique spray can container.


There were comments saying the spray button was easy to use, and it applied an even mist to the face, but there were also comments that the mist was too fine, similar to hairspray, so opinions seem to have been split due to preference. Also, the lingering alcohol scent left a negative impression on many testers, resulting in lower ratings.


This may not be suitable for people who prefer a dewy finish with their setting spray, but it is recommended for those who favor a refreshing feeling.

Amount3.4 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproof
No.5

MorpheContinuous Setting Mist

mybest Score
3.97
Performance
4.05
|
Prevents dryness
3.90
|
Fragrance
3.96
|
Sensation of mist
3.84
Lowest price
$17.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formulaunknown
Film-forming agent

Prevents Sebum, Dryness and Is Comfortable to Use

Morphe's Continuous Setting Mist claims to contain skin-conditioning ingredients, such as Vitamin E, Vitamin B5, and fruit extracts. It is available in three sizes: mini, regular, and jumbo.


It was rated favorably in the fragrance test as having a scent that is universally appealing to everyone. However, there were mixed reviews on the sensation of the mist, with one tester stating, "The spray pump was a little heavy and the mist was more uneven than expected," leading to passable results. Therefore, it is highly suggested to check how much mist comes out before spraying onto the face.


On the other hand, it was comfortable to use, and eyeshadow and blush did not fade or smudge, so it was highly rated in terms of preventing breakdown and dryness.


It's also available in a mini size, so it's recommended for people who are looking for a setting spray for travel or for touch-ups during the day.

Amount2.8 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproofunknown
No.5

TarteShape Tape Stay Spray

mybest Score
3.97
Performance
4.02
|
Prevents dryness
4.05
|
Fragrance
4.02
|
Sensation of mist
3.56
Lowest price
$30.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Pleasant Candy-Like Scent, but Delivers An Uneven Spray of Mist

Tarte's Shape Tape Stay Spray is a product that claims to prevent makeup from melting, cracking, fading, or getting into fine wrinkles. It has the added bonus of being vegan friendly.


After eight hours of use, there wasn't much to criticize as there were almost no fading, color transfer, or smudging of the foundation. Additionally, the foundation didn't crease nor flake, so it can be said that it's effective in preventing breakdown and dryness. This would definitely be a great product for days when you want to put on a lot of makeup, or for when you are invited to a nice dinner.


On the other hand, it required several spritzes to evenly coat the whole face, which some may find troublesome. As this product has a candy-like scent, it is recommended for people who prefer sweet fragrances.


Considering the above points, the sensation of the mist may not be perfect, but it is a product easy to use on a daily basis.

Amount4 oz.
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Waterproof
No.7

MAC CosmeticsPrep + Prime Fix+

mybest Score
3.86
Performance
3.84
|
Prevents dryness
4.11
|
Fragrance
3.84
|
Sensation of mist
3.46
Lowest price
$23.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Good for Preventing Dryness, but Lacks Ease of Use

MAC Cosmetics' Prep + Prime Fix+ features four different scents: Original, Rose, Coconut, and Lavender. It is advertised to be used on its own or as a finishing touch to makeup.


It is a great product for those prone to dryness and during the dry winter months. Although it is alcohol-free and does not contain the scent of alcohol, opinions were divided among the testers, with low ratings given to the fragrance category.


On the other hand, while eyeshadow and blush did not fade or smudge, the product didn't do a very good job at reducing shine in the T-Zone or areas around the nose, leading to less desirable results. Furthermore, the spray pump was slightly stiff and difficult to control the amount of mist, making the experience somewhat lacking.


This may not be the best product for those concerned with controlling sebum, but those with dry skin may take a liking to it.

Amount3.4 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproof
No.8

CharlotteTilburyAirbrush Flawless Setting Spray

mybest Score
3.84
Performance
3.72
|
Prevents dryness
3.93
|
Fragrance
4.14
|
Sensation of mist
3.93
Lowest price
$36.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Gives a Pleasant Fragrance and Mist, but Lacks Sebum Control

Charlotte Tilbury's Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray boasts to keep your makeup looking fresh from the red carpet to the runway to your everyday life.


In the fragrance test, many testers commented, "It has a clean scent that even people with sensitive noses would like," and gave it a fairly high rating. Plus, the spray pump was easy to push and a fine mist applied evenly to the face. Not only does it keep makeup in place, but it also feels enjoyable to use and can easily uplift one's mood.


While the product seems to prevent dryness and received high ratings in that regard, testers commented on inconsistencies such as, "After eight hours, I noticed a bit of shine on my T-Zone and areas around my nose," thus receiving a low rating for preventing makeup breakdown.


It is alcohol-free and great for people with sensitive skin, but may be lacking for those who need a product with good sebum control.

Amount3.3 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproofunknown
No.9

MaybellineMaybelline New YorkFacestudio Lasting Fix

mybest Score
3.80
Performance
3.93
|
Prevents dryness
4.05
|
Fragrance
3.44
|
Sensation of mist
3.32
Lowest price
$7.94
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Keeps Shine and Dryness in Check, but Lacks Ease of Use

Maybelline's Facestudio Lasting Fix comes in an eye-catching magenta packaging, and claims to control shine and provide a matte finish that lasts for a long time.


In testing for dryness prevention, the product received high marks as it did not dry out the skin immediately after use or even eight hours later. It also did well in preventing makeup breakdown, with one tester commenting that "Even in shine prone areas, shine was reduced." As the product is good for both controlling sebum and preventing dryness, it can be counted on regardless of skin type or season.


On the other hand, the fragrance and sensation of mist weren't very favorable with the testers. There were many negative remarks regarding the alcohol scent and its effect on those who are sensitive to smells, as well as the problem of having to spray several times to mist the entire face.


If you're only concerned about keeping your makeup in place, then could be a good product for you. However, if you are particular about the feel of the product, you may better enjoy other products.

Amount3.4 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-free
Waterproof
No.10

LancomeFix It Forget It Setting Spray

mybest Score
3.77
Performance
3.63
|
Prevents dryness
4.17
|
Fragrance
3.60
|
Sensation of mist
3.69
Lowest price
$34.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Extremely Effective in Preventing Dryness, but Breaks Down Easily

Lancome's Fix It Forget It Setting Spray proclaims itself as an ultra-moisturizing setting spray that preserves makeup for a long time. It features a translucent bottle that allows you to see how much product is remaining.


Many testers noticed a lack of tightness in their skin, with some even commenting, "My skin felt moisturized even after several hours," indicating the product is excellent at preventing dryness. However, when testing on how well the spray holds against makeup, there was definite shine on the T-Zone and around the nose after eight hours, and eyeshadow and blush have become less vibrant. This led to a rather lackluster rating for breakdown prevention, and suggests that this product may not be suitable for people with oily skin or those who have trouble with sebum interfering with their makeup.


On top of that, the fragrance and sensation of the mist were not well received. Although it is alcohol-free, it had a strong odor and was difficult to spray evenly onto the face, losing it some points in those two categories.


Aside from people who have issues with dryness, this spray may not be appealing to anyone else.

Amount3.4 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendlyunknown
Cruelty-freeunknown
Waterproof
No.11
No.1 in Fragrance

Anastasia Beverly HillsDewy Set Setting Spray

mybest Score
3.76
Performance
3.54
|
Prevents dryness
4.05
|
Fragrance
4.32
|
Sensation of mist
3.87
Lowest price
$26.00
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Good Scent and Refreshing on the Skin, but Falls Short on Locking in Makeup

Anastasia Beverly Hills' Dewy Set Setting Spray has a water formula that glides lightly onto the skin, leaving it smooth and refreshed. It also doubles as a primer.


Its sweet scent and ease of use left a good impression among the testers. Even eight hours after spraying it onto the face, the skin didn't feel tight and moisture was retained the whole time, making it popular among the testers for its ability to prevent dryness. While some felt that the pump was slightly stiff and difficult to apply the mist evenly, it is still a great option for those with dry or sensitive skin that are concerned with dryness.


On the other hand, it didn't fare well in terms of keeping makeup in place, with one tester saying, "I was getting bothered by the shine on my nose and T-Zone and wanted to touch up my makeup."


Those with oily skin may want to stay away from this product, but for those who do not have issues with shine or wrinkles, it can be a good option.

Amount3.4 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Waterproof
No.12

NYX CosmeticsMatte Makeup Setting Spray

mybest Score
3.75
Performance
3.75
|
Prevents dryness
3.93
|
Fragrance
3.78
|
Sensation of mist
3.40
Lowest price
$10.39
Alcohol-free
Moisturizing formula
Film-forming agent

Prevents Dryness, but Fragrance and Ease of Use Are Lacking

NYX Cosmetics' Matte Makeup Setting Spray claims to control shine and maintain a long-lasting finish. It comes in a compact black packaging for easier use.


When put to the test, it received favorable reviews from testers, with one commenting, "My skin didn't feel tight despite having it on for a long time, and my foundation didn't flake or crease." While it did a good job on preventing flakiness, it was not effective in controlling sebum and preventing breakdown. After eight hours, the T-Zone starts to become noticeably oily, which may not be suitable for those with oily skin. However, if shine was minimized prior to spraying, it may be used without problem.


The fragrance test brought in mixed reviews as some testers reported a medicinal scent, while others weren't particularly bothered by it. Additionally, some testers felt the spray pump was a little stiff and the mist was uneven, resulting in average ratings.


While it has a big advantage in preventing makeup from creasing and flaking due to dryness, it doesn't have any other pros on top of being uncomfortable to use so there is no reason to choose this spray over any other.

Amount2 fl. oz.
Vegan-friendly
Cruelty-free
Waterproofunknown

How We Tested the Setting Sprays

Setting Sprays Evaluation

For our tests, we tried 12 top-selling setting sprays from retailers such as Amazon and other sites to determine the best product. At mybest, we consider a great setting spray to be one that doesn't dry out the skin even after prolonged use, and maintains a freshly-applied look without breaking down.

We tested each product on the following four parameters to find the best one.

  • Performance
  • Prevents dryness
  • Fragrance
  • Sensation of mist

Products we tested

  1. Anastasia Beverly HillsDewy Set Setting Spray
  2. Benefit CosmeticsThe POREfessional Super Setter
  3. CharlotteTilburyAirbrush Flawless Setting Spray
  4. E.L.F. CosmeticsStay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist
  5. LancomeFix It Forget It Setting Spray
  6. MAC CosmeticsPrep + Prime Fix+
  7. MaybellineMaybelline New YorkFacestudio Lasting Fix
  8. MilaniMake It Last Original
  9. MorpheContinuous Setting Mist
  10. NYX CosmeticsMatte Makeup Setting Spray
  11. One SizeOn 'Til Dawn
  12. TarteShape Tape Stay Spray
1

Performance

Performance

We define a good setting spray as one that prevents makeup from breaking down. We gathered testers that have prior experience with using setting sprays, and asked for their evaluation on how well the setting sprays kept their makeup in place, and conducted the test in the following ways.

Scoring Method

We asked testers to use and rate each product after eight hours, followed by a score of recommendation.

Testing Conditions

  • Testers: 5 women in their 20s and 30s that have used setting sprays before

Points of Consideration

  • Did it reduce shine in the T-Zone and areas around the nose? 
  • Did it prevent eyeshadow, blush, eyebrows, etc. from fading and transferring?
2

Prevents Dryness

Prevents Dryness

To set the standard for a setting spray that is resistant to dryness we had our experienced testers rate products within the context of being less drying, and conducted the test in the following ways.

Scoring Method

We asked testers to use and rate each product after eight hours, followed by a score of recommendation.

Testing Conditions

  • Testers: 5 women in their 20s and 30s that have used setting sprays before

Points of Consideration

  • After the mist has dried, does the skin feel dry and tight?
  • Did it prevent foundation from flaking and creasing due to dryness even after eight hours of use?
3

Fragrance

Fragrance

We consider a setting spray with a good fragrance to be one that was evaluated by experienced testers who understand the importance of a pleasant scent, and conducted the test in the following ways.

Scoring Method

We asked testers to use and rate each product's fragrance, followed by a score of recommendation.

Testing Conditions

  • Testers: 5 women in their 20s and 30s that have used setting sprays before

Points of Consideration

  • Is the scent too strong?
  • Is it clear what the fragrance is?
4

Sensation of Mist

Sensation of Mist

We deem a setting spray with a good mist sensation as one that has been highly rated by experienced testers who recognize the importance of an even distribution of the spray. They also evaluated if it feels comfortable when applied to the skin.

Scoring Method

We asked testers to use and rate how each product felt on their skin, followed by a score of recommendation.

Testing Conditions

  • Testers: 5 women in their 20s and 30s that have used setting sprays before

Points of Consideration

  • Is the mist fine and gentle on the skin?
  • Does the mist distribute evenly?

How to Use a Setting Spray, and Its Difference from a Primer

Primer Prepares the Face for Makeup, While a Setting Spray Completes the Look

Primer Prepares the Face for Makeup, While a Setting Spray Completes the Look

Both setting sprays and primers are used to improve the longevity of makeup, but they each have their own roles in a makeup routine.


Setting sprays are used at the end of makeup application to help keep makeup in place, prevent smudging, and leave the skin feeling refreshed. On the other hand, primers are used prior to makeup application to create a clean canvas for makeup to adhere to, blur pores, and extend the wear of makeup.


Similarly, primers should be chosen based on your skin type and concerns.

Aisha Kanaya Yuson
Head of Makeup at mybestAisha Kanaya Yuson

The next time you use your setting spray, try spraying a little bit on your brush to make your eyeshadow more pigmented.

Top 5 Setting Sprays

No. 1: Benefit CosmeticsThe POREfessional Super Setter

No. 2: E.L.F. CosmeticsStay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

No. 3: MilaniMake It Last Original

No. 3: One SizeOn 'Til Dawn

No. 5: MorpheContinuous Setting Mist

View Full Ranking

The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Beauty
  3. Makeup supplies
  4. 12 Best Setting Sprays of 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

Search by category