10 Best Eyebrow Gels in 2022 (Makeup Artist-Reviewed)

Pros:

• Lightweight formula for flexible, natural hold
• Hydrating formula with glycerin 
• Covers gray hairs well
• Waterproof, sweat-resistant, and smudge-proof
• Larger tapered triangle brush for quick application  
• Cruelty-free

Cons:

• Some customers say it didn't work for areas with little hair
  

This gel has a formula for a lighter hold. It eliminates reapplication as the larger tapered brush makes for quicker and easier application. Not only that, but it also covers gray hairs and is waterproof and smudge-proof.

Some reviewers with very light brows found it didn't fill in enough. However, the majority of users loved the long-lasting coverage this product provided. Some also loved how the spoolie allowed them not only to fill in sparse spots but also to draw in a bit of their eyebrow as well.

Pros:

• Formula has small microfibers that mimic natural hair to create a fuller brow 
• 10 shades to choose from
  
• Small spoolie for extra control 
• Lightweight formula 

Cons:

• A couple of people with naturally full brows said it didn't do much for them

This product has small microfibers that cling onto the skin and brows to mimic real hairs and create a naturally fuller brow. The applicator is also a smaller spoolie to provide better control and freedom over how and where to fill your brows. The formula is water-resistant and long-lasting while still being hydrating, with glycerin as an ingredient.

A couple of users said the product didn't do enough to change the look of their brows. However, the rest of the customers said this item is a staple in their makeup routine because of how easy it is to apply and how well it holds the brows to their desired shape. 

Pros:

• Highly pigmented formula for fuller and thicker brows
• Firm hold that lasts up to two days 
• Smudge-proof and waterproof 
• Comes with applicator tip and spoolie for precise coloring and shaping

Cons:

• Could be too pigmented for those looking for a natural look 

This gel is for those looking for fuller, thicker, and pigmented eyebrows with high resistance to water and smudging. Use the applicator tip to fill, shape, and define your brows, and the spoolie to volumize the hairs. It includes glycerin to keep the formula hydrating while still offering a strong hold.

The boldness of the formula did not impress some users, as they felt it was too thick and sticky and overly enhanced their brows. They suggested wiping down the sponge before use to get rid of excess product. Many other users with visibly sparse areas in their brows loved the product and found it held its fullness and boldness. 

Pros:

• Dual-sided with pencil and gel to shape and fill brows
• Sheer and tinted gel for natural look 
• Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers

Cons:

• No mention of whether it's waterproof 

This dual-sided product comes with a pencil to shape the brow and a sheer tinted gel to fill and enhance. Its two-in-one design is great for on the go and travel, and the formula is ophthalmologist-tested to be safe for contact lens wearers. As it's from Revlon's Colorstay range of products, you can expect effects to last for 24 hours.

Some users were disappointed at how the formula was too sheer to coat the eyebrow hairs to their liking. They've noted that you can expect a lightly polished look with this product. However, many more users loved the small spoolie, as it collected the perfect amount of gel and coated the brows without staining the area around them.

Pros:

• Formula includes hair-like fibers for a natural full brow look 
• Waterproof, smudge-proof, transfer-proof
• Five natural and matte shades to choose from 
• Vegan and cruelty-free
• Oil- and alcohol-free

Cons:

• Some customers had trouble getting used to the large spoolie

Wunderbrow eyebrow gel can fill, thicken, and define your brows and boasts an ability to be waterproof, smudge-proof and transfer-proof for up to three days. Its hair-like fibers fill your brows and sculpt them for a naturally fuller appearance. 

Some said that the big spoolie can cause a mess if not carefully used, and others thought the formula was too goopy or dark. But the majority of buyers said that all it takes is a bit of practice to get used to the applicators and find the right one for you. On top of that, they loved how natural the shades were and how long-lasting the formula was. 

Pros:

• Use with an angled brush to fill in sparse areas
• Waterproof and lightweight formula
• Can be used with a brush or spoolie depending on your needs
• Cruelty-free

Cons:

• Doesn't come with an applicator 

This lightweight gel is can be used to create hair-like strokes for filling in, and when it dries it controls any unmanageable brow hairs. The cruelty-free formula comes with waterproof properties for sweat- and smudge-resistance. However, note that it doesn't come with an applicator sponge, brush, or spoolie, so you must purchase your own.

Some users had trouble squeezing out the gel and did not like the darker color payoff. Nevertheless, most others were very impressed by how well it addressed any sparse brow issues for a thicker and fuller brow.

Pros:

• Comes with a sponge, brush, and spoolie for controlled application
• Transfer-, sweat-, water- and smudge-resistant
• Eight different natural shades to choose from 
• 48-hour longevity and hold 

Cons:

• Some buyers didn't like the applicators
• Others say it's hard to wash off
  

L'Oreal's waterproof brow gel fills any gaps and sparse areas. On top of the sponge applicator, you get a soft angled brush to outline your brows and a spoolie to polish. The formula creates a waterproof film around your brow hairs to last for up to 48 hours and is both transfer-proof and sweat-resistant.

Some found the included applicator hard to use, and others said if you make a mistake it's difficult to wash it off. That being said, most happy users said that careful application with the soft sponge gave the brows a great natural finish. 

Pros:

• Formula includes algae extract and other natural ingredients for hydration and conditioning
• Can cover gray hairs 
• Clear shade can double as a mascara 
• Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons:

• A few customers found this created an unnatural finish 

This conditioning gel comes infused with sea minerals which hydrate and moisturize your brows while coating and shaping them. Depending on the shade you choose, you'll also get hydrating and conditioning benefits from wheat protein, jojoba oil, and other botanicals.

A few customers noted that this formula leaves eyebrows looking unnatural as the applicator dispenses too much product. Others thought that the formula was clumpy. That being said, more customers enjoyed how this product helped plump their brows, and blondes especially enjoyed this product's tint. 

Pros:

• Comes in a clear shade for those with thicker eyebrows
• Cream and gel formula for hydrating and anti-flaking effects 
• Flexible hold for natural finish 
• Formula comes with light shimmer to add dimension to brows 
• Vegan
  

Cons:

• Some didn't like the applicator
• No mention of whether it's waterproof 

This lightweight gel gives a flexible hold for brows and comes in a clear option for people with naturally thick or full eyebrows. The formula uniquely includes a light shimmer to reflect light and add dimension to the brows. It also hydrates with glycerin as a moisturizing ingredient, so it might not suit those with oily skin around the brows. 

Some didn't like the applicator, which has long bristles on one side and short on the other. That being said, there were many fans of the clear shade, which people said did a great job at holding their desired eyebrow shape. Those with lighter eyebrows also said the shades helped them define their brows well.

Pros:

• Non-sticky formula 
• Can double as clear mascara
• Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons:

• Some users noted it felt stiff or flaky
  
• Buyers say it's not waterproof
  

This non-sticky formula is made to enhance and tame eyebrow hairs with a clear shade. It works well on powder or pencil, and the formula clings to your brows all day long. It can also double as a clear mascara for those who want to enhance their eyelashes too.

Some users noted that it felt a bit stiff and became a bit flaky once dry. However, the rest of the customers were very impressed by how natural and lightweight the formula was. They appreciated how well it worked for when they didn't want to wear much  makeup but just wanted to tame their brow hairs.