10 Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencils in 2022 (Milani, Tarte, and More)

This retractable pencil features an ultra-fine tip that's half a millimeter wide, which allows you to draw precisely to mimic natural brow hairs. This ophthalmologist-tested product also comes with a spoolie to fill in sparse areas and blend the product. 

Some reviewers noted that this pencil tended to smear when they got sweaty and touched their brows. Even so, a lot of reviewers confirm that its pointed tip makes it easy for them to achieve their desired look. Reviewers also like the formula's smooth consistency.

Milani's waterproof pomade eyebrow pencil is a classic non-retractable pencil. However, this pencil has a unique angled tip that will easily and precisely shape and fill in your brows. It also has a spoolie brush that can tame unruly hairs and make sure your brows are well-blended. 

Although this pencil has a good color pay-off, a few reviewers thought it was too soft and might not be the best option for people with very oily skin. Still, a lot of them loved how buildable and blendable the formula is. You can go for natural and bold looks with this!

Benefit's mini eyebrow pencil has a fine tip for defining and filling in your brows. Its smudge-proof formula will keep your eyebrows filled in throughout the day. The pencil also features a textured grip that will make drawing precise lines easier. 

Some reviewers noted that the product could be brittle and break easily when applied with too much pressure. Nevertheless, a lot of reviewers liked its size, noting how handy and portable the pencil is. Plus, they said the formula is smooth and gives natural-looking results. 

This set might have everything you need to keep your eyebrows defined throughout the day. The eyebrow pencil is dual-ended, featuring a pointed tip and an angled tip to create any look. It also comes with a separate dual-tipped brush to help you blend and shape your brows. 

Some reviewers shared that the tip can easily break, and they recommend only twisting up a little bit of product to prevent this. Still, many loved how the creamy formula glides on their skin. They also liked how it lasts the whole day. Reviewers especially praised the dual-tip and how handy it is, too.

This product might seem like a typical eyebrow pencil, but it features many beneficial ingredients. It has carnauba wax that allows for a smooth application. Plus, it has aloe extract that soothes and softens the skin. It also has vitamins A and E to keep your skin moisturized. 

However, some reviewers said it's not as long-lasting on people with oilier skin. Other than that, most reviewers loved its finish and how easy it is to achieve a natural look. Reviewers also confirmed that the product stayed on the whole day.

This waterproof eyebrow pencil has a precise tip for easy application and a built-in spoolie for blending. Moreover, its formula features castor oil and jojoba oil. Castor oil promotes eyebrow growth, and jojoba oil is an excellent moisturizer. 

A few reviewers noted that the pencil could break easily. Besides that, most reviewers loved the pencil's quality and how it truly stays on all day. They also liked how the product's skinny tip makes it easier to fill in precisely the brows.

On one side, this product has an angled applicator, while the other has both a soft-hold gel and a brow brush. The angled tip will help fill in your brows while the brush and gel will keep them in place. You can also trust the formula to stay on through sweat and humidity.

Some reviewers said that the product tends to break and dry up quickly. Be careful with the tip, and don't forget to cover it after using it. Nonetheless, most of the reviewers found the product very convenient; it makes doing their brows easier and faster. Plus, they said their brows still looked good at the end of the day.

Thrive Causemetic's eyebrow pencil is made with a semi-permanent micro pigment that makes it smudge-proof and waterproof. Moreover, it has a buildable pigment that reflects and matches your eyebrow color when you apply it. 

Some reviewers noted that the product does not adhere as well as on oily skin. Even so, a lot of reviewers shared that it truly did not budge throughout the day. They also liked that it is straightforward to use and has a flawless finish.

Urban Decay's eyebrow pencil is double-ended with a pointed tip and an ink stain tip. The result will provide you with a microblade look without the commitment. Use the pointy end to fill in gaps and the ink stain to make precise hair-like strokes. 

A lot of the reviewers liked how the pointed tip applies and how the stain mimics fine hair. However, a few reviewers noted that the ink stain left them with a green tint. Still, most reviewers loved how it stayed put the whole day and applied easily.

This is another go-to waterproof eyebrow pencil loved by the beauty community. It has a slim design for precise application, and the formula blends and builds easily. You can also trust the product to stay on for long periods of time. 

However, a few reviewers were disappointed that the product isn't as creamy as they hoped. Other than that, most reviewers loved how easy it is to use and how long it stays on! They also appreciated how it gives a natural finish.