10 Best Mystery Board Games in 2022 (Deception, 221B Baker Street, and More)

This is a game that can be played over and over again. With over 50 scenarios, no game is the same.

The players are trying to escape the omen-ridden house on the hill by discovering new rooms. At a random moment, one of the players becomes a traitor and a story is unveiled. The team works together to defeat the traitor as they try to use their powers to defeat the entire team.

Some players didn’t love the number of rules that the game has. They said that you have to read them many times in the beginning. Others mention the content is quite dark, and some were offended by this.

Other reviewers were delighted by the replayability of this game. They also loved how engaging it is, and that it can be enjoyed by both seasoned board game players and beginners.

If you don’t want to get stuck playing a really long game, Deception is a good choice. The game has one murderer and one forensic scientist. The goal of the team is to uncover the criminal along with the weapon that they used. Each game is about 20 minutes, and its 250 cards make it highly replayable.

Some reviewers said they found it too simple and it isn't much fun with only a few players. They said that six or more players leads to more discussion, with people moving around and interacting.

Other reviewers loved that is really quick, easy to learn, and easy to teach. They also liked the art a lot.

A witch hunt has started and the witch could be any of your friends. This traitor/identity game will make you trust no one. Though most of the players will be ordinary townsfolk, some of them will be witches who will try to either kill or convert the rest into witches in order to win the game.

Though some reviewers have complained that the rules are a little hard to understand, most said that it’s highly addictive once you get the hang of it. It can make the nicest of your friends become vicious liars for 45 minutes. They also said it’s expertly crafted.

This is a great game to keep players from getting too competitive. The players get a riddle and they’ll have to explore a series of clues that will help them solve the case. The game can be played by two or more, or even solitaire. There are 200 mysteries, so it has a lot of replay value.

Some reviewers complain that there were missing pieces. However, the rest of the reviewers say the rules are easy and it's fun for adults, older kids and teens. They love that it makes you think while not being overly complicated.

If you are looking within the no-competition realm but you have a bigger group of friends, you will like Mysterium. The players are all mediums or ghosts and work together to solve a crime that was committed at Warwick Manor. The game changes every time depending on the players.

Though it is advertised for two to seven players, the usual rules apply for four and up, and special rules have to be applied for two-and-three player mode.

A few reviewers have mentioned that it takes a long time and a bit of space to set up. Other reviewers, however, love how the game incites them to do abstract thinking. They also adored the art and the good quality of the components.

Exit can be played by one person or up to four. The players came to a haunted house to solve a crime, but they get locked inside. They will have to solve riddles and clues in order to escape before time runs out. 

It can only be played once, because you will damage some parts to reveal the solution. However, there are many spin-off versions in levels from novice to expert.

Some reviewers said that the puzzles are really a stretch and you have to think outside of the box in order to solve them. Other reviewers were fascinated by this game and that it’s like going to an escape room but staying at home. They said that it’s an exciting adventure and recommend others in the series too.

In this game, you are either a spy or a member of the resistance. The resistance will try to pass missions to overthrow the government, and the spies will do everything they can to prevent that from happening. The catch is that no one knows who is a spy and who is a rebel. 

The game is very compact so it’s easy to carry if you want to be the one who brings it to the party.

Some reviewers didn’t like that the mechanic of the game relies a lot on people talking and quiet players may get lost. Other reviewers thought that this is a really fun game. They especially loved how is suitable for a big group and big personalities.

The creators of the acclaimed murder mystery subscription box, Hunt a Killer, created a board game version. Unlike other games that are played with cards and boards, in this one you play with realistic props that will make you feel like a real detective. 

Once you discover the mystery, the game can’t be played again. However, it’s great for special occasions!

Some reviewers were disappointed that it involves a lot of reading and said that led to less discussion. Other reviewers really liked how detailed and thorough the clues are. They mention that even though you can't play again, nothing gets destroyed, so you can give the game to someone else after you play.

Of course, our list couldn’t be completed without mentioning the most famous mystery board game. There is a reason why this has been popular for 35 years, and that's because it's entertaining, the characters have funny, iconic names, and it’s easy enough for children to play. 

The game consists of naming the weapon, the room, and the person who committed the crime as you take on the persona of Colonel Mustard or Mrs. Peacock.

Some reviewers say they modified it to play with two people, but it doesn't really work well with fewer than three. Other than that, everyone is fascinated by Clue. They say that it’s great to have a good time with the family and that the retro version is mostly true to their memories from childhood.

If you like mystery games but you’re not into scary stories that involve ghosts, crime, and murder, you will like this one. The scene is the masquerade party of a wealthy art collector. However, there is a jewel thief among the guests. The players will have to use their deduction skills to find out who that is.

Some reviewers have mentioned that the game can get old or easy after a few rounds. Other reviewers, however, really liked how simple it is to play. They love that is a good game to play in families with children, and even some younger than the recommended age were able to pick it up.