mybest
Kitchen Trash CansHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Kitchen Trash CansHelping You Find the Best
14 Best Kitchen Trash Cans  [Tested and Reviewed]

14 Best Kitchen Trash Cans [Tested and Reviewed]

A kitchen trash bin with a lid can contain garbage while controlling the spread of the smell. With popular brands like Simplehuman, NINESTARS, IKEA, and more, the choices are plentiful. But not all trash bins are effective, even those with modern, high-end design. Since testing them in stores is impossible, it can be hard to decide which one is easy to use and effective at reducing odor.

This time, we gathered 14 popular kitchen trash cans with lids from the latest and best-selling items from various manufacturers and conducted a thorough review based on five points. We ranked our recommended kitchen trash cans with lids from best to worst.


At mybest, we define the best kitchen trash can as a high-capacity bin that reduces odor and stress during use. Below we break down the best way to find the right trash bin for you and explain our testing methods for the top-selling models so you can refer to this when making a purchase.

Last updated 03/29/2024
Eiichi Ishikawa
Expert
Olfactory Measurement Operator
Eiichi Ishikawa

Eiichi Ishikawa is a first-generation olfactory measurement operator, which is nationally recognized in Japan, making him an expert on smells. Eiichi is also a licensed odor control advisor. After working at two companies specializing in odor control, Eiichi launched his own firm as an odor detective, working with various TV shows, magazines, and major companies to test the deodorizing properties of various products as well as provides technical guidance.

Eiichi Ishikawa's Profile
…Continue reading
Masakazu Furukawa
Guide
Content Manager at mybest
Masakazu Furukawa

Masakazu Furukawa has been involved in the creation of over 5,000 articles across a broad range of categories, including everyday essentials, healthcare products, home appliances, financial services, and luxury goods. Currently, he oversees content in the Home Improvement and Everyday Essentials teams. With the aim of "providing choices that everyone feels good about making," he is dedicated to guiding teams and producing content.

Masakazu Furukawa's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

We gathered the 14 bestselling Kitchen Trash Cans and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Size

    1
    Size

    To measure whether the bin was of sufficient size, we established that the trash disposal frequency should be about three times a week for maximum user satisfaction.

  2. Odor Control

    2
    Odor Control

    Our standard for maximum odor control is a product where no odor leaks even after 30 minutes, no odor rises when opening and closing, and there is no remaining odor.

  3. Ease of Changing Trash Bags

    3
    Ease of Changing Trash Bags

    Our standard for bins that allow easy bag replacement is one that can replace the bag quickly with minimal stress.

  4. Ease of Opening the Lid

    4
    Ease of Opening the Lid

    Our standard for a trash bin that is easy to open and users can be very satisfied with means it is easy to use even if both hands are occupied.

  5. Ease of Disposing Trash

    5
    Ease of Disposing Trash

    Our standard for a trash bin that allows for easy garbage disposal is a product where the lid opens wide and does not interfere with garbage disposal.

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

The Benefits of a Kitchen Trash Bin With a Lid

A kitchen bin with a lid can not only consolidate household waste, it can also prevent odor leakage, which is crucial for any busy kitchen. Having a lid has several advantages.

You Can Hide Trash and Control the Smell

You Can Hide Trash and Control the Smell

First, since the garbage is out of sight with a lid, it hides the unsightly piles of trash that accumulate so easily in a busy kitchen. For health, safety, and aesthetic reasons, the kitchen should be a clean place in the house. With a lidded trash can, garbage is hidden, giving the entire kitchen a neat and tidy impression.


Furthermore, a trash bin with a lid is more effective at trapping odors, which can help you maintain a comfortable environment in the home.

How to Choose Kitchen Trash Cans

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Kitchen Trash Cans.

1

For Family Use, Choose Something With More Than 13.2 Gallon Capacity

For families of more than two people, household garbage tends to accumulate in large amounts very quickly, so we recommend a trash bin of the largest possible size.

Reduce the Frequency of Taking Out the Trash and Lighten the Burden of Housework

Reduce the Frequency of Taking Out the Trash and Lighten the Burden of Housework

A family of four produces approximately 17 pounds of garbage in one day, which is a considerable amount. Since one can only dispose of about 0.6 pounds of garbage per gallon, a garbage bin of more than 13.2 gallons is recommended. With a 13.2 gallon capacity, you can throw away about 35 pounds of garbage, so you only need to take out the garbage about once every two days.

 
The larger the size of the trash can, the less frequently you have to take out the trash, which can reduce the burden of trash disposal. If you want to reduce the frequency of trash disposal, consider something of more than 13.2 gallons.

2

For People Who Are Sensitive to Smell, Consider Cans With No Gap

For most trash bins, the cause of odor leakage lies in the gap between the lid and the body. To prevent this, choose something without a gap between the lid and the body.

Sealed Bins Make It Difficult for Odors to Escape

Sealed Bins Make It Difficult for Odors to Escape

To test how well sealed trash bins can reduce odor, we placed garlic in the trash bin, and checked after 30 minutes if there was any smell leaking near the lid. The results showed that almost no smell leaked from the bins without a gap between the lid and the body. So we can confidently say you should choose a bin without a gap between the lid and the body.

Masakazu Furukawa
Content Manager at mybest
Masakazu Furukawa

However, as the size increases, the lid size also increases and the scent tends to diffuse when it is opened and closed, so try not to leave it open for long periods of time.

3

Easy Use Means a Pedal System

Because kitchen bins usually require frequent use, the stress of opening and closing them is noticeable. So we recommend choosing a bin that allows for smooth usability, meaning minimal bending over and no need to fiddle with the various parts of the bin.

A Pedal Lets You Throw Away Trash When Both Hands Are Full

A Pedal Lets You Throw Away Trash When Both Hands Are Full

A trash bin with a pedal-opening system is easy to use, requiring just one light step to open the lid. These types of bins are convenient when both hands are occupied. Furthermore, if the lid opens more than 80 degrees, it makes it easier to throw away large trash. Therefore, even in a kitchen where the trash needs to be thrown away frequently, a pedal bin with a lid that opens more than 80 degrees is ideal for reducing stress.

4

Those Who Frequently Change Trash Will Find Top-Sealed Bags More Convenient

Bins That Secure Garbage Bags From the Top Allow For Quicker Bag Replacement

Bins That Secure Garbage Bags From the Top Allow For Quicker Bag Replacement

Trash bins that can secure the garbage bag near the top of the bin allow you to easily replace the garbage bag when needed and put the lid back on without any hassle. Trash bins without the ability to secure the bag in place risk the possibility that the bag will fall under the weight of the garbage, particularly if the bag size is too small


The butterfly-type trash can, which has two angled panels that swing open and close, is an outdated design that can be difficult to use because the bag holder hits the hand when changing the bag. For those who frequently replace garbage, we recommend a more modern garbage can with a lid where you secure the bag from the top.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

14 Best Kitchen Trash Cans Ranking

Here are the best Kitchen Trash Cans we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
Slim Trash Cans
Compact Size
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Main Score
Details
Odor Control
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
Ease of Disposing Trash
Ease of Opening the Lid
Size
Capacity
Width
Depth
Height With Lid Closed
Height With Lid Open
Weight
Material
Compatible Trash Bag Size
Opening Method
Includes Bag Holder
How the Lid Opens
Removable Lid
1

Qualiaware

QUALIAZEROD-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can

Qualiaware D-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can 1
4.37

mybest's Top Choice: Large Capacity, Highly Recommended for Large Families

4.30
4.00
5.00
4.38
4.50

50 L

19.1 in.

14.5 in.

25.2 in.

36 in.

12.5 lb.

Stainless steel

13.2 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

2

Rubbermaid Home Products

RubbermaidRubbermaid Classic Step-On Trash Can

Rubbermaid Home Products Rubbermaid Classic Step-On Trash Can 1
4.28

Easily Dispose of a Lot of Trash, Breeze to Open and Close

4.35
3.50
5.00
4.50
4.50

49.21 L

17.6 in.

14.7 in.

24.8 in.

36.2 in.

5 lb.

Resin

13 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

3

Simplehuman

Semi-round Step CanCW1355

Simplehuman Semi-round Step Can 1
4.25

Large Capacity, Leaks Odor When Sealed

3.95
4.00
5.00
4.38
4.50

50 L

18.9 in.

14 in.

26.5 in.

38.5 in.

7.9 lb.

Plastic

13.2-15.9 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

4

Amazon

Amazon BasicsSmudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can

Amazon Smudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can 1
4.24

Large Capacity, but May Leak Odor Even When Sealed

3.93
4.00
5.00
4.38
4.50

50 L

16.73 in.

14.65 in.

25.87 in.

36.3 in.

13.2 lb.

Stainless steel

13.2 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

5

Rubbermaid Home Products

RubbermaidPremier Series II Step-On Trash Can2120984

Rubbermaid Home Products Premier Series II Step-On Trash Can 1
4.21

Changing the Bag Is Easy, But It Tends to Leak a Bit of Odor

3.53
5.00
5.00
4.50
4.50

47 L

16 in.

12.25 in.

24.25 in.

33.86 in.

5.2 lb.

Resin

12.4 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

6

Nine Stars Group

Rectangular Motion Sensor Trash CanDZT-50-28

Nine Stars Group Rectangular Motion Sensor Trash Can 1
4.17

Large Capacity, However, There Is a Slight Smell Leakage Even When It’s Sealed

4.05
4.00
4.00
3.75
4.50

50 L

15.24 in.

11.22 in.

25.04 in.

33.5 in.

6.75 lb.

Stainless steel

13 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

7

Simplehuman

Rectangular Step CanCW2024

Simplehuman Rectangular Step Can 1
4.08

Easy Trash Disposal, but Changing the Bag Is a Hassle

3.98
4.00
5.00
4.50
4.00

45 L

15.9 in.

13.3 in.

25.8 in.

36 in.

12.9 lb.

Stainless steel

11.9 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

8

Sterilite Corporation

Trash Can

Sterilite Corporation Trash Can 1
4.07

The Pedal Is Easy to Press, but the Angle at Which the Lid Opens Is Narrow

4.40
4.00
3.00
4.50
4.00

45 L

16.12 in.

13.25 in.

24.5 in.

35.31 in.

4 lb.

Plastic

13 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

9

Brabantia Branding

Newicon Pedal Bin

Brabantia Branding Newicon Pedal Bin 1
3.95

Opening and Closing the Lid Is Easy, But Its Small Size Increases the Frequency of Bag Replacement

4.40
4.00
5.00
4.50
3.50

30 L

11.5 in.

15 in.

26.7 in.

36.9 in.

8.2 lb.

Steel

7.93 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

10

IKEA

Mjösa004.228.54

IKEA Mjösa 1
3.93

Its small 8-gallon size Increases the Frequency of Trash Replacement

4.38
4.00
5.00
4.38
3.50

30 L

13.25 in.

13.25 in.

26.75 in.

35.4 in.

5.6 lbs.

Body: Steel, Galvanized steel, Powder coating ; Lid/Handle/Screw/Plate: Stainless steel ; Lid holder/Bucket/Connector: Polypropylene ; Bar:Steel, Galvanized ; Bottom part: Stainless steel, Synthetic rubber ; Closing device: Acetal plastic

8 gal.

Vertical opening type

Vertical

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Kitchen Trash Cans
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Size

Qualiaware
QUALIAZEROD-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can

mybest Score
4.37
Odor Control
4.30
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.38
Size
4.50
View on Amazon
D-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can 1
Lowest price
$64.95
Mid
Lowest price
$64.95
Mid
Capacity50 L
Width
19.1 in.
Depth
14.5 in.
Weight
12.5 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

mybest's Top Choice: Large Capacity, Highly Recommended for Large Families

What we loved

  • Large capacity
  • Vertical lid opening
  • Can open hands-free

What we didn't love

  • Odor spreads inside quickly
  • Pedal requires a lot of force
  • Some difficulty changing the bag

The D-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can sold by QUALIAZERO is characterized by its stylish stainless steel design.


The size is 13.2 gallons, which should be sufficient to collect the average amount of household waste. Furthermore, the lid opens vertically more than 80 degrees, making it easy to dispose of large trash. It is recommended for people who have a large amount of trash and a high frequency of trash disposal. Moreover, in our test there was hardly any smell leakage when it was sealed for 30 minutes after putting in the smell sample.


On the other hand, the large lid ended up spreading the smell from inside the trash can, which spread quickly when it was opened or closed. Additionally, since there is only an inner bucket inside the trash can, it's a bit difficult to change the garbage bag. Furthermore, while it's easy to open even when both hands are full, thanks to the pedal system, the pedal is stiff and requires force when stepping on it.

Height With Lid Closed25.2 in.
Height With Lid Open36 in.
MaterialStainless steel
Compatible Trash Bag Size13.2 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid
No.1 in Size

Rubbermaid Home Products
RubbermaidRubbermaid Classic Step-On Trash Can

mybest Score
4.28
Odor Control
4.35
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
3.50
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
4.50
Lowest price
$45.49
Low Mid
Capacity49.21 L
Width
17.6 in.
Depth
14.7 in.
Weight
5 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Easily Dispose of a Lot of Trash, Breeze to Open and Close

What we loved

  • Large capacity
  • Light pedal action
  • Minimal odor leak

What we didn't love

  • Odor spreads inside quickly
  • Some difficulty changing the bag
  • Butterfly lid gets in the way

The Classic Step-On Trash Can with Lid sold by Rubbermaid, is praised for its seamless design that makes it easy to maintain.


The size is 13.2 gallons, which should be enough to hold an average-sized amount of household trash. Moreover, the lid opens vertically more than 80 degrees, allowing you to dispose of trash quickly. Additionally, the pedal only requires light force, so even if you dispose of garbage frequently, it won't be a burden.


On one hand, it has a butterfly-type clip, which can get in the way when you change the bag as it touches your hands. Moreover, even though there was hardly any scent leakage 30 minutes after putting in the source of the odor and sealing it, the scent spread when opening and closing because the lid size is large. When opening and closing, be sure to close the lid quickly.

Height With Lid Closed24.8 in.
Height With Lid Open36.2 in.
MaterialResin
Compatible Trash Bag Size13 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.3
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Size

Simplehuman
Semi-round Step CanCW1355

mybest Score
4.25
Odor Control
3.95
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.38
Size
4.50
Reference price
$49.99
Low Mid
Capacity50 L
Width
18.9 in.
Depth
14 in.
Weight
7.9 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Large Capacity, Leaks Odor When Sealed

What we loved

  • Large capacity
  • Vertical lid enables easy disposal

What we didn't love

  • Pedal requires some force
  • Ineffective seal leaks odor
  • No bag holder

The Semi Round Plastic Step Trash Can, sold by Simplehuman, is characterized by its chic black design.


With a large capacity of 13.2 gallons, even a family of four can limit their garbage disposal to around three times a week. Furthermore, since the lid opens more than 80 degrees vertically, you can dispose of the garbage without worrying about the lid hitting the trash.


In our smell test, after adding a sample odor and waiting 30 minutes there was a slight smell leak even when the product was sealed, and due to the large lid, the odor spread when opened or closed. Furthermore, without a device to hold the bag in place—with only the inner bucket inside—it's hard to fix the bag securely, making the exchange a bit difficult. While it's easy to use even if both hands are occupied, the need to apply some force to push the pedal down somewhat hinders easy opening.

Height With Lid Closed26.5 in.
Height With Lid Open38.5 in.
MaterialPlastic
Compatible Trash Bag Size13.2-15.9 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.4
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Size

Amazon
Amazon BasicsSmudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can

mybest Score
4.24
Odor Control
3.93
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.38
Size
4.50
Lowest price
$97.24
Mid
Capacity50 L
Width
16.73 in.
Depth
14.65 in.
Weight
13.2 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Large Capacity, but May Leak Odor Even When Sealed

What we loved

  • Large capacity
  • Vertical lid enables easy disposal
  • Stainless steel exterior dirt resistant

What we didn't love

  • Leaks odor even when sealed
  • Pedal requires a lot of force
  • No bag holder, hard to change

The Smudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can With Soft-Close Foot Pedal, sold by Amazon Basics, is touted for its stainless exterior that is resistant to dirt.


With a capacity of 13.2 gallons, it's sufficient to gather household trash and reduce the frequency of taking out the trash. Furthermore, the lid opens more than 80 degrees vertically, which makes it less obtrusive when throwing away trash.


In our smell test, 30 minutes after placing an odor sample inside, there was a slight scent leakage despite the bin being sealed, and since the lid is large, the smell from inside the garbage bin spread into the room when opened. Also, the pedal requires a bit of force to push all the way down, which is a drawback. Furthermore, there's no system to hold the bag in place, making bag replacement somewhat cumbersome, which hampered the overall rating. It may not be suitable for people who frequently change bags.

Height With Lid Closed25.87 in.
Height With Lid Open36.3 in.
MaterialStainless steel
Compatible Trash Bag Size13.2 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.5
No.1 in Ease of Changing Trash Bags
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid
No.1 in Size

Rubbermaid Home Products
RubbermaidPremier Series II Step-On Trash Can2120984

mybest Score
4.21
Odor Control
3.53
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
5.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
4.50
Lowest price
$55.99
Low Mid
Capacity47 L
Width
16 in.
Depth
12.25 in.
Weight
5.2 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Changing the Bag Is Easy, But It Tends to Leak a Bit of Odor

What we loved

  • Easy bag change
  • Large capacity
  • Hands-free pedal operation

What we didn't love

  • Gap between inner bucket and outer shell leaks odor

The Premier Series II Step-On Trash Can, sold by Rubbermaid, features a refined charcoal finish and metal accents.


With a size of 13.2 gallons, it is large enough to consolidate household trash and can also reduce the frequency of trash disposal. Moreover, due to its pedal operation, the lid opens vertically more than 80 degrees for stress-free garbage disposal. In addition, it allows you to securely fix a garbage bag from the top by snapping on the lid, making bag changes easy.


On the other hand, there was an issue of smell leakage from the gap between the main body and the lid, which hindered its rating. Furthermore, due to the large size of the lid, the smell inside would disperse into the room when opening and closing it.

Height With Lid Closed24.25 in.
Height With Lid Open33.86 in.
MaterialResin
Compatible Trash Bag Size12.4 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.6
No.1 in Size

Nine Stars Group
Rectangular Motion Sensor Trash CanDZT-50-28

mybest Score
4.17
Odor Control
4.05
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
4.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
3.75
Size
4.50
Lowest price
$59.00
Low Mid
Capacity50 L
Width
15.24 in.
Depth
11.22 in.
Weight
6.75 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Large Capacity, However, There Is a Slight Smell Leakage Even When It’s Sealed

What we loved

  • Large capacity
  • Motion sensors allow for easy use

What we didn't love

  • No bag holder
  • Leaks odor even when sealed

The Rectangular Motion Sensor Trash Can, sold by NINESTARS, is advertised as having a long battery life, which is an advantage for a bin that will be used frequently throughout the day.


Since the size is 13.2 gallons, it should be large enough to gather the family's trash. It can help reduce the frequency of taking out the trash.


In our smell test, 30 minutes after inserting the sample, there was a slight odor leak even when the lid was tightly sealed. In the bag replacement test, it was difficult to hold the bag in place as there was no secure bag stopper. On the other hand, the lid opens just by waving your hand over the sensor, which makes it easy to throw away trash, but gauging the sensor's response range was somewhat troublesome. It may not be suitable for those who have to throw away trash frequently.

Height With Lid Closed25.04 in.
Height With Lid Open33.5 in.
MaterialStainless steel
Compatible Trash Bag Size13 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.7
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid

Simplehuman
Rectangular Step CanCW2024

mybest Score
4.08
Odor Control
3.98
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
4.00
Lowest price
$119.99
High Mid
Capacity45 L
Width
15.9 in.
Depth
13.3 in.
Weight
12.9 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Easy Trash Disposal, but Changing the Bag Is a Hassle

What we loved

  • Vertical lid allows for easy disposal
  • Hands-free pedal operation

What we didn't love

  • No holder to secure trash bag
  • Capacity too small for a large family
  • Odor leaks and increases over time

The Rectangular Step Can, sold by Simplehuman, is made of stainless steel, which is easy to clean and is resistant to surface stains.


The lid is easy to open with a pedal mechanism and it opens vertically more than 80 degrees, making it easy to discard trash swiftly.


On the other hand, its 11.8-gallon capacity may not be large enough for a large family. It's not suitable for those who wish to curb their garbage disposal frequency. In our smell test, 30 minutes after putting in the sample, a faint odor started to leak out, and a stronger smell emerged when opening and closing. Furthermore, there's no bag holder, making it cumbersome to secure it in place, which hindered the ease of changing bags.

Height With Lid Closed25.8 in.
Height With Lid Open36 in.
MaterialStainless steel
Compatible Trash Bag Size11.9 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.8
No.1 in Odor Control
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid

Sterilite Corporation
Trash Can

mybest Score
4.07
Odor Control
4.40
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
3.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
4.00
Lowest price
$39.99
Low
Capacity45 L
Width
16.12 in.
Depth
13.25 in.
Weight
4 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

The Pedal Is Easy to Press, but the Angle at Which the Lid Opens Is Narrow

What we loved

  • Hands-free pedal operation
  • Light force required for pedal

What we didn't love

  • Large lid leaks odor easily
  • Smaller opening angle hinders use
  • Capacity too small for large family

The Sterilite 11.9 Gallon Trash Can, sold by Sterilite, has sleek lines and an attractive, easy-to-clean finish.


Its smaller size of 11.9 gallons may feel somewhat insufficient when collecting trash for a large number of people. If used by the entire family, the frequency of changing the trash might increase. Also, although there was no odor leakage 30 minutes after putting in the smell sample and sealing it, the lid is large, causing the smell to disperse when opening and closing, which brought it down in our ranking.


Furthermore, the lack of a bag holder made securing the garbage bag troublesome. If you don't use a bag of the right size, it can fall off. Also, while the pedal is light and makes it easy to open the lid, the fact that the lid only opens about 70 degrees is somewhat bothersome. It may not be suitable for people who need to dispose of trash frequently.

Height With Lid Closed24.5 in.
Height With Lid Open35.31 in.
MaterialPlastic
Compatible Trash Bag Size13 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.9
No.1 in Odor Control
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid

Brabantia Branding
Newicon Pedal Bin

mybest Score
3.95
Odor Control
4.40
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
3.50
Capacity30 L
Width
11.5 in.
Depth
15 in.
Weight
8.2 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Opening and Closing the Lid Is Easy, But Its Small Size Increases the Frequency of Bag Replacement

What we loved

  • Light, hands-free pedal action
  • Strong seal reduces odor

What we didn't love

  • Capacity too small for large family
  • No bag holder

The NEWICON PEDAL BIN, sold by Brabantia, is available in a wide variety of 12 colors.


The lid opens more than 80 degrees vertically and can be easily opened with a pedal, making it ideal for daily use. Thirty minutes after putting in the smell sample, we checked for any smell leaks after sealing the container, and there was almost no smell detected.


On the other hand, our testers noticed a slight smell when opening and closing it. Additionally, with only an 8-gallon capacity, it's not suitable for those who want to reduce the frequency of taking out the trash. Furthermore, there is no bag holder, which makes it difficult to secure the bag.

Height With Lid Closed26.7 in.
Height With Lid Open36.9 in.
MaterialSteel
Compatible Trash Bag Size7.93 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.10
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash

IKEA
Mjösa004.228.54

mybest Score
3.93
Odor Control
4.38
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.38
Size
3.50
Lowest price
$72.99
Mid
Capacity30 L
Width
13.25 in.
Depth
13.25 in.
Weight
5.6 lbs.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Its small 8-gallon size Increases the Frequency of Trash Replacement

What we loved

  • Wide opening allows for easy use
  • Minimal smell when closed

What we didn't love

  • No bag holder
  • Small size requires more frequent bag replacement
  • Slight smell leak when opening

The mjosa, sold by IKEA, is touted for its gray design that easily matches room decor.


The lid opens wide at over 80 degrees, which allows for stress-free opening.


On the other hand, there's a need to exert strong force on the pedal, and the frequent need for trash disposal can be slightly bothersome. In addition, when we checked for odor leakage, there was very little when it was sealed, but some odor was noted upon opening and closing, which brought its score down in our smell tests. Also, the size is 8 gallons, which is quite small for multiple people to use, and as a result, the frequency of replacing trash bags may increase. Furthermore, the lack of a bag holder might make changing bags stressful.

Height With Lid Closed26.75 in.
Height With Lid Open35.4 in.
MaterialBody: Steel, Galvanized steel, Powder coating ; Lid/Handle/Screw/Plate: Stainless steel ; Lid holder/Bucket/Connector: Polypropylene ; Bar:Steel, Galvanized ; Bottom part: Stainless steel, Synthetic rubber ; Closing device: Acetal plastic
Compatible Trash Bag Size8 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.11
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash

Simplehuman
Dual Compartment Rectangular Step CanCW2025

mybest Score
3.92
Odor Control
4.30
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.38
Size
3.50
Lowest price
$189.75
High Mid
Capacity58 L
Width
22 in.
Depth
14.2 in.
Weight
21.3 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Allows for Easy Trash Sorting, but the Small Capacity Is Troublesome

What we loved

  • Dual compartments make for easy trash sorting
  • Pedal allows for hands-free use
  • Effective seal reduces odor when lid is closed

What we didn't love

  • No bag holder
  • Small capacity not ideal for frequent use

The steel pedal of the Dual Compartment Rectangular Step Can, sold by Simplehuman, is touted to withstand 150,000 steps.


The lid opens vertically over 80 degrees, so it tends not to get in the way when throwing away trash. It would probably be suitable for those who have to dispose of garbage frequently.


On the one hand, it’s easy to open with a pedal, but it is necessary to put more force on the pedal. In addition, in the odor leakage test, there was almost no odor leakage 30 minutes after the garlic sample was put in and sealed, but the odor did leak when the lid opened and closed. Although the official website claims it's 15.3 gallons, the problem is that each space can only hold about 8 gallons when sorted. Furthermore, the lack of a bag holder might make it feel troublesome to secure the garbage bags.

Height With Lid Closed25.8 in.
Height With Lid Open36 in.
MaterialStainless steel, Recycled plastic
Compatible Trash Bag Size8-9.3 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.12
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash

Brabantia Branding
Bo Touch Bin

mybest Score
3.90
Odor Control
4.35
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
3.25
Size
3.70
Lowest price
$298.00
High
Capacity36 L
Width
21.3 in.
Depth
12.3 in.
Weight
12.2 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

The Size is Small at 9.5 gallons and Requires Manual Opening and Closing

What we loved

  • Wide opening
  • No odor when lid is sealed

What we didn't love

  • Small capacity
  • Slight odor leak when opening and closing
  • No bag holder

The Bo Touch Bin, sold by Brabantia, is available in eight colors.


The lid opens to more than 80 degrees vertically, allowing use without the trash hitting the lid, making it easy to dispose of large trash.


In our smell test, 30 minutes after putting in the garlic sample and closing it tightly, there was no smell leakage, but it did leak a slight odor when opening and closing the lid, which hindered its evaluation. Furthermore, the lack of a bag holder made it difficult to stabilize the bag. In addition, it's necessary to manually open the lid, making it impossible to throw away trash hands-free. Additionally, the size is small at 9.5 gallons, making it unsuitable for consolidating household trash.

Height With Lid Closed26.8 in.
Height With Lid Open36.6 in.
MaterialSteel
Compatible Trash Bag Size9.5 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.13
No.1 in Ease of Disposing Trash
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid

SONGMICS HOME
Trash Can

mybest Score
3.87
Odor Control
4.08
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
5.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
3.50
Lowest price
$132.99
High Mid
Capacity60 L
Width
23 in.
Depth
12.6 in.
Weight
20.1 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Vertical
Removable Lid

Can Be Easily Opened and Closed but Pedal Is Somewhat Small

What we loved

  • Pedal allows for hands-free use
  • Dual compartments for easy sorting

What we didn't love

  • Very small capacity
  • Odor leaks even when sealed

The Trash Can, sold by SONGMICS, is made of stainless steel, making it easy to clean and resistant to fingerprints.


The pedal can be pressed with light force, and the fact that the lid opens vertically over 80 degrees makes it easy to throw away items. Children should be able to open and close it easily. Moreover, because the lid is small, odor diffusion when opening and closing is kept to a minimum.


On the other hand, even 30 minutes after putting in the garlic sample in our smell test, a slight smell leaked even when the lid was sealed. Moreover, there is no bag holder, so it may not be suitable for those who replace bags frequently. Also, while the space is divided for sorting, each space can only hold 8 gallons, which has limited its rating for size.

Height With Lid Closed25.6 in.
Height With Lid Open37 in.
MaterialPowder coated steel bin, PP Plastic inner bucket, ABS Plastic lid
Compatible Trash Bag Size8 gal.
Opening MethodVertical opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all
No.14
No.1 in Ease of Opening the Lid

Simplehuman
Dual Compartment Butterfly Step CanCW2017

mybest Score
3.63
Odor Control
4.08
Ease of Changing Trash Bags
4.00
Ease of Disposing Trash
4.00
Ease of Opening the Lid
4.50
Size
3.17
Lowest price
$169.99
High Mid
Capacity40 L
Width
10.4 in.
Depth
23.3 in.
Weight
24.2 lb.
How the Lid Opens
Butterfly
Removable Lid

The Large Pedal Makes It Easy to Open, but There’s a Slight Odor Leak

What we loved

  • Large pedal allows for hands-free use
  • Sustainable with 100% recycled plastic

What we didn't love

  • Small capacity
  • Consistent odor leak
  • No bag holder

The inner bucket of the Dual Compartment Butterfly Step Can sold by Simplehuman is made of 100% recycled plastic, making it more environmentally friendly than other models.

 
It features a large foot pedal, making it easy to open without the use of your hands.

 
In our smell test, 30 minutes after placing the garlic sample inside, a slight odor leakage was noticeable even when sealed. Additionally, there's no bag holder, which makes changing and securing the bag a bit troublesome. Also, the ease of garbage disposal suffered due to its butterfly opening type design, which increases the likelihood of your hand touching the trash during use. Additionally, while the official site states that the main body's capacity is 10.5 gallons, the inside can is divided into two compartments, so if you are sorting the trash, only 5.2 gallons can fit in one side. Because of this, it may not be suitable for consolidating a family's waste.

Height With Lid Closed26 in.
Height With Lid Open30.5 in.
MaterialStainless steel, Recycled plastic
Compatible Trash Bag Size5.3 gal.
Opening MethodButterfly opening type
Includes Bag Holder
View all

How We Tested the Kitchen Trash Cans

Kitchen Trash Cans Evaluation

At mybest, the best kitchen garbage can with a lid is defined as one that is a high-capacity bin that reduces odor and stress during use.

 
To find the best product, we collected 14 top-selling kitchen garbage cans with lids from popular manufacturers and retailers such as Amazon, Target, and more and thoroughly tested them on the following five points. 


  • Size
  • Odor Control
  • Ease of Changing Trash Bags
  • Ease of Disposing Trash
  • Ease of Opening the Lid

Products we tested

  1. AmazonAmazon BasicsSmudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can
  2. Brabantia BrandingNewicon Pedal Bin
  3. Brabantia Branding Bo Touch Bin
  4. IKEAMjösa004.228.54
  5. Nine Stars GroupRectangular Motion Sensor Trash CanDZT-50-28
  6. QualiawareQUALIAZEROD-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can
  7. Rubbermaid Home ProductsRubbermaidRubbermaid Classic Step-On Trash Can
  8. Rubbermaid Home ProductsRubbermaidPremier Series II Step-On Trash Can2120984
  9. SONGMICS HOMETrash Can
  10. SimplehumanSemi-round Step CanCW1355
  11. SimplehumanRectangular Step CanCW2024
  12. SimplehumanDual Compartment Butterfly Step CanCW2017
  13. SimplehumanDual Compartment Rectangular Step CanCW2025
  14. Sterilite CorporationTrash Can
1

Size

Size

To measure whether the bin was of sufficient size, we established that the trash disposal frequency should be about three times a week for maximum user satisfaction.

Scoring Method

We checked the size of the product from the official website. The larger the size, the higher it was scored as recommended.

Test Conditions

  • When calculating the capacity by adding two boxes, the score is based on the capacity of only one box. (For example, if there are two 8 gallon boxes, it's not measured as 15.8 gallons but as 8 gallons.)
2

Odor Control

Odor Control

Our standard for maximum odor control is a product where no odor leaks even after 30 minutes, no odor rises when opening and closing, and there is no remaining odor.

Scoring Method

Add 0.5 grams of garlic paste to a 1-quart capacity container. A scent checker then checks for any odor leaks after 30 minutes, any odor emitted when the container is opened or closed, and any remaining scents in the container. We scored each product based on its recommendation level.

What We Checked

  • The degree of odor leakage after being sealed for 30 minutes

  • The strength of odor after being opened for 30 minutes

3

Ease of Changing Trash Bags

Ease of Changing Trash Bags

Our standard for bins that allow easy bag replacement is one that can replace the bag quickly with minimal stress.

Scoring Method

Testers checked each product and scored them based on the points below, quantifying the recommendation level of each product.

What We Checked

  • Is the bag holder easily detachable?

  • Are there holes on the side of the trash can to secure the bag?

4

Ease of Opening the Lid

Ease of Opening the Lid

Our standard for a trash bin that is easy to open and users can be very satisfied with means it is easy to use even if both hands are occupied.

Scoring Method

The testers checked each product and scored them based on the following points, converting the recommended level of each product into a score.

What We Checked

  • Is it possible to open and close even if both hands are occupied?

  • Can the pedal be stepped on with light force?

  • Does the pedal size make it easy to step on?

5

Ease of Disposing Trash

Ease of Disposing Trash

Our standard for a trash bin that allows for easy garbage disposal is a product where the lid opens wide and does not interfere with garbage disposal.

Scoring Method

The testers checked each product and scored them based on the points below.

What We Checked

  • Does the lid open without hitting your hand?

  • Does it open to a wide enough angle that makes it easy to throw away the trash?

Top 5 Kitchen Trash Cans

No. 1: QualiawareQUALIAZEROD-Shape Stainless Steel Step Can

No. 2: Rubbermaid Home ProductsRubbermaidRubbermaid Classic Step-On Trash Can

No. 3: SimplehumanSemi-round Step CanCW1355

No. 4: AmazonAmazon BasicsSmudge Resistant Rectangular Trash Can

No. 5: Rubbermaid Home ProductsRubbermaidPremier Series II Step-On Trash Can2120984

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Kitchen Trash Cans

Display Cases

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.