10 Best Colored Mascaras in 2025 (Makeup Artist-Reviewed)
How fun is it to create different types of makeup looks with just one mascara? With colored mascaras, you can create any makeup look you want. Whether you want a natural look, a stunning look, or a wild look, colored mascaras can do it all. Choosing a good one can be tricky, however, because there are many things to consider and so many options on the market. That's why you should check out our buying guide reviewed by a makeup artist for tips on how to choose the right product for you.
But we did more of the work for you, too! We picked out 10 great products and ranked them. The L'Oreak Telescopic Lift is one of the products on our list ecause it's easy to use, matches with most eye colors, and comes with a nice brush that can fix all lash concerns. If you want to know more, check out the rest of our favorites in our top 10 list!
Quick List - Top Colored Mascaras
Natalya is a professional makeup artist based in Los Angeles and has been trying new products to find what is best for each individual's skin tone and type. She is self-taught but wanted to further her education, and she went to a makeup school in Los Angeles to learn the ins and outs of makeup. She has tried many makeup brands and products and can proudly say she has found some of the best and longest-wearing products. As a freelance makeup artist, she wants her clients not to worry about their makeup not lasting as long as they need it to.
mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
How to Choose a Colored Mascara - Buying Guide
Check out our tips and suggestions below for more information about colored mascaras. Keep these four points in mind to make your shopping experience much easier!
Choose the Color That Suits You Best
Colored mascaras can make your eyes pop and create gorgeous makeup looks only if you choose the right color for you.
Brown Mascaras are Perfect for Natural Looks
Brown mascaras are perfect for soft daytime makeup looks. This color can be worn by most eye colors and skin tones since it comes in many shades.
If you have a fair and light skin tone with blonde, light brown, or red hair, brown mascaras are your perfect choice for natural looks. Additionally, they suit people with brown, green, or blue eyes, too! In case you have a medium or olive skin tone, we suggest you choose darker shades of brown.
Create a Trendy, Poppy Look With Bright Colors
Both blue and purple mascaras look great with most eye colors; however, purple mascaras will look the best on blue-grey eyes. Blue mascaras can help to fix dull eyes and make your eyes look more awake. Since blue and purple come in many shades, they can work with most skin tones, too!
On the other hand, green mascaras go well with eyes colors like hazel, brown, and green. A lot of people like to pair green with black mascaras since they make great color combinations. And if you have green eyes, red mascaras will look good on you, too!
If you're not confident wearing bright colors, try to stick with the shades that are close to your eyebrow color. We suggest you choose no more than a couple of shades darker than the color of your eyebrows for a natural look. If you want to create fancy makeup looks, have fun with bright colors, too!
White Mascaras are Versatile and Offer You Many Benefits
White mascaras help to lengthen and thicken your lashes when you apply them as a base coat before applying darker colors on top.
They also help to lighten your lashes to get the color results you want, especially for people with darker lashes. In addition to that, they help your eyes look wide awake when you apply them to the inner corners of your eyes.
However, white mascaras might be difficult to wear on their own unless you want to create specific looks for parties or special events. Some white mascaras are sold alone, while others are sold as duo mascara sticks that usually come in black and white color.
Consider Metallic Colored Mascaras for a Glamorous Look
One idea is to consider metallic mascaras for parties or night-out makeup looks. This type of mascaras will help you create an elegant look and make your eyes look more sparkling.
One thing to keep in mind when you apply brightly colored metallic mascaras is to avoid heavy makeup on other areas on your face to avoid looking gaudy or drawing attention away from your eyes instead of to them. Keep in mind that balancing all the colors on your face is the key to get the most stunning looks.
Decide Between Types of Applicators
If you’re a mascara beginner, we suggest you start with straight brushes, comb brushes, or small brushes. They're easy to apply and you can easily access small areas like your lower lashes and inner eyelid lashes. That means you can avoid clumps and mess on your lashes and surrounding skin.
Big brushes and curved brushes suit people who want to add volume and texture to the lashes. Since the brushes are quite big, they might be a little difficult to apply. However, these types of applicators go well with smoky makeup and are perfect for party and night-out looks.
If you have short lashes, we suggest you choose a lengthening brush. This type of brush is perfect for someone who already has thick lashes, but wants to extend the length of the lashes.
There are also many options for all-in-one brushes that can curl, thicken, lengthen, and separate the lashes, too! This type makes a perfect option for someone who doesn't want to apply false eyelashes but is looking for an easy way to solve all their lash problems.
Think About Getting Waterproof Mascara
Waterproof mascaras are designed for a long-wearing application. They can be worn all year round, but they make the best option for wet-look makeup, summer, workouts, and outdoor activities when you tend to sweat a lot. Waterproof mascaras help to avoid panda eyes and save you from ruined makeup, too!
One thing to note about waterproof mascaras is that they can be harder to remove compared to regular mascaras. However, cleansing oils are the best way to wipe away all waterproof mascaras on your lashes.
Waterproof mascara is the safest option for long days you need to hold and last all day without smudging. Waterproof mascara is a great option for those with sensitive and watery eyes. Waterproof mascara is less likely to run or sweat. Waterproof mascara is great for holding the curl of the lash all day.
For those who feel they tend to rub their eyes at all due to tiredness or simply forgetting you were even wearing makeup, waterproof mascara won't smudge on you or give you that raccoon look we all fear. For wedding days and special events I always recommend a waterproof mascara when you know there may be tears.
Avoid Harmful Chemicals for Sensitive Eyes and Skin
In general, mascaras are safe for most people. But for those who have sensitive eyes and skin, it's a good idea to avoid chemical ingredients like fragrance, parabens, retinyl acetate, and coal tar dyes. These ingredients can lead to itching, redness, and other irritations around the eyes of some people.
Also, use caution with fiber mascaras, too! Although they're popular and can make your lashes look longer, there is a chance that fibers can fall into your eyes. Additionally, make sure to replace new mascaras every three months to avoid bacteria that can lead to eye infections.
Mascara is normally the last step to the makeup routine and pulls the whole look together. But sensitive eyes can be a daily struggle. To avoid stinging, burning or irritation to the eye, find the best mascara that will won't affect any allergies.
The eyelid and lash line is very thin and can be easily damaged due to the lack of oil glands in the area. The eyes can tend to get dry and can easily ruin the whole makeup look if they're irritated. Stick to fragrance free and natural products. Another tip is to never share your mascara with anyone due to bacteria. Bacteria on eye products can cause unfavorable results.
10 Best Colored Mascaras
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | Details | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Color | Waterproof | Hyperallergenic | Brush Type | |||||
1 | BINGBRUSH Multi-colored Mascara | | Bold color, all-day wear—lashes that shine | Black、Brown、Blue、White、Purple | Lengthening | |||
2 | BONNIE CHOICE 9 Colors Colored Mascara Set | | Nine colors, endless possibilities | Black、Brown、Red、Blue、Green、Pink、Purple、Yellow、Orange、White | ||||
3 | L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Lift | | Lift, lengthen, and shine in bold color | Black、Purple、Blue | Double-Hook、Bristle | |||
4 | UCANBE Burgundy Mascara and Liquid Eyeliner Set | | Brown Mascara Set | Black、Brown、Red、Purple | Lengthening、Curved | |||
5 | CAKAILA 3 Color Colored Mascara Set | | Bold color, all-day volume | Blue、Green、Purple | Thickening、Curved | |||
6 | MIESCHER White Mascara for Eyelashes | | Pure White Mascara | White | Curved、Lengthening、Thickening | |||
7 | LYSdefeu 5D Volume Lash Mascara, Purple | | Bold color, limitless volume | Black、Blue、Green、Purple、White | Lengthening、Thickening | |||
8 | LGSZGDCN Purple Lashes Extensions | | Mascara in Adorable Packaging | Purple、Black | Lengthening、Thickening | |||
9 | Maydear Pink Mascara for Eyelashes | | Bold volume, vibrant color—lashes that last | Brown、Blue、Green、Pink、White | Thickening | |||
10 | Lestpola Lengthening Mascara | | 24-Hour Mascara | Blue | Curved、Thickening、Lengthening | |||
BINGBRUSHMulti-colored Mascara
| Color | Black、Brown、Blue、White、Purple |
|---|
Bold color, all-day wear—lashes that shine
Make your eyes pop with BINGBRUSH Colored Mascara, designed for vibrant, long-lasting color that’s perfect for daily wear, clubbing, or parties. Featuring a long-brush applicator, this mascara coats every lash evenly without smudging onto the skin, delivering a natural yet striking look.
Waterproof, vegan, and cruelty-free, it provides comfortable, all-day wear without clumping or flaking. Lightweight and easy to apply, this mascara is your go-to for effortless, eye-catching lashes—in every color you crave!
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Lengthening |
BONNIE CHOICE9 Colors Colored Mascara Set
| Color | Black、Brown、Red、Blue、Green、Pink、Purple、Yellow、Orange、White |
|---|
Nine colors, endless possibilities
Make a bold statement with the BONNIE CHOICE 9-Color Mascara Set, featuring vivid, waterproof shades that lengthen, volumize, and define your lashes. From classic black to vibrant pink, blue, green, and more, this set lets you switch up your look every day of the week.
Formulated with natural, smudge-free ingredients, this mascara glides on smoothly, stays put all day, and removes effortlessly with makeup remover. Whether for daily wear, parties, or special events, these long-lasting, cruelty-free mascaras let your lashes shine in every color imaginable!
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type |
Lift, lengthen, and shine in bold color
Take your lashes to the next level with L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift Mascara in Galactic Purple, designed to instantly volumize, lift, and lengthen up to 5mm. The double-hook bristle brush grabs and coats every lash for a bold, dramatic look with up to 36-hour wear.
Easy to apply and remove, this ophthalmologist-tested formula is safe for sensitive eyes and washes off effortlessly with soap and water. Whether you're creating a subtle pop of color or a bold, cosmic-inspired look, this mascara delivers high-impact lashes that last.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Double-Hook、Bristle |
UCANBEBurgundy Mascara and Liquid Eyeliner Set
| Color | Black、Brown、Red、Purple |
|---|
Brown Mascara Set
Elevate your eye look with UCANBE Colored Mascara & Eyeliner, a waterproof, long-lasting duo designed for vibrant, smudge-proof wear. The buildable, lengthening mascara adds natural curl and volume, while the precise liquid eyeliner glides on effortlessly for sharp wings or smoky eyes.
Available in six eye-catching shades, this high-pigment, all-day formula makes it easy to create bold, expressive looks that stay put through sweat and tears. Whether you want a subtle pop or a statement eye, this perfect color-matched set has you covered!
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Lengthening、Curved |
Bold color, all-day volume
Make a statement with CAKAILA Colored Mascara, a waterproof, hypoallergenic formula that delivers long-lasting volume and bold color. Available in Dark Green, Purple, and Dark Blue, this mascara lifts, thickens, and lengthens lashes while staying smudge-resistant and flake-free all day.
Perfect for parties, events, or everyday wear, this cruelty-free, travel-friendly mascara adds a pop of color to any look. With a lightweight, non-clumping formula, your lashes stay defined, vibrant, and effortlessly stunning from morning to night.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Thickening、Curved |
Pure White Mascara
Create eye-catching, voluminous lashes with MIESCHER 5D Luxurious Colored Mascara in White, designed for lengthening, defining, curling, and volumizing with a smudge-proof, waterproof formula. Its 5D silk fiber technology coats each lash evenly, delivering intense color and dramatic lift that lasts 24 hours without clumping or flaking.
Featuring a flexible 360° spiral brush, this mascara separates and enhances lashes effortlessly while remaining lightweight and easy to remove. Perfect for daily wear, cosplay, or stage looks, this travel-size, beginner-friendly formula ensures your lashes stay bold and beautiful all day.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Curved、Lengthening、Thickening |
LYSdefeu5D Volume Lash Mascara, Purple
| Color | Black、Blue、Green、Purple、White |
|---|
Bold color, limitless volume
Enhance your lashes with LYSdefeu 5D Colored Mascara, a volumizing and lengthening formula designed to add rich, vibrant color in purple, blue, white, black, or brown. The olive-shaped brush lifts and coats every lash without clumps, delivering dramatic volume and sculpted length.
This waterproof, smudge-proof mascara stays flawless all day, yet removes easily with makeup remover. Lightweight and beginner-friendly, it’s perfect for daily wear, cosplay, parties, and special occasions—because your lashes deserve to stand out.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Lengthening、Thickening |
Mascara in Adorable Packaging
Make your lashes pop with LGSZGDCN 6-Color Mascara, featuring vivid shades like purple, blue, pink, and white for a unique, eye-catching look. The exclusive conic-shaped fiber brush volumizes and lengthens without clumping, giving you dramatic, sculpted lashes in just one swipe.
Smudge-proof, flake-free, and long-lasting, this paraben-free, ophthalmologist-tested formula is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Whether for daily wear or special occasions, this mascara delivers intense color and limitless volume that lasts all day.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Lengthening、Thickening |
MaydearPink Mascara for Eyelashes
| Color | Brown、Blue、Green、Pink、White |
|---|
Bold volume, vibrant color—lashes that last
Get instant, dramatic volume with Maydear Mascara, a smudge-proof, flake-free formula that keeps lashes full and defined all day. Available in vibrant shades like Rose, this mascara lets you create bold or natural looks with ease.
Designed to lengthen and nourish, its non-toxic formula promotes healthier, stronger lashes over time. Perfect for everyday wear, parties, and performances, this high-impact mascara ensures your eyes stand out in any setting.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Thickening |
24-Hour Mascara
Turn up the drama with Lestpola 5D Silk Fiber Mascara, a waterproof, smudge-proof formula that delivers 24-hour volume, length, and curl. Infused with silk fibers for ultra-long, thick lashes, this mascara resists rain, sweat, and tears while keeping your lashes defined and voluminous all day.
Available in multiple vibrant colors, including bold blue, it features a large silicone brush for smooth, clump-free application. Hypoallergenic, vegan, and easy to remove, this mascara is perfect for every occasion, every mood, and every lash look you dream of.
| Waterproof | |
|---|---|
| Hyperallergenic | |
| Brush Type | Curved、Thickening、Lengthening |
Natalya's Recommended Colored Mascara
The Big Prime Conditioning Lash Primer by Morphe is a primer with blue coloring to add more volume and amplify your regular mascara. Since this is a blue color, you can wear this alone for a pop of color. It's great for naturally short lashes because it adds length and volume. This product does not flake or clump on the lashes due to the fact it is created as a primer.
I first saw this mascara worn by one of my roommates. She wears this daily on its own. She wears a clean makeup look and adds her pop of color with this blue mascara. She makes it her brand. I love when she wears this mascara because it makes her eye color pop! I added this to my kit for those who want to wear it for a fun night out or for a fun editorial shoot.
Frequently Asked Questions
In addition to checking our buying guide for accuracy, Natalya took the time to answer some commonly asked questions about colored mascaras.
How do I make colored mascara?
"You can DIY your own colored mascara at home if you do not want to buy the whole product yourself. This would be a good idea to see if you really enjoy the look of colored lashes before you go out and buy something that you won't use," Natalya told us.
"A mixing medium and eyeshadow is one way to create a colored lash. A makeup mixing medium by Inglot is a great option for turning powders into liquids. Scrape some eyeshadow onto a clean surface and mix with the mixing medium. You then should have a clean spooly that does not have any product on it to apply with. You can find disposable spoolies on Amazon. Then apply as you would mascara."
She adds, "If you have disposable lash brushes, another way to DIY color mascara would be colorful eyeliner. You would dip the spooly into the liner product and apply directly to the lashes."
How do you make colored mascara show up on dark lashes?
Natalya taught us this secret: "Dark lashes will not show the color mascara as much as blonde lashes would. If you do not have a lash primer and need to make your colorful mascara as vibrant as can be, you can use your everyday concealer to prime the lashes. Coat the lashes with concealer to add a lighter base for the colored mascara.
If you are wanting to make your false lashes colored, you can use this same technique and apply concealer to the false lashes before applying to the eye. You would apply concealer with a brush or spooly to the dark lashes and then go in with your colored mascara for the extra pop to the eye."
Looking for More Eye Makeup?
To get a perfect makeup look, it requires practice and quality makeup tools. But, the most important thing is to choose products that suit your skin tone, outfits, and any concerns to fix your problem areas. Check out our suggestions to find out which makeup products are suitable for you.
Top 5 Colored Mascaras
No. 1: BINGBRUSH｜Multi-colored Mascara
No. 2: BONNIE CHOICE｜9 Colors Colored Mascara Set
No. 3: L'Oreal Paris｜Telescopic Lift
No. 4: UCANBE｜Burgundy Mascara and Liquid Eyeliner Set
No. 5: CAKAILA｜3 Color Colored Mascara Set
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Most ViewedFeatured Rankings Similar to Colored Mascaras
Search by category
Health
Body care products, Health accessories, Health foods and supplementsBeauty
Blushes, Bronzers, CleansersHome goods
Bath supplies, Ceremonial occasion supplies, Cleaning suppliesHome electronics
Air conditioners and coolers, AV accessories, Blenders and food processorsPC
Computer supplies, Desktop computers, TabletsCamera
Camera bags and backpacks, Camera supplies, Digital single lens camerasFood and drinks
Jams and Jellies, Alcohol, BreadsKitchen
Coffee and tea products, Cooking utensils, CupsFashion
Footwear products, Men's shoes, SandalsAccessories
Wristwatches, Accessories and jewelry, Umbrellas and parasolsKids and baby
Baby carriers, Baby food, Baby formulaInterior
Beds, Beds and bedding, ChairsHobbies
Aromatherapy products, Art supplies, Arts and collectiblesOutdoor
Barbecue grills and fire pits, Camping beds and cots, Camping gearHome, garden, and tools
Agricultural materials and gardening supplies, Exterior and garden furniture, Materials and repairing agentsSports and fitness
Sports shoes, Surfing supplies, Badminton suppliesPets
Bird and small animal supplies, Cat Supplies, Dog SuppliesMedia
Books and magazines, CD, Children's books, picture books and illustrated encyclopediasGames
Gaming accessories, Nintendo Switch games, PC gamesApps
Business apps, Cooking apps, Dating appsAutomotive
Car accessories, Car navigation systemsGifts
Christmas gifts, Father's Day gifts, Gifts for childrenMobile devices
Mobile phone and smartphone accessories, Wearable devices and smart watches