mybest
Cooking utensilsHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Cooking utensilsHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More) 5

10 Best Ice Cube Trays in 2022 (OXO, W&P, and More)

There's nothing like a cool and refreshing drink on a warm summer day - or any day for that matter. If you like to keep your drinks cool, it's great to invest in a good-quality ice cube tray. This is a must-have, especially if you don't have an ice maker. You can also opt for ice cube trays with fun molds that will let you personalize your drinks.


We've made your search for the best ice cube tray easier by finding you 10 of the best products. Our favorite is from Doquas. These trays with lids combine silicone for easy removal of the cubes, and plastic for rigidity. Check out the rest of our picks and read on to see our handy buying guide that will help you make your choice.

Last updated 09/26/2023

Quick List - Top Ice Cube Trays

1

Doquas

Easy-Release Ice Tray
Easy-Release Ice Tray

Best Plastic and Silicone Trays With Lids

2

Kitch

Ice Tray Easy Release
Ice Tray Easy Release

Best Simple and Easy Release Ice Cube Trays

3

Arrow Home

60 Cube Ice Tray
60 Cube Ice Tray

Best for Smoothies and Concentrated Drinks

4

OXO

Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

Best for Stacking and Easy Storage

5

Adoric

Ice Ball and Square Molds
Ice Ball and Square Molds

Best for Keeping Your Drinks Cold and Concentrated

mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

Why You Can Trust Us

Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.


mybest’s Content Policy

How to Choose Ice Cube Trays

When buying an ice cube tray, always consider the tray's material, capacity, size, and mold. This buying guide will help you come to a decision!

1

Consider Your Needs to Choose the Mold Shape

Consider Your Needs to Choose the Mold Shape

It's essential to consider the ice tray's mold shape by how you intend to use the ice. If you want to put ice in your narrow-mouthed water bottle, opt for long thin molds, but if you're going to keep drinks like whiskey cold without diluting it quickly, opt for big sphere-shaped ones that melt slowly. 


You can go for square or rectangular molds if you want to freeze herbs to preserve their intense flavor for use later. Nowadays, you can even find ice cube trays with uniquely shaped molds like stars, hearts, and more. These will make your drinks look more personalized and fun, especially if you have kids. You can also use them to create homemade desserts. 


You can also look for trays that come with lids. Lids will help keep your trays organized, prevent contamination, and keep your ice free from odors and flavors from other items in your freezer.


Ones that come with lids are also especially helpful if you’re going to buy multiple trays. Ice cube trays with covers make them easily stackable. These will save you space and allow you to make more ice at a time. 

2

Look for Sturdy Ice Cube Tray Materials

Ice cube trays are made of different materials like plastic, silicone, and steel. Each of these materials has advantages and disadvantages that you should keep in mind when choosing.

Plastic Trays Are Lightweight but Breakable

Plastic Trays Are Lightweight but Breakable

The most common kind of ice cube tray is made of plastic. Plastic trays are lightweight and easy to clean. However, these can be too rigid, which makes them susceptible to breaking when twisted too much. 


Most plastic ice cube trays can also be easy to clean and dishwasher-safe. However, they tend to absorb food odors over time. You also might want to look for Bisphenol A or BPA-free plastic ice trays, since this chemical has been linked to health problems, especially in children, when used in food products.

Silicone Is Versatile and Easy to Use

Silicone Is Versatile and Easy to Use

Silicone trays are durable, lightweight, and more flexible than plastic and steel. However, just like plastic, silicone tends to absorb odors from the freezer.


These can be hard to fill up because of their flexibility. They might also have a sticky texture that is prone to trapping residue, which means they require more frequent cleaning, especially if you use them for freezing things other than water. Even so, they are easy to clean, and most are dishwasher safe.


Their main advantage is that it is much easier to remove the ice with silicone trays, and they can come in fun shapes that will help you personalize your drinks. You can also use these to make desserts like cheesecake pops, froyo pops, and Jell-O.


If you are worried that your ice cube tray is too flexible, you can opt for ice cube trays made of both plastic and silicone. These have the flexibility of silicone molds but with plastic frames that offer more stability.


You can also use some silicone ice cube trays for cooking and baking. These are great additions to your kitchen because they are safe to use in the microwave and oven. Silicone is temperature resistant to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Check the manufacturer's specifications to make sure before making your chocolates or muffins in them, though!

Stainless Steel Is Rigid but Won't Crack

Stainless Steel Is Rigid but Won't Crack

Although not as common as plastic and silicone ice cube trays, you can also find stainless steel ice cube trays. These are heavier and more durable compared to plastic. They are less prone to absorbing food smells over time, plus, they're dishwasher safe. 


Your ice should also freeze faster in a metal tray since metal doesn't insulate the water well. However, these trays do not form perfect cubes. Getting ice out of these trays can also be challenging. They usually come with a lever that you need to lift to break the ice cubes apart to remove them.

3

Pick a Size and Capacity That Works for You

Pick a Size and Capacity That Works for You

When thinking of which ice tray to buy, you also have to think about how big you want your ice cubes to be and how many you want to make. Ice trays that make larger three- to four-inch cubes are great if you want something that will melt slower. Although they take more time to freeze, they are ideal for drinks you don’t want to get diluted fast. 


However, bigger ice means one ice tray can only make about two to four cubes. You also have to consider the freezing time, so this might not be as efficient unless you buy multiple trays. 


There are others that make super small cubes the size of pebbles. Although these melt quicker, they work well with concentrated drinks. These are also useful for making smoothies since they will be easier for your blender to crush. Ice trays that make these can make up to 60 ice cubes. 


If you want something in between, you can always opt for standard ice trays, making medium-sized cubes about one to one and a half inches and making around 12 to 16 or more ice cubes. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Ice Cube Trays Ranking

Here are the best Ice Cube Trays, ranked according to 10 Best Ice Cube Trays (as of 11-04-2022). The products are ranked independently by mybest.
Popularity

Products

Image

Click to purchase

Key features

1

Doquas

Easy-Release Ice Tray

Doquas Easy-Release Ice Tray 1

Best Plastic and Silicone Trays With Lids

2

Kitch

Ice Tray Easy Release

Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release  1

Best Simple and Easy Release Ice Cube Trays

3

Arrow Home

60 Cube Ice Tray

Arrow Home 60 Cube Ice Tray 1

Best for Smoothies and Concentrated Drinks

4

OXO

Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray 1

Best for Stacking and Easy Storage

5

Adoric

Ice Ball and Square Molds

Adoric Ice Ball and Square Molds 1

Best for Keeping Your Drinks Cold and Concentrated

6

W&P

Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray

W&P Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray 1

Best Silicone Ice Tray With Internal Frame

7

Webake

Webake  1

Best for Making Fun Drinks or Homemade Desserts

8

Lily's Home

Narrow Ice Stick Tray

Lily's Home  Narrow Ice Stick Tray 1

Best for Water Bottles With Small Openings

9

Shaped

3D Skull Ice Mold

Shaped 3D Skull Ice Mold 1

Best for Unique Drinks to Serve at Parties

10

RSVP International

Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray

RSVP International Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray 1

Best Stainless Steel Tray That Freezes Fast

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Doquas
Easy-Release Ice Tray

Easy-Release Ice Tray 1
Source:amazon.com
Easy-Release Ice Tray 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$10.99
Mid
Reference price
$10.99
Mid

Best Plastic and Silicone Trays With Lids

Pros:

  • Made of BPA-free plastic and silicone
  • Comes with lids that prevent contamination and allow them to stack neatly  
  • Each lid has two handles that make the tray easier to open
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher friendly

Cons:

  • A few buyers said it wasn't as durable as they had hoped

Daquas's ice cube trays are made with BPA-free plastic, which gives the tray structure, and silicone at the bottom, making ice easy to remove. The trays have rounded rectangle molds and lids that enable you to stack them easily and prevent contamination from other food in the freezer. These are also dishwasher-safe, making them a breeze to clean.


Some buyers said that the trays broke just after a few uses. You should not twist them to remove the ice cubes! Still, many more reviewers loved that the trays were easy to use, and the stable stacking helped keep their freezer more organized. They also liked that the lids prevented spills and leaks.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Kitch
Ice Tray Easy Release

Reference price
$6.95
Low

Best Simple and Easy Release Ice Cube Trays

Pros:

  • Made in the USA with FDA-approved materials
  • Features two handles at the end to make twisting the tray more manageable
  • BPA-free and dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Some users said the trays got stuck together when stacked

Made in the USA, these ice trays are simple and straightforward to use. They are made of plastic that is flexible for easy release. The trays are also stackable, allowing you to save space, as well as BPA-free and dishwasher-safe.


Some said that the trays did not stack well together, but the majority of buyers were happy that ice cubes came out with ease. They said the handles at the edge of the trays helped in quickly releasing the ice cubes. They also are happy with the size of the cubes they make.

No.3

Arrow Home
60 Cube Ice Tray

Reference price
$9.99
Low Mid

Best for Smoothies and Concentrated Drinks

Pros:

  • Creates 60 mini cubes per tray
  • Made with BPA-free and dishwasher-safe plastic
  • Designed to be stackable and space-saving

Cons:

  • Could be hard to fill and remove ice from the tray

If you are looking for a mold to make tiny ice, these trays are the ones for you. They make 60 mini ice pebbles each, which are great for water bottles and smoothies. The trays are made of BPA-free plastic and are dishwasher-safe. 


Some reviewers complained about how hard the ice was to remove from the trays. A few also said that they didn't stack well. But for the most part, customers liked that the ice pebbles worked well with their blenders. They also appreciated that they freeze quickly and that they can make a lot.

No.4

OXO
Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

Reference price
$10.99
Mid

Best for Stacking and Easy Storage

Pros:

  • Comes with a silicone lid that lets you squeeze out excess water
  • Equipped with grip handles that make it easier to fill up and carry to the refrigerator 
  •  Features a rounded bottom for quick ice removal
  • Can be stored in any position in the freezer without leaking 

Cons:

  • There were a few buyers who said the tray had a plastic smell that was hard to get rid of

OXO's ice cube tray comes with a silicone lid and grip handles that make it easy to store and stack. Not only that, but the cover also keeps the ice from absorbing freezer odor and lets you freeze ice sideways! The tray is made of plastic and has a rounded cube mold for easy release. The lid is silicone.


A few reviewers had trouble filling the tray and made a mess when they tried to do so. Nonetheless, most buyers were happy with their purchase. They loved how easy it was to get the ice cubes out. They also liked that they can place it at any angle in the freezer without leaking.

No.5

Adoric
Ice Ball and Square Molds

Reference price
$12.97
Mid

Best for Keeping Your Drinks Cold and Concentrated

Pros:

  • Made with silicone that makes ice easier to release
  • Silicone is naturally BPA-free, and safe for the dishwasher, microwave, and oven
  • Can be used from minus 40 to 446 degrees Fahrenheit
Cons:
  • Some have a strong chemical smell
  • Can leave a white film that's hard to remove 

These are great if you like to enjoy cocktails, whiskey, or if you're looking for bigger ice. You get two ice trays that have large rounded and cube molds. The silicone is dishwasher-safe and even safe to use in the oven or microwave if you want to use them for baking.


Some buyers had issues with a strong chemical smell and a white film that's hard to remove. But, other than that, more reviewers loved that the ice came out perfectly and quickly every time. They also liked that the trays made their drinks look cooler.

No.6

W&P
Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray

Reference price
$13.61
Mid

Best Silicone Ice Tray With Internal Frame

Pros:

  • Made with stainless steel frame that gives the tray more structure and stability
  • Silicone is naturally BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and oven-safe
  • Each mold is separated individually, making it easier to pop one cube out at a time
  • Comes with a protective cover 

Cons:

  • Tray might come with a strong smell, according to reviewers

This 12-cube tray is flexible and rigid at the same time. It is made with a silicone-wrapped stainless steel frame, making filling and transporting easier. In addition, the provided lid will block out flavors and odors from your freezer. This ice tray is available in other fun colors and prints too!


A few reviewers disliked the lid design. It's not meant to seal tightly, but will make stacking easier. Meanwhile, many said that they loved how the tray looked and how practical it was. They liked that it didn't take up much room in the freezer and that it was easy to use. 

No.7

Webake

Reference price
$12.99
Mid

Best for Making Fun Drinks or Homemade Desserts

Pros:

  • Made with flexible and food-grade silicone
  • Can be used as a mold for different homemade desserts, candies, and chocolate

Cons:

  • Does not come with a lid
  • Like all silicone trays, they can be too flexible, making it hard to get to the freezer without spilling

These fun ice cube trays come with heart-shaped molds that are perfect for kids, romantic cocktails, or fun parties. You can also use them to make homemade desserts and candies. They are made of flexible silicone, making them easy to unmold and clean. 


A small number of reviewers said that the tray was too flimsy and that it was hard to fill up and place in the fridge without spilling. Still, the majority loved that the ice cube tray made perfectly shaped hearts and it was easy to remove them from the tray. They liked that it was adorable and easy to use.

No.8

Lily's Home
Narrow Ice Stick Tray

Reference price
$12.99
Mid

Best for Water Bottles With Small Openings

Pros:

  • Makes ice that is approximately three and three-quarter inches long and under an inch in diameter
  • Bottom of the ice tray is made of BPA-free silicone, making it easier to remove the ice
  • Narrow molds make the ice freeze faster 

Cons:

  • Material can be too flexible to carry easily
  • Reviewers say the sticks can be hard to remove and hard to fill

These trays may be worth having if you want ice sticks for bottles with smaller openings. The trays are made with flexible and soft silicone for a quick release. With these, you'll get 10 ice sticks per colorful tray


A few reviewers noted that the trays were flimsy and hard to stack. Some also said they were messy to fill because they're shallow. On a positive note, many said that the ice sticks froze quickly and most importantly, they fit in bottles.

No.9

Shaped
3D Skull Ice Mold

Reference price
$12.50
Mid

Best for Unique Drinks to Serve at Parties

Pros:

  • Makes large ice cubes that are about two inches diameter
  • Made with naturally BPA-free silicone
  • Can be safely used in the microwave, oven, and dishwasher
  • Comes in gift box

Cons:

  • Might not give you the perfect skulls

This tray features a skull mold that will let you put your own twist on a drink. This makes large skull-shaped ice that lasts longer and is great if you don't want to dilute your drink fast. It is made from dishwasher-safe silicone and comes with a lid.


However, there were a few reviewers who said it was hard to get the two parts to seal together and turn out perfect skulls. Overall, though, many thought the ice the tray produced was cool. A lot of them used it for parties or as a gift. They also said the ice came out of the tray easily.

No.10

RSVP International
Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray

Reference price
$20.99
High

Best Stainless Steel Tray That Freezes Fast

Pros:

  • Constructed with stainless steel that is durable and corrosion-resistant
  • Lever that will break the ice off the tray easier 
  • Easy to clean, can be placed in the dishwasher
  • Retro design

Cons:

  • Might take time to get used to using it

This stainless steel tray can make 18 ice cubes. This type of tray came about in the 1950s. It has a two-part system, and it comes with an easy-release handle, so you won't have to struggle with releasing the ice. It's great if you're looking to reduce your use of plastics.


Reviewers say it does have a bit of a learning curve, so you don't end up with ice all over your kitchen when you pull the handle. But they say once you get the technique down, this brand is built to last and makes great ice. They also like that it freezes fast and doesn't hold odors.

Amazon's Best Selling Ice Cube Trays

If you need a little more help in choosing the best ice cube trays for you, or if you want to see the many different options you have, check out the best ice cube trays Amazon has to offer. 

Top 5 Ice Cube Trays

No. 1: DoquasEasy-Release Ice Tray

No. 2: KitchIce Tray Easy Release

No. 3: Arrow Home60 Cube Ice Tray

No. 4: OXOGood Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

No. 5: AdoricIce Ball and Square Molds

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Cooking utensils

Pastry Mats

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.