mybest
Drip Coffee Makers

Recommendation Service

  1. TOP
  2. Home electronics
  3. Coffee makers
  4. 14 Best Drip Coffee Makers in 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]
14 Best Drip Coffee Makers in 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

14 Best Drip Coffee Makers in 2023 [Tested and Reviewed]

A drip coffee maker allows you to easily brew one cup or large batches of coffee at the push of a button. But with so many options available from well-known brands like OXO, Bonavita, and Technivorm, you might be wondering, "What are the benefits of buying one?" and "Does the brand affect the taste?". In this article, we answer these questions and more.

We've compared 14 bestselling Drip Coffee Makers available online and put them to the test to recommend the best one for you.


We tested each product for the following:

  • Taste
  • Optimal Temperature Maintenance
  • Brewing Time
  • Ease of Cleaning
  • Compactness

Which product ended up being the best of the best? We'll also tell you how to pick the best Drip Coffee Makers on your own in our buying guide, so read on for more shopping tips.

Last updated 09/14/2023
Matt S
Expert
Matt S

Matt is the creator and host of Lifestyle Lab. He started his YouTube channel and blog in early 2020 to help aspiring “home baristas” make informed buying decisions and get the most out of their existing equipment. As an engineer by training, he tries to bring a systematic approach to my reviews and techniques, breaking things down so that people of all skill levels can understand. Over two years and 100+ videos later, he has built a supportive community of coffee lovers eager to learn (and help him learn) and look at the newest, most exciting products in the home brewing space.

Matt S's Profile
…Continue reading
Daisuke Ainoya
Guide
Head of Kitchen and Coffee at mybest
Daisuke Ainoya

For seven years, Daisuke has served specialty coffees as a barista and taught hand-drip latte art seminars. Currently, at mybest, he conducts the verification for all coffee-related products and equipment, including major manufacturers such as Kalita, Hario, and De'longhi, and specialty coffee brands such as Starbucks, UCC, Maruyama Coffee, and Blue Bottle Coffee. He creates content with the motto of "making ordinary coffee more delicious" by utilizing his experience as a barista. In addition, he also operates his own coffee roastery.

Daisuke Ainoya's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

Scroll to testing method
We gathered the 14 bestselling Drip Coffee Makers and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Taste

    Test① Taste

    The top priority when picking out a drip coffee maker is the taste of its brew. To figure out which products produce delicious black coffee, we had ten reviewers, who enjoy coffee every day, rate each machine on taste. The criteria for this evaluation include six aspects regarding taste.Evaluation CriteriaOverall tasteAromaBitternessStrengthSweetnessAcidityEvaluation Methodology1) Coffee was brewed according to each manufacturer's recommended six-serving recipe (using a "normal" setting when available)2) Conducted a post-brew taste testMaterials UsedCoffee grounds: Starbucks House BlendWater: Kirkland Signature Spring Water

  2. Optimal Temperature Maintenance

    Test② Optimal Temperature Maintenance

    Brewing temperature and temperature retention are crucial for enjoying a hot coffee. To figure out which coffee makers were best at this, we measured the immediate temperature and the temperature one hour after brewing at their minimum and maximum capacity. Products with higher brewing temperatures and those whose coffee temperature didn't drop after one hour were given higher ratings.Evaluation CriteriaMinimum capacity temperature immediately after brewingMaximum capacity temperature immediately after brewingMinimum capacity temperature one hour after brewingMaximum capacity temperature one hour after brewingEvaluation Methodology1) Brew coffee using each manufacturer's recipe for the minimum and maximum volume of coffee2) Measure temperature immediately after brewing3) Measure temperature one hour after brewing4) Assign ratings based on temperature differences post-brew

  3. Brewing Time

    Test③ Brewing Time

    Busy mornings call for the shortest possible brewing time. We measured the brew time for each product's minimum and maximum capacity in order to figure out which was the fastest. Shorter brew times received higher ratings.Evaluation CriteriaBrewing time for the minimum volume of coffeeBrewing time for the maximum volume of coffeeEvaluation Methodology1) Brew coffee using each manufacturer's recipe for the minimum and maximum volume of coffee2) Time the brewing process3) Rate based on brewing time

  4. Ease of Cleaning

    Test④ Ease of Cleaning

    An appliance you use every day has to be easy to clean. In order to figure out which coffee makers were easiest to clean, we rated them on factors such as whether they had detachable parts, their weight, and how easy they were to move around. Higher ratings were given to products that were lightweight, easy to move, and simple to clean.Evaluation CriteriaIs the water tank detachable?Is the carafe lid removable?Is it dishwasher-safe?How much does it weigh?

  5. Compactness

    Test⑤ Compactness

    Compactness is important for a coffee maker to fit well in your kitchen. To find the most compact products that won't get in the way, we rated each one based on the criteria below. We calculated the volume of each coffee maker, with smaller products receiving high ratings.Evaluation CriteriaA volume of less than 800 cubic inchesA volume of less than 950 cubic inchesA volume of less than 1,100 cubic inchesA volume of less than 1,200 cubic inchesA volume of less than 1,300 cubic inchesA volume of less than 1,400 cubic inchesA volume of more than 1,600 cubic inches

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

What Are the Benefits of a Drip Coffee Maker?

The main benefit to buying a drip coffee maker is the convenience of being able to brew delicious coffee at home, as well as the flexibility it provides over other pod or instant-style systems.

Enjoy Café-Quality Coffee at Home

Enjoy Café-Quality Coffee at Home

The first benefit of owning a drip coffee maker is the ability to enjoy café-quality coffee right at home. You'll be able to savor freshly brewed coffee using only grounds and water.


Using a drip coffee maker allows you to tailor your coffee's flavor by adjusting water temperature and brew ratios to your own personal preferences. This ensures that you can enjoy a consistently delicious cup of coffee every day without worrying if the flavors will be too weak or strong.

Low Cost per Cup Compared to a Coffee Shop

Low Cost per Cup Compared to a Coffee Shop

The second advantage is how much you'll save compared to buying from a coffee shop every day. While a single cup costs around five dollars from a café, brewing your own at home will cost between 50 cents to two dollars depending on the coffee used


That's a difference of about four dollars per cup, which could lead to savings of around $120 a month if you're a daily coffee drinker. Although buying a coffee maker comes with an upfront cost, the longer you use it, the more you'll be able to save on your daily expenses.

Does the Coffee Maker Brand Affect the Taste?

Does the taste of the coffee brewed differ based on the manufacturer or model? For this round of tests, we used the same brand of coffee beans to see whether it affected the taste.

Significant Differences in Flavor: Various Factors Influence the Taste

Significant Differences in Flavor: Various Factors Influence the Taste

Even though we used the same coffee beans, the brewed taste differed depending on the drip coffee maker used.


Upon testing, we noticed distinctions in taste between each coffee maker, such as a full bitter flavor or pronounced fruit-like acidity. Differences in drip tray height, brewing temperature consistency, brewing methods, and pour timing resulted in varied flavors from each manufacturer and model.


Knowing exactly how each drip coffee maker impacts the taste of the coffee can be the key factor that influences which one you choose.

How to Choose Drip Coffee Makers

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Drip Coffee Makers.

① Enjoy Delicious Coffee Every Morning With the Moccamaster KBT

Our testers concluded that the overall top-rated product was Technivorm's Moccamaster KBT. It received high ratings for the flavor of coffee brewed and its short brewing time.

Balanced Flavor With a Firm Bitterness

Balanced Flavor With a Firm Bitterness

During the taste tests, all 10 of our coffee enthusiasts said this coffee maker brews delicious coffee, ranking it first for flavor.


When sampling coffee from this model, testers said that it brought out strong notes of bitterness, acidity, and sweetness. Thanks to the machine's temperature stability and pour timing adjustment features, the coffee had a well-balanced acidity and bitterness similar to pour-over coffee but with less astringency.


While other machines were also able to produce a strong bitterness, few were able to get a good balance between acidity and sweetness. Technivorm's Moccamaster KBT was the best at achieving a balanced blend of robust bitterness, acidity, and sweetness.


Many of our testers reported that, compared to the other coffee makers, it offered a distinct bitterness and enjoyable acidity. We recommend this drip coffee maker to anyone seeking a rich and deep coffee flavor.

Quick Brews for Your Busy Mornings

Quick Brews for Your Busy Mornings

Drip coffee makers generally start their brewing process once they are loaded up with coffee grounds, filled with water, and switched on. However, brew times differ based on various factors, such as how fast the water can be boiled and the brewing method.


Technivorm's Moccamaster KBT takes about two minutes and 50 seconds to brew two cups of coffee. You can have a nice cup of coffee brewing while you get ready for your day by simply adding the water and coffee grounds when you wake up.


Some products, however, take over seven minutes to brew the same two-cup quantity. So if you prefer taking your time over a delicious morning coffee, choose a product with a short brew time.

Cleaning Can Be Time-Consuming

Cleaning Can Be Time-Consuming

Cleaning up after using a drip coffee maker can be a bit of a challenge. While most of the water in the tank is used during brewing, there can be a small amount that remains after. Since this machine doesn't have a detachable water tank, you'll have to lift up the entire machine to drain it.


Moreover, since you can't remove the tank to wash it, you won't be able to use a sponge or soap to give it a thorough cleaning. For those concerned with the cleanliness of their machine, we advise periodically wiping out the water tank with a clean cloth to prevent stagnant water and grime build-up.


Leaving water in your coffee maker's reservoir can cause bacterial growth, so it's important to completely drain and dry it out after use.

② The Ninja Is Our Top Pick for Those Who Drink a Lot of Coffee

The Ninja Is Our Top Pick for Those Who Drink a Lot of Coffee

Ninja's Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker Pro secured second place in our ranking for this round of testing. It earned high marks for its brewing temperature, temperature retention, and ease of cleaning.

Enjoy a Warm Cup of Coffee Anytime Thanks to the Heat Plate

Enjoy a Warm Cup of Coffee Anytime Thanks to the Heat Plate

This machine's optimal temperature maintenance feature will keep your pot of coffee warm for longer. Measuring the temperature one hour after brewing, we saw a noticeable difference in models equipped with a heat plate and a stainless steel carafe.


Coffee makers with optimal temperature maintenance heat the base of the carafe, keeping your coffee's temperature from dropping and sometimes even raising it. This test found that the average temperature of the Ninja's coffee increased by 44.78°F one hour after brewing.


Although products with a stainless steel carafe also provide some temperature retention, we noted a temperature decrease of 53.6°F one hour after brewing. We recommend a drip coffee maker with optimal temperature maintenance for those who like to sip and enjoy their coffee slowly.


The Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO's optimal temperature maintenance will retain the warmth and flavor of your brew for an extended period. However, caution is advised when the coffee in your carafe starts to run low since it may boil dry.

A Removable Water Tank Makes Daily Cleaning Easy

A Removable Water Tank Makes Daily Cleaning Easy

This machine features a removable water reservoir, making daily cleaning effortless. Having a detachable water tank simplifies draining as you won't need to lift the entire machine to empty it.


The design also allows you to give it a thorough scrub in the sink. If you're concerned about your coffee maker's upkeep or hassle-free cleaning is a priority, be sure to choose a product with a removable water tank.

The Ninja Stands Out With Balanced Flavor and Optimal Temperature Maintenance

The Ninja Stands Out With Balanced Flavor and Optimal Temperature Maintenance

The Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO received the highest ratings for taste among the drip coffee makers with optimal temperature maintenance.


When we took a sip of the coffee brewed by this machine, it stood out for having a pure and fruity acidity compared to other makers with suitable temperature maintenance. There were also fewer variations in taste, typically caused by temperature differences, which resulted in a clear and fruity acidity drawn out through the consistent brew temperature.


Our product reviewers noted that it had a bright acidity, which made it very easy to drink. Many of the other drip coffee makers with optimal temperature maintenance lacked depth of flavor.


We recommend the Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO if you're after a drip coffee maker with optimal temperature maintenance that brews delicious coffee.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?
It was helpful.
It wasn't helpful.

14 Best Drip Coffee Makers Ranking

Here are the best Drip Coffee Makers we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Edit rankings
Recommended
Sort by
Filter
Warm coffee all morning long
Fast brewing
Compact models
Easy to clean
Sort by
Price x RatingHow important is each one to you?
Price
0%
Product-testing Rating
100%
Breakdown of Product-testing CriteriaHow was each criteria weighted?
Filter
Detachable water tank
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function
Reset
Products
Image
Total score
Click to purchase
Key features
Ranking spec
Details
Taste
Optimal temperature maintenance
Brewing time
Ease of cleaning
Compactness
Width
Depth
Height
Weight
Brewable cups (total)
Detachable water tank
Minimum brew time
Minimum brew temperature
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function
1

Technivorm

Moccamaster KBT

Technivorm  Moccamaster KBT 1枚目
4.04

A Delicious Taste Reminiscent of Pour-Over Coffee and Our Top Recommendation You’ll Want to Use Every Morning

4.11
3.99
4.20
3.70
3.87

11.5 in.

6.75 in.

15.25 in.

6 lb.

10 cups

N/A

2min50second

167°F

-

2

Shark Ninja Operating

Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO

Shark Ninja Operating Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO 1枚目
3.95

For an Endless Supply of Piping Hot Coffee With a Clean Flavor

3.99
4.16
3.45
4.20
3.92

7.87 in.

10 in.

14.25 in.

6.39 lb.

14 cups

5min

84.4°F

3

Ratio

Ratio Six

Ratio Ratio Six 1枚目
3.80

Includes a Steam Blooming Function for a Balanced Brew

3.78
3.95
4.20
3.60
3.46

6.75 in.

13.5 in.

14.25 in.

8 lb.

8 cups

N/A

2min32second

167°F

-

4

Bonavita

Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee Brewer

Bonavita Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee Brewer 1枚目
3.78

Enjoy a Robust Bitterness, Even if Brewing Takes Time

3.87
4.17
3.20
3.70
4.32

6.8 in.

12.4 in.

12.2 in.

5.8 lb.

8 cups

N/A

1min17second

173.5 °F

-

5

OXO

9-Cup Coffee Maker

OXO 9-Cup Coffee Maker 1枚目
3.75

A Quick Brewing Time, but Lacks Full-Bodied Taste

3.75
3.76
3.90
3.70
3.53

15in.

8.3in.

17.2in.

10.5lb.

9 cups

N/A

3min56second

162°F

-

6

Café

Cafe Café Specialty Drip Coffee Maker

Café Café Specialty Drip Coffee Maker 1枚目
3.72

Top-Notch for Short Brewing Time, but Imbalanced Taste Sets It Back

3.69
3.74
4.14
3.60
3.55

7.3 in.

12.5 in.

14 in.

9.5 lb.

10 cups

N/A

2min10second

158°F

7

Cuisinart

Cuisinart Brew Central 12 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

Cuisinart Cuisinart Brew Central 12 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker 1枚目
3.63

Compact for Easy Placement, but the Coffee Has a Light Aftertaste

3.50
4.27
3.60
3.70
4.50

9 in.

7.75 in.

14 in.

9.7 lb.

12 cups

N/A

3min41second

172.6°F

8

Mr. Coffee

Mr. Coffee Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker, Brew Now or Later

Mr. Coffee  Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker, Brew Now or Later 1枚目
3.61

A Rich Taste and Strong Bitterness, but Not Well-Balanced

3.63
4.36
3.20
3.33
4.42

8 in.

12.3 in.

12.5 in.

4.8 lb.

12 cups

N/A

5min40second

172.9°F

9

Black & Decker

12 Servings Programmable Coffeemaker

Black & Decker 12 Servings Programmable Coffeemaker 1枚目
3.60

Enjoy a Bold Acidity and Bitterness, Even if Hindered by a Slow Brewing Time

3.75
4.50
3.00
3.33
4.45

8.4 in.

11.5 in.

13.3 in.

4.9 lb.

12 cups

N/A

6min14second

179.1°F

10

Cuisinart

Cuisinart 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

Cuisinart  Cuisinart 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker 1枚目
3.58

A Rich Taste With a Strong Bitterness, but Held Back by a Lengthy Brewing Time

3.63
4.28
3.00
3.70
4.10

9 in.

7.75 in.

14 in.

9.6 lb.

14 cups

N/A

5min4second

170.6°F

Product details
Close
If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Drip Coffee Makers
No.1 in Taste

Technivorm Moccamaster KBT79112

Overall rating

4.04

  • Taste
    4.11
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.99
  • Brewing time
    4.20
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    3.87
Moccamaster KBT Image 1
Lowest price
$339.00
Brewable cups (total)10 cups
Minimum brew time2min50second
Minimum brew temperature167°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function-

A Delicious Taste Reminiscent of Pour-Over Coffee and Our Top Recommendation You’ll Want to Use Every Morning

The Moccamaster KBT by Technivorm is certified by the Specialty Coffee Association for meeting its Golden Cup standards. The drip head comes with a stopper for manual adjustment that can be used to fine-tune the brewing time.


This machine is designed to pour hot water over the coffee grounds evenly, ensuring complete coverage without missing a single grain. The brewed coffee has a rich taste, and all the flavor notes are distinct. Our product reviewers noted that the bitterness, acidity, and sweetness were well-balanced and that they'd happily drink it every day.


With a short brewing time of just two minutes and 50 seconds for two cups, there's almost no wait time until your coffee is ready. Perfect for busy mornings. The brewing temperature for two cups of coffee was average at 167 degrees Fahrenheit, but it received slightly lower ratings due to the lack of an optimal temperature maintenance feature.


The coffee maker measures 11.5 inches wide, 6.75 inches long, and 15.25 inches high. It will fit on most kitchen countertops with its narrow width and length, but the height may require extra space. The water tank is not removable, so you'll have to lift the entire machine to empty the reservoir.


This machine brews coffee that tastes similar to pour-over, making it our top recommendation for those who want to enjoy a well-balanced bitterness, acidity, and sweetness, even on busy mornings.

Width11.5 in.
Depth6.75 in.
Height15.25 in.
Weight6 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
Was this Ranking helpful?
It was helpful.
It wasn't helpful.
No.2
No.1 in Ease of cleaning

Shark Ninja OperatingNinja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRODCM201

Overall rating

3.95

  • Taste
    3.99
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.16
  • Brewing time
    3.45
  • Ease of cleaning
    4.20
  • Compactness
    3.92
Brewable cups (total)14 cups
Minimum brew time5min
Minimum brew temperature84.4°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

For an Endless Supply of Piping Hot Coffee With a Clean Flavor

The Ninja XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO's standout feature is that it can brew up to 14 cups at once. It promises to produce a coffee full of flavor thanks to careful control of the brewing temperature.

By keeping the brewing temperature consistent, the coffee has minimal impurities and robust acidity. Our testers noted that the brew was fruity with a shining acidity and light enough to enjoy many cups, earning it high ratings for taste.


The Ninja also received high ratings for brewing temperature and optimal heat maintenance. While the brewing temperature for two cups was average at 167 degrees Fahrenheit, the optimal temperature maintenance makes use of a heater. This prevents your coffee from cooling, even on your second or third cup. The water reservoir is detachable, easy to clean, and dishwasher-safe, making tank maintenance effortless.


With compact dimensions of 7.87 inches in width, 10 inches in length, and 14.25 inches in height, this machine won't take up much space, even in smaller kitchens. On the downside, the brewing time for two cups is fairly long, at five minutes, which isn't ideal for busy mornings.


We recommend this coffee maker for anyone who prefers a fruity yet refreshing coffee, as well as those who enjoy many cups throughout the day.

Width7.87 in.
Depth10 in.
Height14.25 in.
Weight6.39 lb.
Detachable water tank
No.3

RatioRatio SixSix

Overall rating

3.80

  • Taste
    3.78
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.95
  • Brewing time
    4.20
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.60
  • Compactness
    3.46
Brewable cups (total)8 cups
Minimum brew time2min32second
Minimum brew temperature167°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function-

Includes a Steam Blooming Function for a Balanced Brew

The Ratio Six Drip Coffee Maker can brew up to eight cups of coffee at once. It comes equipped with a steamer, which simulates a barista's pour-over technique.


As the coffee grounds can bloom before the brewing process, this machine fully extracts both bitter and acidic notes. However, the bitter notes tend to be slightly overpowering, resulting in an imbalance. Our reviewers indicated that the brewed coffee was moderately acidic, but the bitterness was a bit too strong.


The brewing time is short, producing two cups in two minutes and 32 seconds, so you won't have any stress waiting for your brew to finish in the morning. It has an average brewing temperature of 167 degrees Fahrenheit for two cups of coffee, and although it lacks optimal temperature maintenance functionality, the stainless steel carafe is well-insulated. This allows you to enjoy your coffee without it going cold for about an hour.


Removing the water tank is a bit challenging, and the machine's nearly 11-pound weight makes draining somewhat cumbersome. Size-wise, the length is slightly larger than usual, so you'll need to think about where you'd place this machine if your countertop is shallow.


This machine is a great choice for those who want to enjoy a robust coffee flavor and also prioritize a quick brewing time.

Width6.75 in.
Depth13.5 in.
Height14.25 in.
Weight8 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.4

BonavitaBonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee BrewerBV1901TS

Overall rating

3.78

  • Taste
    3.87
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.17
  • Brewing time
    3.20
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    4.32
Brewable cups (total)8 cups
Minimum brew time1min17second
Minimum brew temperature173.5 °F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function-

Enjoy a Robust Bitterness, Even if Brewing Takes Time

The Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee Brewer is another product that has met the Specialty Coffee Association's (SCA) Golden Cup standards. It can brew up to eight cups of coffee at one time.


This maker's design ensures that hot water is evenly distributed over the coffee grounds during brewing to draw out a strong, full-bodied flavor. However, the bitterness of the coffee is overpowering. Our product reviewers said, "The bitter flavors are strong, while the acidic and sweet notes are faint."


It may not have optimal temperature maintenance, but the brewing temperature is reasonably high at 174 degrees Fahrenheit for two cups of coffee. Your coffee should remain warm for an hour if you keep it in the included stainless steel carafe. However, it takes a long time to brew at seven minutes and 17 seconds for two cups. While this may not be an issue for those with ample time in the morning, it may not be suitable if you're often in a rush.


The water tank cannot be removed, which makes cleaning and draining more of a hassle. With dimensions of 6.8 by 12.4 by 12.2 inches, this drip coffee maker is compact, so finding somewhere to place it shouldn't pose too much of a challenge.

Width6.8 in.
Depth12.4 in.
Height12.2 in.
Weight5.8 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.5

OXO9-Cup Coffee Maker8710100

Overall rating

3.75

  • Taste
    3.75
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.76
  • Brewing time
    3.90
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    3.53
Brewable cups (total)9 cups
Minimum brew time3min56second
Minimum brew temperature162°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function-

A Quick Brewing Time, but Lacks Full-Bodied Taste

The 9-Cup Coffee Maker by OXO is a certified product meeting the Golden Cup standards of the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA). It can make up to nine cups of coffee in a single batch.


Unfortunately, the brewed coffee tastes somewhat diluted and lacks a satisfying richness. Bitter notes are strong, while acidic and sweet flavors are subdued. Reviewers commented that while there's an initially strong bitterness from the first sip, it quickly fades away.


It brews coffee slightly faster than the average, providing two cups in three minutes and 56 seconds. The brewing temperature was slightly lower than the average, coming in at 162 degrees Fahrenheit for two cups. Luckily, the stainless steel carafe has excellent insulation, which earned this coffee maker good ratings for its brewing temperature and optimal temperature maintenance.


This machine may feel heavy to lift with its 7.7-pound weight, and the water tank is not removable, making it cumbersome to clean and drain. With dimensions of 15 inches in width, 8.3 inches in length, and 17.2 inches in height, you'll also need to plan where you'll put this larger-sized coffee maker before you buy.

Width15in.
Depth8.3in.
Height17.2in.
Weight10.5lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.6

CaféCafeCafé Specialty Drip Coffee MakerC7CDABS4RW3

Overall rating

3.72

  • Taste
    3.69
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.74
  • Brewing time
    4.14
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.60
  • Compactness
    3.55
Brewable cups (total)10 cups
Minimum brew time2min10second
Minimum brew temperature158°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

Top-Notch for Short Brewing Time, but Imbalanced Taste Sets It Back

Café's Specialty Drip Coffee Maker is certified to meet the SCA (Specialty Coffee Association) Golden Cup standards and can be linked to the SmartHQ app, allowing you to brew coffee using your favorite recipes directly from your device.


The taste of the brewed coffee has a markedly strong fruity acidity with a refreshing appeal. However, the bitter and sweet notes are faint. Our testers pointed out that it had a gorgeous aroma and fruit-like acidity, but the lack of bitterness resulted in an imbalanced taste.


With two cups brewed in just two minutes and 10 seconds, this machine is one of the fastest products we tested. There's barely any time to wait after powering it on, which is sure to be appreciated on busy mornings. The brewing temperature for two cups of coffee is slightly lower than average at 158 degrees Fahrenheit, but the optimal temperature maintenance function allows you to enjoy hot coffee for an extended period without it cooling off.


The water tank can't be taken off, and because this maker weighs around 8.8 pounds, cleaning and draining may be arduous. It's also on the larger side with dimensions of 7.3 inches in width, 12.5 inches in length, and 14 inches in height. This is another one requiring careful consideration of where to set it up.

Width7.3 in.
Depth12.5 in.
Height14 in.
Weight9.5 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.7
No.1 in Compactness

CuisinartCuisinart Brew Central 12 Cup Programmable CoffeemakerDCC-1200P1

Overall rating

3.63

  • Taste
    3.50
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.27
  • Brewing time
    3.60
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    4.50
Brewable cups (total)12 cups
Minimum brew time3min41second
Minimum brew temperature172.6°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

Compact for Easy Placement, but the Coffee Has a Light Aftertaste

The Brew Central Programmable Coffeemaker by Cuisinart can brew up to 12 cups of coffee per batch. It comes equipped with a heat plate that keeps your coffee at your preferred temperature.


The brewed coffee has a balanced mix of acidity, bitterness, and sweetness, but it feels a bit thin. Our product testers noted that it had a good balance but was too light with no aftertaste.


The 173 degrees Fahrenheit brewing temperature for two cups is relatively high, and with the optimal heat maintenance function, your coffee will stay nice and warm. It takes slightly longer to brew two cups of coffee than some, clocking three minutes and 41 seconds. This drip coffee maker isn't ideal for those who want to brew and drink their coffee immediately.


The water tank can't be detached, which makes cleaning tasks like draining and washing quite labor-intensive. It's 9 inches wide, 7.75 inches long, and has a height of 14 inches, so it's compact enough that you won't struggle to find a place for it.

Width9 in.
Depth7.75 in.
Height14 in.
Weight9.7 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.8

Mr. Coffee Mr. CoffeeMr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker, Brew Now or Later2132160

Overall rating

3.61

  • Taste
    3.63
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.36
  • Brewing time
    3.20
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.33
  • Compactness
    4.42
Brewable cups (total)12 cups
Minimum brew time5min40second
Minimum brew temperature172.9°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

A Rich Taste and Strong Bitterness, but Not Well-Balanced

The Brew Now or Later Programmable Coffeemaker by Mr. Coffee is able to make up to 12 cups of coffee per brew. Its stand-out feature is a timer, allowing you to set it to brew at a specific time.


The coffee has a full-bodied richness, but the balance is off due to an overpowering bitterness and weak acidity. The feedback we received noted that while there was a hint of rich and bitter notes, the coffee's heaviness made it difficult to keep drinking.


It brews coffee at a slightly higher temperature, with two cups of coffee measuring in at 173 degrees Fahrenheit. The optimal temperature maintenance function can even keep your coffee piping hot with zero cool-down for your second and third rounds. Brewing times, however, were recorded at five minutes and 40 seconds for two cups of coffee, which is considerably longer than average.


The water tank and carafe lid do not come apart, so draining and washing may be a struggle. But with smaller dimensions of 8 inches in width, 12.3 inches in length, and 12.5 inches in height, it's compact enough to comfortably fit in any available kitchen space.

Width8 in.
Depth12.3 in.
Height12.5 in.
Weight4.8 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.9
No.1 in Optimal temperature maintenance

Black & Decker12 Servings Programmable CoffeemakerDLX1050B-1

Overall rating

3.60

  • Taste
    3.75
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.50
  • Brewing time
    3.00
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.33
  • Compactness
    4.45
Brewable cups (total)12 cups
Minimum brew time6min14second
Minimum brew temperature179.1°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

Enjoy a Bold Acidity and Bitterness, Even if Hindered by a Slow Brewing Time

The 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker by Black+Decker can make up to 12 cups of coffee per brew. It stands out for its timer feature, which allows you to set your coffee to be brewed at a specific time.


The brewed coffee's flavor is strong and features distinct bitter and acidic tastes, though sweetness is lacking and creates an imbalanced profile. Our testers even said, "The overpowering bitterness and acidity made me grow tired of this coffee quite easily."


The brewing temperature for two cups is quite high, recorded at 179 degrees Fahrenheit during our tests. Plus, the optimal heat maintenance function will keep your coffee from cooling down, so you can enjoy a hot brew over a longer time. Brewing two cups of coffee takes a lengthy six minutes and 14 seconds, which isn't ideal when you're short on time.


Because both the water tank and carafe lid are not removable, cleaning this machine will be difficult. On the plus side, its compact dimensions of 8.4 inches in width, 11.5 inches in length, and 13.3 inches in height mean it will fit comfortably in smaller kitchens.

Width8.4 in.
Depth11.5 in.
Height13.3 in.
Weight4.9 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.10

Cuisinart Cuisinart 14 Cup Programmable CoffeemakerDCC-3200BKSP1

Overall rating

3.58

  • Taste
    3.63
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.28
  • Brewing time
    3.00
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    4.10
Brewable cups (total)14 cups
Minimum brew time5min4second
Minimum brew temperature170.6°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

A Rich Taste With a Strong Bitterness, but Held Back by a Lengthy Brewing Time

Cuisinart's 14-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker is able to produce 14 cups of coffee at once. It offers two modes, regular and bold, allowing you to brew coffee of varying strengths.


The coffee has a well-defined bitterness with rich notes. However, due to this pronounced bitterness, the acidity and sweetness are diluted, leading to a slightly imbalanced taste. Our reviewers included comments like, "I was surprised by how bitter this coffee tastes. It would have been better if the bitter and acidic notes were more balanced."


Two cups of coffee were recorded with a higher-than-average brewing temperature of 171 degrees Fahrenheit, and with the optimal temperature maintenance function, you'll be able to enjoy hot coffee all day. The brewing time for two cups, however, took a bit longer at five minutes and four seconds. This coffee maker won't be ideal for busy mornings.


Because the water tank isn't removable, draining and maintenance will be a challenge. It has a compact size you'll be able to fit easily in any kitchen space since its dimensions measure in at 9 inches in width, 7.75 inches in length, and 14 inches in height.

Width9 in.
Depth7.75 in.
Height14 in.
Weight9.6 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.11

OXO8-Cup Coffee Maker8718800

Overall rating

3.56

  • Taste
    3.42
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.82
  • Brewing time
    4.20
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.70
  • Compactness
    4.28
Brewable cups (total)8 cups
Minimum brew time2min44second
Minimum brew temperature164.1°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function-

A Short Brewing Time, but the Brewed Coffee Is Overpowering

The 8-Cup Coffee Maker by OXO is certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) for meeting their Golden Cup standards. It claims to evenly distribute hot water over coffee grounds to allow the optimal extraction of flavor.


The taste of this machine's coffee had various oddities that obscured its distinct bitter and acidic flavor, leaving our testers dissatisfied. They indicated that while there was a hint of bitterness and acidity, it was overpowered by a watery, slightly off flavor.


It has a fast brewing time, needing only two minutes and 44 seconds to make two cups of coffee. This is faster than average and will reduce the stress of waiting around when you're in a rush. On the other hand, the brewing temperature for two cups of coffee is lower than average at 164 degrees Fahrenheit. Although it lacks functionality for optimal temperature maintenance, the stainless steel carafe works well enough for you to enjoy hot coffee for about an hour.


Draining and washing may be a bit of a hassle since the water tank can't be removed. But this coffee maker's compact size won't get in the way even in smaller kitchens, thanks to its dimensions of 7 inches in width, 10.5 inches in length, and 13.5 inches in height.

Width7 in.
Depth10.5 in.
Height13.5 in.
Weight6.13 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.11

Hamilton Beach Brands2-Way Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Carafe49980A

Overall rating

3.56

  • Taste
    3.69
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.71
  • Brewing time
    3.60
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.33
  • Compactness
    3.00
Brewable cups (total)12cups
Minimum brew time4min20second
Minimum brew temperature156.6°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

Considerable Space Required Due to Its Large Size

The 2-Way Coffee Maker by Hamilton Beach Brands can provide up to 12 cups of coffee per batch. It offers two ways to brew: directly into your mug or into the carafe.


The coffee brewed by this maker balances notes of bitterness, acidity, and sweetness well. Yet, it also seems diluted and weak. Our reviewers stated, "You'll enjoy the balanced taste, but the coffee was thin with a watered-down concentration."


It brews two cups at a relatively low temperature of 164 degrees Fahrenheit, but the optimal temperature maintenance function allows you to enjoy hot coffee for longer. The brewing time is fairly long at four minutes and two seconds, so this coffee maker may not be the best match for busy mornings.


Once again, cleaning will be troublesome since the water tank can't be detached. You'll also have to carefully consider where this substantial coffee maker will go since it measures 12.2 inches in width, 11.1 inches in length, and 13.9 inches in height.

Width12.2 in.
Depth11.1 in.
Height13.9 in.
Weight4lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.13

BraunBraun PureFlavor Coffee MakerKF5650BK

Overall rating

3.53

  • Taste
    3.60
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    4.43
  • Brewing time
    3.00
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.33
  • Compactness
    3.91
Brewable cups (total)14 cups
Minimum brew time5min21second
Minimum brew temperature177.4°F
Dishwasher safe
Keep warm function

Adjustable Optimal Heat Maintenance, but the Brewed Coffee Is Imbalanced

The PureFlavor Coffee Maker by Braun is able to brew a maximum of 14 cups of coffee. It features a heat plate that can be set to keep your coffee at your preferred temperature.


The brewed coffee has a strong bitterness that makes it difficult to pick out any acidic or sweet notes. Our product testers commented, "It was extremely bitter from the very first sip. This aspect dominates the overall taste and masks the acidic and sweet flavors."


It brews at a slightly higher temperature than the average, with two cups of coffee reaching 171 degrees Fahrenheit. You'll also be able to enjoy a warm brew for longer thanks to the optimal temperature maintenance function. On the downside, the brewing time for two cups of coffee was about five minutes and 21 seconds, which is a bit slow and not the best for busy mornings.


You can't remove the water tank or carafe lid, so it won't be easy to clean and drain. However, it won't be an issue to place or store this machine in your kitchen since it has a compact size measuring 9.3 inches in width, 8.7 inches in length, and 14.8 inches in height.

Width9.3 in.
Depth8.7 in.
Height14.8 in.
Weight6.29 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A
No.14
No.1 in Brewing time

BrevilleBreville Precision Brewer Thermal Coffee MakerBDC450BSS1BUS1

Overall rating

3.50

  • Taste
    3.52
  • Optimal temperature maintenance
    3.28
  • Brewing time
    4.50
  • Ease of cleaning
    3.33
  • Compactness
    3.39
Brewable cups (total)12 cups
Minimum brew time2min51second
Minimum brew temperature140.2°F
Dishwasher safe-
Keep warm function-

Difficult to Clean, With a Brew That's Watered Down

The Precision Brewer Thermal Coffee Maker by Breville can make up to 14 cups of coffee at once. It features six brewing modes: Gold, Fast, Strong, Ice, Cold Brew, and My Brew.


The brewed coffee has hints of bitter and sweet notes, but the sweetness is practically undetectable, and the concentration is diluted. Our product reviewers said the coffee was neither bitter nor acidic, tasting more like tea.


This coffee maker has a fast brewing time of two minutes and 51 seconds for two cups, reducing any early-morning stress. The minimum brewing temperature is quite low at 140 degrees Fahrenheit, and because it has no optimal temperature maintenance, both this and the brewing temperature received low ratings.


This coffee maker is difficult to clean since it is not dishwasher-safe and has a non-removable water tank. It is also large and tall, measuring 6.7 inches in width, 12.7 inches in length, and 15.7 inches in height, so you'll have to find a designated space for it.

Width6.7 in.
Depth12.7 in.
Height15.7 in.
Weight3.15 lb.
Detachable water tankN/A

How We Tested the Drip Coffee Makers

Drip Coffee Makers Evaluation

We purchased the top 14 best-selling drip coffee makers available on sites such as Amazon to find out which is the best of the best. mybest defines the best drip coffee maker as a compact and easy-to-clean product that can brew a delicious coffee and prevent it from cooling too quickly.


We ran tests on the following five criteria in order to determine which product best meets this definition:

  • Taste
  • Optimal Temperature Maintenance
  • Brewing Time
  • Ease of Cleaning
  • Compactness

Products we tested

  1. Black & Decker12 Servings Programmable CoffeemakerDLX1050B-1
  2. BonavitaBonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee BrewerBV1901TS
  3. BraunBraun PureFlavor Coffee MakerKF5650BK
  4. BrevilleBreville Precision Brewer Thermal Coffee MakerBDC450BSS1BUS1
  5. CaféCafeCafé Specialty Drip Coffee MakerC7CDABS4RW3
  6. CuisinartCuisinart Brew Central 12 Cup Programmable CoffeemakerDCC-1200P1
  7. Cuisinart Cuisinart 14 Cup Programmable CoffeemakerDCC-3200BKSP1
  8. Hamilton Beach Brands2-Way Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Carafe49980A
  9. Mr. Coffee Mr. CoffeeMr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker, Brew Now or Later2132160
  10. OXO8-Cup Coffee Maker8718800
  11. OXO9-Cup Coffee Maker8710100
  12. RatioRatio SixSix
  13. Shark Ninja OperatingNinja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRODCM201
  14. Technivorm Moccamaster KBT79112

Test① Taste

Taste

The top priority when picking out a drip coffee maker is the taste of its brew. To figure out which products produce delicious black coffee, we had ten reviewers, who enjoy coffee every day, rate each machine on taste. The criteria for this evaluation include six aspects regarding taste.


Evaluation Criteria
  • Overall taste
  • Aroma
  • Bitterness
  • Strength
  • Sweetness
  • Acidity

Evaluation Methodology

1) Coffee was brewed according to each manufacturer's recommended six-serving recipe (using a "normal" setting when available)
2) Conducted a post-brew taste test


Materials Used
  • Coffee grounds: Starbucks House Blend
  • Water: Kirkland Signature Spring Water

Test② Optimal Temperature Maintenance

Optimal Temperature Maintenance

Brewing temperature and temperature retention are crucial for enjoying a hot coffee. To figure out which coffee makers were best at this, we measured the immediate temperature and the temperature one hour after brewing at their minimum and maximum capacity. Products with higher brewing temperatures and those whose coffee temperature didn't drop after one hour were given higher ratings.


Evaluation Criteria
  • Minimum capacity temperature immediately after brewing
  • Maximum capacity temperature immediately after brewing
  • Minimum capacity temperature one hour after brewing
  • Maximum capacity temperature one hour after brewing

Evaluation Methodology
1) Brew coffee using each manufacturer's recipe for the minimum and maximum volume of coffee
2) Measure temperature immediately after brewing
3) Measure temperature one hour after brewing
4) Assign ratings based on temperature differences post-brew

Test③ Brewing Time

Brewing Time

Busy mornings call for the shortest possible brewing time. We measured the brew time for each product's minimum and maximum capacity in order to figure out which was the fastest. Shorter brew times received higher ratings.


Evaluation Criteria

  • Brewing time for the minimum volume of coffee
  • Brewing time for the maximum volume of coffee


Evaluation Methodology

1) Brew coffee using each manufacturer's recipe for the minimum and maximum volume of coffee
2) Time the brewing process
3) Rate based on brewing time

Test④ Ease of Cleaning

Ease of Cleaning

An appliance you use every day has to be easy to clean. In order to figure out which coffee makers were easiest to clean, we rated them on factors such as whether they had detachable parts, their weight, and how easy they were to move around. Higher ratings were given to products that were lightweight, easy to move, and simple to clean.


Evaluation Criteria
  • Is the water tank detachable?
  • Is the carafe lid removable?
  • Is it dishwasher-safe?
  • How much does it weigh?

Test⑤ Compactness

Compactness

Compactness is important for a coffee maker to fit well in your kitchen. To find the most compact products that won't get in the way, we rated each one based on the criteria below. We calculated the volume of each coffee maker, with smaller products receiving high ratings.


Evaluation Criteria
  • A volume of less than 800 cubic inches
  • A volume of less than 950 cubic inches
  • A volume of less than 1,100 cubic inches
  • A volume of less than 1,200 cubic inches
  • A volume of less than 1,300 cubic inches
  • A volume of less than 1,400 cubic inches
  • A volume of more than 1,600 cubic inches

Top 5 Drip Coffee Makers

No. 1: Technivorm | Moccamaster KBT | 79112

No. 2: Shark Ninja Operating | Ninja Programmable XL 14-Cup Coffee Maker PRO | DCM201

No. 3: Ratio | Ratio Six | Six

No. 4: Bonavita | Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup Drip Coffee Brewer | BV1901TS

No. 5: OXO | 9-Cup Coffee Maker | 8710100

View Full Ranking

When you purchase products mentioned in the article, part of the sales may be returned to mybest.

Popular articles

Search by category