mybest
Dog GatesHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Dog GatesHelping You Find the Best
10 Best Dog Gates  [Tested and Reviewed]

10 Best Dog Gates [Tested and Reviewed]

Dog gates are the best way to secure your space so that your pets and family can be comfortable and safe in the environment. They can be installed in doorways, kitchens, under stairs, and any enclosed space where you don't want your dog to access. Also referred to as an indoor fence or railing, dog gates come in various types and installation methods, so it's important to do some research before you decide to purchase.

We've compiled 10 best-selling dog gates from a range of manufacturers, thoroughly examined them based on four points, and ranked them from best to worst.


At mybest, we think the best dog gate is one that securely restricts a dog's movement area and can be used without causing stress to the owner or pet. We will explain what qualities you should look for in a dog that best fits your needs so you can use it as a reference when purchasing.

Last updated 04/10/2024
Sheri Rydyznski
Expert
Pet Care Service Provider
Sheri Rydyznski

Sheri Rydyznski is a professional pet care service provider who operates Fetch.Sit.Stay. Cincinnati. LLC. When she’s not busy providing care for clients, she is an avid audiophile, curious traveler, entertaining raconteur and content creator for @fetch_sit_stay. She lives in the Greater Cincinnati, OH area with her husband and spirited tortie, Mischief.

Sheri Rydyznski's Profile
…Continue reading
Nanako Sekiguchi
Guide
Head of Pets at mybest
Nanako Sekiguchi

Since joining mybest, Nanako Sekiguchi has mainly overseen pet-related content. She has experience testing and comparing more than 350 pet products, from cat litter to pet strollers. Utilizing her own experience of living with dogs and cats, she strives to create content from both the perspectives of pets and their owners so that they can select products for a more comfortable and enjoyable life.

Nanako Sekiguchi's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

We gathered the 10 bestselling Dog Gates and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Ease of Passage

    1
    Ease of Passage

    Dog gates that ranked high in this category allow the owner to pass smoothly through the gate when needed.

  2. Escape Prevention

    2
    Escape Prevention

    In our tests, the products that ranked highly in escape prevention did not fall or break even when pressure was put on by a dog.

  3. Jump Protection

    3
    Jump Protection

    In our tests, the dog gates that excelled in the jump protection category successfully prevented dogs from jumping over or through the product.

  4. Ease of Set Up

    4
    Ease of Set Up

    The dog gates that excel in the ease of installation category can be installed with minimal effort or hassle.

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

Is a Gate for Dogs Really Necessary?

By Limiting the Range of a Dog’s Movement, Dog Gates Can Help Prevent Accidents

By Limiting the Range of a Dog’s Movement, Dog Gates Can Help Prevent Accidents

The main benefit of a dog gate is that it can prevent dogs from entering dangerous areas and keep them safe from accidents when unattended


For instance, it’s often necessary to prevent a dog from entering the kitchen and eating potentially hazardous food that can result in vomiting or even poisoning when ingested. There’s also a risk that they could get hurt by fallen kitchen utensils. The ability to freely climb up and down stairs can also lead to falls, fractures, and injuries. 


Furthermore, there are considerations such as the dog jumping outside the moment you open the door to receive a parcel or running away in panic due to loud noises like fireworks or thunder. Unforeseen issues can also arise in rooms with babies or valuable possessions. 


To prevent such problems, it's advisable to set up gates in rooms you don't want them in or other dangerous areas to restrict your dog's movement. 


Before purchasing, it's essential to check if you can attach the gate in your desired location. Measure the size of the intended installation space and compare it to the shape and size of the gate to ensure it can be installed.

Nanako Sekiguchi
Head of Pets at mybest
Nanako Sekiguchi
When purchasing a wall-mounted gate, please choose one where the size between the wall and the wall where it will be installed is as close as possible to the minimum mounting width of the product. Choosing the appropriate one makes it easier to tighten the adjustment bolts evenly, ensuring it is firmly fixed and less likely to wobble.

How to Choose Dog Gates

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Dog Gates.

1

There Are Two Types: Wall-Mounted and Free-Standing. We Recommend the Wall-Mounted Type!

There Are Two Types: Wall-Mounted and Free-Standing. We Recommend  the Wall-Mounted Type!

There are mainly two types of gates for dogs: wall-mounted and freestanding. The wall-mounted type is recommended for any breed of dog as it is more secure and is less likely to fall even if the dog pushes it. Furthermore, these are either screwed into the walls or fixed in place using tension rods. The kind that uses screws are usually more secure. However, that doesn't mean the type that uses tension rods lacks fixing power. Those who have small dogs or who don't want to drill holes in their walls might consider choosing the pressure (tension) rod type.

Sheri Rydyznski
Pet Care Service Provider
Sheri Rydyznski
People who live in rented houses tend to prefer types that are either free-standing or tension-mounted, which do not require screws, in order to avoid damaging the walls. Since you don't need to make holes with screws, they can be easily installed.

If You’re Using It for a Specific Spot, a Free-Standing Gate Is an Easy-To-Install Option

If You’re Using It for a Specific Spot, a Free-Standing Gate Is an Easy-To-Install Option

The free-standing dog gate is advantageous due to its flexibility in placement; no wall installation is required, making setup a breeze. However, it falls short in stability and sturdiness compared to wall-mounted types. 


Since it's lightweight and not fixed, there's a concern that it might topple over if a dog bumps into or jumps on it, making it unsuitable for medium to large-sized dogs. However, the risk of it toppling over is not that high for small dogs. 


Therefore, if you have a small dog and you want to keep them out of the way occasionally when you have guests, this could be a sufficient option for you.

Nanako Sekiguchi
Head of Pets at mybest
Nanako Sekiguchi

When using it for senior dogs, a high gate is not necessarily required. However, it is recommended to use something that can be firmly fixed and is stable to prevent the gate from falling unexpectedly.

2

For a Gate That’s Going to be Used Daily, Choose One That Is Easy to Pass through With a Low-Step and a Door

Dog gates are often installed in areas frequently used throughout the day, such as entrances, kitchens, and under the stairs. A gate that is easy to pass through and doesn't interfere with daily life is desirable.

It’s Easier to Pass Through Because You Don’t Have to Step Over Anything

It’s Easier to Pass Through Because You Don’t Have to Step Over Anything

When you install a gate for dogs, it naturally makes it difficult for people to pass through. Therefore, we recommend ones with doors and lower steps, or those with ramps. Those without doors must be stepped over each time you pass, which poses a risk of tripping and falling, and is especially dangerous for the elderly and children.


Some even have a feature that allows the gate to stay open, which is useful when you are able to keep your pet in a cage, keep the gate in place, but still have an unobstructed passage to walk through as needed.

3

Choose a Gate That Is Over 36 Inches Tall

Choose a Gate That Is Over 36 Inches Tall

Finding a gate of the right size that fits your beloved dog is also an important factor. For small to medium-sized dogs, you can prevent them from jumping over if the gate is around 36 inches, which is about twice their body height


On the other hand, for large dogs with high physical ability, it is safer to choose a height of 40 inches or more, and you will need to take note of how high your dog can actually jump. Many large dogs, such as Labradors and Golden Retrievers, tend to have a relatively calm disposition and may not be prone to jumping, but you know your dog better than anyone, so be sure to factor in their normal tendencies.

Sheri Rydyznski
Pet Care Service Provider
Sheri Rydyznski

Working dog breeds such as Border Collies and German Shepherds, often used for herding livestock and hunting, tend to be born with high agility and jumping ability. It is recommended that active breeds and energetic or naughty dogs use a type of dog gate that can be fixed to high and durable walls.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Dog Gates Ranking

Here are the best Dog Gates we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
No-Damage Installation
For Entryways
For Miniature Breeds
For Small Breeds
For Rowdy Pups
For Ease of Set Up
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Main Score
Details
Ease of Passage
Escape Prevention
Jump Protection
Ease of Set Up
Width
Depth
Height
Minimum Installation Width
Maximum Installation Width
Weight
Gate Type
Installation Method
Material
Auto Close Function
Hold-Open Feature
Double Lock Function
Double Opening Compatible
1

Mid-West Metal Products

Steel Pet Gate

Mid-West Metal Products Steel Pet Gate 1
4.50

mybest's Top Choice: Perfect Choice for Pets and Owners Alike

4.44
4.67
4.50
4.22

29.5 in.

1 in.

39.125 in.

29.5 in.

38 in.

196.8 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Steel

2

North States Industries

MyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate4944

North States Industries MyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate 1
4.43

Highly Stable and User-Friendly

4.44
4.84
4.00
3.92

38.3 in.

1 in.

30 in.

38.3 in.

72 in.

16 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)

Metal

3

Cumbor

Auto-Close Safety Gate‎S7V1

Cumbor Auto-Close Safety Gate 1
4.42

Has an Inconvenient Step, but Does the Job

4.44
4.67
4.00
4.22

29.7 in.

1.28 in.

30.5 in.

29.7 in.

46 in.

224.32 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Metal

3

Evenflo Company

BARN DOOR WALK-THRU BABY GATE

Evenflo Company BARN DOOR WALK-THRU BABY GATE 1
4.42

Keeps Your Dog Out of Trouble While Being Accessible for You

4.44
4.67
4.00
4.22

29 in.

1 in.

30 in.

29 in.

43 in.

304 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Metal, Wood

5

Carlson Pet Products

Extra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door0941 PP DS

Carlson Pet Products Extra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door 1
4.39

Perfect Height With Accessibility for Humans

4.38
4.67
4.50
3.59

29 in.

2 in.

36 in.

29 in.

36.5 in.

176 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit), Wall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)

Steel

6

BalanceFrom

BalanceFrom Safety GateBFSG-291338

BalanceFrom BalanceFrom Safety Gate 1
4.37

Easy to Assemble, but a Little Low

4.44
4.50
4.00
4.22

29.1 in.

1 in.

30 in.

29.1 in.

33.8 in.

48 oz.

Door Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Alloy Steel

7

North States Industries

MyPet Extra Tall & Wide Wire Mesh Wood Petgate4617A

North States Industries MyPet Extra Tall & Wide Wire Mesh Wood Petgate 1
4.24

Prevents Jumping, but a Little Hard to Open

4.25
4.00
4.50
4.75

28.75 in.

2.88 in.

37.75 in.

29.5 in.

48 in.

117.28 oz.

Fence Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Wood

8

Cumbor

Retractable Safety Gate

Cumbor Retractable Safety Gate 1
4.13

Easy to Pass Through, but Installation Is a Hassle

4.44
4.43
4.00
3.00

55 in.

0.01 in.

33 in.

0 in.

55 in.

63 oz.

Roll-Up Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)

PVC, Plastic, Carbon Steel

9

Carlson Pet Products

Plastic Expandable Pet Gate2323 DS

Carlson Pet Products Plastic Expandable Pet Gate 1
3.51

Stays Secure Despite Not Being User-Friendly

3.00
4.29
3.80
4.07

28-42 in.

1 in.

23 in.

28 in.

42 in.

80 oz.

Fence Style

Wall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)

Frame: Plastic, Bumpers: Rubber

10

spirichhome

SPIRICH HOME Steel Wire Pet GateSS19-SPT-104E

spirichhome SPIRICH HOME Steel Wire Pet Gate 1
3.23

Easy-To-Install Door; Worries of Easily Shifting and Falling

3.00
3.13
4.00
4.50

80 in.

0.75 in.

31 in.

20 in.

74 in.

368 oz.

Fence Style

Freestanding Type

Metal, Wood

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Dog Gates
No.1 in Ease of Passage
No.1 in Jump Protection

Mid-West Metal Products
Steel Pet Gate

mybest Score
4.50
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.67
Jump Protection
4.50
Ease of Set Up
4.22
View on Amazon
Steel Pet Gate 1
Lowest price
$53.60
Mid
Lowest price
$53.60
Mid
Height39.125 in.
Width
29.5 in.
Depth
1 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29.5 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

mybest's Top Choice: Perfect Choice for Pets and Owners Alike

What we loved

  • Accessible for humans
  • Good height for small and medium-sized dogs
  • Easy to install

What we didn't love

  • Nothing in particular.

The Steel Pet Gate by Mid-West Metal Products has a door that allows people to pass through and can be easily unlocked with one hand. Additionally, it has a stay-open feature, so you can leave it open when it is okay. 


Standing at 39 inches tall, it's quite high, so there's less worry about small and medium-sized dogs jumping over it. If you're using the gate for a large dog, it would be prudent to limit the run-up space to prevent the dog from jumping over. Also, it has an auto-close feature that naturally closes the gate when you let go of the door, which reduces the risk of forgetting to close it. 


The installation method is tension-mounted, and the mounting area on the wall for the fixture is wide enough to ensure it is secure for a variety of dogs. Small and medium-sized dogs are unlikely to knock it down or break it easily. 

This gate is our top choice since it thoroughly prevents dogs from jumping over and remains convenient even when installed in frequently used paths.

Maximum Installation Width38 in.
Weight196.8 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialSteel
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2
No.1 in Ease of Passage
No.1 in Escape Prevention

North States Industries
MyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate4944

mybest Score
4.43
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.84
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
3.92
Lowest price
$94.99
High Mid
Height30 in.
Width
38.3 in.
Depth
1 in.
Minimum Installation Width
38.3 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Highly Stable and User-Friendly

What we loved

  • Accessible lock system
  • Can be left open easily
  • Stable tension mounted brackets

What we didn't love

  • Low height lessens the security

The MyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate features a door for easy access and a lock that can be released with one hand for smooth passage. It also has an open function that allows you to leave the gate open when you don't need it. However, there is a step at the base, so be careful not to trip. 


The height is 30 inches, which could allow small to medium-sized dogs to easily jump over. For dogs with a strong jump, it may be necessary to train them beforehand.


The gate is installed using a tension method, and the wall mounting surface of the fixtures is sufficiently wide, which adds to the stability. The force of a small to medium-sized dog is unlikely to knock it over or break it easily.

Maximum Installation Width72 in.
Weight16 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)
MaterialMetal
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.3
No.1 in Ease of Passage

Cumbor
Auto-Close Safety Gate‎S7V1

mybest Score
4.42
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.67
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
4.22
Lowest price
$99.99
High Mid
Height30.5 in.
Width
29.7 in.
Depth
1.28 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29.7 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Has an Inconvenient Step, but Does the Job

What we loved

  • Front and back doors easily accessible
  • No assembly required
  • Auto close feature

What we didn't love

  • Low height, not secure for jumpy dogs
  • Bottom step increases risk of tripping

The Auto-Close Safety Gate ‎S7V1 by Cumboron can open in both directions, and the opening and closing operations can be easily handled with one hand, allowing for effortless passage. It's possible to smoothly enter and exit even if you're carrying a dog in one hand. Additionally, it features an auto-close function that automatically closes when you let go of the door after passing through, a nice feature that eliminates the risk of forgetting to close it. 


Also, no assembly is required, as it can be easily installed by pressing against a wall or pillar. A special tool for tightening the bolt is also included, which allows it to be firmly secured. This model is secure enough to keep small and medium-sized dogs from shifting or breaking it. 


However, with a height of 30.5 inches, it's slightly low. There is a risk that a dog with high jumping ability might leap over it, so it should only be used after appropriate training.

Maximum Installation Width46 in.
Weight224.32 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialMetal
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.3
No.1 in Ease of Passage

Evenflo Company
BARN DOOR WALK-THRU BABY GATE

mybest Score
4.42
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.67
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
4.22
Lowest price
$114.99
High Mid
Height30 in.
Width
29 in.
Depth
1 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Keeps Your Dog Out of Trouble While Being Accessible for You

What we loved

  • Accessible, can be opened with one hand
  • Easy installation
  • Auto open feature

What we didn't love

  • Low height, not great for jumpy dogs
  • Extra step at the bottom
The Barn Door Walk-Thru Baby Gate can be firmly fixed to the wall with screws, so there's less worry of it being moved or damaged by small to medium-sized dogs. Additionally, it's highly rated for its ease of installation without the need for assembly — just brace it against a wall or pillar. 

Moreover, it's equipped with a door and a lock that can be unlocked with one hand, allowing for smooth passage. It also has an open feature, which allows you to leave the gate open when not needed. There's a step at the foot of the gate, so be careful not to trip over it. 


However, at 30 inches, it is on the shorter side. There's a risk that a highly energetic dog may jump over it, so it's necessary to train your pet before using this gate.
Maximum Installation Width43 in.
Weight304 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialMetal, Wood
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.5
No.1 in Jump Protection

Carlson Pet Products
Extra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door0941 PP DS

Lowest price
$44.56
Mid
Height36 in.
Width
29 in.
Depth
2 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Perfect Height With Accessibility for Humans

What we loved

  • Tall height
  • Auto close feature
  • One-hand accessibility

What we didn't love

  • Assembly required before installation

Carlson Pet Products, a company that handles a wide range of pet supplies, offers an Extra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door.

 

The gate is very tall at 36 inches, so it's less likely that small to medium-sized dogs will be able to jump over it. Additionally, the gate comes with an auto-close feature that automatically shuts the door, reducing the risk of accidentally leaving it open. The gate has a lock that is easy to unlock with one hand, allowing for smooth passage. 


The installation surface area is sufficient, and the tension can be tightened with bolts, so even small to medium-sized dogs are unlikely to shift or destroy it. However, a drawback is that assembly is required before installation, so the gate cannot be used immediately after purchase.

Maximum Installation Width36.5 in.
Weight176 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit), Wall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)
MaterialSteel
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.6
No.1 in Ease of Passage

BalanceFrom
BalanceFrom Safety GateBFSG-291338

mybest Score
4.37
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.50
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
4.22
Lowest price
$29.99
Height30 in.
Width
29.1 in.
Depth
1 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29.1 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Easy to Assemble, but a Little Low

What we loved

  • Front and back opening
  • Double lock
  • Easy installation

What we didn't love

  • Extra step at the bottom
  • Low height

BalanceFrom's Safety Gate can be opened from both front and back, and the lock can easily be disengaged with one hand. This is especially convenient when carrying bags or holding a dog, making entering and exiting effortless. However, there's a step at the bottom, so caution is needed to avoid tripping. 


No assembly is required, just prop it against a wall for easy installation. The included tool smoothly tightens the bolts. There's ample installation surface area, allowing a tight fit and reducing the likelihood of small to medium-sized dogs shifting or damaging it. Additionally, it features a double lock function, minimizing worry about the lock being disengaged, along with an auto-close function that shuts the gate when you let go. 


However, with a height of 30 inches, it is somewhat low. There's a risk of a high-jumping dog going over, so it's necessary to train your dog to use it properly.

Maximum Installation Width33.8 in.
Weight48 oz.
Gate TypeDoor Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialAlloy Steel
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.7
No.1 in Jump Protection
No.1 in Ease of Set Up

North States Industries
MyPet Extra Tall & Wide Wire Mesh Wood Petgate4617A

mybest Score
4.24
Ease of Passage
4.25
Escape Prevention
4.00
Jump Protection
4.50
Ease of Set Up
4.75
Lowest price
$48.99
Mid
Height37.75 in.
Width
28.75 in.
Depth
2.88 in.
Minimum Installation Width
29.5 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Prevents Jumping, but a Little Hard to Open

What we loved

  • Good height to prevent dogs from jumping
  • Easy installation

What we didn't love

  • Sliding open mechanism is difficult to handle
  • Slightly unstable, easy for a large dog to knock over
  • No auto close function

North States Industries manufactures and sells MyPet Extra Tall & Wide Wire Mesh Wood Petgate 4617A, a product for small children and pets.


This model requires no assembly, just take it out of the box and press it against the wall for easy installation. This is the ideal product for those who want to start using it immediately after purchase. With a height of 37 inches, there is little worry about small and medium-sized dogs jumping over it. 


However, because the mounting area on the wall is small and it cannot be secured with screws, there is concern about medium and large dogs jumping or leaning against it. There is also no auto-close function, so be sure to remember to close it. In addition, the gate does not have a door and is the type where you have to remove the hook and slide it to pass through, which was a bit of a hassle.

Maximum Installation Width48 in.
Weight117.28 oz.
Gate TypeFence Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialWood
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.8
No.1 in Ease of Passage

Cumbor
Retractable Safety Gate

mybest Score
4.13
Ease of Passage
4.44
Escape Prevention
4.43
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
3.00
Lowest price
$39.99
Low Mid
Height33 in.
Width
55 in.
Depth
0.01 in.
Minimum Installation Width
0 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Easy to Pass Through, but Installation Is a Hassle

What we loved

  • One hand accessibility
  • No steps to worry about

What we didn't love

  • Low height, not great for jumpy dogs
  • Slightly difficult to install
  • No screwdriver included

Cumbor's Retractable Safety Gate is a slide-style gate that can be unlocked with one hand, so you can pass smoothly even while carrying items. Additionally, there's no level difference, so you don't have to worry about getting caught, which is a nice feature. It is recommended for households with elderly people or small children. The height of 33 inches may be a little low for medium-sized dogs or small dogs with strong legs. Since it's fixed to the wall, there's less concern about it falling or breaking. 


However, during installation positioning the gate correctly on the wall can be difficult, and it was cumbersome for our testers to screw it into four places. Furthermore, a screwdriver is needed for installation, but it is not included, so please be aware that you’ll need to have some tools already in hand.

Maximum Installation Width55 in.
Weight63 oz.
Gate TypeRoll-Up Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Screw Fit)
MaterialPVC, Plastic, Carbon Steel
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.9

Carlson Pet Products
Plastic Expandable Pet Gate2323 DS

mybest Score
3.51
Ease of Passage
3.00
Escape Prevention
4.29
Jump Protection
3.80
Ease of Set Up
4.07
Lowest price
$24.84
Height23 in.
Width
28-42 in.
Depth
1 in.
Minimum Installation Width
28 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Stays Secure Despite Not Being User-Friendly

What we loved

  • Securely mounted on the wall

What we didn't love

  • No auto-open feature, not accessible for humans
  • Low height, easy for small dogs to jump over
  • Installation tools not included

The Plastic Expandable Pet Gate 2323 DS is a product by Carlson Pet Products, a company based in Minnesota that offers a wide range of pet supplies.


This gate can be firmly attached to the wall with screws, and because it has a wide enough installation area, it is less likely to be shifted or destroyed by small or medium-sized dogs. However, the height is quite low at 23 inches, which can be a drawback. As it seems easy for a small dog to jump over, it's safest to use it after training your pet. 


However, when testing the ease of passage, it was difficult for our testers to go through it each time as they had to raise their legs high to avoid tripping over it. Also, although no assembly is required, the necessary tools for attaching it to the wall were not included, so we had to prepare them ourselves. This product may not be suitable for people who want to start using it immediately after purchase.

Maximum Installation Width42 in.
Weight80 oz.
Gate TypeFence Style
Installation MethodWall-Mounted Type (Pressure Fit)
MaterialFrame: Plastic, Bumpers: Rubber
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all
No.10

spirichhome
SPIRICH HOME Steel Wire Pet GateSS19-SPT-104E

mybest Score
3.23
Ease of Passage
3.00
Escape Prevention
3.13
Jump Protection
4.00
Ease of Set Up
4.50
Lowest price
$85.99
High Mid
Height31 in.
Width
80 in.
Depth
0.75 in.
Minimum Installation Width
20 in.
Auto Close Function
Double Lock Function

Easy-To-Install Door; Worries of Easily Shifting and Falling

What we loved

  • Easy installation

What we didn't love

  • Freestanding gate, can be easily knocked over
  • No auto-open feature
  • Requires extra weight to reinforce for larger dogs

The SPIRICH HOME Steel Wire Pet Gate is from spirichhome, an e-commerce site focusing on home interiors.


It has a height of 32 inches, which is unfortunately low enough for small to medium-sized dogs to easily jump over. Additionally, because it's a freestanding type, there's a concern that pets might knock it over or slip through it. If you have a medium to large-sized dog with a lot of strength, it's recommended to place weights on the leg part for reinforcement. 


Also, the need to step over the gate each time you wish to pass through is bothersome. it may not be suitable to install it in areas where there is high traffic.

Maximum Installation Width74 in.
Weight368 oz.
Gate TypeFence Style
Installation MethodFreestanding Type
MaterialMetal, Wood
Hold-Open Feature
Double Opening Compatible
View all

How We Tested the Dog Gates

Dog Gates Evaluation

mybest defines the best dog gate as one that properly restricts the dog's range of activity, providing a stress-free experience for both the owner and the pet


To find the best product, we collected ten popular dog gates that were either top sellers or new releases from each manufacturer and used four specific criteria to evaluate and rank them:


  • Ease of Passage
  • Escape Prevention
  • Jump Protection
  • Ease of Set Up

Products we tested

  1. BalanceFromBalanceFrom Safety GateBFSG-291338
  2. Carlson Pet ProductsExtra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door0941 PP DS
  3. Carlson Pet ProductsPlastic Expandable Pet Gate2323 DS
  4. CumborRetractable Safety Gate
  5. CumborAuto-Close Safety Gate‎S7V1
  6. Evenflo CompanyBARN DOOR WALK-THRU BABY GATE
  7. Mid-West Metal ProductsSteel Pet Gate
  8. North States IndustriesMyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate4944
  9. North States IndustriesMyPet Extra Tall & Wide Wire Mesh Wood Petgate4617A
  10. spirichhomeSPIRICH HOME Steel Wire Pet GateSS19-SPT-104E
1

Ease of Passage

Ease of Passage

Dog gates that ranked high in this category allow the owner to pass smoothly through the gate when needed.

Scoring Method

The tester checked each product and scored them based on the following points, quantifying the recommendation level for each product.

What We Checked

  • What is the method for coming in and going out?

  • Is the process to cross through easy?
  • Is the height of the step low?
  • Does it have an open function?
2

Escape Prevention

Escape Prevention
In our tests, the products that ranked highly in escape prevention did not fall or break even when pressure was put on by a dog.

Scoring Method

The tester checked each product and scored them based on the points below, converting the recommended level of each product into a score.

What We Checked

  • Is there a way to securely fix it so that it won't shift even if a dog pushes against it?

  • Does the base of the fixing device cover a wide area and ensure firm fixation?
  • Are there multiple points of attachment to the wall?
  • Are there any clever designs implemented to prevent the fixed parts from being tampered with?
  • Is there an auto close function?
  • Is there a method of locking that the dog can't open?
3

Jump Protection

Jump Protection
In our tests, the dog gates that excelled in the jump protection category successfully prevented dogs from jumping over or through the product.

Scoring Method

We interviewed Sheri Rydyznski, a pet sitter, about the height that is difficult for dogs to jump over. Based on her insights, testers checked each product and scored them according to each point, thus scoring the level of recommendation for each product.

What We Checked

  • Does the gate have a height that the dog cannot jump over?

4

Ease of Set Up

Ease of Set Up
The dog gates that excel in the ease of installation category can be installed with minimal effort or hassle.

Scoring Method

The tester has checked each product and scored them based on the points below, then quantified the recommendation level for each product.

What We Checked

  • Does it require assembly?

  • Can installation be done in a few steps?
  • Does it require special tools?

Top 5 Dog Gates

No. 1: Mid-West Metal ProductsSteel Pet Gate

No. 2: North States IndustriesMyPet Extra-Wide Windsor Arch Petgate4944

No. 3: CumborAuto-Close Safety Gate‎S7V1

No. 3: Evenflo CompanyBARN DOOR WALK-THRU BABY GATE

No. 5: Carlson Pet ProductsExtra Tall Walk-Thru Pet Gate with Small Pet Door0941 PP DS

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Dog Gates

Dog Clippers

10 Best

Tested and Reviewed

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.