mybest
KitchenHelping You Find the Best
mybest
KitchenHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More) 5

10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters in 2022 (Ann Clark, Wilton, and More)

Cookie cutters are a convenient baking tool that helps you create various designs of Christmas cookies in very little time. You can make gingerbread cookies, Santa sugar cookies, or any other types of cookies and designs you want with them! But since they come with many materials, shapes, and sizes, you may wonder what needs to be considered to get a good Christmas cookie cutter, right?


Don't worry! In our buying guide, you'll find many tips and suggestions on how to choose a good Christmas cookie cutter. We also did our research and went through reviews to pick the 10 best Christmas cookie cutters that can be purchased online. Ann Clark's Christmas cookie cutters are our top-ranking product because they're easy to use, made with high-quality material, and give a perfect cutting result. Keep reading for even more great products!

Last updated 09/26/2023

Quick List - Top Christmas Cookie Cutters

1

Ann Clark

Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet
Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet

High-Quality, Deep Cut Cookie Cutters

2

Wilton

Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
Christmas Cookie Cutter Set

Standard Size Cookie Cutters in Jolly Shapes

3

Unomor

Christmas Cookie Cutters with Comfort Grip
Christmas Cookie Cutters with Comfort Grip

Cookie Cutters With a Safe Grip

4

Kayaso

Round Cookie Cutter Set
Round Cookie Cutter Set

Multi-Purpose Cookie Cutters

5

R&M International

Star Tree Cookie Cutters
Star Tree Cookie Cutters

Enjoy Decorating Your Own Cookie Christmas Tree

mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

Why You Can Trust Us

Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.


mybest’s Content Policy

How to Choose Christmas Cookie Cutters

Read on to learn the differences between types of Christmas cookie cutters as well as things to consider to get quality cutters that can make perfect cookies.

1

Decide Between Common Cookie Cutter Materials

Cookie Cutters are made of one of two materials: metal and plastic. Both types offer different advantages and disadvantages. Choose one that makes your baking the easiest it can be.

Metal Cookie Cutters Come With Many Options

Metal Cookie Cutters Come With Many Options

Metal cookie cutters are made of aluminum, stainless steel, tin, or copper. They can come with a handle or without a handle. Handles make it easier to use the cookie cutters, but they may take up more storage space. On the other hand, a cookie-cutter that comes without a handle may hurt your fingers when pressing it into the dough.


Metal cookie cutters can easily bend and lose their shapes over some time. However, the good thing about metal cookie cutter is they’re sturdy and they don’t rust. Since they’re sharp, they're easy to cut into the dough with.

Plastic Cookie Cutters are Safe and Inexpensive

Plastic Cookie Cutters are Safe and Inexpensive

Plastic cookie cutters can also come with or without handles. Unlike metal cookie cutters, the edges of plastic cookie cutters aren't very sharp. Thus, you may have to push into the dough harder or cut it twice to get the results you want.


However, they are safer and make a better option for kids compared to metal cookie cutters. Additionally, they're inexpensive, easy to clean, and can be washed in the dishwasher!

Some Stainless Steel Cutters Come With Plastic Holders

Some Stainless Steel Cutters Come With Plastic Holders

If you're looking for safe cookie cutters that still cut well, we suggest you choose stainless steel cutters that come with plastic covers on top. They're durable, rust-resistant, and reliable. Since they come with plastic holders, they can reduce the risk of finger injuries. This type of cookie cutter is a great option for both kids and adults.

2

Consider 3D Cutters for a Fun Challenge

Consider 3D Cutters for a Fun Challenge

If you’re new to baking, it’s a good idea to start with regular cookie cutters. This is because they're easy to use and suit all baking skill levels. If you want to try something different or want to make your cookies look more professional, you may want to try 3D cookie cutters.


These let you cut the dough into different shapes and bake them separately. After that, you'll need to assemble them into 3D standing cookies. It’s important to make sure that your cookies are properly baked to make a perfect 3D cookie.


If your cookies are underbaked, they'll be too soft and moist. Thus, they can be hard to combine with other pieces. On the other hand, if your cookies are overbaked, they’ll be too crispy and break easily.

3

Pick Cookie Cutter Shapes and Designs That You'll Like and Use

Pick Cookie Cutter Shapes and Designs That You'll Like and Use

Christmas cookie cutters come in a set of a wide variety of shapes, like Santa's face, Christmas tree, gingerbread, snowflake, candy, glove, reindeer, Christmas stocking, and many more. They usually come in a set of three to 20 different designs, but you can also find single Christmas cookie cutters.


Cookie cutters that are in standard shapes like circles, squares, stars, and more can also be useful. Circles can become the base of ornament cookie decorations, squares can be the building blocks for your own gingerbread house, stars can be stacked into the shape of a Christmas tree - get creative!

4

Get the Right Size for Your Baking Project

Get the Right Size for Your Baking Project

The average cookie cutter size is between three to four inches. These sizes make the cookies easy to decorate. Keep in mind that the smaller the cookies are the harder they will be to decorate, especially if you want to include small details.


A bite-size cookie cutter ranges from one to two inches. They’re cute and don’t take much time baking in the oven. They can make a perfect bowl of cereal when you douse them in milk, too! Since they have a smaller surface area, they can be difficult to decorate with icing unless you're an experienced baker.


On the other hand, large cookie cutter sizes are around four inches or bigger. Large-size cookies aren’t only easy for decorating, they also allow you to add extra ingredients like chocolate chips and nuts! Most people like large cookies because they can enjoy a big chunk of these ingredients in every single bite.


If you're a beginner and plan to decorate your cookies with sugar icing, we recommend you buy standard or big sized cookie cutters to reduce the chance of messing up your cookies. If you're an experienced baker, choose the size based on your preferences.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters Ranking

Here are the best Christmas Cookie Cutters, ranked according to 10 Best Christmas Cookie Cutters (as of 11-04-2022). The products are ranked independently by mybest.
Popularity

Products

Image

Click to purchase

Key features

1

Ann Clark

Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet

Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet 1

High-Quality, Deep Cut Cookie Cutters

2

Wilton

Christmas Cookie Cutter Set

Wilton Christmas Cookie Cutter Set 1

Standard Size Cookie Cutters in Jolly Shapes

3

Unomor

Christmas Cookie Cutters with Comfort Grip

Unomor Christmas Cookie Cutters with Comfort Grip 1

Cookie Cutters With a Safe Grip

4

Kayaso

Round Cookie Cutter Set

Kayaso Round Cookie Cutter Set 1

Multi-Purpose Cookie Cutters

5

R&M International

Star Tree Cookie Cutters

R&M International Star Tree Cookie Cutters 1

Enjoy Decorating Your Own Cookie Christmas Tree

6

Ann Clark

Gingerbread Man Cookie CutterLarge

Ann Clark Gingerbread Man Cookie Cutter 1

A Sharp, Big Size Cutter for Easy Decorating

7

ilauke

Snowflake Cookie Cutters

ilauke Snowflake Cookie Cutters 1

Durable, Stamp-Like Cookie Cutters

8

Tovolo

Gingerbread Boys

Tovolo Gingerbread Boys 1

2-in-1 Must-Have Cookie Cutters for Beginners

9

Sweet Creations

3D Mini Santa Cookie Cutter Kit

Sweet Creations 3D Mini Santa Cookie Cutter Kit 1

Make Santa Cookies With this Simple Tool

10

Lurch

Christmas Cookie Cutters

Lurch Christmas Cookie Cutters 1

A Perfect Cookie Cutter Set for Your Kids

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Ann Clark
Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet

Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$19.99
High Mid
Reference price
$19.99
High Mid

High-Quality, Deep Cut Cookie Cutters

These cookie cutters are made with stainless steel, which is sturdy and durable. They come with sharp edges for optimized dough cutting. They make a safe cut for both cold and hot dough.


Additionally, they're made in the USA and come with a deep one-inch cut, which means they can be used for making thin and thick cookies. Last but not least, they come with a free booklet that contains various types of cookie recipes, too!


Most reviewers agreed that they are excellent cookie cutters in terms of quality and size. Since stainless steel can easily get rusted, some people suggested to dry them immediately after washing to prevent this issue.


A lot of people said they're easy to use and clean. The various Christmas designs make for perfect holiday cookies. Additionally, some reviewers said they're a useful tool for both kids and adults.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Wilton
Christmas Cookie Cutter Set

Reference price
$24.75
High

Standard Size Cookie Cutters in Jolly Shapes

This set includes popular Christmas designs like a snowman, reindeer, candy cane, and Santa hat. These cookies cutters come packed in a reusable plastic container for easy storage. They're easy to work with and will give you a neat result. They're easy to clean, too!


A few reviewers noted that these cutters bend and rust easily. However, others said they arrived quickly. Most reviewers like the fact that these cutters come in many shapes. They're sharp, well-made, and an excellent size for making perfect Christmas sugar cookies.

No.3

Unomor
Christmas Cookie Cutters with Comfort Grip

Reference price
$11.99
Mid

Cookie Cutters With a Safe Grip

With these comfort grip cutters, you don't need to worry about finger injuries anymore. The removable glue mold on top of the cutters makes it easy to clean and protect your fingers.


They're a little smaller than the standard size. However, the high-quality and cute colors of these cutters can make a great Christmas gift idea for people who like baking.


Most reviewers supported the claim that they're safe, fun to use, and easy to hold. The glue grip is very helpful in terms of preventing slips and reducing finger and hand fatigue. Some people also said they're versatile and can be used for Christmas cakes and brownies! Additionally, they arrived quickly and without any damage.

No.4

Kayaso
Round Cookie Cutter Set

Reference price
$12.85
High Mid

Multi-Purpose Cookie Cutters

Round cookie cutters are classic and versatile. This set comes with 12 different sizes, which can also be used for other types of foods such as sandwiches, pizza, donuts, and muffins! Since they come in a basic shape, they're suitable for all-year use and make a perfect choice for someone who likes baking holiday cookies.


A few reviewers said these cookies cutters are made with a thin material, which makes them easily bend. However, other reviewers noted that they're very useful and easy to clean. Plus, they come in different sizes and in a compact case to keep them organized. Overall, most people said this was a great investment!

No.5

R&M International
Star Tree Cookie Cutters

Reference price
$8.09
Low Mid

Enjoy Decorating Your Own Cookie Christmas Tree

Christmas will never be complete without a Christmas tree! You can create and decorate your own 3D Christmas tree with these different sizes of cookie cutters. They're easy to clean, dishwasher-safe, and make a great option for someone looking for a fun family activity. 


Additionally, they're made of plastic and have no sharp edges, so they're safe for your little ones! A few reviewers suggested not to use a thick dough because it'll be hard to assemble the pieces. However, most reviewers said they're very easy to use and they were able to make a Christmas tree that turned out perfectly.


Some people also said the instructions are easy to read and follow. A few reviewers used royal icing to connect each layer, which they said worked very well.

No.6

Ann Clark
Gingerbread Man Cookie CutterLarge

Reference price
$5.99
Low

A Sharp, Big Size Cutter for Easy Decorating

This cutter's large surface area makes it very easy for cookie decoration. This big size cookie cutter suits kids and adults who have little to no experience in decorating. It has a gingerbread man design that is perfect for Christmas. Plus, the sharp cutting edges make it easy to work with so you won't have to press it so hard into the dough.


Some reviewers noted that the material is a little flimsy and it got rusty after the first wash; however, others said it's simple, cuts well, and comes in the right size.


Unlike other cookie cutters, this one doesn't have any thin edges, which can prevent dry edges that are easily break after baking. Additionally, some people noted that Ann Clark has excellent customer service and respond quickly to solve customer complaints.

No.7

ilauke
Snowflake Cookie Cutters

Reference price
$7.99
Low Mid

Durable, Stamp-Like Cookie Cutters

Although they're made from plastic, these cookie cutters can withstand varying temperatures ranging from -140 to 446 degrees Fahrenheit. Since they come in different sizes, they are versatile and can be used both for cookies and cake decorations.


They feature a spring mechanism that allows you to release the detailed snowflake from the mold perfectly. A lot of reviewers said they're easy to clean as well as sharp, which makes them very easy to work with. Many people also recommended to use them for making a winter-themed dessert.

No.8

Tovolo
Gingerbread Boys

Reference price
$8.69
Low Mid

2-in-1 Must-Have Cookie Cutters for Beginners

These cookie cutters will not only save you time in the kitchen, but they can also make your cookies look professional regardless of your baking skill level. The set comes with three double-sided stamp plates and six different characters. For decoration, you can follow the design on the mold or make your own!


Most reviewers like the fact that they came exactly as in the pictures and others praised their cute and detailed designs. Additionally, some people said their size makes for perfect templates for decorating with royal icing. They're great fun to make with kids.

No.9

Sweet Creations
3D Mini Santa Cookie Cutter Kit

Reference price
$9.99
Mid

Make Santa Cookies With this Simple Tool

You can easily make 3D Santa Cookies with only one tool! This cookie cutter is made with a safe and sturdy material. Although it's made from plastic, the edges are straight and sharp enough to cut the dough into a clean shape. It's also lightweight and dishwasher-safe.


Most reviewers are very satisfied with this cookie cutter because it's fun, fast, and easy to assemble. You can cut out three pieces of cookie dough with only one press.


Additionally, it includes a recipe on the back of the package! Many people also said this is a must-have item for their Christmas baking, while others said it makes a great Christmas gift.

No.10

Lurch
Christmas Cookie Cutters

Reference price
$10.59
Mid

A Perfect Cookie Cutter Set for Your Kids

This is a perfect cookie cutter set for your kids because they're easy to use and free from sharp edges. These cutters are also dishwasher-safe. Plastic cutters are easy to take care of since they will never rust. In this set, you'll get eight different Christmas shapes such as a star, snowman, and Christmas tree.


Some reviewers noted that these cutters are tiny, whereas others said they're cute and make perfect mini cookies. Although they're small, they're easy to work with and give great results.


Most importantly, all kids love using them! Many people like the fact that the set includes many lovely shapes. They also said these cutters are a perfect option to use at home, daycare, and school.

The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Kitchen

Vegetable Choppers

17 Best

Tested and Reviewed

New Arrivals
Featured Rankings Similar to Kitchen

Most Viewed
favlist Similar to Kitchen

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.