mybest
Vanilla ExtractsHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Vanilla ExtractsHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed) 1
  • 10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed) 2
  • 10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed) 3
  • 10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed) 4
  • 10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed) 5

10 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2024 (Chef-Reviewed)

Vanilla extract is a versatile ingredient made by steeping whole vanilla beans in ethyl alcohol and water. Its rich and complex flavor enhances the sweetness in your favorite dessert and tones down the acidity in savory dishes. Whether it's vanilla cake, a meat marinade, or coffee, if you want to bring out the best in your recipe, you'll want a vanilla extract that is free from synthetic chemicals and unnecessary ingredients.


To help get you started on choosing a high-quality vanilla extract, we gathered 10 of the best. It has a mellow, creamy flavor and sweet aroma that can be used in a variety of recipes. Keep reading for more great options, and to learn more about choosing a vanilla extract make sure to read our buying guide, which was reviewed by a professional chef.

Last updated 12/16/2024

Quick List - Top Vanilla Extracts

1

Watkins

All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla
All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla

Pure Vanilla Extract: Naturally Derived Perfection

2

McCormick

Vanilla Extract
Vanilla Extract

Pure, Versatile Vanilla Perfection

3

Molina

Mexican Vanilla Blend Extract
Mexican Vanilla Blend Extract

Enrich Your Baking With Mexican Vanilla

4

Nielsen-Massey

Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract21004 / RBO4CI
Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract

Best All-Purpose Vanilla Extract

5

Simply Organic

Pure Vanilla Extract18532
Pure Vanilla Extract

Best Organic Vanilla Extract

Jim Quast
Expert
Executive R&D Chef
Jim Quast

Jim Quast (JQ) is a lifelong professional restaurant and corporate R&D chef who loves everything food-related and the tools, both big and small, to make those great food memories. He's a super huge BBQ, grill, and kitchen gadget fanatic. JQ has spent the last 30+ years trying to figure out what works to make your kitchen life easier and fun. If you can use it to slice it, dice it, cook it, smoke it, or store it, he's been there checking it out. Food = Life!

Jim Quast's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

How to Choose a Vanilla Extract - Buying Guide

Distinguishing between vanilla extract and imitation vanilla can be difficult if you don't know what to look for. From bean origin to bottle type, there are quite a few things to take into consideration. We've compiled a list of buying tips to make it easier when choosing the best vanilla extract.

1

Check the Ingredient List to Determine Purity

When selecting a vanilla extract, it is important to inspect the label and ensure that it is free from synthetic chemicals. Familiarizing yourself with the different types of labeling and how vanilla extract is made will help you choose the perfect vanilla extract.

Ensure That It’s Actually an Extract

Ensure That It’s Actually an Extract

According to the FDA, vanilla beans must be soaked in water and ethyl alcohol for a product to be considered and labeled an extract. It may also contain sugar and corn syrup to soften the flavor of the alcohol and act as a stabilizer. However, keep in mind that the fewer ingredients there are on the label, the purer the extract is.


Imitation vanilla is usually made with vanillin, derived from wood pulp. It may contain clove oil or other synthetic chemicals to make up for the lower ratio of vanilla bean.


For those who would like to go without the alcohol, you can also find alcohol-free vanilla extract that has been made using propylene glycol. These products are a combination of imitation vanilla and pure vanilla extract and are labeled as "vanilla flavoring."

Pure Vanilla Extract Offers the Best Flavor

Pure Vanilla Extract Offers the Best Flavor

When searching for a high-quality vanilla extract, look for "pure vanilla" on the label. For a vanilla extract to be called pure, it must contain at least 35 percent ethyl alcohol and 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon.


Pure vanilla has a rich, complex flavor and aroma that's hard to replicate. Imitation vanilla, on the other hand, is one-note and can sometimes give your food a bitter aftertaste. 

One way to differentiate between pure vanilla and imitation vanilla is to check the color of the extract. Pure vanilla has a dark brown color, whereas imitation vanilla has a clear or caramel color.


Avoid Tonka Bean Extract

Avoid Tonka Bean Extract

Some vanilla extracts made in Mexico and other Latin American countries are actually made from tonka beans. Tonka beans are a legume that belongs to the pea family. They have a sweet aroma with a hint of spice that is reminiscent of vanilla, but they also contain coumarin, a chemical that is banned for consumption by the FDA.


Many Mexican vanilla extracts are often made with chemicals and contain very little or no alcohol. Although they're listed as pure on the label, there is a strong chance that they're not pure vanilla extract. If you like the aroma and taste of Mexican vanilla beans, choose a vanilla extract that's bottled in the United States. 

2

Pick Double- or Triple-Fold Vanilla for More Flavor

Pick Double- or Triple-Fold Vanilla for More Flavor

Most vanilla extracts are single-fold, meaning they contain about 100 vanilla beans per one gallon of alcohol. Single-fold vanilla extracts are widely used by home bakers.


Double-fold and triple-fold vanilla extracts are made using twice and triple the number of vanilla beans. These are a great option for recipes that call for a strong flavor or people who like an intense vanilla aroma. Since they're more concentrated, you can use a bit less to make the bottle last longer, too!

3

Consider the Origin of the Vanilla Beans

Consider the Origin of the Vanilla Beans

Madagascar vanilla, also known as Bourbon vanilla, is the most popular type. Its classic, creamy, and rich flavor complements all recipes.


Tahiti vanilla has a delicate and fruity flavor. It has a strong aroma with notes of anise, plum, and cherry. We recommend pairing it with fruits and frozen desserts.


If you want to add a hint of spice to your recipe, consider Mexican vanilla. It offers a smooth and spicy flavor with a woody scent. It pairs well with dark chocolate, alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, and meat.

4

Look for Amber Glass to Preserve the Quality

Look for Amber Glass to Preserve the Quality

Vanilla extract has a long shelf life, but it can lose its aroma and flavor over time, especially if it's improperly stored. To maintain the quality, keep it away from sunlight and heat.


An amber glass bottle is the perfect packaging choice since it helps to keep the vanilla extract away from ultraviolet light, which is the main cause of oxidation and degradation. Plus, glass will not leach chemicals into the extract. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Vanilla Extracts

Our 10 best picks for vanilla extracts include a variety of vanilla beans, flavor profiles, and sizes in order to cover a wide range of options. We made our choices based on the points listed in the buying guide below, as well as reviewer comments when available.
Popularity
Filter
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
Details
Ingredients
Contains Alcohol
Pure Vanilla
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla Beans
Amber Glass
Weight
1

Watkins

All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla

Watkins All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla 1

Pure Vanilla Extract: Naturally Derived Perfection

Water, sugar, glycerin, vanilla extract (water, alcohol, extractive of vanilla beans), alcohol, natural flavors, fruit juice (color)

unknown

11 ounces

2

McCormick

Vanilla Extract

McCormick Vanilla Extract 1

Pure, Versatile Vanilla Perfection

Vanilla Extract, Water, Alcohol

Madagascar

16 ounces

3

Molina

Mexican Vanilla Blend Extract

Molina Mexican Vanilla Blend Extract 1

Enrich Your Baking With Mexican Vanilla

Water, 1.8 Ethyl Alcohol, Propylene Glycol, Vanillin, Pure Vanilla Extract, Caramel Color, Ethyl Vanillin, Potassium Sorbate (as Preservative), Potassium Hydroxide (Acidity Regulator)

Mexico

8.3 ounces

4

Nielsen-Massey

Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract21004 / RBO4CI

Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract 1

Best All-Purpose Vanilla Extract

Water, Alcohol (35%), Sugar, Vanilla Bean Extractives

Madagascar

8 ounces

5

Simply Organic

Pure Vanilla Extract18532

Simply Organic Pure Vanilla Extract 1

Best Organic Vanilla Extract

Organic Vanilla Bean Extractives in Water, Organic Alcohol

Madagascar

4 ounces

6

Magnolia-Star

Pure Vanilla Extract

Magnolia-Star  Pure Vanilla Extract 1

Pure Vanilla Perfection from Bean to Bowl

Vanilla Bean Extractives in Water. Alcohol (35%)

Madagascar

16 ounces

7

Native Vanilla

Vanilla Extract

Native Vanilla Vanilla Extract 1

Pure Flavor, Ethically Sourced

Vanilla Beans, Water, and Alcohol

Papa New Guinea

8 ounces

8

Amazon Brand

Happy Belly Pure Vanilla Extra

Amazon Brand Happy Belly Pure Vanilla Extra 1

Essential Vanilla Extract

Vanilla Bean Extract, Water, Alcohol

unknown

1 ounces

9

Watkins

Clear Vanilla Flavor

Watkins Clear Vanilla Flavor 1

Best for Pure White Baking

Water, Sugar, Propylene Glycol, Alcohol, Artifical Flavors

11 ounces

10

McCormick

Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract

McCormick Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract 1

Clear Vanilla for Pure White Desserts

Water, Alcohol (13%), Vanillin and other Artificial Flavorings, and Citric Acid

32 ounces

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Watkins
All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla

All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla 1
Source:amazon.com
All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla 2
Lowest price
$12.35
Mid
Lowest price
$12.35
Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight11 ounces

Pure Vanilla Extract: Naturally Derived Perfection

Enhance your baking with Pure Vanilla Extract, made from all naturally derived ingredients for a rich and authentic flavor. This concentrated blend is perfect for both baking and freezing, delivering consistent quality in every use. Free from artificial colors and flavors, it provides a pure, clean taste to your recipes.


Non-GMO, gluten-free, corn syrup-free, and kosher, this vanilla extract caters to a variety of dietary needs. Crafted with care in the USA, it ensures top-notch quality for all your culinary creations. Please note that it contains sulfites.

IngredientsWater, sugar, glycerin, vanilla extract (water, alcohol, extractive of vanilla beans), alcohol, natural flavors, fruit juice (color)
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla Beansunknown
Amber Glass
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

McCormick
Vanilla Extract

Lowest price
$21.96
High Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight16 ounces

Pure, Versatile Vanilla Perfection

McCormick Pure Vanilla Extract delivers a deep, rich flavor crafted from premium vanilla beans. Ideal for bakers, its smooth, sweet taste enhances desserts, from cookies to cakes, while adding a warm balance to savory dishes like seafood or meat marinades. Each batch is expertly blended for consistency, ensuring flawless flavor in every use.


Free of corn syrup, gluten, and artificial ingredients, this extract is perfect for vegetarian, low-carb, and kosher diets. Whether you're crafting decadent pastries or elevating everyday recipes, McCormick Vanilla Extract is a must-have staple in every kitchen.

IngredientsVanilla Extract, Water, Alcohol
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansMadagascar
Amber Glass
View all
No.3

Molina
Mexican Vanilla Blend Extract

Lowest price
$1.68
Low
Pure Vanilla
Weight8.3 ounces

Enrich Your Baking With Mexican Vanilla

Discover the rich, aromatic flavor of Molina Mexican Vanilla Blend. This 8.3 fluid ounces bottle offers a versatile addition to your kitchen, enhancing a wide range of dishes from meat and fish to chicken. Its unique vanilla flavor also adds a special touch to coffee, smoothies, cakes, and cookies, as well as to drinks and cocktails.


Kosher and crafted with high-quality ingredients, this blend provides a delightful twist to both savory and sweet recipes. Elevate your culinary creations with Molina’s distinctive vanilla flavor and make every dish a memorable experience.

IngredientsWater, 1.8 Ethyl Alcohol, Propylene Glycol, Vanillin, Pure Vanilla Extract, Caramel Color, Ethyl Vanillin, Potassium Sorbate (as Preservative), Potassium Hydroxide (Acidity Regulator)
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansMexico
Amber Glass
View all
No.4

Nielsen-Massey
Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract21004 / RBO4CI

Lowest price
$34.98
High
Pure Vanilla
Weight8 ounces

Best All-Purpose Vanilla Extract

Nielsen-Massey's vanilla extract is made from hand-picked Madagascar vanilla beans and a small amount of cane sugar for a more consistent flavor. Its smooth, full-body flavor makes this vanilla extract perfect for both cold and hot dishes. Plus, it comes housed in an amber bottle to maintain its quality.


The vast majority of reviewers loved this vanilla's aroma and flavor, saying it's rich, smooth, and sweet. They also said it enhances the flavor of baked goods and ice cream.

IngredientsWater, Alcohol (35%), Sugar, Vanilla Bean Extractives
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansMadagascar
Amber Glass
View all
No.5

Simply Organic
Pure Vanilla Extract18532

Lowest price
$21.59
Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight4 ounces

Best Organic Vanilla Extract

This certified-organic Madagascar vanilla extract is made without added sugar, GMOs, or artificial ingredients. It has a warm aroma and deep, rich flavor. It also comes in an amber glass bottle to preserve its freshness. 


A few reviewers noted that it's more on the mild side. However, they said it has a pure vanilla flavor and delicious scent. They especially enjoyed using it in tea and coffee.

IngredientsOrganic Vanilla Bean Extractives in Water, Organic Alcohol
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansMadagascar
Amber Glass
View all
No.6

Magnolia-Star
Pure Vanilla Extract

Lowest price
$31.99
High Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight16 ounces

Pure Vanilla Perfection from Bean to Bowl

Elevate your recipes with Magnolia-Star Pure Vanilla Extract, crafted from premium Madagascar Bourbon vanilla beans. This pure extract enhances the flavor of cakes, brownies, cookies, smoothies, tea, coffee, shakes, and more. It’s naturally sugar-free, gluten-free, and free from corn syrup, artificial colors, and flavors, making it a superior choice for your baking needs.


Sourced from Madagascar, the bourbon vanilla beans are aged for up to three months, then steeped and pressed to extract maximum flavor before being bottled. Magnolia-Star’s commitment to quality ensures that every drop is pure and delicious, with no synthetics or additives. Explore Magnolia-Star’s range of flavors, including vanilla, lemon, and almond, and find your new favorite.

IngredientsVanilla Bean Extractives in Water. Alcohol (35%)
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansMadagascar
Amber Glass
View all
No.7

Native Vanilla
Vanilla Extract

Lowest price
$17.99
Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight8 ounces

Pure Flavor, Ethically Sourced

Experience the robust, natural flavor of Native Vanilla Pure Vanilla Extract. Our proprietary extraction process captures the essence of 300 flavor compounds from real vanilla beans, ensuring a rich and authentic taste. With a clean label, this extract contains no additives, colorants, fake flavors, or sugars, maintaining purity in every drop.


Ethically sourced, Native Vanilla supports hundreds of micro farmers in Papua New Guinea through fair trade practices and environmentally friendly growing methods. Certified Kosher and Vegan, this vanilla extract is a versatile ingredient, where 1 tablespoon of extract equals 1 whole vanilla bean, 1 tablespoon of vanilla bean paste, or 1 tablespoon of vanilla powder in your recipes.

IngredientsVanilla Beans, Water, and Alcohol
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla BeansPapa New Guinea
Amber Glass
View all
No.8

Amazon Brand
Happy Belly Pure Vanilla Extra

Lowest price
$2.70
Pure Vanilla
Weight1 ounces

Essential Vanilla Extract

Happy Belly Pure Vanilla Extract brings the authentic, rich essence of vanilla to your favorite recipes. Made with premium vanilla bean extract in water and alcohol, this versatile ingredient enhances the flavor of baked goods, desserts, and more with its smooth, natural taste.


Packaged in a convenient 1 fl oz size, it’s perfect for everyday use. As an Amazon Brand product, Happy Belly delivers quality you can trust at an affordable price. Handle with care and avoid pouring near an open flame for safe and flavorful kitchen adventures.

IngredientsVanilla Bean Extract, Water, Alcohol
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla Beansunknown
Amber Glass
View all
No.9

Watkins
Clear Vanilla Flavor

Lowest price
$12.28
Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight11 ounces

Best for Pure White Baking

Watkins Clear Vanilla Flavor is the perfect choice for recipes requiring a flawless white finish. This premium baking essential delivers rich, gourmet vanilla flavor that holds its essence through baking and freezing without adding color. It's ideal for wedding cakes, frostings, and any recipe where aesthetics matter as much as taste.


Crafted in the USA, Watkins Clear Vanilla is free from artificial colors, GMOs, gluten, and corn syrup, meeting the highest quality standards. Add this versatile, kosher-friendly staple to your pantry and elevate your baking creations with pure, vibrant flavor.

IngredientsWater, Sugar, Propylene Glycol, Alcohol, Artifical Flavors
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla Beans
Amber Glass
View all
No.10

McCormick
Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract

Lowest price
$14.99
Mid
Pure Vanilla
Weight32 ounces

Clear Vanilla for Pure White Desserts

McCormick Culinary Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract delivers a pleasantly sweet vanilla flavor, ideal for baked goods, beverages, and desserts that require colorless ingredients. Made from premium, high-quality ingredients, this versatile extract maintains its flavor even at high temperatures, ensuring consistent, delicious results every time.


Perfect for chefs and bakers, the 32-fluid-ounce bottle offers convenience and control for both small and large applications. Kosher-certified and free from sugar, this clear vanilla flavor is a versatile, feel-good ingredient for creating stunning confections, custards, and frostings.

IngredientsWater, Alcohol (13%), Vanillin and other Artificial Flavorings, and Citric Acid
Contains Alcohol
No Tonka Bean Extract
Origin of Vanilla Beans
Amber Glass
View all

Top 5 Vanilla Extracts

No. 1: WatkinsAll Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla

No. 2: McCormickVanilla Extract

No. 3: MolinaMexican Vanilla Blend Extract

No. 4: Nielsen-MasseyMadagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract21004 / RBO4CI

No. 5: Simply OrganicPure Vanilla Extract18532

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Vanilla Extracts

Green Hot Sauce

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.