mybest
Books and magazinesHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Books and magazinesHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More) 5

10 Best Mystery Books in 2022 (C. J. Tudor, Lisa Gardner, and More)

Whether you're an introvert specializing in being inside or an extrovert who thrives at the center of attention, a good mystery novel is one of the best ways to spend time.  As many of us are holed up inside staring at our walls thanks to COVID-19, now is the time to snuggle with one from our list of the top 10 best mystery books.


A mystery novel is an interactive experience. The author isn't just telling a story, but is consciously showing half-truths and contradictions to send the reader down different convoluted paths towards or away from the crux of the plot. Here are our top 10 choices and a buying guide to help you find your next mystery story escape!

Last updated 09/26/2023

Quick List - Top Mystery Books

1

Lisa Gardner

When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11)
When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11)

Three of Reader's Favorite Characters Visit a Quaint Town with a Dark Past

2

Sophie Hannah

Perfect Little Children
Perfect Little Children

What Happened to the Children?

3

Kwei Quartey

The Missing American
The Missing American

Risk for the Sake of Love

4

Graham Moore

The Holdout: A Novel
The Holdout: A Novel

A Career Move from Juror to Murder Suspect

5

Tanen Jones

The Better Liar
The Better Liar

Share Secrets with Strangers

mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

How to Choose a Mystery Book - Buying Guide

Here we have compiled a few pointers to keep in mind as you browse the fascinating world of mystery and suspense!

1

Narrow Down the Choices by Type of Mystery

Narrow Down the Choices by Type of Mystery

The mystery genre is extremely diverse, which makes it difficult to choose what to read. However, if you ask yourself some key questions, making a selection becomes a easier.


Are you someone who enjoys a lighthearted read with comical capers or cozy domesticity? Or are you in the mood for something dark and gritty involving the world of crime? Do you want to read about the paranormal and supernatural events or would you prefer to read something procedural and more realistic? Serial killers, yay or nay?


By asking yourself these questions, it's easy to narrow down the choices and choose something that will grip your interest. 

2

Do You Prefer the OGs of the Detective World or Contemporary Crime Writers?

Do You Prefer the OGs of the Detective World or Contemporary Crime Writers?

Chances are you have already heard of Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie and Raymond Chandler. These writers have shaped the genre we know today. While their works are set in the past, these writers are always worth a read as they delve into the timeless human conflicts of fear, greed and love.


On the other hand, if you want to read something more current, there are a number of best selling authors like Lisa Gardner, James Patterson and Mary Higgins-Clark that set their stories in the contemporary world. Such books often follow a procedural style to show how the mystery is uncovered using the latest scientific methods police use.


You can also enter the world of True Crime. Actual people have done the most shocking things, from grisly murders to astounding thefts. As they say, 'truth is stranger than fiction.' 

3

Choose between Stand-Alone Books and Series

Choose between Stand-Alone Books and Series

Many mystery authors have a main character, like a detective or private investigator, to lead the reader into the belly of the beast. This character usually grapples with her or his own personal demons as they solve the case.


Instead of just reading about one mystery after the next, the readers become emotionally involved in the personal trials and tribulations that the character faces.


As most mystery novels have stand alone plots, they are fun to read even if you don't want to follow a series. On the other hand, there are plenty of mystery novels that are based on a single episode. Such stories throw the readers into turmoil and leave them wondering how the characters will recover or be changed following the events in the book, even if the mystery is solved.

4

Try International Authors for a Change of Pace

Try International Authors for a Change of Pace

These days the choice of books has widened as many authors books from different countries are having their works translated into English to make them more accessible to a wider audience.


If you're interested in how crime and mystery are solved in other countries, choosing an international mystery novel is they way to go. International books are illuminating to describe the human values of justice and how different people from different backgrounds approach it. 

5

Enlist the Help of Others to Find a Juicy Mystery

Enlist the Help of Others to Find a Juicy Mystery

Nothing is a bigger letdown than when a mystery plot isn't as satisfying as we had hoped it would be. It's always a good idea to read reviews from websites like Amazon or Goodreads when in doubt. You can also check out reviews on YouTube.


If you're already a fan of an author, maybe check out their recommendations, as writers usually review other writers as well. Think about the authors you already like and search for mystery authors that are somewhat close to them.


Mystery authors also usually have a fanbase that are eager to share their favorites. You can try asking your neighborhood book club or at your local library for recommendations. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Mystery Novels

We've searched Amazon and pored through reviews to find the best mystery novels to keep you engrossed and on the edge of your seat!
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Lisa Gardner

When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11)

Lisa Gardner When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11) 1

Three of Reader's Favorite Characters Visit a Quaint Town with a Dark Past

2

Sophie Hannah

Perfect Little Children

Sophie Hannah Perfect Little Children 1

What Happened to the Children?

3

Kwei Quartey

The Missing American

Kwei Quartey The Missing American 1

Risk for the Sake of Love

4

Graham Moore

The Holdout: A Novel

Graham Moore The Holdout: A Novel 1

A Career Move from Juror to Murder Suspect

5

Tanen Jones

The Better Liar

Tanen Jones The Better Liar 1

Share Secrets with Strangers

6

C.J. Tudor

The Other People

C.J. Tudor The Other People 1

The Other People Know about the Dead

7

B.A. Paris

The Dilemma

B.A. Paris The Dilemma 1

A Secret Kept from Each Other

8

Peter Swanson

Eight Perfect Murders

Peter Swanson Eight Perfect Murders 1

A Romp through the Genre of Mystery and Thrillers

9

Peter James

Find Them Dead

Peter James Find Them Dead 1

A Ruthless Drug Dealers Orders the Death of a Widow's Only Daughter

10

Robert Galbraith (J.K. Rowling)

Troubled Blood

Robert Galbraith (J.K. Rowling) Troubled Blood 1

The Next Installment of the Cormoran Strike Novels

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Lisa Gardner
When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11)

When You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11) 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$19.24
Mid
Reference price
$19.24
Mid

Three of Reader's Favorite Characters Visit a Quaint Town with a Dark Past

The prolific author Lisa Gardner weaves a tense tail of trauma and murder. Detective Sergeant D.D. Warren joins SSA Kimberly Quincy as fresh murders take place while the number of cold cases keep mounting in the sweet town of Niche. How can a young girl, suffering from PTSD from her time being imprisoned by a murderer, help their case?


This novel is well-researched as the author breaks down the technical details and processes of FBI task forces while delivering a gripping tale. Reviewers loved how this book unites three of her most-beloved characters, and say it proves the author is in the prime of her creativity.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Sophie Hannah
Perfect Little Children

Reference price
$17.79
Mid

What Happened to the Children?

Twelve years have passed since Beth has seen Flora, her ex-best friend. But when she finds herself in the Flora's neighborhood, she can't resist trying to catch a glimpse of her. 


As Beth watches her former friend step out of her car, she sees Flora's children, Thomas and Emily, as well. They are five and three years old, the same ages they were twelve years ago.


Reviewers called it an absorbing escape. The story is cunningly plotted with a central character who must face her own flaws as she seeks for a truth that is not hers to know in the first place.

No.3

Kwei Quartey
The Missing American

Reference price
$16.95
Mid

Risk for the Sake of Love

Private Investigator Emma Djan will find out how the darkest depths reach the upper echelons in her first missing person case. Middle-aged widower Gorden Tilson is infatuated with a mysterious Ghanian widow much to the dismay of his son Derek. 


After sending her thousands of dollars, Gorden jets off to Accra to meet his online love and disappears. Derek engages local PI Emma to find his father. The case will drag both through dark places with secrets people will kill to keep.


Readers were intrigued by the connection between the sniper assassination of a politician to the online scams that brought the wealthy American to Ghana. However, the jumps in the timeline from future to past were a little bewildering if not followed carefully.

No.4

Graham Moore
The Holdout: A Novel

Reference price
$17.05
Mid

A Career Move from Juror to Murder Suspect

Maya is convinced of a black teacher's innocence when she serves as a juror on the trial where the man is accused of murdering his wealthy white student. Though she's quite young, she manages to persuade the others as well


Ten years later, the jurors of the sensational trial have a reunion, which is covered by a documentary film crew. The only problem is that one of her fellow jurors turns up dead in Maya's bedroom, and all signs point to her as the killer.


The screenwriting background of the author is quite evident as there quite a bit of dialogue, but reviewers found the story gripping with a clear narrative style that gives insight into the motivations of the players. 

No.5

Tanen Jones
The Better Liar

Reference price
$16.17
Mid

Share Secrets with Strangers

After spending years taking care of her dying father, Leslie receives a rude awakening when she finds out that they only way she can receive her inheritance is with her estranged sister Robin, or not at all. 


Fortunately, no one else except Leslie knows Robin is dead. Leslie engages a charismatic actress Mary to take Robin's place. But neither woman realizes how their pasts will come to haunt the future.


Readers found this debut novel twisted and devious, exuding a sense of unease. The narrators are unreliable and selfish, but each has a voice, a sense of ruthless resourcefulness and won't be parted with what they consider theirs.

No.6

C.J. Tudor
The Other People

Reference price
$17.15
Mid

The Other People Know about the Dead

After three years of searching, the rusty old car which was used to abduct Gabe's five year old daughter is found at the bottom of the lake. Gabe is forced not only to face this tragedy but other specters from his past. His search for answers leads him to the Other People. 


While this book is worth a read, it's considered not as strong as C.J Tudor's first two releases. The coincidences that occurred may seem a little convenient, but reviewers enjoyed the sinister and chilling atmosphere the authors weaves around the highway, haunted not only by questions but also Gabe, the grieving father.

No.7

B.A. Paris
The Dilemma

Reference price
$17.44
Mid

A Secret Kept from Each Other

Livia has planned her fortieth birthday for decades, and her husband Adam is determined it will go well. But neither knows that each is keeping a secret from the other, and only when the party comes to a close will it be revealed.


For many readers, the harmless childishness of a long planned birthday party contrasted intensely with the brutal secrets that each character kept and heightened the stakes of the fallout that would decidedly occur in the 24 hour time frame. 

No.8

Peter Swanson
Eight Perfect Murders

Reference price
$29.99
High

A Romp through the Genre of Mystery and Thrillers

A murder aficionado Malcolm finds himself entangled in an investigation when the FBI knocking at his door as a string of killings have happened that are eerily similar to a list of famous murders he had compiled years ago. As Malcolm tries to identify who the killer may be, he starts seeing motives for his own murder.


This book seems specifically written for crime lovers. Sinister plots are interwoven with laugh out loud moments. Reviewers loved how Malcolm seemed to embody everyone's inner bookworm.

No.9

Peter James
Find Them Dead

Reference price
$11.95
Low

A Ruthless Drug Dealers Orders the Death of a Widow's Only Daughter

After losing her son and husband in a terrible car crash, it took Meg Magellen five years to rebuild her life with her teenage daughter Laura. Now Laura is off on a gap year in South America, Meg is at a loose end and is excited to be called for jury duty, something to keep her from worrying about Laura.


However, the trial is that of a ruthless drug lord who has no qualms about forcing Meg to make sure the trial goes his way by threatening the life of her daughter.


While this books is set to be released, readers can't wait to get their hands on the next installment of Roy Grace's gripping adventures.

No.10

Robert Galbraith (J.K. Rowling)
Troubled Blood

Reference price
$26.10
High Mid

The Next Installment of the Cormoran Strike Novels

J.K. Rowling returns as Robert Galbraith to release the new installment of the Cormoran Strike Books. The series continues to follow PIs Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacot as is sure to delight old fans and thrill new ones.


Reviewers for the previous installment say it's an addictive series and flies by quickly because it's so entertaining. 

Top 5 Mystery Books

No. 1: Lisa GardnerWhen You See Me (Detective D.D. Warren Book 11)

No. 2: Sophie HannahPerfect Little Children

No. 3: Kwei QuarteyThe Missing American

No. 4: Graham MooreThe Holdout: A Novel

No. 5: Tanen JonesThe Better Liar

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Books and magazines

Pie Cookbooks

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.