mybest
Nonstick PansHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Nonstick PansHelping You Find the Best
12 Best Nonstick Pans  [Tested and Reviewed]

12 Best Nonstick Pans [Tested and Reviewed]

A nonstick pan is a convenient tool in the kitchen. They’re great to have on hand when you’re cooking foods that tend to stick, such as eggs, pancakes, and fish. Manufacturers like Calphalon, OXO, Carote, and T-fal are known as top brands for nonstick pans, and they feature a range of coatings. But which nonstick pans stand the test of time?

To find out, we collected 12 popular nonstick pans, including the latest products and top-sellers from an assortment of manufacturers, and tested them on three quality measures. Based on our results, we ranked the nonstick pans to help you find the best option for your needs. 


At mybest, we define the best nonstick pan as one that remains nonstick even after long use and is easy to cook with. We will also explain what to look for in a nonstick pan, based on our results, so you can use this buying guide as a resource as you shop.

Last updated 03/28/2024
Dann Reid
Expert
Freelance Food Writer
Dann Reid

Dann got his first job in 1977 as a dishwasher at a YMCA camp. The food service industry appealed to him. Since that young age, he's been a head chef, a head baker, worked in grocery retail baking, and written three books (two were cookbooks and one a question and answer about being a chef). He's also learning about gluten-free cooking and baking.

Dann Reid's Profile
…Continue reading
Haruna Tabe
Guide
Head of Health Foods and Kitchenware at mybest
Haruna Tabe

Haruna Tabe is a registered dietitian with five years of experience working in the content creation team for a recipe media outlet. There, her primary responsibilities included recipe supervision and quality control. She joined mybest in 2023, bringing her valuable experience to guide users in health foods, foods, and kitchenware. With a motto of "thinking from the users' perspective," she is dedicated to enriching users' lives through their diet, working daily to contribute to their well-being.

Haruna Tabe's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

We gathered the 12 bestselling Nonstick Pans and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Resistance to Sticking

    1
    Resistance to Sticking

    We set the standard for satisfaction for a non-stick pan as "a product that prevents food from sticking to the nonstick pan even after two years." The testing of each product was conducted in the following manner.

  2. Ease of Cooking

    2
    Ease of Cooking

    We set the standard for a user-friendly nonstick pan as "a product that is easy to handle even with one hand, and allows for smooth cooking." We have tested each product using the following methods.

  3. Heat Distribution Uniformity

    3
    Heat Distribution Uniformity

    We defined the standard for heat distribution uniformity that will highly satisfy users as: "A product that allows heat to be evenly distributed to the ingredients." We tested each product in the following manner.

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

The Nonstick Pans We Tested Provided Steady Heat and Cooked Evenly

The Nonstick Pans We Tested Provided Steady Heat and Cooked Evenly

Do nonstick pans cook food evenly? We set out to test the pans on our list by cooking pancakes. The good news? Each nonstick pan heated the batter evenly from the center, resulting in even browning. While some pans heated up faster than others, all the pans browned the pancakes evenly.


Pans that were larger than 12 inches in diameter took longer to heat up, and the outer part of the pancakes was lightly browned. If you're making pancakes for a crowd, we recommend you use a large pan and keep it on low, steady heat for even cooking. 

Half the Pans We Tested Lost Their Nonstick Quality, So Replace Them Every 2 to 3 Years

Half the Pans We Tested Lost Their Nonstick Quality, So Replace Them Every 2 to 3 Years

The longevity of a nonstick pan depends on how often you use it, but generally, it lasts for about two to three years. To test the durability of the nonstick pans on our list, we simulated wear and tear equivalent to two years by scratching the coated cooking surface of each pan.


When we tested the 12 nonstick pans by cooking eggs, we found that eggs stuck to the surface of six of the pans. The eggs were harder to get out of some pans than others, and half the pans we tested didn’t really live up to the label “nonstick."


Keep in mind that scraping the nonstick surface with a hard spatula or spoon or cooking at extremely high heat can also cause the coating to deteriorate or peel off.

Dann Reid
Freelance Food Writer
Dann Reid

Also, some coatings become potentially unsafe when they’re heated to extremely high temperatures. Fluororesins such as PTFE and PFA, which are often used as coating materials, can emit harmful gases and chemicals when they exceed 500°F, so we advise you to avoid cooking at high temperatures. 


Starting in 2015, all cooking utensils sold in the United States are PFOA-free, which means that no PFOE fluorocarbons are used in the coating, which is a selling point for many companies. However, once the coating of a nonstick pan is damaged, there’s less guarantee of safety. So we recommend that you consider nonstick pans as products that you need to replace every few years for optimum safety and performance.

How to Choose Nonstick Pans

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Nonstick Pans.

1

The Easiest Pans to Cook With Are the Blue Diamond And SENSARTE

The Easiest Pans to Cook With Are the Blue Diamond And SENSARTE

Our test showed that the easiest nonstick pans to cook with were the "Classic Frypan" by Blue Diamond and the "Granite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet" by SENSARTE. Below, we will explain in detail why these two products topped our rankings.

Lightweight and Easy to Grip, You Can Hold Each Pan With One Hand

Lightweight and Easy to Grip, You Can Hold Each Pan With One Hand

Both nonstick pans are lightweight, weighing less than 2 pounds. That’s handy as they’re not too heavy, even when they’re filled with food. In addition, both pans have round handles, so they’re easy to grip. You can hold them comfortably with one hand, allowing you to use your other hand for other tasks.


On the other hand, the nonstick pans that weighed more than 2 or 2.5 pounds were cumbersome to cook with. Some people may find it challenging to use these heavier pans for cooking, serving, and cleanup.

Haruna Tabe
Head of Health Foods and Kitchenware at mybest
Haruna Tabe

If you're using a nonstick pan to make eggs or pancakes, about 9-10 inches is the optimum size. The larger the pan, the heavier it is, and the longer it takes to heat up.

Both Pans Have Excellent Durability. Even After Inflicting Two Years’ Worth of Damage, the Eggs Did Not Stick

Both Pans Have Excellent Durability. Even After Inflicting Two Years’ Worth of Damage, the Eggs Did Not Stick

One of the outstanding features of the top-ranking nonstick pans we tested is the durability of the coating. Even after we simulated two years of wear and tear, the eggs were as easy to remove in pans with high durability as when they were brand new.


With some of the other nonstick pans we tested, some eggs remained, or the egg fell apart as we tried to remove it from the pan. But our top-ranking pans cooked the eggs cleanly, and their coatings lasted even after frequent use.

When NonStick Pans Are Oven-Compatible, You Can Roast Meat and Cook Side Dishes in Them

When NonStick Pans Are Oven-Compatible, You Can Roast Meat and Cook Side Dishes in Them

Another reason we recommend these two nonstick pans is that they’re oven-compatible. If your pan also works in an oven, you can prepare dishes like roast beef or gratin beforehand and then heat them directly in the oven without the need to change pans.


The Blue Diamond brand can withstand ovens up to 600°F, and the SENSARTE brand can handle heat up to 302°F

They’re Dishwasher-Safe And Easy to Clean

They’re Dishwasher-Safe And Easy to Clean

Another reason we recommend these pans is you can clean them in a dishwasher. Some pans can only be washed by hand and aren't dishwasher-safe. So if you have a dishwasher at home, look for a nonstick pan that is dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

12 Best Nonstick Pans Ranking

Here are the best Nonstick Pans we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
Oven Compatible
Dishwasher Safe
Induction Heating Compatible
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Main Score
Details
Nonstick Performance
Ease of Cooking
Heat Uniformity
Compatible Heat Sources
Frying Pan Material
Surface Coating
Handle Material
Dishwasher Safe
Inner Diameter
Weight
Total Length
Comes With Lid
Detachable Handle
1

The Cookware Company

Blue DiamondClassic Frypan

The Cookware Company Classic Frypan 1
5.00

Easy to Clean, Lightweight, and Makes Cooking Fun

5.00
5.00
5.00

Gas, Electric Stove, Oven

Alminum

Ceramic Coating (Diamond-Infused)

Stainless Steel

10.63 in.

1.46 lb.

18.31 in.

1

SENSARTE

Granite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet

SENSARTE Granite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet 1
5.00

Easy to Use With One Hand; Holds Up Well Against Wear and Tear

5.00
5.00
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove, Oven

Cast Aluminium

ILAG nonstick coating

Bakelite

9.5 in.

1.78 lb.

17.5 in.

3

Tramontina USA

Tri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior

Tramontina USA Tri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior 1
4.87

Heavier Than Other Options, but Its Coating Should Go the Distance

5.00
4.50
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove , Ceramic Heater, Oven

18/10 Stainless Steel,Aluminum

Teflon Coating

Stainless Steel

10.47 in.

2.02 lb.

18.6 in.

4

OXO International

Good Grips Pro Frying Pan

OXO International Good Grips Pro Frying Pan 1
4.85

Handle Is Rounded and Easy to Grip, but Less Durable

4.75
5.00
5.00

Gas, Electric Stove, Oven

Hard Anodized Nonstick Aluminum, Stainless Steel

unknown

Stainless Steel

10 in.

1.82 lb.

16 in.

5

CAROTE

Non Stick Granite Fry Pan

CAROTE Non Stick Granite Fry Pan 1
4.69

Handle Fits Comfortably in the Hand, but Lacks in Performance

4.50
5.00
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating) , Ceramic Heater, Halogen Heater, Electric Stove

Granite

Teflon Coating

Bakelite

10.63 in.

1.89 lb.

18.11 in.

6

Groupe SEB

All-CladD3 Stainless 3-ply Nonstick Fry Pan4110 NS R2

Groupe SEB D3 Stainless 3-ply Nonstick Fry Pan 1
4.67

The Coating Holds up Well, but the Thin Handle and Weight Are Drawbacks

5.00
3.92
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove, Ceramic Cooktop, Oven

Stainless Steel

Fluororesin Coating (PTFE)

Stainless Steel

(Handwashing is recommended)

10.5 in.

2.20 lb.

17.9 in.

7

The Cookware Company

GREENPAN RIOCeramic Nonstick Frypan

The Cookware Company Ceramic Nonstick Frypan 1
4.57

Handle Is Easy to Grip, but the Coating's Durability Is Questionable

4.50
4.50
5.00

Gas, Electric Stove, Oven

Aluminum

Ceramic Coating with Diamonds

phenolic resin(Bakelite)

12 in.

2.13 lb.

19.1 in.

8

Caraway Home

Frying Pan

Caraway Home Frying Pan 1
4.56

Durable With Care; Weight Is a Drawback

4.75
4.00
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove , Oven

Alminum

Ceramic Coating

Stainless Steel

10.5 in.

2.82 lb.

18.4 in.

9

Tramontina USA

PRO SeriesProfessional Aluminum Nonstick Restaurant Fry Pan10

Tramontina USA Professional Aluminum Nonstick Restaurant Fry Pan 1
4.45

Cooks Well, but Coating Isn't Durable

4.50
4.09
5.00

Gas, Ceramic Heater, Electric Stove, Oven

Aluminum Alloy

Teflon Coating

Stainless Steel, Silicone

10.43 in.

2.02 lb.

25 in.

10

Groupe SEB

T-falAdvanced Nonstick Fry Pan

Groupe SEB Advanced Nonstick Fry Pan 1
3.86

Lightweight and Easy to Use; Nonstick Quality Is Lacking

3.40
5.00
5.00

Gas, IH (Induction Heating), Oven

Aluminum

Titanium Coating

Metal, Silicone

10.5 in.

1.68 lb.

18.03 in.

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Nonstick Pans
No.1 in Nonstick Performance
No.1 in Ease of Cooking
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

The Cookware Company
Blue DiamondClassic Frypan

mybest Score
5.00
Nonstick Performance
5.00
Ease of Cooking
5.00
Heat Uniformity
5.00
View on Amazon
Classic Frypan 1
Lowest price
$19.88
Low Mid
Lowest price
$19.88
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, Electric Stove, Oven
Weight1.46 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Easy to Clean, Lightweight, and Makes Cooking Fun

What we loved

  • Durable
  • Lightweight
  • Can use in high heat

What we didn't love

  • Nothing in particular.

The key feature of Blue Diamond's "Classic Frypan" is the diamond-infused coating. This pan is PFAS- and PFOA-free, and can be heated in ovens and broilers up to 600°F.


When we tested for non-stickiness, even after inflicting half a year's and two years’ worth of damage, this pan still cooked effectively and the eggs came out of the pan easily and kept their form. Although the pan had slight scratches, they did not affect the quality of the cooking, so the durability of the coating was high.


This pan weighs 1.46 pounds, which is light enough for cooks to hold with one hand. The handle is smooth, so it feels good in the hand. Even when you’re busy making breakfast, this pan is easy to use.


When we tested for heat distribution, the pancake had been evenly browned and heated without any hot spots. With this pan, you can beautifully cook ingredients that tend to stick, like eggs and fish, with no worries.

Frying Pan MaterialAlminum
Surface CoatingCeramic Coating (Diamond-Infused)
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10.63 in.
Total Length18.31 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.1
Top Choice Nonstick Pans
No.1 in Nonstick Performance
No.1 in Ease of Cooking
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

SENSARTE
Granite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet

Lowest price
$23.99
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove, Oven
Weight1.78 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Easy to Use With One Hand; Holds Up Well Against Wear and Tear

What we loved

  • Cooks well
  • Durable
  • Features wooden handle

What we didn't love

  • Nothing in particular.

The SENSARTE "Granite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet" features a wood grain handle. This PFOA-free product is oven-safe up to 302°F.


When we tested for stickiness, even after inflicting half a year's worth and two years' worth of damage, we were able to easily remove the eggs using light force, which was impressive. The eggs didn’t stick at all and came off in one piece. The scratches weren’t visible, and the coating was durable. 


At 1.78 pounds, this pan is light enough to hold in one hand. The handle has a rounded bottom, with a matte surface, that feels good in your hand. This pan is also easy to handle, so you can cook meals quickly and efficiently


When we evaluated heat distribution, this pan produced pancakes with an even brown color that were cooked evenly. This pan is perfect for cooking food that sticks to the pan, so it will help make busy mornings easier

Frying Pan MaterialCast Aluminium
Surface CoatingILAG nonstick coating
Handle MaterialBakelite
Inner Diameter9.5 in.
Total Length17.5 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.3
No.1 in Nonstick Performance
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Tramontina USA
Tri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior

Lowest price
$48.63
Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove , Ceramic Heater, Oven
Weight2.02 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Heavier Than Other Options, but Its Coating Should Go the Distance

What we loved

  • Cooks evenly
  • Easy to grip
  • Doesn’t stick

What we didn't love

  • Heavy

Tramontina USA's "Tri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior" features aluminum encased by two layers of stainless steel. It is oven-safe up to 450° F, and its exterior is shiny and polished. 


When we tested for cooking uniformity, the pancakes were browned evenly. The pan’s handle is a thick oval, so it’s easy to grip due to its lack of corners. However, at 2.02 pounds, this pan is more substantial than other models and might feel heavy to some users when filled with food.


This pan also earned high marks in the test for non-stickiness. The eggs we cooked easily came out of the pan. Even after simulating half a year's worth of scratches, the eggs still didn’t stick to the pan and came out with just a light pull from the edge. Moreover, even after simulating two years of scratches, the impact on the surface was minimal and the eggs still came out of the pan easily. Although this pan might be a little heavy for some users, its coating is highly durable, so it’s a solid choice. 

Frying Pan Material18/10 Stainless Steel,Aluminum
Surface CoatingTeflon Coating
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10.47 in.
Total Length18.6 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.4
No.1 in Ease of Cooking
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

OXO International
Good Grips Pro Frying Pan

Lowest price
$44.04
Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, Electric Stove, Oven
Weight1.82 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Handle Is Rounded and Easy to Grip, but Less Durable

What we loved

  • Lightweight
  • Round handle

What we didn't love

  • Starts to stick after about 2 years

The "Good Grips Pro Frying Pan Skillet" from OXO International, which won BEST IN SHOW at America's Test Kitchen, is oven-safe up to 430°F.


Our testing for cooking uniformity revealed that the pancake had an even sear all over and was thoroughly cooked. The handle has a rounded bottom, so it won't dig into your palm. This pan also weighs in at 1.82 pounds, so it’s easy to handle with one hand.


In testing the resistance to sticking, we didn’t encounter any stickiness with the eggs we cooked, and we were able to remove them with a light pull. Even after inflicting six months' worth of scratches, the eggs still didn’t stick or leave residue in the pan and were as easy to remove as when the pan was new. On the other hand, after two years' worth of scratches, the eggs stuck to the pan slightly. We also observed a faint burn mark on the right side of the pan, but we were still able to remove the eggs cleanly, so the coating is relatively durable

Frying Pan MaterialHard Anodized Nonstick Aluminum, Stainless Steel
Surface Coatingunknown
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10 in.
Total Length16 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.5
No.1 in Ease of Cooking
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

CAROTE
Non Stick Granite Fry Pan

Lowest price
$28.99
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating) , Ceramic Heater, Halogen Heater, Electric Stove
Weight1.89 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Handle Fits Comfortably in the Hand, but Lacks in Performance

What we loved

  • Cooks evenly
  • Lightweight
  • Easy-to-grip handle

What we didn't love

  • Not completely non-stick

The "Non Stick Granite Fry Pan" by CAROTE, which stands out for its wood grain handle, is PFOS- and PFOA-free.

Our testing for cooking uniformity resulted in a pancake that was evenly browned and uniformly hot. When it came to cooking convenience, the smooth curved handle fit comfortably in the hand. And at 1.89 pounds, this pan is light enough to carry in one hand.

That said, when we tested for resistance to sticking, even when this pan was new, some food stuck and we had to remove the eggs slowly. After we applied half a year's worth of scratches, the eggs stuck a bit more in the pan, but they didn’t burn, and they were still easy to remove. But when we applied two year's worth of scratches, a portion of the egg about the size of a fingernail stuck to the right side, but the bulk of the egg still peeled off and was hardly affected. While this pan isn’t completely non-stick, the coating is generally durable. 

Frying Pan MaterialGranite
Surface CoatingTeflon Coating
Handle MaterialBakelite
Inner Diameter10.63 in.
Total Length18.11 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.6
No.1 in Nonstick Performance
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Groupe SEB
All-CladD3 Stainless 3-ply Nonstick Fry Pan4110 NS R2

mybest Score
4.67
Nonstick Performance
5.00
Ease of Cooking
3.92
Heat Uniformity
5.00
Lowest price
$178.99
High
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove, Ceramic Cooktop, Oven
Weight2.20 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
(Handwashing is recommended)
Comes With Lid

The Coating Holds up Well, but the Thin Handle and Weight Are Drawbacks

What we loved

  • Durable coating
  • Can cook at high heats in oven

What we didn't love

  • Heavy
  • Thin handle isn’t user-friendly

The "D3 Stainless 3-ply Nonstick Fry Pan 4110 NS R2" from Groupe SEB's All-Clad, is designed and assembled entirely within the United States. It features a three-layer structure with aluminum sandwiched between stainless steel layers and is oven-safe up to 500°F.


The pancake we cooked was evenly browned all over, indicating that it had been uniformly heated. On the other hand, the pan’s handle isn’t as user-friendly as some other options. It’s thin and has a dip in the upper part of the handle, which makes it hard to grip. And at 2.20 pounds, it might feel heavy to hold with one hand.


In our test of resistance to sticking, this pan showed no sign of adhesion when brand new, as the eggs could be peeled off easily in one go. When subjected to half a year's worth of scratches, the eggs were slightly harder to remove, but nothing stuck or burned on the pan, and we were able to peel the eggs off much like a sticker. Even with two years' worth of scratches, we could cleanly remove cooked food from the entire surface of this pan. The durability of this pan’s coating is high, but the difficulty of gripping the handle and its weight are drawbacks.

Frying Pan MaterialStainless Steel
Surface CoatingFluororesin Coating (PTFE)
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10.5 in.
Total Length 17.9 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.7
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

The Cookware Company
GREENPAN RIOCeramic Nonstick Frypan

Lowest price
$19.99
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, Electric Stove, Oven
Weight2.13 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Handle Is Easy to Grip, but the Coating's Durability Is Questionable

What we loved

  • Cooks entire surface evenly
  • Handle fits well in the hand

What we didn't love

  • Large
  • May be harder to handle

The Ceramic Nonstick Frypan by GREEN PAN from The Cookware Company is a nonstick pan with a PFAS- and PFOA-free ceramic coating. This coating is reinforced with diamond to enhance durability, and it is advertised as oven-proof up to 350°F.


With a diameter of 12 inches, this pan is larger than others on our list, but it still performed well in cooking uniformity. The outside of the pancake was browned, and the color spread in a circle, indicating that the heat was evenly distributed. If you heat this pan slowly over low heat, it cooks uniformly. In terms of ease of cooking, the bottom of the handle is rounded and fits in the palm of your hand. However, at 2.13 pounds, this pan might be difficult to handle with one hand.


In our testing of this pan’s non-stick properties, we were impressed to observe that when the product was new, freshly laid eggs could be gently peeled off the cooking surface. Even after being scratched equivalent to six months of use, the eggs didn’t stick to the pan, and only a slight amount of egg scorched on the scratched section on the right of the pan. Even with scratches equivalent to two years of use, only a piece of egg as small as the tip of a fingernail remained in the pan, so we found the coating to be fairly durable.

Frying Pan MaterialAluminum
Surface CoatingCeramic Coating with Diamonds
Handle Materialphenolic resin(Bakelite)
Inner Diameter12 in.
Total Length19.1 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.8
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Caraway Home
Frying Pan

mybest Score
4.56
Nonstick Performance
4.75
Ease of Cooking
4.00
Heat Uniformity
5.00
Lowest price
$95.00
High Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove , Oven
Weight2.82 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Durable With Care; Weight Is a Drawback

What we loved

  • Cooks evenly
  • Durable

What we didn't love

  • Heavy

You can choose from a rich selection of colors with Caraway Home's "Frying Pan." It features a ceramic coating that does not use PFOA, PTFE, or PFAS, and it is oven-safe up to 550°F.

The pancake we made had an evenly browned surface all around, so the pan appeared to cook evenly. The handle has a smooth, round shape, so it feels good in the palm. However, this pan’s slim profile might not be ideal for people with larger hands. Also, at 2.82 pounds, this pan was heavy to handle with one hand.

In our test for non-stickiness, when the pan was brand new, we didn’t encounter any stickiness and with a gentle shake, the eggs were easy to peel off. When scratched with the equivalent of half a year's worth of wear and tear, the eggs stuck slightly where the pan was scratched, but the egg could be peeled off cleanly. Two years' worth of scratches didn’t alter the performance substantially but left about a fingernail’s worth of egg in the center of the pan. Overall, if you take care of this pan to keep scratching at a minimum and the coating intact, it should last a long time.

Frying Pan MaterialAlminum
Surface CoatingCeramic Coating
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10.5 in.
Total Length18.4 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.9
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Tramontina USA
PRO SeriesProfessional Aluminum Nonstick Restaurant Fry Pan10

mybest Score
4.45
Nonstick Performance
4.50
Ease of Cooking
4.09
Heat Uniformity
5.00
Lowest price
$28.04
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, Ceramic Heater, Electric Stove, Oven
Weight2.02 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Cooks Well, but Coating Isn't Durable

What we loved

  • Handle made with silicone grip
  • Cooks evenly

What we didn't love

  • Non-stick fades over time
  • Heavy

The "Professional Aluminum Nonstick Restaurant Fry Pan" from Tramontina USA is a PFOA-free frying pan, compatible with ovens up to 400°F. It comes with a silicone grip on the handle.


When we tested, the pancake had an even sear all over, indicating that it had been heated uniformly. The handle is in a slim oval shape covered with a silicone grip, which prevents slippage, a major selling point. However, this pan weighs 2.02 pounds, which makes it a bit heavy, and we found it difficult to handle with one hand when it's filled with ingredients.


In our test for non-stickiness in a brand-new pan, the eggs could easily be peeled off with a light pull, with absolutely no stickiness. When subjected to the pan to the equivalent of half a year's worth of scratches, we observed slight stickiness on the scratched areas, but we could still remove the eggs cleanly from the cooking surface. However, after the equivalent of two years worth of scratches, we encountered some stickiness and a bit of scorching on the left edge of the pan. If you cook often and decide to buy this pan, we recommend you replace it after about two years of use.

Frying Pan MaterialAluminum Alloy
Surface CoatingTeflon Coating
Handle MaterialStainless Steel, Silicone
Inner Diameter10.43 in.
Total Length25 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.10
No.1 in Ease of Cooking
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Groupe SEB
T-falAdvanced Nonstick Fry Pan

mybest Score
3.86
Nonstick Performance
3.40
Ease of Cooking
5.00
Heat Uniformity
5.00
Lowest price
$26.19
Low Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Oven
Weight1.68 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Lightweight and Easy to Use; Nonstick Quality Is Lacking

What we loved

  • Lightweight
  • Easy to use

What we didn't love

  • Food tended to stick in pan

The "Advanced Nonstick Fry Pan" is from Groupe SEB, which is well-known for its T-fal brand. This frying pan features a titanium coating and is oven-safe up to 350°F.


The pancake was somewhat fox-colored on the outside but was evenly cooked from the center to the edges. The handle had a matte texture and a gentle curve at the bottom, which made it easy to grip. With a light weight of 1.68 pounds, this pan was easy to handle with one hand, even when holding ingredients with the other hand.


However, when we tested for stickiness, even when this pan was new, we observed slight adhesion, similar to the sensation of peeling off adhesive tape. After applying half a year's worth of scratches, eggs stuck to the edge, which left residue on the right and left side of the pan. Two years' worth of scratches resulted in the egg tearing if we didn’t peel it off gradually, leaving a portion of the egg on the grilled surface. And when cooking delicate ingredients, this pan proved to be somewhat unreliable. 

Frying Pan MaterialAluminum
Surface CoatingTitanium Coating
Handle MaterialMetal, Silicone
Inner Diameter10.5 in.
Total Length18.03 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.11
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

HexClad
Hybrid Nonstick Frying Pan

Lowest price
$184.00
High
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, IH (Induction Heating), Electric Stove, Oven
Weight3.13 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

While the Handle Is Easy to Grip, Eggs Are Hard to Peel Off

What we loved

  • Cooks evenly
  • Handle is comfortable to hold

What we didn't love

  • Large
  • Heavy
  • Some stickiness

HexClad's "Hybrid Nonstick Frying Pan" is a triple-layered frying pan with aluminum sandwiched between layers of stainless steel. It is a PFOA-free product, compatible with ovens up to 500°F.


Due to its large size of 12 inches, the outside of the pancake was lightly browned during our testing of this pan, and the heat appeared to spread evenly in a circular pattern. If you warm up this pan slowly over low heat, the heat will be distributed evenly throughout. When it comes to ease of use, the handle has no corners and has a plump shape that fits comfortably in your hand. However, at 3.13 pounds, this pan is more than a pound heavier than some on this list, and you may find it challenging to hold it with one hand.


When we tested this pan for non-stickiness, the surface felt rough, and it was hard to peel eggs off it even when it was brand new. When scratched its surface to simulate half a year's use, this pan produced a suction effect when we tried to pull the egg out of the pan. It ended up splitting with both sides left on the cooking surface. When we scratched the surface to simulate two years' use, the suction effect was still a factor, resulting in the left side of an egg splitting. Although the egg peeled off when we rubbed it lightly with tongs, this pan wasn’t truly non-stick. 

Frying Pan MaterialStainless Steel
Surface CoatingHexagonal Steel Ridges
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter12 in.
Total Length20 in.
Detachable Handle
View all
No.12
No.1 in Heat Uniformity

Calphalon
Calphalon PremierPremier Hard-Anodized Nonstick 10-Inch Fry Pan2172330

mybest Score
3.60
Nonstick Performance
3.20
Ease of Cooking
4.50
Heat Uniformity
5.00
Lowest price
$54.99
High Mid
Compatible Heat SourcesGas, Electric Stove, Oven
Weight2.24 lb.
Dishwasher Safe
Comes With Lid

Egg Stuck in the Pan, but Has an Easy-to-Hold Handle

What we loved

  • Cooks evenly
  • Handle feels good in the hand

What we didn't love

  • Not non-stick
  • Heavy

The Calphalon "Premier Hard-Anodized Nonstick 10-Inch Fry Pan" boasts a durability that is five times higher than conventional products. It is compatible with ovens up to 450°F.

When we tested for even cooking, we observed that the pancake became lighter towards the outside, but its crispy edges were evenly spread out in a circular manner, so it appeared to have been heated uniformly. The handle doesn't have sharp edges, so it feels good to hold. However, at 2.24 pounds, this pan felt heavy to handle with one hand once the ingredients were added.

When we tested for non-stickiness, we observed a suction effect similar to peeling off old adhesive tape. With the equivalent of half a year's worth of scratches, the egg was hard to peel off and partially stuck to the pan. At two years' worth of scratches, food in this pan is even more likely to stick, and the right half of the egg ends up crumbling. In the end, this pan doesn’t live up to the label “non-stick.” 

Frying Pan MaterialHard Anodized Aluminum
Surface CoatingMineralShield Nonstick
Handle MaterialStainless Steel
Inner Diameter10 in.
Total Length18.1 in.
Detachable Handle
View all

How We Tested Nonstick Pans

Nonstick Pans Evaluation

At mybest, we define the best nonstick pan as one that doesn't stick to food even after long use and is easy to cook with.

 

To find the best product, we gathered 12 high-ranking nonstick pans from popular manufacturers, the latest products, and those available at Amazon, Walmart, Target, etc., and thoroughly tested them using the following three measures. 


  • Resistance to Sticking
  • Ease of Cooking 
  • Heat Distribution Uniformity

Products we tested

  1. CAROTENon Stick Granite Fry Pan
  2. CalphalonCalphalon PremierPremier Hard-Anodized Nonstick 10-Inch Fry Pan2172330
  3. Caraway HomeFrying Pan
  4. Groupe SEBT-falAdvanced Nonstick Fry Pan
  5. Groupe SEBAll-CladD3 Stainless 3-ply Nonstick Fry Pan4110 NS R2
  6. HexCladHybrid Nonstick Frying Pan
  7. OXO InternationalGood Grips Pro Frying Pan
  8. SENSARTEGranite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet
  9. The Cookware CompanyGREENPAN RIOCeramic Nonstick Frypan
  10. The Cookware CompanyBlue DiamondClassic Frypan
  11. Tramontina USAPRO SeriesProfessional Aluminum Nonstick Restaurant Fry Pan10
  12. Tramontina USATri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior
1

Resistance to Sticking

Resistance to Sticking
We set the standard for satisfaction for a non-stick pan as "a product that prevents food from sticking to the nonstick pan even after two years." The testing of each product was conducted in the following manner.

Scoring Method

We recommend and have rated products based on their ability to cleanly release fried eggs from the nonstick pan with just a tug. Furthermore, to simulate the degradation over six months to two years, we compared them by cooking eggs after scratching the surface of the pan with a metal spatula attached to a vibrating machine.

Test Conditions

  • Heat the nonstick pan over medium heat 
  • When the inside temperature reaches 356°F, lower the heat and add one tablespoon of sugar to the well-mixed egg mixture. Pour it in
  • When it's about 80% set, start peeling the egg from the edge towards you
2

Ease of Cooking

Ease of Cooking

We set the standard for a user-friendly nonstick pan as "a product that is easy to handle even with one hand, and allows for smooth cooking." We have tested each product using the following methods.

Scoring Method

Testers checked each product and scored their satisfaction on the following points, and we converted the satisfaction level of each product into a number score.

What We Checked

  • Weight
  • Shape of the handle
  • Presence or absence of the removable handle
3

Heat Distribution Uniformity

Heat Distribution Uniformity

We defined the standard for heat distribution uniformity that will highly satisfy users as: "A product that allows heat to be evenly distributed to the ingredients." We tested each product in the following manner.

Scoring Method

We recommended and scored pancakes that were evenly browned when cooked in a nonstick pan for the same amount of time.

Test Conditions

  • Heat the nonstick pan over medium heat 
  • Once the interior temperature reaches 356°F, place the pan on a damp cloth, and let it cool until the center temperature drops to 221°F 
  • Pour the pancake batter into the pan, spreading it evenly, and cook on low heat for three minutes
  • After three minutes, flip it and check the cooked side

Top 5 Nonstick Pans

No. 1: The Cookware CompanyBlue DiamondClassic Frypan

No. 1: SENSARTEGranite Stone Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet

No. 3: Tramontina USATri-Ply Base 10 in Stainless Steel Fry Pan with Nonstick Interior

No. 4: OXO InternationalGood Grips Pro Frying Pan

No. 5: CAROTENon Stick Granite Fry Pan

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Nonstick Pans

Cast Iron Skillets

9 Best

Tested and Reviewed

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.