10 Best Liquid Eyeliners in 2022 (NYX, Tarte, and More)

This intensely-pigmented waterproof eyeliner with a flexible tip gives you better control over the line thickness. The vegan formula contains propylene glycol and castor oil to prevent moisture loss. If you have dry skin, this velvety-smooth formula will suit you. Impressively, it's available in both matte and metallic finishes. 

Some users disliked it because it leaked from the brush or too much formula came out of it. One user recommended storing it upright to prevent clumping. On the other hand, many users loved its ease of use and staying power. They could make narrow to broad wings and perfectly symmetrical cat eyes effortlessly. 

This is an award-winning product from Kat Von D. We love its vegan and cruelty-free formula. The precision brush tip is a highly impressive accessory. You can confidently draw a thin and precise line like a calligraphy pen. Or layer it up for that classic winged look! The slightly glossy formula also makes it perfect for most skin types. 

However, some users expressed concerns about the formula drying up after a few uses. Also, it wasn't that easy for beginners to use the brush. But many expert users loved the precision the brush tip gave and how well the liner stayed on. It was complemented by users with a variety of skin tones and types.

Using this marker-like felt tip pen, you can draw dramatic thick strokes or fine and precise lines. The waterproof and long-wear formula has great staying power. The pen stays grippy even in the hands of a novice makeup enthusiast. And if you're a professional, you can experiment with a variety of perfect strokes and finishes. 

However, some users questioned its waterproofing capabilities, and others its authenticity. We've included the link to the official site just in case. On the other hand, many users recommended this formula because it was fast-drying. The tip didn't dry out inside the bottle. It was easy to apply even for a beginner. 

This will be a favorite for those wanting ultra-fine strokes on their eyes. A 0.4 millimeter felt tip pen is paired with a formula that can resist the elements for up to 12 hours. Regardless of whether you're a pro or a novice, you can safely play around with different styles using this quick-drying formula and the super-sleek precise tip. 

The product quickly dried up for some users, and it didn't stay waterproof and smudge-proof for some others. However, the felt tip pen gave better control to many. Makeup enthusiasts say the gliding formula gave a perfectly smooth semi-matte finish to their look. 

Tarte offers this dual-ended product with a pencil liner on one side and liquid eyeliner on the other. Its precision tip brush is designed to deposit the right amount of the pigmented formula to create a perfect line or a dramatic wing. The infusion of Amazonian clay makes it wear-resistant and mineral pigments are gentle on the skin. 

However, most dislikes were about the eyeliner smudging and not staying as expected. On the whole, many users loved how dark the color was and how smooth and easy the application was. Many loved the glossy deposit that turned matte and opaque when dry. 

This eyeliner from NYX Professional Makeup uses an ultra-fine precision brush to achieve a perfectly thin line in a few seconds. The wider body makes it ergonomic for you to hold and gain control over the strokes. Plus, it has humectants like ethylexylglycerin and emollients like hydrogenated castor oil to keep the formula smooth regardless of the matte finish. 

Some users complained of it flaking off after a few hours. However, many users complimented its super dark color and matte finish. It dried fast on the eyes and stayed resistant to smudging and moisture for a long time.

Those who love demi-matte or satin finish should try this quick-drying eyeliner from Lady Gaga's Haus Laboratories. The rich and dark formula is designed to resist flaking and smudging and to ensure long wear and its super-fine felt tip is flexible and angled to make perfect strokes smoothly.

It might not be that great for oily skin, as some users reported it smudging. Also, the pen dried up for some users, so store the eyeliner tip-down. But for many others, the formula stayed resistant to moisture and wear. The pointy brush tip was perfect for making thin strokes, thick lines, and cat eyes. 

For sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, Clinique has this glossy eyeliner tested by ophthalmologists to attest to its safe use. It uses a brush tip to deliver a precise and sharp line that's thin or thick in one sweep. Layer it up for that dramatic winged look or cat eye, or try tightlining with it to make your lashes appear darker and thicker.  

However, some users found the liquid formula too watery. It didn't stay long for them. Overall, many users attested to its super-smooth application and smudge-resistance. For them, the brush tip helped to apply with great precision.

Revlon offers this ophthalmologist-tested eyeliner. The tapered holder gives you better control and keeps your hand steady. The brush can deposit just the right amount of formula regardless of whether it's a thin stroke, wings or cat-eye that you're drawing. The highly-pigmented eyeliner is also perfect for tightlining. 

However, some users felt that the formula smudged and wore off. The tip felt too flexible for some. Overall, many users loved the eyeliner, especially its brush, which made it easy for beginners. Making a thin line over the lash line and getting a perfectly thick cat-eye had never been this easy for them.  

When getting perfectly symmetrical wings is challenging, you should try these dual-ended waterproof eyeliner pens. Each has an eight millimeter wing stamp that can get you the mischievous kitten eye wing look even if you have hooded eyes. Plus, the bottle is sizeable, and that makes holding on to it and applying relatively easy. 

However, some buyers received dried out pens, and some experienced them drying out after a few uses. But overall, for many users these pens made it easier to make wings that lasted for a long time. If you're new to the winged look, these pens will be a perfect choice.