mybest
Protein ShakersHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Protein ShakersHelping You Find the Best
8 Best Protein Shakers  [Tested and Reviewed]

8 Best Protein Shakers [Tested and Reviewed]

Protein shakers are the easiest way to mix your favorite protein or workout drinks and take them on the go. But with many types and materials available, from plastic ones with mixing balls to stainless steel and even electric designs, you might be unsure which is best if you’re buying for the first time.  

That’s why we collected 8 top-selling protein shakers from VOLTRX, PROMiXX, Trove Brands, and other popular manufacturers and thoroughly examined them based on four points. Then, we ranked them in order to find the best. 


At mybest, we think the best protein shaker is one that offers quick nutrition replenishment, doesn't leak, and requires minimal cleaning effort. In this article, we will also explain the proper way to choose a protein shaker, as found through our testing process, so you can use this as a reference when purchasing. 

Last updated 03/22/2024
John Lindala
Expert
John Lindala

John Lindala is a biomechanics specialist with a master's degree in Performance Enhancement and Injury Prevention. During his 18+ year fitness career, John has trained professional athletes for championship teams and special populations of all ability levels. Additionally, he has published his book, Hip Neutral. His work has sold internationally and helped thousands of clients relieve and restructure their hip complex. He has worked as an expert consultant for the Nautilus Brand, ACE Fitness, and various tech-based fitness startups. He has published articles with multiple organizations creating a global fitness influence.

John Lindala's Profile
…Continue reading
Yui Maeno
Guide
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

In addition to her work at mybest, Yui Maeno is active as a personal trainer and powerlifter. Previously, she worked at a major fitness club and was involved in various health-related activities, such as personal training and teaching classes. Currently, at mybest, she is in charge of fitness products, such as protein powders and exercise balls.

Yui Maeno's Profile
…Continue reading

How We Tested the Products

We gathered the 8 bestselling Protein Shakers and put them through rigorous testing.
  1. Ease of Shaking

    1
    Ease of Shaking

    In this category, we set the top-level standard for mixability as a shaker that blends quickly and easily without using much force. We tested each product using the following methods.

  2. Drinkability

    2
    Drinkability

    In this category, we set the top-level standard for easy-to-drink as a shaker that is smooth in texture and easy for users to drink the contents in a gulp. We tested each product using the following methods.

  3. Leak Resistance

    3
    Leak Resistance

    We set the standard for a highly leakproof protein shaker as a product that does not leak, even when prepared as a liquid and placed in a bag. We tested each product in the following way based on this criterion.

  4. Ease of Cleaning

    4
    Ease of Cleaning

    To be an easily washable protein shaker, we set the standard as a product that reduces protein buildup in the grooves and is easy to clean by hand, even at the bottom. Based on this, we evaluated various products as outlined below, with which users have been greatly satisfied.

All product tests
were conducted in-house at mybest

Company Facility
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.The mybest team independently conducts its own tests to rank products.

Table of Contents

Why a Shaker Is Essential for Protein Drinkers

Why a Shaker Is Essential for Protein Drinkers

You might think that buying a protein shaker is only necessary for serious gym goers who drink protein or workout supplements religiously. But that couldn’t be further from the truth! Here’s why:


Compared to ordinary bottles, protein shakers are designed to make mixing and enjoying your workout drinks much easier, with features such as: 


  • A spout for easy drinking on the go

  • Clear markings to show the amount of liquid inside

  • A large opening for easy pouring of protein powder

  • A mixer or ball to ensure powder mixes quickly and smoothly 


Protein shakers are available in various shapes and capacities in all price ranges, and it's not necessarily true that the more expensive it is, the better it is. In this guide, we recommend products regardless of price, so make sure to check out all of them before deciding.

John Lindala
John Lindala

If you regularly consume protein or workout drinks, you should have a protein shaker at the ready. For use during workouts, a 24-ounce capacity is ideal to keep you hydrated.

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

Many people think that plastic sports or water bottles can be used as a substitute for protein shakers. But these can be inconvenient and aren't designed for the task, as it’s difficult to put the powder in and check the amount of water. For hassle-free use before, during, or after your workout, protein shakers are a must-buy for those who don't yet own one. 

How to Prevent Clumping: Add Liquid First, Then Powder

How to Prevent Clumping: Add Liquid First, Then Powder

While shakers are designed to mix protein powders with liquids quickly and easily, how you prepare them affects how smoothly they blend. The method also varies between manual and electric versions, so be sure to follow the right steps:


For Manual Shakers:

1. Add the desired amount of liquid, such as water or milk

2. Put in the protein powder

3. While pressing the lid with your index finger, shake vertically


For Electric Shakers:

1. Put in the protein powder

2. Add the desired amount of liquid, such as water or milk

3. Press the power button

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

When using an electric mixer, if you put the liquid in first, the powder can clump in the center and not mix properly. To dissolve the powder quickly, make sure to add it in the correct order.

How to Choose Protein Shakers

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best Protein Shakers.

1

The Key Points for Easy Mixing Are Weight, Shaker Shape, and Visibility

By following these key points, you’ll be able to quickly prepare your protein or workout drinks without too much vigorous shaking and strain. 

Shakers Weighing Less Than 14 Ounces Make Blending Easy, Even After a Hard Workout

Shakers Weighing Less Than 14 Ounces Make Blending Easy, Even After a Hard Workout

Protein shakers are sold in various weights, but those less than 14 ounces are easiest to use. The last thing you want after a grueling workout is more arm fatigue!


During our tests, shakers weighing under 14 ounces received positive feedback from testers, such as “Because it's lightweight, it was easy to shake and didn’t slip from my hand," and "Even with minimal force, I could grip it and mix the contents well."

 
For protein shakers over 14 ounces, more than half of our testers felt they were heavy to shake, and some noted feeling strain in their wrists.

Curved Shakers Give a Firm Grip When Force Is Applied, Making It Easier to Mix Thoroughly

Curved Shakers Give a Firm Grip When Force Is Applied, Making It Easier to Mix Thoroughly

Shakers with indents or curves allow you to get a much firmer grip, making it easier to mix the contents inside.

 
We received a lot of positive feedback about this from our testing panel, who said, "The curve of the bottle fits the shape of the hand perfectly, so it was less likely to slip." As for flat-sided shakers, testers noted that they had to put in a lot of effort to stop it from slipping out of their hands. So if there is no curve, it's difficult to grip with all five fingers, making it hard to exert force and blend smoothly. 

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

After checking the shaker’s weight, make sure to check its shape. Also, those who sweat a lot after working out should pay attention to the surface design. 


Protein shakers come in two finishes: smooth and textured. During our tests, we found that those with a slightly rougher finish were more slippery, so if you tend to have sweaty hands, you might be better off choosing one with a smooth finish.

Choose Transparent Bottles to Add the Right Amount of Water and Check on Your Shake

Choose Transparent Bottles to Add the Right Amount of Water and Check on Your Shake

Transparent shakers are better for two reasons: 1) You can see exactly how much liquid you’re adding to ensure your shake won’t be too watery or too thick. 2) You can check whether your shake is ready to drink or if there are still a few lumps to dissolve.


If the bottle isn't transparent, it's the opposite: you won’t know when the contents are fully mixed, so you'll need to keep opening the lid to check. Some non-transparent shakers even lack scale markings on the inside of the bottle. For ease and convenience, it’s best to choose a transparent shaker.

2

Check the Lid and Spout for Stress-Free Drinking

After mixability, the next important thing is drinkability. We’ll introduce the features that make gulping down your shake easier when you’re short on time before or after a workout.

With a Capped Lid That’s Hard to Lower, You Can Gulp Down What’s Inside

With a Capped Lid That’s Hard to Lower, You Can Gulp Down What’s Inside

Protein shaker lids come in two types: flip-top caps and sliding types that cover with a flat lid. Without a doubt, it's better to choose a cap type with a wider opening


Among the cap types, we recommend those where the cap doesn't drop when you tilt the bottle. They generally make drinking your shake easier and the lid also won't hit your nose, allowing you to tilt the bottle freely. 


The drawback of sliding lids is that they often hit your upper lip as you tilt the container back and drink. This narrows the opening of your shaker, so they’re not suitable if you want to drink the contents in one go.


We have indicated which type of lid and non-dropping cap each product in our ranking has, so be sure to check them out.

Curved Drinking Spouts Make for Smooth Sips and Easy Drinking

Curved Drinking Spouts Make for Smooth Sips and Easy Drinking

Protein shakers have different styles of drinking spouts, too, with some curved and others straight. The benefit of a curved spout is that it fits the shape of the lips, providing a smooth and generally more comfortable drinking experience. A straight spout, meanwhile, isn’t as comfortable and often pokes into your lips.

 
Especially if you’re new to protein shakes or workout drinks, a shaker that's easy to drink from will make a world of difference. 

3

Look for Locking Caps to Reduce the Risk of Leaks

Look for Locking Caps to Reduce the Risk of Leaks

If you choose a shaker with a cap, it’s best to find one that closes with an audible click since these designs are less likely to leak


When we checked the leak-resistance of each product, caps that clicked when you closed them did not leak, while those that did not make a sound did the opposite and spilled the contents. 


You can see which products did or didn’t make a clicking sound when closed in our ranking. If you take your shake or drink pre-mixed in your gym bag or on the go, make sure to go for one that locks firmly with a click.

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

In our tests, bottles with a screw-cap closure or sliding cap did not leak. While these don’t offer the same easy drinkability, they are a good choice if you prioritize leak resistance.

4

Focus on Easy-Clean Features Like Wider Openings

Even if you regularly use a dishwasher, a quick pre-wash in the sink means cleaner dishes overall. Here, we share which features make it easiest to clean out your protein shaker by hand. 

Shakers With Wide Openings Allow You to Get Right to the Base

Shakers With Wide Openings Allow You to Get Right to the Base

Shakers with wider openings are much easier to clean, as you can get your dish sponge all the way to the bottom.

 
If the opening is narrow, it's difficult to get your hand inside, requiring extra time for pre-washing or the use of a bottle brush. Plus, it’s harder to remove clumps of shake that often accumulate at the base.

 
To keep your protein shaker clean and hygienic, remember to check whether it has a wide enough opening.

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

Protein powder tends to settle at the bottom of the container even after you finish drinking, and there's a chance that it might not come off just by washing it in a dishwasher. Therefore, it's good to get into the habit of thoroughly pre-rinsing with water before putting it in the dishwasher.

Lids With Removable Rubber Seals Are Easier to Maintain

Lids With Removable Rubber Seals Are Easier to Maintain

Finally, we recommend looking for protein shakers with removable rubber seals on the underside of the lid, as they can make cleaning easier.

 
Since they’re removable, you can take off the seal and wash each part individually, keeping things sparkling clean. Having a rubber seal can also help prevent dirt from gathering in the grooves of a screw-top lid, which is a definite plus. Products without this seal accumulate dirt much more easily, and it may not even come off completely in the dishwasher.


To keep your shaker clean and odor-free for long-term use, always choose ones with removable rubber seals.

Yui Maeno
Personal Trainer; Head of Fitness & Baby at mybest
Yui Maeno

A non-removable rubber seal may be inconvenient if it's not heat resistant, as it cannot be placed in the dishwasher and must be hand-washed.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

8 Best Protein Shakers Ranking

Here are the best Protein Shakers we found after testing them. We ranked them after weighting each of our testing specs.
Recommended
Price Performance
Sort
Filter
Leakproof
Dishwasher Safe
Products
Image
mybest Score
Click to purchase
Key features
Main Score
Details
Ease of Shaking
Drinkability
Leak Prevention
Ease of Cleaning
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Type of Lid
Bottle Texture
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
Diameter of the Bottle Base
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Operation Mode
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the Bottle
Included Accessories
Weight of the Main Body
Width of the Main Body
Depth of the Main Body
Height of the Main Body
1

VOLTRX

Electric Protein Shakervt001-black

VOLTRX	 Electric Protein Shaker 1
4.79

mybest's Top Choice: A Speedy Electric Shaker That Fits Perfectly in Your Hand

4.50
5.00
5.00
4.50

Cap type

Smooth

3.34 in.

2.59 in.

Electric

TRITAN Copolyester

Warranty, Product brochure,USB cable

9.4 oz.

‎3.54 in.

3.54 in.

9.64 in.

2

PROMiXX

Electric Shaker Bottles ORIGINAL

PROMiXX Electric Shaker Bottles ORIGINAL 1
4.60

Creates Smooth Shakes and Is Easy to Maintain

4.25
5.00
5.00
3.75

Cap type

Smooth

2.83 in.

2.75 in.

Electric

ABS

Instruction Manual

10.58 oz.

3.34 in.

3.34 in.

9.25 in.

3

PROMiXX

Classic Shaker Bottles PURSUIT

PROMiXX Classic Shaker Bottles PURSUIT 1
4.52

Lightweight and Effortless to Use Even After a Workout

4.30
5.00
5.00
3.30

Cap type

Smooth

2.83 in.

2.36 in.

Manual

ECOZEN

Leakproof Sports Lid with Carry Loop,Soft-edge domed Snap-fit Agitator

5.07 oz.

3.93 in.

3.93 in.

7.87 in.

4

ShakeSphere

Tumbler VIEW Protein Shaker Bottle

ShakeSphere Tumbler VIEW Protein Shaker Bottle 1
4.48

Quick to Mix but Tricky to Drink From

4.30
4.25
5.00
4.34

Slide type

Rough

3.50 in.

1.77 in.

Manual

Plastics and silicone

5.74 oz.

3.93 in.

3.93 in.

7.87 in.

5

Newell Brands

contigoShake & Go® Fit 28oz, Shaker Bottle2076883

Newell Brands Shake & Go® Fit 28oz, Shaker Bottle 1
4.45

Fits in Car Cup Holders but Needs Careful Cleaning

4.15
4.50
5.00
3.88

Cap type

Rough、Smooth

3.14 in.

2.87 in.

Manual

BPA-free plastic

Shaker ball

6.91 oz.

4.33 in.

4.33 in.

9.44 in.

6

HELIMIX

2.0 Vortex Shaker Bottle

HELIMIX 2.0 Vortex Shaker Bottle 1
4.40

Good Spill Resistance but Thick and Hard to Grip

4.20
4.25
5.00
4.00

Cap type

Smooth

3.46 in.

2.75 in.

Manual

Copolyester BPA/BPS-free Plastic

6.73 oz.

4.13 in.

4.13 in.

9.05 in.

7

Trove Brands

BlenderBottleRadian™ Insulated Stainless Steel

Trove Brands Radian™ Insulated Stainless Steel 1
4.19

An Insulated Steel Option With Pros and Cons

3.70
4.00
5.00
4.50

Cap type

Rough

3.03 in.

2.95 in.

Manual

Insulated Stainless Steel

Screw ball

14.56 oz.

4.52 in.

4.52 in.

10.03 in.

8

ZONGYM

Electric Protein Shaker Bottle

ZONGYM Electric Protein Shaker Bottle 1
3.84

Easy to Grip and Fast Mixing but Not Leakproof

4.40
5.00
3.00
3.88

Cap type

Smooth

3.26 in.

2.59 in.

Electric

Tritan copolyester

USB cable

10.61 oz.

4.33 in.

4.33 in.

10.62 in.

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1
Top Choice Protein Shakers
No.1 in Ease of Shaking
No.1 in Drinkability
No.1 in Leak Prevention
No.1 in Ease of Cleaning

VOLTRX
Electric Protein Shakervt001-black

mybest Score
4.79
Ease of Shaking
4.50
Drinkability
5.00
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
4.50
View on Amazon
Electric Protein Shaker 1
Lowest price
$25.99
High Mid
Lowest price
$25.99
High Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.34 in.
Weight of the Main Body
9.4 oz.
Height of the Main Body
9.64 in.

mybest's Top Choice: A Speedy Electric Shaker That Fits Perfectly in Your Hand

What we loved

  • Easy mixing; lasts a month on one charge
  • Well-designed shape and drinking spout
  • No leaks even when thrown in a bag

What we didn't love

  • Nothing in particular.

The VOLTRX Electric Protein Shaker can be conveniently charged with a USB-C cord, lasting up to a month if used three times a week. 


This product received many positive comments for ease of use from our testers, regardless of gender, such as "Its shape fits easily in the hand, with no worry of it slipping," and "I could shake it firmly with using a lot of force."


Its well-designed spout is smooth and comfortable to drink from, and as the cap does not drop when the shaker is tilted, it's easy to gulp down the contents. Additionally, there's a removable rubber seal in the lid, making it a cinch to keep clean. 


But the best part is that our tests proved you can throw it in your backpack or gym bag, and the contents will not leak at all, even while moving around.


To prepare your protein or workout drinks with minimal effort both at home or on the go, and for stress-free clean up afterward, this is a best-buy protein shaker that’s super easy to use.

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.59 in.
Operation ModeElectric
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleTRITAN Copolyester
Included AccessoriesWarranty, Product brochure,USB cable
Width of the Main Body‎3.54 in.
Depth of the Main Body3.54 in.
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2
No.1 in Drinkability
No.1 in Leak Prevention

PROMiXX
Electric Shaker Bottles ORIGINAL

mybest Score
4.60
Ease of Shaking
4.25
Drinkability
5.00
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
3.75
Lowest price
$22.99
Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
2.83 in.
Weight of the Main Body
10.58 oz.
Height of the Main Body
9.25 in.

Creates Smooth Shakes and Is Easy to Maintain

What we loved

  • Comfortable and mess-free to drink from
  • Super easy to keep clean
  • Fully leakproof

What we didn't love

  • Heavier weight at the bottom made it trickier to shake
  • Battery-powered so could run out at any time

Another electric shaker, only this time battery-powered, PROMiXX’s ORIGINAL can be used straight out of the box with two AAA batteries. 


In the mixability review, many testers said that the cup-style shape was easy to grip. However, some felt that it was difficult to shake because all the weight was in the bottom of the container. To mix the contents evenly, it’s best to hold it at the top. 


The drinking spout is curved and comfortable, and the cap doesn't drop down when drinking, so you can tilt the bottle as much as you want. The parts are removable, and it even has a self-cleaning function, allowing you to keep it fresh and hygienic.  


Even after placing it upside down in a backpack and performing 30 leg raises, it didn't leak, so you can safely carry around a pre-made drink. This shaker is perfect for those who value ease of use and like the idea of hassle-free charging. Just remember, you may need to put a spare pair of batteries in your workout bag. 

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.75 in.
Operation ModeElectric
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleABS
Included AccessoriesInstruction Manual
Width of the Main Body3.34 in.
Depth of the Main Body3.34 in.
View all
No.3
No.1 in Drinkability
No.1 in Leak Prevention

PROMiXX
Classic Shaker Bottles PURSUIT

mybest Score
4.52
Ease of Shaking
4.30
Drinkability
5.00
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
3.30
Lowest price
$12.99
Low
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
2.83 in.
Weight of the Main Body
5.07 oz.
Height of the Main Body
7.87 in.

Lightweight and Effortless to Use Even After a Workout

What we loved

  • Lightweight with a sleek design
  • High-performance mixing with a unique agitator
  • Fully leakproof

What we didn't love

  • Wide container shape won’t suit those with smaller hands
  • Mixing ball must be removed and cleaned separately

The PURSUIT by PROMiXX is a classic shaker characterized by its integrated snap-fit agitator, which promises to be quieter and more effective than regular mixer balls.


Testers loved its lightweight design, which they could grab firmly with no need to exert force. It also has a carry hook. However, some testers with smaller hands felt the container was too wide and thus difficult to get a good hold on.

 
While the innovative mixing agitator creates a smooth shake, it needs to be removed every time for cleaning and could get lost. On the upside, our tests found this shaker to be enjoyable to drink from and fully leakproof. Overall, we recommend it for people with larger hands looking for something lightweight and thoughtfully designed. 

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.36 in.
Operation ModeManual
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleECOZEN
Included AccessoriesLeakproof Sports Lid with Carry Loop,Soft-edge domed Snap-fit Agitator
Width of the Main Body3.93 in.
Depth of the Main Body3.93 in.
View all
No.4
No.1 in Leak Prevention

ShakeSphere
Tumbler VIEW Protein Shaker Bottle

mybest Score
4.48
Ease of Shaking
4.30
Drinkability
4.25
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
4.34
Lowest price
$24.99
High Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Slide type
Bottle Texture
Rough
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.50 in.
Weight of the Main Body
5.74 oz.
Height of the Main Body
7.87 in.

Quick to Mix but Tricky to Drink From

What we loved

  • Quick mixing, even including soft fruit
  • Capsule shape is easy to hold and clean
  • No leaks

What we didn't love

  • Slippery outer coating
  • Straight spout isn’t comfortable
  • Lid design limits how much you can drink at once

ShakeSphere's VIEW tumbler gets its name from the unique capsule shape, claiming that the contents (even including soft fruit and peanut butter) can be mixed in 5 seconds. While it has a transparent viewing window for accurate measurements, it is small, so you won’t be able to fully see how well-mixed your shake is.

 
This shaker earned positive feedback for how firmly it could be held, but some testers felt the material was slippery, making them nervous to shake it. If your hands get sweaty after a workout, be sure to dry off before using this one.

 
As for upkeep, the wide mouth allows you to get your entire hand in for easy cleaning, and the ‘no corner’ capsule shape limits clumps getting stuck at the bottom. However, it is not dishwasher-safe.

 
The straight drinking spout isn’t as comfortable as curved styles. Also, the sliding lid hits the upper lip and narrows the opening, so it may be unsuitable if you like to quickly drink down your entire shake after a workout.

Diameter of the Bottle Base1.77 in.
Operation ModeManual
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottlePlastics and silicone
Included Accessories
Width of the Main Body3.93 in.
Depth of the Main Body3.93 in.
View all
No.5
No.1 in Leak Prevention

Newell Brands
contigoShake & Go® Fit 28oz, Shaker Bottle2076883

mybest Score
4.45
Ease of Shaking
4.15
Drinkability
4.50
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
3.88
Lowest price
$14.99
Low
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Rough、Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.14 in.
Weight of the Main Body
6.91 oz.
Height of the Main Body
9.44 in.

Fits in Car Cup Holders but Needs Careful Cleaning

What we loved

  • Fits in most car cup holders
  • Light and easy to shake
  • Leakproof

What we didn't love

  • Shaker material feels slippery
  • Requires extra cleaning steps

Contigo’s Shake & Go® Fit is designed to fit most car cup holders, which is ideal for those who drive to and from the gym.


With its simple design, tests found it to be lightweight and easy to shake, even when tired. But there were many negative comments too, such as, "The bottle is thick and made of slippery material, so you need to grip it hard.”

 
The drinking spout is straight, but since the cap doesn't fall, you can tilt the bottle and drink freely. Also, it aced our tests for leak-resistance.


However, the lack of a rubber seal means that dirt can easily accumulate in the grooves. The mixing ball will also need to be washed separately. A dishwasher alone may not remove all traces of shake, so we recommend thoroughly pre-washing it to keep it hygienic.

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.87 in.
Operation ModeManual
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleBPA-free plastic
Included AccessoriesShaker ball
Width of the Main Body4.33 in.
Depth of the Main Body4.33 in.
View all
No.6
No.1 in Leak Prevention

HELIMIX
2.0 Vortex Shaker Bottle

mybest Score
4.40
Ease of Shaking
4.20
Drinkability
4.25
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
4.00
Lowest price
$22.95
Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.46 in.
Weight of the Main Body
6.73 oz.
Height of the Main Body
9.05 in.

Good Spill Resistance but Thick and Hard to Grip

What we loved

  • Choice of 18 colors in odor-resistant plastic
  • Blends well without a mixing ball
  • Well-designed spill-proof cap

What we didn't love

  • Bottle is thick and difficult to grip
  • Straight spout can feel uncomfortable
  • Needs careful cleaning

HELIMIX's stylish Vortex shaker comes in 18 colors made with odor-resistant BPA/BPS-free plastic.

 
Unfortunately, the shape and thickness of the bottle received many unfavorable comments, with even male testers finding it uncomfortable to hold and shake. So if you have smaller hands, this may not be the best option.

 
This shaker did score well for its cap design and spill resistance, but the drinking spout is straight, which can feel like it's poking your lips. Also, while it manages to blend well without a separate mixing ball, this is another one without a rubber seal, so you’ll have to pre-rinse it carefully.

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.75 in.
Operation ModeManual
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleCopolyester BPA/BPS-free Plastic
Included Accessories
Width of the Main Body4.13 in.
Depth of the Main Body4.13 in.
View all
No.7
No.1 in Leak Prevention
No.1 in Ease of Cleaning

Trove Brands
BlenderBottleRadian™ Insulated Stainless Steel

mybest Score
4.19
Ease of Shaking
3.70
Drinkability
4.00
Leak Prevention
5.00
Ease of Cleaning
4.50
Lowest price
$24.99
High Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Rough
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.03 in.
Weight of the Main Body
14.56 oz.
Height of the Main Body
10.03 in.

An Insulated Steel Option With Pros and Cons

What we loved

  • Vacuum insulated to keep drinks cool
  • Twist-on cap is very secure

What we didn't love

  • Heavy with a slippery surface
  • Dropping cap gets in the way while drinking
  • Only the lid is dishwasher-safe

An alternative to plastic, Trove Brands’ BlenderBottle Radian™ is made with double-wall vacuum-insulated stainless steel to keep your shakes cool.


While the steel design is a definite plus for hot days, it also makes this shaker heavier than most and the smooth surface is slippery. Testers found that ensuring a thorough mix required a lot of force. After a hard workout, this isn’t ideal. Another drawback is that while it does have capacity markers, you won’t be able to easily see how well your shake is mixed.


The drinking spout scored fairly well for comfort and functionality, but the dropping cap got in the way while tilting the bottle back, which could be annoying. Also, while it has a removal rubber seal, only the plastic top is dishwasher-safe and not the body.


With its insulation and extra-secure twist-on cap, this shaker is worth considering if you’re looking for something you can throw in a bag for all-day adventures.

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.95 in.
Operation ModeManual
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleInsulated Stainless Steel
Included AccessoriesScrew ball
Width of the Main Body4.52 in.
Depth of the Main Body4.52 in.
View all
No.8
No.1 in Drinkability

ZONGYM
Electric Protein Shaker Bottle

mybest Score
3.84
Ease of Shaking
4.40
Drinkability
5.00
Leak Prevention
3.00
Ease of Cleaning
3.88
Lowest price
$25.99
High Mid
Curved Bottle
Stable Cap
Curved Spout
Locking Sound
Rounded Bottle Shape
Bottle Shape with a Central Indentation
Type of Lid
Cap type
Bottle Texture
Smooth
Bottle Transparent
Diameter of the Bottle Opening
3.26 in.
Weight of the Main Body
10.61 oz.
Height of the Main Body
10.62 in.

Easy to Grip and Fast Mixing but Not Leakproof

What we loved

  • Great mixing in a user-friendly design
  • Comfortable to drink from with no annoying drop caps

What we didn't love

  • Not leak-resistant
  • Non-removable rubber seal requires extra cleaning

ONGYM's USB electric shaker promises to offer 14 uses with just a two-hour charge.


Thanks to its slim design and high-capacity battery, this product received excellent feedback in the mixability tests. Reviewers felt it fit well in the hand and the mixer button was easy to press with one finger, offering a quick and easy way to mix your post-workout shakes when energy is low.


Other positive design features are its comfortable curved drinking spout and non-dropping cap, allowing you to gulp down your shake hassle-free.


However, this shaker fell short in one of the most crucial tests: leak resistance. When thrown in a backpack and shaken around, liquid spilled out from the gap in the lid. So while this shaker does have some plus points, it’s only suitable if you consume your workout drink immediately and can’t be carried around. 

Diameter of the Bottle Base2.59 in.
Operation ModeElectric
Embossed Measurement Marks
Dishwasher Safe
Includes Metal Spring Ball
Includes Plastic Mixer
Material of the BottleTritan copolyester
Included AccessoriesUSB cable
Width of the Main Body4.33 in.
Depth of the Main Body4.33 in.
View all

How We Tested the Protein Shakers

Protein Shakers Evaluation

At mybest, we define the best protein shaker as one that offers quick nutrition replenishment, doesn't leak, and requires minimal cleaning effort.

 
To find the best products, we collected the top-selling protein shakers from popular manufacturers as well as the latest bestsellers on Amazon, Target, and other sites. 


  • Ease of Shaking

  • Drinkability

  • Leak Resistance

  • Ease of Cleaning

Products we tested

  1. HELIMIX2.0 Vortex Shaker Bottle
  2. Newell BrandscontigoShake & Go® Fit 28oz, Shaker Bottle2076883
  3. PROMiXXElectric Shaker Bottles ORIGINAL
  4. PROMiXXClassic Shaker Bottles PURSUIT
  5. ShakeSphereTumbler VIEW Protein Shaker Bottle
  6. Trove BrandsBlenderBottleRadian™ Insulated Stainless Steel
  7. VOLTRX Electric Protein Shakervt001-black
  8. ZONGYMElectric Protein Shaker Bottle
1

Ease of Shaking

Ease of Shaking

In this category, we set the top-level standard for mixability as a shaker that blends quickly and easily without using much force. We tested each product using the following methods.

Scoring Method

The testers shook the protein shakers and evaluated them, scoring the recommendation level of each product.

Test Conditions

  • 5 men and 5 women aged 20-40 who exercise regularly

  • Shake vertically 10 times while holding the lid with the index finger

  • Volume of water in the bottle: 240 ml 

What We Checked

  • Can it be mixed with only light force? 
2

Drinkability

Drinkability

In this category, we set the top-level standard for easy-to-drink as a shaker that is smooth in texture and easy for users to drink the contents in a gulp. We tested each product using the following methods.

Scoring Method

The testers checked each product and scored them based on points, turning these recommendations into a score for each product.

What We Checked

  • The shape of the drinking spout
  • The height of the drinking spout
  • Whether the lid closes when you drink up
3

Leak Resistance

Leak Resistance

We set the standard for a highly leakproof protein shaker as a product that does not leak, even when prepared as a liquid and placed in a bag. We tested each product in the following way based on this criterion.

Scoring Method

The testers checked each product and scored them based on points, turning these recommendations into a score for each product.

What We Checked

  • Put the protein shaker upside down in the bag, then do 30 leg lifts to see if the contents leak or not
4

Ease of Cleaning

Ease of Cleaning

To be an easily washable protein shaker, we set the standard as a product that reduces protein buildup in the grooves and is easy to clean by hand, even at the bottom. Based on this, we evaluated various products as outlined below, with which users have been greatly satisfied.

Scoring Method

The testers checked each product and scored them based on points, turning these recommendations into a score for each product.

What We Checked

  • The diameter of the bottle's opening
  • Whether there is a rubber seal on the underside of the bottle cap
  • If there is a groove on the drinking mouth cap
  • If there are not too many additional parts

Top 5 Protein Shakers

No. 1: VOLTRX Electric Protein Shakervt001-black

No. 2: PROMiXXElectric Shaker Bottles ORIGINAL

No. 3: PROMiXXClassic Shaker Bottles PURSUIT

No. 4: ShakeSphereTumbler VIEW Protein Shaker Bottle

No. 5: Newell BrandscontigoShake & Go® Fit 28oz, Shaker Bottle2076883

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Protein Shakers

Exercise Balls

10 Best

Tested and Reviewed

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.