10 Best Tomato Soups in 2023 (Chef-Reviewed)

Pros:

• Uses vine-ripened tomatoes for a rich tomato flavor 
• Chunky, thick texture 
• Certified organic by the USDA 

Cons:

• Contains 16 grams of sugar per serving, which is quite high for some buyers 

What sets Amy's Organic's tomato soup apart is its natural, satisfying taste made from high quality, organic vine-ripened tomatoes. Instead of completely blending all the ingredients, the soup still contains chunks of tomatoes, which gives it a great texture and a homey taste.

A couple of reviewers found the taste overwhelmingly sweet. Nevertheless, the majority of reviewers complimented the soup for its comforting flavor and great chunky texture. According to many, this soup served as a nice base for chili, a quick pasta sauce, or for adding in other vegetables and meat. 

Pros:

• Comes in a condensed form, so you can easily adjust the consistency to your liking by adding water or milk
  
• Gluten-free and doesn't contain GMO ingredients
  
• Classic recipe, with onion, garlic and added vinegar for zing
  

• None

Dei Fratelli's tomato soup is made with simple ingredients like tomatoes, cane sugar, rice flour, and dehydrated onion. Since the soup is concentrated, you can dilute it with water or milk. You can also use this gluten-free condensed soup to make sauces!

The review section is overwhelmingly positive, with many buyers enjoying the flavorful taste of this tomato soup. They liked the thick consistency, rich flavor and balanced saltiness, and said it tasted great with grilled cheese sandwiches.

Pros:

• The inclusion of basil brightens up the flavor 
• Has a smooth and creamy texture 
• Two servings per can
  

Cons:

• Some reviewers found it too sweet
  

This tomato soup includes basil for a fresh herbal twist. The savory flavor and thick texture make it a perfect choice to dip your grilled cheese sandwich in for a hearty winter lunch.

It's made without any artificial colors or flavors, too.

Many reviewers loved the smooth texture of the soup and further commented that the flavor combination of tomatoes and basil was spot on. Several say it's lower in acidity than other brands. Many enjoyed this soup with some crackers, and even use it as a base for stuffed peppers or slow-cooker meals. 

Pros:

• Has a flavorful taste with a hint of basil 
• Packed in a microwavable cup that you can drink from
  
• Olive oil and milk make for a creamy mouthfeel
  

• There are some reports complaining that it's difficult to open the lid 

Made with butternut squash, tomato purée, cream, and basil, Campbell's Well Yes!soup is creamy and rich with a hint of sweetness. It's packed in a to-go container. You don't even need a spoon, just sip and enjoy this nutritious tomato soup! 

The major complaint some buyers had about this product was that the lid was tough to open. Nevertheless, many reviewers loved the convenience and portability of the soup. They praised the flavorful and creamy taste and the thick texture of the soup. 

Pros:

• Convenient microwavable bowl for easy preparation 
• Contains cream and butter for a creamy taste 
• Comes with tomato basil seasoned croutons and Parmesan cheese crisps 

• It's said the portion size is small

This creamy tomato soup is made with ingredients such as tomato purée, cream, wheat flour, butter, and spices. It comes in a convenient microwavable bowl and is easy to prepare. There are two toppings, including tomato basil seasoned croutons and Parmesan cheese crisps, that you can add to the soup for some crunchy deliciousness! 

A few buyers thought the portion size was too small. Yet, most reviewers loved how rich, creamy, and tasty the soup was. They enjoyed the flavorful croutons and Parmesan cheese crisps and further mentioned that they stayed crunchy in the soup. The ease of preparation was another bonus point for buyers! 

Pros:

• Each serving provides only 10 grams of sugar, 410 milligrams of salt, and 70 calories
• Smooth texture 
• Simple flavor is easy to customize with your favorite ingredients
  
• 2.5 servings per can
  

Cons:

• Some reviewers wish it didn't contain high fructose corn syrup
  

If you're looking for a healthy canned soup that doesn't sacrifice any flavor, this Campbell's tomato soup might be a great choice. It's made with farm-grown tomatoes and has only 10 grams of sugar per serving. Each serving also contains only 70 calories.

Many reviewers said that the soup was basic and could be paired perfectly with sandwiches or other main dishes. Another plus point for buyers was that it's lower in sodium than regular canned tomato soups. They also said that since the soup was not heavily flavored, they could add extra spices according to their preferences. 

Pros:

• Tomato soup is rich and creamy thanks to ingredients like chicken broth, garlic, onion, and tomato purée
• Penne rigate pasta gives the soup more texture
  
• Two servings per can
  

Cons:

• If you prefer al dente pasta, you might find the penne too soft
  

Progresso's creamy tomato soup is made with tomato purée, chicken broth, tomatoes, garlic, onion, and other spices for a rich flavor. It includes penne rigate pasta to add more texture to the soup and is free from artificial additives.

Many reviewers commented that the soup was creamy, scrumptious, and filling. They liked to add some cheese like Parmesan or mozzarella on top. Some even add in ground beef or fried chicken!

Pros:

• Combines vine-ripened tomatoes, roasted red bell peppers, milk, roasted garlic, and butter for a creamy, rich, and aromatic taste with a hint of sweetness 
• Contains only 330 milligrams of sodium per serving 
• Gluten-free and certified organic by the USDA 

Cons:

• 14 grams of sugar per serving are too much for some buyers

With milk, butter, slow-roasted red bell peppers, and spices such as roasted garlic and onion, this tomato soup has a creamy and complex taste. Moreover, compared to Pacific Foods' regular soup, this product has 50 percent less sodium, while providing your body with a lot of vitamins and protein. 

There were some concerns over the high sugar level of this soup. Still, most reviewers complimented the natural sweetness coming from red peppers in the soup. They loved the flavor and said the spices provided a kick to the soup. The thick, smooth texture was a plus for many buyers as well. 

Pros:

• Each serving has only 90 calories
• Easy to store and great for traveling 
• Fast to prepare as it only requires mixing with hot water 
• Makes four servings, one per packet
  

• Some buyers say the taste is bland
  
• Cannot add cold water and then microwave
  

With 90 calories per packet, Batchelors' tomato soup is a great low-calorie option for dieters. The packet is convenient to bring while traveling and is easy to use as well. You just need to mix it with hot water and after some stirring, a hearty soup will appear in front of you! 

A few buyers complained that the flavor was a bit bland. Nevertheless, the majority loved how easy it was to make tomato soup with this mix. They also appreciated that it's easy to store and further mentioned that the texture of the soup was quite thick. 

Pros:

• The addition of rice makes the soup more filling 
• Chunky texture
• 2.5 servings per can
  

Cons:

• Not a gluten-free option even though the base is rice
  

If you're looking for a soup that's fulfilling, Campbell's tomato rice soup might be a great choice. It's made from farm-grown tomatoes and rice to produce a healthy, homey flavor. The soup is condensed, so you can add water or milk. To make it even more tasty, you can try adding some slices of avocado. 

Many reviewers loved the simple flavor of the soup and suggested that it could be paired with a grilled cheese sandwich, a refreshing salad or used as a sauce in meals like stuffed peppers.