5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
Looking for a safe and soothing binky for your baby without dangerous substances like phthalates and PVC? Natural pacifiers are the way to go, and many parents are seeing their benefits.
We've done our research and compiled a list of the best natural pacifiers, such as Natursutten's pacifier made seamlessly with natural rubber. There are five more parent and baby-approved pacifiers to choose from, plus a buying guide to get you started on the path of no-plastic baby soothers.
Quick List - Top Natural Pacifiers
Dr. Regina Hardin is a pediatrician and the founder of MyKidzMD Pediatrics. She enjoys spending her day caring for newborns and helping parents handle their most common pediatric concerns. Dr. Hardin says: "Parents are often afraid of routine newborn care for fear of hurting the baby or possibly doing something wrong. My mission is to empower parents with education and by giving them the tools to keep children healthy, happy, and thriving."
mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
Table of Contents
- Why You Can Trust Us
- Why Get a Natural Pacifier?
- Decide if Your Baby Needs a Pacifier
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What's the best way to clean a natural pacifier?
- A Pediatrician's Favorite Natural Pacifier
- Try These Baby Essentials Parents Love
- Buying Guide Reviewed by Board-Certified Pediatrician Dr. Regina Hardin
Why You Can Trust Us
Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.
Why Get a Natural Pacifier?
The main advantage of getting a natural pacifier is the lack of potentially harmful chemicals and components such as phthalates, parabens, and PVC (polyvinyl chloride).
They're also produced in more eco-friendly ways using sustainable resources. An environmentally-friendly option can go a long way, given a pacifier's short life span. Experts advise replacing pacifiers every two months. Since you'll replace it anyway, one that won't have as much impact on the environment could help!
Other advantages include them being softer and more like the feel of a breast.
Natural rubber is not only used in pacifiers but also in medical devices, gloves used in doctor's offices, balloons, and many toys. Although the risk is not zero, natural rubber pacifiers are less allergenic and don't have any artificial colorants. Biodegradability is a definite plus!
How to Choose Natural Pacifiers
If you're new to the idea of using a natural pacifier for your baby, the following buying guide should help explain why this is a parent-approved alternative.
Be Aware That Rubber Comes From Latex
Natural pacifiers are made from rubber. Rubber trees are an eco-friendly and sustainable resource because they can be tapped up to 35 years for material while serving as a habitat for wildlife. In addition, rubber pacifiers are soft, and it has been found that babies like the feel of this material.
However, the rubber is made from latex, which is the sap-like component of rubber trees. Therefore, if your child is allergic to latex, this material should be avoided.
Some natural rubber pacifiers have had the latex proteins that trigger allergies removed during production. Still, experts advise those with diagnosed latex allergies to proceed with caution when choosing such "latex-free" products.
The FDA has recommended that manufacturers stop using the term since it is too vague to be helpful. There is no accurate test to determine if a natural rubber has zero allergy-causing latex proteins. In addition, the production or packaging process could still result in contamination.
Latex exposure over time is a factor in the development of an allergy to it, so if you are concerned about this, it's best to avoid natural rubber pacifiers altogether.
What might an allergy to latex look like? Symptoms could include itching, redness, hives, rash, runny nose, cough, wheezing, swelling, or trouble breathing. The reaction or reactions can be mild to severe.
Parents, siblings, or close family members who have latex or food allergies should first discuss the use of natural rubber pacifiers with the pediatrician.
Pick Between an Orthodontic and a Round Pacifier
Pacifiers have three key parts: the nipple, which should be soft and comfortable for the baby to suckle on; the shield, to stop the nipple from becoming a choking hazard; and the ring, to make it easy to remove and hold the pacifier.
From there, you have two main designs or pacifier shapes: orthodontic and round pacifiers. Orthodontic pacifiers have a flat nipple on the bottom side and a rounded area at the top. The design complements the baby’s flat tongue surface and curved roof area of the mouth.
Meanwhile, round pacifiers have nipples that are round throughout, much like a baby bottle nipple, and it mimics a female’s nipple. You might need to mix and match a particular nipple type to your baby’s preference, so we recommend trying out different shapes until you find one that sticks.
Orthodontic pacifiers help lessen the pressure on the baby's gums and developing teeth, which helps with issues like malalignment, including overbite and underbite.
However, whether the choice is orthodontic or traditional round shape, the length of use can play a factor, as both types can be problematic if used for long periods of time.
Check the Size Based on Age
Pacifiers are often created in different sizes depending on a baby’s age or developmental stage. The pacifier size is a crucial consideration to ensure that it isn’t too big or too small for their mouth, both for optimal soothing and to minimize choking risks.
You can find pacifiers for made for babies from newborn to three or six months old and older. We recommend checking the product dimensions carefully as manufacturers don’t follow a standard regarding the sizing of pacifiers and the nipples.
Double-Check the Design for Safety
Natural pacifiers often feature a seamless design, wherein the rubber is molded out of one piece with a shield that is at least an inch and a half wide so that your baby can’t put the entire piece into their mouth. A multi-piece pacifier should be securely fastened without the risk of the nipple accidentally dislodging and becoming a choking hazard.
We recommend pacifiers with holes in the shield to allow for air circulation. A baby’s saliva can quickly accumulate behind the shield, and the ventilation helps reduce rashes or irritation.
We advise periodically cleaning it when needed with soap and warm water to prevent dirt and bacteria buildup. Some are dishwasher-safe, so give the product description a look-through regarding this.
5 Best Natural Pacifiers Ranking
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Ecopiggy Ecopacifier | | Sustainably-Sourced Natural Rubber Binky | |
2 | Sophie La Girafe Ergonomic Natural Rubber Pacifier | | Eco-Friendly Pacifier With an Ergonomic Design | |
3 | Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifier | | A Pacifier for Easy Transitioning | |
4 | Natursutten Butterfly Pacifier｜2 pack | | Natural Rubber Pacifier With a Specially-Designed Shield | |
5 | Bibs Baby Pacifier｜2 pack | | Pacifiers With Natural Rubber Nipples Offered in Different Colors |
Sustainably-Sourced Natural Rubber Binky
This pacifier’s shield might seem large, but it does a great job of protecting the baby from choking hazards while mimicking natural nursing. It’s a one-piece construction made with sustainably sourced rubber from the Hevea brasiliensis rubber tree. The product also doesn’t contain any chemical softeners or colorants.
A few parents noted that the product came in inconsistent sizing, and found the nipple or the shield was too big for their babies. Meanwhile, many others had no complaints about the pacifier and said it was a hit with their babies, especially picky ones. They also said this didn’t cause nipple confusion for breastfeeding moms.
Eco-Friendly Pacifier With an Ergonomic Design
This pacifier comes from natural rubber and is sent in recyclable cardboard packaging, making it eco-friendly too. It is colored with vegan, food-grade dye. The one-piece, seamless design means easy cleaning and more hygienic soothing.
The pacifier is also curved, so it sits naturally on a baby's jaw while the top curve allows for enough space for the nose. The manufacturer offers up to a one-year warranty against any defects. To clean, you can wash the pacifier with warm or hot water and mild liquid soap.
A Pacifier for Easy Transitioning
This pacifier is cherry-shaped, making it easy to switch a baby from feeding to soothing. This is specially catered to bottle-fed babies as the nipple shape mimics most bottle nipples. The product conforms to safety standards and the packaging is made from sustainably-harvested trees.
A few parents complained that the nipple was on the harder side, making it difficult to get their babies to like the pacifier. Some also said that the size was smaller than expected. Meanwhile, many reviewers highly recommended them because they’re shaped perfectly and can withstand chewing from teething babies.
Natural Rubber Pacifier With a Specially-Designed Shield
This one-piece pacifier is designed for comfortable sucking thanks to the butterfly-shaped shield with a curve at the top to fit around your baby’s nose. It’s made with natural rubber without potentially harmful components such as chemical softeners or artificial coloring.
A few reviewers said that the pacifier might be too large for newborns, while others shared getting your baby to latch to it might be hit or miss. Still, many parents confirmed that the product is well-made and especially liked how breastfed babies took to the pacifier quickly. They liked the safe and sustainable option for a binky.
Pacifiers With Natural Rubber Nipples Offered in Different Colors
If you're looking for something with a bit of color, check this one out. The nipple is made with latex rubber and shaped to mimic the real thing. The shield comes in a myriad of color choices so you can choose your favorite, or your toddler can choose the one they like!
A few parents complained that the nipple expands with continued use, which may cause babies to dislike it. Some also said that the sizing was a hit and miss. Meanwhile, many others shared this was one of the best binkies that their babies would accept. Reviewers noted that it’s lightweight and the nipple is very soft.
Decide if Your Baby Needs a Pacifier
You might be wondering if babies need a pacifier at all, as some parents swear by it while others consider it detrimental to a child’s development.
Pacifiers were created to calm and soothe babies through the sucking motion mimicking breast or bottle feeding. Some studies have shown that pacifiers may help reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), which happens during deep sleep. Pacifiers also mean babies don’t suck their fingers or items they come into contact with.
On the downside, pacifiers have been found to increase the risk of dental problems. There is also the chance of the child losing interest in breastfeeding after being too accustomed to a pacifier. Therefore, going the pacifier route depends solely on the parent and what they deem fit for their child.
Other reasons to consider using a pacifier might include easing ear discomfort caused by cabin pressure changes when flying on an airplane, helping to soothe your baby through painful procedures, easing the process of falling asleep and settling down for your baby. Of note, not all babies will need or accept a pacifier.
Frequently Asked Questions
If you have questions about caring for your baby's natural pacifier, check out Dr. Regina's input below!
What's the best way to clean a natural pacifier?
Dr. Hardin says, "The best way to clean a natural rubber pacifier and to ensure adequate shelf life is to boil it initially for five minutes when you receive it. Allow it to cool down and dry on a clean towel.
For subsequent cleanings, using warm water and baby-safe dish soap is sufficient. Remember to replace your baby's pacifier every six to eight weeks."
A Pediatrician's Favorite Natural Pacifier
In addition to her advice in our buying Guide, Dr. Hardin was also kind enough to recommend her favorite natural pacifier.
Try These Baby Essentials Parents Love
You might be interested in adding these must-have items for your nursery to make parenting and child-rearing more convenient, efficient, hygienic, and safe for your baby.
Buying Guide Reviewed by Board-Certified Pediatrician Dr. Regina Hardin
This expert reviewed the contents of the buying guide for accuracy and provided factual corrections when necessary. They did not participate in the product selection process, nor are they affiliated with any of our choices unless explicitly stated so.
Top 5 Natural Pacifiers
No. 1: Ecopiggy｜Ecopacifier
No. 2: Sophie La Girafe｜Ergonomic Natural Rubber Pacifier
No. 3: Hevea｜Natural Rubber Pacifier
No. 4: Natursutten｜Butterfly Pacifier｜2 pack
No. 5: Bibs｜Baby Pacifier｜2 pack
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Most ViewedFeatured Rankings Similar to Baby supplies
Search by category
Health
Body care products, Health accessories, Health foods and supplementsBeauty
Blushes, Bronzers, CleansersHome goods
Bath supplies, Ceremonial occasion supplies, Cleaning suppliesHome electronics
Air conditioners and coolers, AV accessories, Blenders and food processorsPC
Computer supplies, Desktop computers, TabletsCamera
Camera bags and backpacks, Camera supplies, Digital single lens camerasFood and drinks
Jams and Jellies, Alcohol, BreadsKitchen
Coffee and tea products, Cooking utensils, CupsFashion
Footwear products, Men's shoes, SandalsAccessories
Wristwatches, Accessories and jewelry, Umbrellas and parasolsKids and baby
Baby carriers, Baby food, Baby formulaInterior
Beds, Beds and bedding, ChairsHobbies
Aromatherapy products, Art supplies, Arts and collectiblesOutdoor
Barbecue grills and fire pits, Camping beds and cots, Camping gearHome, garden, and tools
Agricultural materials and gardening supplies, Exterior and garden furniture, Materials and repairing agentsSports and fitness
Sports shoes, Surfing supplies, Badminton suppliesPets
Bird and small animal supplies, Cat Supplies, Dog SuppliesMedia
Books and magazines, CD, Children's books, picture books and illustrated encyclopediasGames
Gaming accessories, Nintendo Switch games, PC gamesApps
Business apps, Cooking apps, Dating appsAutomotive
Car accessories, Car navigation systemsGifts
Christmas gifts, Father's Day gifts, Gifts for childrenMobile devices
Mobile phone and smartphone accessories, Wearable devices and smart watches