mybest
CondimentsHelping You Find the Best
mybest
CondimentsHelping You Find the Best
  • 25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More) 1
  • 25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More) 2
  • 25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More) 3
  • 25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More) 4
  • 25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More) 5

25 Best Tried and True Japanese Black Vinegars in 2022 (Sakamoto Brewing, Melodian, and More)

Black vinegar is popular as a diet and health supplement, and it also makes a delicious, refreshing drink! Of course it has other culinary uses too, so why not pick some up? But, which one is the best? Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites such as Amazon, Rakuten, and Yahoo! Shopping for the best black vinegars available online. We then picked out the most popular products and tested them.


We focused on drinking taste for this verification. You may be using black vinegar for health reasons, but you still want it to taste good!

We then ranked the products and put what we learned into a buying guide to help you choose the best Japanese black vinegars available online.


Last updated 09/26/2023

Quick List - Top Japanese Black Vinegars

1

Yakult

Black Vinegar Drink6 pack
Black Vinegar Drink

mybest's Top Choice! A Delicious Plum Wine Taste That's Good for Digestion, Too!

2

Sakamoto Brewing

Black Vinegar and Red Grape3-pack
Black Vinegar and Red Grape

Deliciously Versatile! It Tastes Just Like Grape Juice!

3

Melodian

Healthy Black Vinegar24-pack
Healthy Black Vinegar

A Mild Apple Flavor That's Great for Kids and Dieters on the Go

4

Kisaichi Brewing

Pure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink
Pure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink

The Best Brown Rice Vinegar We Tasted

5

Mizkan

Yogurt Black Vinegar
Yogurt Black Vinegar

A Unique Flavor for Those Who Want Something Different

mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

Why Drink Black Vinegar?

Black vinegar is aged and fermented vinegar. It's popular in cooking, especially in China, but today we're looking at kurosu with a focus on ones you can drink. In Japan, kurosu (the Japanese word for "black vinegar") is made primarily from raw brown rice or semi-polished white rice, sometimes with barley malt added.

Black Vinegar is Used as a Weight Control Supplement

Black Vinegar is Used as a Weight Control Supplement

Black vinegar is full of amino acids and citric acid. Citric acid works by converting fat into energy, helping to prevent it from accumulating in your body!


Amino acids activate the enzyme lipase and support fat-burning. It works more efficiently when consumed anywhere from 30 minutes to one hour before exercise.

It Can Reduce Blood Sugar and Blood Pressure Levels

It Can Reduce Blood Sugar and Blood Pressure Levels

The acetic acid in black vinegar can help those suffering from hyperglycemia and hypertension if one half ounce (15ml) is consumed daily.


A study by the Japanese Society of Clinical Nutrition found that consuming a half ounce of black vinegar containing 750mg of acetic acid after a meal reduced blood sugar 89% more than not drinking it.


According to the Japan Health and Nutrition Food Association, when this same amount of black vinegar was given to patients with high blood pressure for 10 weeks, their blood pressure showed a measurable drop.

How to Choose Japanese Black Vinegars

We have two points for you to think about when choosing the right black vinegar.

1

Choose between Diluted or Straight

Some vinegars are concentrated, so you can add water or another liquid yourself, and others are diluted so you can drink them right from the bottle. Here's how they're different.

Straight Black Vinegar is Versatile and Cheap

Straight Black Vinegar is Versatile and Cheap

These are the most versatile and the lowest cost in the long run. You can mix them with sparkling water or alcohol or use them in cooking. They tend to cost about half as much per drink as the pre-diluted types.


Not all of them are suited for cooking, however. If they contain honey or fruit those may interfere with the flavor of your dish, so check our rankings for recommend cooking vinegars.

Diluted Black Vinegar is Nutritious and Easy to Drink

Diluted Black Vinegar is Nutritious and Easy to Drink

These are easy to prepare and easy to drink. Many are blended with brown sugar or honey, and some come in individual drink boxes with straws.


Some also contain ingredients and supplements for health, such as polyphenols, oligosaccharides, or calcium. They can help to provide beneficial bacteria for gut health, too.

2

Brown Rice Black Vinegar is Best for Weight Loss

Brown Rice Black Vinegar is Best for Weight Loss

Most of these are made with semi-polished white rice, but the brown rice ones are better for dieters. Although all black vinegar contains amino acids for fat-burning, brown rice vinegars contain more. If you're drinking it for weight control or loss, choose brown rice.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

13 Best Japanese Black Vinegars Ranking

Here are the best Japanese Black Vinegars, ranked according to Compare the Best Japanese Black Vinegars (as of 11-04-2022). The products are ranked independently by mybest.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Yakult

Black Vinegar Drink6 pack

Yakult Black Vinegar Drink 1

mybest's Top Choice! A Delicious Plum Wine Taste That's Good for Digestion, Too!

2

Sakamoto Brewing

Black Vinegar and Red Grape3-pack

Sakamoto Brewing Black Vinegar and Red Grape 1

Deliciously Versatile! It Tastes Just Like Grape Juice!

3

Melodian

Healthy Black Vinegar24-pack

Melodian Healthy Black Vinegar 1

A Mild Apple Flavor That's Great for Kids and Dieters on the Go

4

Kisaichi Brewing

Pure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink

Kisaichi Brewing Pure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink 1

The Best Brown Rice Vinegar We Tasted

5

Mizkan

Yogurt Black Vinegar

Mizkan Yogurt Black Vinegar 1

A Unique Flavor for Those Who Want Something Different

6

Tamanoi

Honey Black Vinegar Diet

Tamanoi  Honey Black Vinegar Diet 1

Recommended for Health-Conscious People with a Sweet Tooth

7

Yamamori

Lactic Acid Bacteria Black Vinegar

Yamamori Lactic Acid Bacteria Black Vinegar 1

A Refreshing and Summery Citrus Drink

8

Ito Kampo Pharmaceuticals

Vinepple Pomegranate Black Vinegar Drink

Ito Kampo Pharmaceuticals Vinepple Pomegranate Black Vinegar Drink 1

A Luxurious Taste That Would Make a Perfect Gift

9

Mizkan

Blueberry Black Vinegar

Mizkan Blueberry Black Vinegar 1

Burn Fat with a Balanced Fruity Taste

10

Itoen

Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar

Itoen Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar 1

Enjoy the Sweet & Sour Taste of Okinawa

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Yakult
Black Vinegar Drink6 pack

Black Vinegar Drink 1
Source:global.rakuten.com
Black Vinegar Drink 2
Black Vinegar Drink 3
Black Vinegar Drink 4
Black Vinegar Drink 5
Reference price
$24.97
High Mid
Reference price
$24.97
High Mid

mybest's Top Choice! A Delicious Plum Wine Taste That's Good for Digestion, Too!

This black vinegar from Yakult is delicious! If you like umeshu plum wines like Choya brand, you'll surely love this one.


It's refreshingly sweet and lightly sour. The aroma is enticing and the taste is well-balanced. It's not too sugary or too acidic and leaves a pleasant aftertaste. Both women and men, and people of all ages, will enjoy this vinegar right from the first sip!


It's made with Kishu Minami Takaume plums. Yakult is well-known for making drinks that adjust your gut bacteria to aid digestion, and this vinegar will do the same. It contains galacto-oligosaccharides (sugars) that increase the growth of healthy bifidobacteria in your intestines.


If you choose this black vinegar, you'll get health benefits and a great taste in one product. We recommend it highly!

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Sakamoto Brewing
Black Vinegar and Red Grape3-pack

Reference price
$10.42
Mid
Reference price
$10.42
Mid

Deliciously Versatile! It Tastes Just Like Grape Juice!

This is so yummy you'll want to put it in everything! It's made by combining Concord grapes and black vinegar from rice. The sweet grape flavor lingers on your tongue, muting the acidity of the vinegar, and the taste overall is well-balanced.


We recommend enjoying it with Japanese sake or other alcohol, or sparkling water. It would also be a perfect match for ice cream or yogurt, or to make a dessert sauce. And it's quite delicious just on its own, too!

No.3

Melodian
Healthy Black Vinegar24-pack

Reference price
$15.55
Mid
Reference price
$15.55
Mid

A Mild Apple Flavor That's Great for Kids and Dieters on the Go

This one tastes just like apple juice! We think children would love it diluted with sparkling water, or it can be enjoyed straight like a juice. In fact, it's great for dieters too, because it's blended with polyphenols from apples. But if you're looking for the sourness of vinegar, you'll have to look elsewhere.


These come in small drink boxes with little straws. You could pop one into your kids' lunchboxes, or toss one in your gym bag for some refreshing hydration.

No.4

Kisaichi Brewing
Pure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink

Reference price
$28.12
High Mid
Reference price
$28.12
High Mid

The Best Brown Rice Vinegar We Tasted

This vinegar is made from healthy, unpolished brown rice and blended with honey, apple juice, and oligosaccharides. The resulting flavor is sweet, with a lingering aftertaste and clear throat.


It may not be suitable to use with food, but as a drink, it can be enjoyed with sparkling water or hot water for a delicious refreshing beverage.

A Unique Flavor for Those Who Want Something Different

Even though this is unique, it's easy to drink and would be enjoyed by anyone! If you're looking for fat-burning benefits and want to buy from Mizkan but don't want their blueberry variety, try this one.


Yogurt is added to black vinegar, giving it a sweet and sour taste. The mild sourness reminds us of yogurt, though; it doesn't have a pungent vinegar flavor. It's balanced and differently delicious.

Recommended for Health-Conscious People with a Sweet Tooth

With a modest sour taste and strong sweetness, this vinegar is easy to drink like a juice. In fact, some of our tasters thought is was a bit too syrupy sweet.


It contains vitamins C and E, calcium, and fiber. You can find it in small drink boxes too, which are good to toss in your lunch or backpack. If you want a healthy drink that's also sweet, it's a great choice.

No.7

Yamamori
Lactic Acid Bacteria Black Vinegar

Reference price
$27.57
High Mid
Reference price
$27.57
High Mid

A Refreshing and Summery Citrus Drink

Containing 10 billion lactic acid bacteria for gut health, this vinegar is blended with iyokan juice from Ehime prefecture. The result is a citrusy drink that's refreshing and light. The sourness of the citrus fruit masks the vinegar.


It's a delicious choice for a summer drink or for anyone who likes citrus tastes and wants to give their gut a boost, too.

No.8

Ito Kampo Pharmaceuticals
Vinepple Pomegranate Black Vinegar Drink

Reference price
$3.04
Low Mid
Reference price
$3.04
Low Mid

A Luxurious Taste That Would Make a Perfect Gift

This blend of black vinegar and pomegranate juice is refreshing and light. There is a bit of astringency in the aftertaste, but this perfectly compliments the flavor, providing a grapeskin-like flavor accent. There are also hints of acerola tropical fruit.


It's a great choice for anyone who likes light, exotic flavors. It would also make a nice gift, and is tasty enough to drink for breakfast every day.

No.9

Mizkan
Blueberry Black Vinegar

Reference price
$6.23
Low Mid

Burn Fat with a Balanced Fruity Taste

A refreshing blend of blueberry, grape and black vinegar, this one has a deep taste a bit like red wine. The acidity is balanced with the sweet, fruity taste of blueberries, and the astringency of grape skins comes out as an accent.


It contains acetic acid, which has visceral fat-burning properties. It you want a good taste with health benefits, give this a try.

No.10

Itoen
Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar

Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar 1
Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar 2
Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar 3
Black Vinegar Plus Active Moromi Vinegar 4
Reference price
$3.06
Low Mid
Reference price
$3.06
Low Mid

Enjoy the Sweet & Sour Taste of Okinawa

Moromi vinegar is made from the used rice after making Okinawa sake. Here it's blended with barley malt vinegar and seasoned with apples and mango puree. The taste is very rich, and the acids are balanced by sweetness.


However, some of our tasters thought it was too sweet, having a syrupy taste similar to mirin.

No.11

Japan Luna
Honey Black Vinegar Power16 pack

Honey Black Vinegar Power 1
Honey Black Vinegar Power 2
Honey Black Vinegar Power 3
Honey Black Vinegar Power 4
Reference price
$12.55
Mid
Reference price
$12.55
Mid

It's Easy to Drink and Easy to Store

You'll have no trouble finishing the whole little drink box with this blend of apples, honey and black vinegar. It's very sweet, and would also be good served over shaved ice for a refreshing dessert. But like some of the others we tried, the syrupy sweetness wasn't popular with everyone.


It comes in individual boxes that can be kept at room temperature for easy storage in your cabinet. That also makes is easy to carry around all day.

No.12

Japan Natural Fermentation
Oishii Black Vinegar

Oishii Black Vinegar 1
Oishii Black Vinegar 2
Oishii Black Vinegar 3
Oishii Black Vinegar 4
Oishii Black Vinegar 5
Reference price
$10.73
Mid
Reference price
$10.73
Mid

The Best Black Vinegar for Cooking

With modest acidity and sweetness, this is easy to drink and can be used in cooking as well. It won't overpower your dishes, but is sweet and sour with honey and fruit flavors.


It got a low score from those who wanted to really feel like they were drinking vinegar, but as a secret ingredient to enhance the flavor of your dishes at home.

No.13

Mizkan
<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink

<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink 1
<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink 2
<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink 3
<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink 4
<Mainzu> Black Vinegar Drink 5
Reference price
$3.44
Low Mid
Reference price
$3.44
Low Mid

Recommended if You're Counting Calories

This "Every Day Vinegar" is marketed as being good for people with high blood pressure. We didn't test that, but we found it very acidic with a strong vinegar taste that tingled our throats. 


However, it was neutralized by a sweet taste, so it was perfectly drinkable. It has only 16 calories per 100 milliliters, so it's a good choice for dieters.

How to Drink Black Vinegar Safely

How to Drink Black Vinegar Safely

Just because something is good for you doesn't mean that it's okay to overindulge. Most manufacturers recommend a daily dose of one half to one ounce (15-30ml) so use that as a rough guide.


Drinking too much black vinegar can lead to nasty side effects like abdominal pain and diarrhea. It may also cause discomfort if you drink it on an empty stomach, so if you're worried about that, have it after a meal.

Top 5 Japanese Black Vinegars

No. 1: YakultBlack Vinegar Drink6 pack

No. 2: Sakamoto BrewingBlack Vinegar and Red Grape3-pack

No. 3: MelodianHealthy Black Vinegar24-pack

No. 4: Kisaichi BrewingPure Brown Rice Black Vinegar Drink

No. 5: MizkanYogurt Black Vinegar

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Condiments

Coconut Aminos

10 Best

New Arrivals
Featured Rankings Similar to Condiments

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.