10 Best Jelly Beans in 2022 (Candy Blogger-Reviewed)
The ultimate pack of jelly beans has got all three amazing features: texture, taste, and appearance. But with all the different brands and varieties out there, how can you be sure that you’re really chewing on the best ones? To help narrow down your choices, we have put together a list of the 10 best beans, including our favorite, Brach's Classic Jelly Beans. We have also created a buying guide reviewed by Chris, the Candy Critic. Be sure to check out both below!
Quick List - Top Jelly Beans
Originally hailing from Canada, the Candy Critic is a globe-trotter. He’s visited and lived in various countries, and has feasted on delicacies and candy from all corners of the world. He runs and pens the Candy Critic blog. You can also follow his adventures and read his candy reviews on Twitter and Instagram.
mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
Table of Contents
- Why You Can Trust Us
- 10 Best Jelly Beans
- No. 1Brach's | Nerds Covered Chewy & Bumpy Jelly Beans, 13 oz
- No. 2Gaudum | Jelly Belly 4th Edition Beanboozled Jelly Beans Spinner Gift Box, 3.5 oz
- No. 3Jelly Belly | Jelly Belly Jewel Valentine Mix Jelly Beans, 2 lb
- No. 4Starburst | Starburst Original Jellybeans Candy, 14 oz
- No. 5Jelly Belly | Signature Jelly Belly Jelly Beans, 4 lb
- 5 more products
- More Satisfying Food Articles
- Amazon's Best Selling Jelly Beans
Why You Can Trust Us
Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.
How to Choose Jelly Beans – Buying Guide
Though you might have had an easy time picking jelly beans as a kid, your palette as an adult has probably developed to crave new textures, flavors, or experiences. To this end, we asked the Candy Critic for his take on what makes a good bean.
Choose Flavors That Appeal to You
Ultimately, jelly beans are a sugary and sweet treat—and anything we put into our stomachs, we want to taste good whether it's a gourmet, sour, or sugar-free bean. So, first up on our quest to find the perfect jelly bean is flavor.
Traditional Flavors Are Crowd-Pleasers
If you love all the original 49 flavors of Jelly Bellies, then you should go for a variety pack. But picky eaters typically turn their noses up at over half the flavors—like chocolate and cinnamon and licorice beans.
Now you can get small assortments of beans that are limited to six or eight popular flavors. That way, you don’t need to spend hours searching for your favorite fruit and beverage flavors—like cherry, watermelon, cola, pina colada, or blackberry. You can also choose assortments with sour and tart flavors or sweet, traditional varieties.
The general rule of thumb is this: the stronger your likes and dislikes are, the fewer flavors should be in the pack. You could even just go for a bag with just a single flavor.
If I were buying a gift for a friend who wasn’t into candy, I would go with simple fruit. The majority of people are going to like it. Creatively, it’s the cheap way out; logically, it’s the flavor people are actually going to like.
But the thing I find with some of the more obscure flavors is that there were certain flavors that were always good combined with other beans. In fact, Jelly Belly used to come out with a recipe book every year that showed you how to create new flavors by eating multiple beans at once.
Themed Flavor Mixes Are Fun
Jelly Belly really gets creative with their creations. They have gone through so many collaborations you can find almost any type of food in jelly bean form—like Krispy Kreme Doughnuts, Cold Stone Ice Cream, Dr. Pepper, A&W Cream Soda, Snapple, and Pancake flavors. They are not all equally delicious, but they are out there for the adventurous and brand-loving.
Many brands have also introduced mixes that are purely fruit flavors only, like Jelly Belly’s Superfruit Mix, Brach’s Island Fruit, or Welch’s Assorted. If you’re feeling daring, you can always get bags that are all spicy or all sour, too. For example, Warhead’s does have its own line of jelly beans—and they are not that sour, so can really be enjoyed by all.
You can also opt for jelly bean collections that taste like candy flavors. Starburst is one example, as there are several varieties with different flavors. Some include original Starburst flavors and others include only cherry and strawberry. Jolly Rancher jelly beans are another candy-themed collection.
Food science is an ever-expanding field, as far as developing synthetic flavors that you can stuff into a Jelly Belly. Certain flavors work really well, and certain flavors are just so new. And one of the things I discovered is sometimes a flavor requires a texture as well to really work.
Unique Flavors for Adventurous Eaters
Of course, there are always mischievous or curious people out there who collect odd or unique flavors like Tabasco sauce. There are also more mature flavors out there like Champagne, Margarita, and draft beer.
If you want to play pranks or just try the odd flavor, then get Bertie Bott’s classic vomit and grass flavors. Jelly Belly has also come out with new crowd-pleasers, like spoiled milk and dead fish in their BeanBoozled line. Though they may sound odd, you never know if they will actually become a new favorite.
Ensure They Suit Your Dietary Preferences
Not all jelly beans are created with the same ingredients. You will find collections that cater to special dietary needs and preferences. For example, there are sugar-free and vegan varieties. You can also find gluten-free jelly bean collections in some stores or online.
The good news is that you can still enjoy jelly beans with dietary restrictions. However, you should double-check the label and the list of ingredients. For example, vegan jelly beans may have a certified vegan logo and sugar-free beans should have sugar substitutes in lieu of sugar or high-fructose corn syrup.
Consider the Size and Texture of the Beans
Some beans are like little stones or old jerky—especially if they have been left sitting out for a while. A good jelly bean has got a crunchy exterior and an interior that is the perfect amount of chewiness—just enough to slowly give way as your teeth slide through, but not enough to get stuck in the little grooves of your teeth.
The best way to check for texture, of course, is by eating. If you’re at a store that lets you taste test, you should do it. But if you’re a purist and must buy online, make sure to check the reviews. Rest assured that if the bean does not have that satisfying shell and soft jelly belly, people are going to complain.
Keep in mind that size can also impact texture and taste. Smaller beans have a crunchier texture, but larger or standard-sized jelly beans will be softer on the inside. The outside or shell of the bean is where the flavor is at. Lean toward smaller beans if you want a short, strong burst. For a slower release, choose standard or larger sizes.
If you’re adding a texture to a candy, you want to make sure it suits the flavor. Jelly Belly tends to have more crunchy beans, since they’re smaller. Whereas your standard bulk jelly beans—since they’re a little bit bigger—tend to have more squishy stuff in the middle, and the texture of the outside tends to be less predominant.
Think About What Flavors and Colors Meet Your Needs
Jelly beans can be surprisingly beautiful. Some are color-coordinated for Valentine’s Day, for instance, and some are jeweled and look like little pearls. You can use them as party favors or even as interior decorations.
Pouring a bunch of aquamarine, navy, and sky-blue ones into a clear, glass jar creates a sea-like look. Lustrous whites or pinks work well with princess-themed children's parties, where you can even top cupcakes with jelly beans.
Different flavors also come in handy for special occasions and events. For example, Easter-themed flavors and colors suit egg hunts and Easter baskets. On the other hand, sour or black licorice collections might work well for a loved one's birthday party if they prefer those flavors.
Keep Your Beans Fresh With Resealable Packaging
Packaging does matter. It’s little things like this that will save you a lot of pain and heartache in the long run.
For those on the go, plastic bags are the most compact, and you can fold the top over as you work your way through the bag. Sometimes the bag is even resealable, which makes it even more convenient, as it helps the beans' texture last longer. If you’re buying a gift for a jelly bean-loving coworker, go for a box or jar, though jars make the superior interior decoration.
Finally, if you are of the generous sort and share your beans, get a plastic tub. They stand on their own and are easy to scoop out, portion, and share. Plus, tubs are the easiest to close up again, so they’re the best at keeping your mountain of beans fresh.
There’s two points to packaging. Packaging can keep something fresh. But presentation can also give you an expectation of where you're going, since there are certain expectations connected to how jelly beans are packaged.
I remember a while back, Jelly Belly sent me this sample—it was like a bouquet. And they sent these floral-type fruity flavors, and that worked. If I had had a root beer one in there, it would’ve been weird.
10 Best Jelly Beans
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Brach's Nerds Covered Chewy & Bumpy Jelly Beans, 13 oz | | Best for Classic Flavors and Taste | |
2 | Gaudum Jelly Belly 4th Edition Beanboozled Jelly Beans Spinner Gift Box, 3.5 oz | | Best for Parties | |
3 | Jelly Belly Jelly Belly Jewel Valentine Mix Jelly Beans, 2 lb | | Best for Black Licorice Lovers | |
4 | Starburst Starburst Original Jellybeans Candy, 14 oz | | Best for Starburst Lovers | |
5 | Jelly Belly Signature Jelly Belly Jelly Beans, 4 lb | | Best for Chewy Flavor Variety | |
6 | Just Born Just Born Jelly Beans, 4.5 lb | | Best for Juicy Flavors in Smaller-Sized Beans | |
7 | Jelly Belly Jelly Belly Harry Potter Bertie Bott’s, 1.2 oz | | Best for Offering a Surprise in Every Bite | |
8 | YumEarth Jelly Belly Sport Beans, Assorted Flavors 24 Pack, 1 oz | | Best Organic and Vegan Jelly Beans | |
9 | Wonka Jelly Belly Classic Glass Jar, 14.5 oz | | Best for a Sour and Tangy Crunch | |
10 | Russell Stover Jelly Belly Sunkist Tangerine Jelly Beans, 1 lb | | Best for Sugar-Free Classics |
Brach'sNerds Covered Chewy & Bumpy Jelly Beans, 13 oz
Best for Classic Flavors and Taste
- Classic flavor mix
- Soft texture
- Fits all occasions
- Good flavor variety
- Resealable packages
Cons:
- Some reviewers found them overly sweet
These jelly beans are best for those who like classic flavor mixes that are sure to be crowd-pleasers. You can use Brach's jelly beans for multiple holidays and occasions. These beans can serve as candy toppers on ice cream, cakes, and cupcakes. You can also use them in a candy dish for snacking or as party favors.
Some reviewers were disappointed with the taste of the beans, as they thought they were too sugary or weak. However, the majority of reviewers appreciated the classic flavor mix and the resealable packaging. They liked being reminded of jelly bean flavors from their childhoods.
GaudumJelly Belly 4th Edition Beanboozled Jelly Beans Spinner Gift Box, 3.5 oz
Best for Parties
- Unique flavors
- Comes with original Jelly Belly game spinner plus 10 extra game ideas
- Three versions, for kids, teens or adults
Cons:
- Meant to be enjoyed in groups
- Not all flavors are appetizing
The original Bean Boozled game's rules are simple; you flick a spinner and eat whatever is depicted, delicious or gross. As fun as that sounds, it might not keep the party going for long, so we like this set that comes with additional game ideas using the Jelly Belly beans. It even comes in three versions with challenges geared to different age groups.
The majority of reviewers thought the game was fun to play and a different type of experience. They say it's great for kids, and like how the additional games make the hilariousness of watching your friends try not to gag last even longer.
Jelly BellyJelly Belly Jewel Valentine Mix Jelly Beans, 2 lb
Best for Black Licorice Lovers
- Just black licorice flavor
- Can use for Halloween parties
- Smaller size for dessert toppings
- Some reviewers found the licorice taste milder than other brands
Black licorice is known to be a polarizing flavor. But if you love it, you no longer have to separate the black beans from the rest of the classic flavors. Give this bag to the black licorice lovers in the family and spare the rest!
Some reviewers thought these black licorice jelly beans did not have as much authentic flavor as the Brach's or other brands. However, most reviewers who love black licorice beans found these satisfied their cravings and hit the sweet spot.
StarburstStarburst Original Jellybeans Candy, 14 oz
Best for Starburst Lovers
- Original Starburst flavors
- Smaller, chewable size
- Do not stick to teeth
Cons:
- Does not contain classic jelly bean flavors
These beans are best for Starburst fans because they are a mix between jelly beans and Starburst candy. They have the coating and sugariness of Jelly Bellies, but the tender, juicy, and tart center you'd expect from Starburst.
A handful of reviewers did not think the beans tasted like Starburst. However, the majority of reviewers loved the freshness of the product and found the flavors addicting.
Jelly BellySignature Jelly Belly Jelly Beans, 4 lb
Best for Chewy Flavor Variety
- 50 different classic and unique flavors
- Soft and chewy texture
- Package includes flavor pairing ideas
Cons:
- Some contain beeswax or caffeine
This huge bag comes with three pounds of Jelly Bellies and is best for those who crave flavor variety. There is a good mix of classics like cherry and some more unique flavors like coffee and popcorn. Eat them one at a time and savor each, or try pairing them up for unique tastes!
Some reviewers were not impressed with a few of the more unique flavors, such as maple syrup and Krispy Kreme doughnut. But for the most part, buyers liked the large amount and variety of sweet tastes. Some enjoyed getting surprised by the various flavors.
Just BornJust Born Jelly Beans, 4.5 lb
Best for Juicy Flavors in Smaller-Sized Beans
- Less intense, juice-like flavors
- Smaller size perfect for dessert toppings
Cons:
- Might not be as flavorful for some taste preferences, according to reviewers
Just Born jelly beans are best for those looking for a smaller bean with a softer and less intense flavor than your typical Jelly Bellies. The shell is just thick enough, and the inside is yielding, smooth, and juicy. They don’t gum up your throat with sugar but are as fruity as a box of Mike and Ikes.
Some reviewers were disappointed in the balance of flavors in the package. However, most buyers liked the freshness of the flavors. They also appreciated that the beans were not too overwhelming or sugary.
Jelly BellyJelly Belly Harry Potter Bertie Bott’s, 1.2 oz
Best for Offering a Surprise in Every Bite
- Unique and rare flavors
- Movie and literature theme
Cons:
- Flavors might not appeal to everyone
- Small box size isn't best for sharing
Bertie Bott's Every Flavor Beans are famous for originating from Harry Potter and are best for those who want to be surprised. These beans come in flavors ranging from the sweet and delicious to the horrifying and prank-worthy. If you don't know how strange the flavors can get, know that they include vomit and earthworm.
The most prevalent complaints from buyers were the small box size and that some of the flavors were not the most appealing. But a lot of reviewers liked buying these beans for occasions like Halloween, to pull pranks, or as a treat for their kids. They also thought the beans were a great gift for Harry Potter fans or themed parties.
YumEarthJelly Belly Sport Beans, Assorted Flavors 24 Pack, 1 oz
Best Organic and Vegan Jelly Beans
Pros:
- Smaller, individual packs for snacking or lunches
- Organic, non-GMO
- Sour flavors
- Some said they can melt together too easily
These jelly beans are best for those who want natural, organic flavors and colors. They're vegan and free from all major allergens such as gluten, dairy and nuts. They also come in smaller snacking sizes to help with portion control and so you can toss them in lunch boxes easily.
Some reviewers experienced problems with the beans being stuck together or too moist in the packages. That being said, the majority of reviewers liked the sour and natural fruit flavors. Some buyers mentioned how addictive the beans were.
WonkaJelly Belly Classic Glass Jar, 14.5 oz
Best for a Sour and Tangy Crunch
Pros:
- Bright colors
- Sour flavors for those who like a punch
- Crunchy candy texture
Cons:
- According to reviewers, some flavors aren't that sour
These jelly beans are best for people who like Nerds candy, sour flavors, and crunchy textures. The beans come in a bulk bag so you can divide them up for different occasions. If you like candy flavors or are nostalgic for your childhood favorites, these beans might be for you.
A few reviewers thought some flavors were not sour enough. Yet, most reviewers liked the balance between the taste, crunchy feel on the outside, and soft texture on the inside.
Russell StoverJelly Belly Sunkist Tangerine Jelly Beans, 1 lb
Best for Sugar-Free Classics
Pros:
- Sugar-free and sweetened with maltitol and sucralose
- Mostly classic flavors
- Medium-sized beans
Cons:
- Sugar substitutes can cause upset stomach
These jelly beans from Russell Stover are best for those who need to follow a sugar-free or reduced sugar diet. The mix contains mostly classic flavors with a couple more unique ones thrown in. However, be sure to consume these beans in moderation as sugar substitutes can cause gastrointestinal problems.
The most common complaint from reviewers was not realizing that eating too many of these jelly beans could lead to an upset stomach and excess gas. Yet, many reviewers commented about the fresh and fruity taste of these beans. They liked having a sugar-free option that didn't have an aftertaste.
More Satisfying Food Articles
Jelly beans may be a great snack, but there are a variety of other foods out there that are just as equally amazing as beans. We have written about other delicious (and healthy!) munchies too, so check out the links below.
Top 5 Jelly Beans
No. 1: Brach's｜Nerds Covered Chewy & Bumpy Jelly Beans, 13 oz
No. 2: Gaudum｜Jelly Belly 4th Edition Beanboozled Jelly Beans Spinner Gift Box, 3.5 oz
No. 3: Jelly Belly｜Jelly Belly Jewel Valentine Mix Jelly Beans, 2 lb
No. 4: Starburst｜Starburst Original Jellybeans Candy, 14 oz
No. 5: Jelly Belly｜Signature Jelly Belly Jelly Beans, 4 lb
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Search by category
Health
Body care products, Health accessories, Health foods and supplementsBeauty
Blushes, Bronzers, CleansersHome goods
Bath supplies, Ceremonial occasion supplies, Cleaning suppliesHome electronics
Air conditioners and coolers, AV accessories, Blenders and food processorsPC
Computer supplies, Desktop computers, TabletsCamera
Camera bags and backpacks, Camera supplies, Digital single lens camerasFood and drinks
Jams and Jellies, Alcohol, BreadsKitchen
Coffee and tea products, Cooking utensils, CupsFashion
Footwear products, Men's shoes, SandalsAccessories
Wristwatches, Accessories and jewelry, Umbrellas and parasolsKids and baby
Baby carriers, Baby food, Baby formulaInterior
Beds, Beds and bedding, ChairsHobbies
Aromatherapy products, Art supplies, Arts and collectiblesOutdoor
Barbecue grills and fire pits, Camping beds and cots, Camping gearHome, garden, and tools
Agricultural materials and gardening supplies, Exterior and garden furniture, Materials and repairing agentsSports and fitness
Sports shoes, Surfing supplies, Badminton suppliesPets
Bird and small animal supplies, Cat Supplies, Dog SuppliesMedia
Books and magazines, CD, Children's books, picture books and illustrated encyclopediasGames
Gaming accessories, Nintendo Switch games, PC gamesApps
Business apps, Cooking apps, Dating appsAutomotive
Car accessories, Car navigation systemsGifts
Christmas gifts, Father's Day gifts, Gifts for childrenMobile devices
Mobile phone and smartphone accessories, Wearable devices and smart watches