10 Best Cookie Mixes in 2022 (Chef-Reviewed)

• Great buttery flavor
  
• Has a firm consistency that holds its shape well
  
• Reports that the dough is easy to work with
• Company has a hotline to troubleshoot baking issues
  

Cons:

• A few reviewers’ cookies came out too hard
  

Sugar cookies are simple but versatile, and great for adding your own twist, like vanilla, almond extract, lemon zest, or cinnamon. These cookies bake up sturdy as well, so you can easily decorate them. They’re also light and buttery, and taste slightly similar to a shortbread cookie.

A few reviewers ended up with rock-hard cookies. However, most felt that the dough was easy to work with and perfect for rolling and cutting. Plus, most said the cookies tasted almost indistinguishable from homemade ones. 

Pros:

• Makes for a great gift
  
• 30 different mixes to choose from
  
• Instructions are easy to follow
• Seasonal gift bags and customization available
  

• None
  

For those wondering what to buy for their loved ones during the holiday season or looking for party favors, consider cookie mix in a jar! This shop offers 30 different mixes, including s'mores, pumpkin caramel, and fudge peppermint.

Reviewers say the cookies are delicious, and the seller is helpful. They say the baking instructions are easy to follow and the packaging is gift-worthy. Several have re-ordered a few times for different occasions!

Pros:

• Can be used to make cakes and cobblers
  
• Soft and chewy texture
  

Cons:

• Some reviewers felt like the cookies were a little too sweet
  

Snickerdoodles get their classic, warm flavor due to an outer coating of cinnamon sugar. This mix already comes with a cinnamon sugar packet, so all you need to provide is butter and an egg! If you'd like, you can even add two teaspoons of cocoa powder to make chocolate snickerdoodles. 

Although some reviewers felt that the cookies were on the sweet side, most liked the chewy texture and easy preparation. Many also raved about the flavor and even said they tasted like homemade snickerdoodles. Bakers also used this mix to make cakes and cobblers with successful results. 

Pros:

• Easy to experiment with
  
• Filled with lots of fun add-ins
  
• Satisfying chewy texture
  

Cons:

• Some reports of it being overly sweet
  

Meli's monster cookie mix is packed with gluten-free oats, and chocolate and peanut butter M&M candies. Add your own nut butter, egg and butter for a baked cookie, or try using honey for a no-bake snack. Either way, it makes a perfect snack for a quick little energy boost during the day. 

Although there were a few comments that the cookies were too sweet for their liking, most reviewers praised their chewy texture and called this their favorite gluten-free cookie mix. Some also noted that they tasted great warm right out the oven.

Pros:

• Can be used to make gingerbread houses
  
• Easy to cut and form into shapes
  

Cons:

• Some felt that the flavor was slightly bland
  

This gingerbread cookie mix from Betty Crocker is quite versatile, and can be used to make cookies or gingerbread houses. The warm spices and molasses make for an inviting aroma while baking that will get you in the holiday spirit!

Some reviewers found the taste a bit lacking, and wanted more ginger flavor. Despite this, many people had a lot of fun using cookie cutters to make cookies with their kids. They like how it saves them time and work, so they can spend more on decorating the cookies.

Pros:

• Peanut butter and peanut butter chips for a double punch
  
• Creamy on the inside and crunchy on the outside
  

Cons:

• Reviewers mentioned that the dough tends to be a little dry and hard to mix
  

Krusteaz’s double peanut butter cookie mix contains peanut butter and peanut butter chips, making it both creamy and crunchy. Make crisscrosses with your fork for the best visual results, or stick a Hershey's Kiss in the middle while they're warm from the oven!

Some cookie fans felt that the dough was dry and difficult to work with, and they had to put in extra effort while hand mixing. On the other hand, most praised the gooey center and crispy outside. They say they're deliciously nutty and go great with ice cream.

Pros:

• Extra chewy texture due to oats
  
• Lots of chocolate chips
  

Cons:

• Some comments that the cookie turned out too flat when baked

Betty Crocker’s Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix is perfect for those who love oatmeal cookies but could do without the raisins. Instead, this mix is packed full of melty chocolate chips, leaving you with a chewy cookie that tastes surprisingly homemade.

Although a couple reviewers were disappointed that the cookies baked out too flat, most loved how soft and moist they were. Some even added extra oats to enhance the chewiness. Pecans, butterscotch chips, and cinnamon were also popular add-ins. 

Pros:

• Taste is indiscernible from gluten version
  
• Can replace extract with other flavors to make various types of cookies
  
• Firm on the outside and soft on the inside
  

Cons:

• A few reviewers felt like the cookies were too fragile to decorate

This sugar cookie mix from Betty Crocker is loved by both gluten-free and regular foodies alike, with many saying they couldn’t tell that they were gluten-free. You can swap out the recommended vanilla extract for other flavored extracts. Some suggestions included strawberry, peppermint, or almond. 

Some reviewers ran into trouble when they tried to decorate the cookies because they were fragile to handle. However, most praised the excellent flavor, versatility, and ease of use. They also say the dough is easy to roll out.

Pros:

• Chocolate chips are not too sweet
  
• Two types of chocolate chips
  

Cons:

• Some reviewers felt that there weren’t enough chips
  

Ghirardelli's cookie mix utilizes bittersweet and semisweet chocolate chips, resulting in a balanced flavor. Those who don’t like overly sweet cookies will definitely enjoy these! They make a soft, more cake-like cookie.

Although most loved the chocolate flavor, some reviewers lamented that there weren’t enough chips for their liking. However, some added white or milk chocolate chips to increase the chocolaty goodness.

Pros:

• Good for special occasions and small parties; serves two to four
  
• Easy to bake or microwave, and comes with a pan
  
• Super gooey center and crispy edges
  

Cons:

• Reviewers say it's easy to overcook it in the microwave; you have to pay attention
  
• Some reviewers found it difficult to bake evenly
  

This chocolate cookie mix from Duncan Hines has plenty of dark chocolate chunks and is the perfect shareable snack for a small party. Utensils are unnecessary, and there's a six-inch pan included for your convenience. You can even bake it in a microwave!

Some reviewers noted that it was easy to overcook, so you should keep an eye on it. Nonetheless, most reviewers loved the indulgent, gooey center and crunchy edges, and some recommend topping it with ice cream or whipped cream. They say it serves around four people.