mybest
Steak SaucesHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Steak SaucesHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Steak Sauces  (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Steak Sauces  (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Steak Sauces  (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Steak Sauces  (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Steak Sauces  (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More) 5

10 Best Steak Sauces (A1, Primal Kitchen, and More)

Given the name, steak sauce tends to find its way onto steak. However, the flavor works just as well on other meats too. While the history of some steak sauces reaches back centuries, others are newly created to capitalize on the latest health and culinary trends. With so much variety, picking the right one can be a bit of a daunting task.


This guide will help simplify the process by highlighting some key points to consider when choosing your steak companion. As always, we have curated a list of the top steak sauces from sites like Amazon and Walmart to help you get started on your sauce search

Last updated 09/12/2024

Quick List - Top Steak Sauce

1

A.1.

A.1.Original Sauce
Original Sauce

The Ubiquitous Steak Sauce

2

Peter Luger Steak House

Peter Luger Steak HouseOld Fashioned Steak Sauce
Old Fashioned Steak Sauce

Balanced Flavors From a Renowned Steak House

3

Primal Kitchen

Primal KitchenOrganic Steak Sauce
Organic Steak Sauce

Light on Sugar, Heavy on Flavor

4

Le Sauce & Co.

Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce
Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce

Demi-Glace Sauce in Pouches

5

Golden West Specialty Foods

Shemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce
Shemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce

Steak Sauce With Whiskey and Hot Peppers

Christopher Heffner
Guide
Content Planner at mybest
Christopher Heffner

With over a decade of weightlifting experience, Christopher Heffner is an avid fitness enthusiast who enjoys starting his day with a good workout. He also has a background in engineering and business, bringing a unique blend of technical knowledge and practicality to his endeavors.

Christopher Heffner's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

Why You Can Trust Us

Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.


mybest’s Content Policy

Is Steak Sauce the Same as a Marinade?

Is Steak Sauce the Same as a Marinade?

Steak sauce and marinades are both popular choices for enhancing the flavor of steak, but they serve different purposes.


  • Steak sauce is typically used as a condiment after cooking. It offers a tangy and distinctive taste.
  • Marinades and rubs are applied to meat before cooking. They not only add flavor but also help to tenderize the meat. Marinades are often thinner than steak sauces, allowing for deeper penetration into the meat.

While steak sauce and marinades have distinct uses, there's flexibility in their application. You can use a steak sauce as a base for a homemade marinade or even marinate with a steak sauce. The key is to understand their unique characteristics and choose the method that best suits your desired flavor profile and cooking preferences.

How to Choose Steak Sauce - Buying Guide

Here are the points to keep in mind when choosing the best steak sauce for you.
1

Choose Your Steak Sauce Based on the Flavor

The most important aspect of any condiment, steak sauce included, is the flavor. Even if you're only using a bit, the impact it has on your meal can be surprisingly big.

Look for a Sauce Made With Vinegar, Lemon Juice, or Worcestershire Sauce for Extra Tang

Look for a Sauce Made With Vinegar, Lemon Juice, or Worcestershire Sauce for Extra Tang
For people who grew up with A1 like I did, "tangy" is the first thing that comes to mind when thinking of steak sauce. Vinegar, citrus juice, and Worcestershire sauce are three of the most common ingredients that contribute to a steak sauce's tanginess. 


If you want to use steak sauce to marinade something, these acidic ingredients will help tenderize the meat by breaking down some of the fibers that can make it a bit tougher to chew.

Look for a Sauce Made With Black and Cayenne Peppers for Their Spice

Look for a Sauce Made With Black and Cayenne Peppers for Their Spice
Cayenne and black pepper are the most commonly found varieties of peppers in steak sauces, and they're also typically considered to be among the most mild. 


Remember, this is a steak sauce, not a hot sauce, so the heat will add to and support the overall flavor rather than be the center of attention. If you want more heat, you can always mix in a bit of your favorite hot sauce into your steak sauce.

Look for Ingredients Like Ketchup, Brown Sugar, or Molasses for a Sweet Sauce

Look for Ingredients Like Ketchup, Brown Sugar, or Molasses for a Sweet Sauce

Steak sauce might be tangier than barbecue sauce, but that doesn't mean it can't have a sweet side, too. A sauce using ketchup as a base can inherit its sweetness and tang. Brown sugar lends the sauce a rich, caramel-like sweetness, while molasses imparts its own flavor. 


The best sweeteners will add their own unique flavors to the sauce rather than just making it sweeter. 

Look for Garlic, a Versatile Enhancement Your Dish’s Natural Flavor

Look for Garlic, a Versatile Enhancement Your Dish’s Natural Flavor
Garlic is one of the most commonly used seasonings around the world. It's just as much a part of Italian cooking as it is for cuisine from East and Southeast Asian and Middle Eastern countries. 


Known for bringing out the natural flavors of other ingredients and adding complexity to various dishes, garlic is certainly popular for a reason. Anyone looking to add depth and a savory twist to their steak sauce should consider one that uses garlic.

2

Choose Convenient Packaging for Your Next Cookout

Choose Convenient Packaging for Your Next Cookout
While the way it's packaged won't make or break a steak sauce, it can be the little finishing touch that makes it more convenient to use. Or the wrong package can make you less likely to reach for a delicious sauce because of how troublesome it is.

  • Glass Bottles: These are a great option for storing steak sauce as they are BPA-free and highly inert, preventing flavor transfer. However, their fragility may make them less suitable for outdoor events or situations where kids may be running around.


  • Plastic Squeeze: These offer a balance of convenience and durability, making them suitable for various settings, especially gatherings. Their flexibility allows for easy dispensing, and they are less likely to break than glass bottles.


  • Individual Packets: Individual packets make it easy to bring a bit of your favorite steak sauce with you. This packaging lends itself very well to cookouts.

3

Avoid Added Sugars for a Natural, Healthier Steak Sauce

Avoid Added Sugars for a Natural, Healthier Steak Sauce

A lot of foods and condiments contain a surprising amount of sugar. While there are numerous health benefits to reducing sugar, sometimes it's difficult to avoid entirely, especially without compromising on flavor. 


If you are watching your sugar intake, it may be best to look for sauces with zero added sugars or that are sugar-free. Another good compromise is to look for a steak sauce that gets its sweetness from inherently sweet ingredients rather than added sugar (or other sweeteners like corn syrup). 

4

For a Tried and True Classic, Check the Brands Like A1 with History

For a Tried and True Classic, Check the Brands Like A1 with History
Source:amazon.com
While new brands appear all the time, and some are very good, one hallmark of a great steak sauce is its history. Some sauces have been around for decades or longer


The precursor to A1 was invented over 200 years ago by Henderson William Brand for King George IV. While the exact recipe has certainly undergone a few changes since then, the brand must have been onto something for his sauce to retain its popularity for so long. 


Even if they're not cooking for royalty, having the reputation of a renowned chef or restaurant can be a useful indicator of a good sauce. The Texas Roadhouse restaurant chain has its own brand of steak sauces, and the iconic Heinz's 57 Sauce is worth noting as well.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

Best Steak Sauces Ranking

Here are the top 10 best-selling steak sauces available on sites like Amazon, Walmart, and Target. We independently ranked them based on popularity among steak lovers and how well each sauce aligned with our buying guide.
Popularity
Filter

Products

Image

Click to purchase

Key features

Details

Serving Size

Servings per Container

Total Sugars

Added Sugars

Calories

Garlic

Package Type

Organic

Gluten Free

Tangy

Spicy

Sweet

1

A.1.

A.1.Original Sauce

A.1. Original Sauce 1

The Ubiquitous Steak Sauce

0.6 oz.

17 Servings

2g

2g

15 Calories

Glass Bottle

2

Peter Luger Steak House

Peter Luger Steak HouseOld Fashioned Steak Sauce

Peter Luger Steak House Old Fashioned Steak Sauce 1

Balanced Flavors From a Renowned Steak House

0.5 oz.

25 Servings

4g

2g

30 Calories

Glass Bottle

3

Primal Kitchen

Primal KitchenOrganic Steak Sauce

Primal Kitchen Organic Steak Sauce 1

Light on Sugar, Heavy on Flavor

0.56 oz.

15 Servings

1g

0g

10 Calories

Glass Bottle

4

Le Sauce & Co.

Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce

Le Sauce & Co. Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce 1

Demi-Glace Sauce in Pouches

2.12 oz.

2 Servings

1g

0g

50 Calories

Individual Packets

5

Golden West Specialty Foods

Shemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce

Golden West Specialty Foods Shemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce 1

Steak Sauce With Whiskey and Hot Peppers

10 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

Glass Bottle

6

365 by Whole Foods Market

365 Organic Steak Sauce

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Steak Sauce 1

Organic Steak Sauce From Whole Foods

10 oz.

19 Servings

1g

1g

10 Calories

Glass Bottle

7

Badia Spices

Chimichurri Steak Sauce

Badia Spices Chimichurri Steak Sauce 1

A Chimichurri Sauce That Gets Its Tanginess From Red Wine Vinegar

8 oz.

16 Servings

0g

0g

60 Calories

Glass Jar

8

Braswell's

Vidalia Onion Steak Sauce 13.5 oz

Braswell's Vidalia Onion Steak Sauce 13.5 oz 1

Made With Vidalia Onion and Mustard Seeds for a Unique Flavor

13.5 oz.

22 Servings

5g

4g

20 Calories

Glass Bottle

9

Pendennis Club

The Original Henry Bain’s Sauce

Pendennis Club The Original Henry Bain’s Sauce 1

Steak Sauce With a Century of History

8 oz.

unknown

unknown

unknown

unknown

Glass Jar

10

London Pub

Steak & Chop Sauce

London Pub Steak & Chop Sauce 1

Traditional British Pub Flavor

10 oz.

18 Servings

2g

0g

15 Calories

Glass Bottle

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

A.1.
A.1.Original Sauce

Original Sauce 1
Source:amazon.com
Original Sauce 2
Source:amazon.com
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
2g
Added Sugars
2g
Calories
15 Calories

The Ubiquitous Steak Sauce

A1’s Original Sauce is a classic steak sauce known for its bold, tangy flavor. For many people, this versatile condiment is the steak sauce. Its features a blend of ingredients and a base of pureed tomatoes that create a satisfying balance of sweet, savory, and slightly spicy notes. Many customers appreciate A1 Original Sauce for its ability to enhance the flavor of grilled or pan-seared steak (and other meats) without becoming overpowering. Its thick, rich consistency provides a satisfying coating that lends itself to dipping. 
Serving Size0.6 oz.
Servings per Container17 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Peter Luger Steak House
Peter Luger Steak HouseOld Fashioned Steak Sauce

Old Fashioned Steak Sauce 1
Source:amazon.com
Lowest price
$19.99
High Mid
Lowest price
$19.99
High Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
4g
Added Sugars
2g
Calories
30 Calories

Balanced Flavors From a Renowned Steak House

Created by the renowned Peter Luger Steak House, this signature steak sauce is known for its rich, savory flavor and the level of quality befitting of its namesake. 


This sauce is crafted with a carefully selected blend of ingredients, including horseradish, two kinds of vinegar, and three types of sweeteners, to achieve a balanced flavor. This focus on balance and quality is popular among customers, many of whom praise its ability to enhance the flavor of high-quality steak while still allowing the meat's inherent flavor to shine. The sauce's thick consistency and bold taste make it a popular complement to a variety of dishes. 

Serving Size0.5 oz.
Servings per Container25 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.3

Primal Kitchen
Primal KitchenOrganic Steak Sauce

Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
1g
Added Sugars
0g
Calories
10 Calories

Light on Sugar, Heavy on Flavor

For health-conscious consumers seeking a high-quality, organic steak sauce, Primal Kitchen offers a delicious and nutritious option. Made with organic ingredients and free from added sugar, this sauce provides a bold flavor without compromising on taste or health. Many customers appreciate the clean ingredient list and the ability to enjoy a flavorful steak sauce without compromising on their dietary goals. Reviews also praise this sauce's thick consistency and rich flavor.
Serving Size0.56 oz.
Servings per Container15 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.4

Le Sauce & Co.
Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce

Lowest price
$13.82
Low Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
1g
Added Sugars
0g
Calories
50 Calories

Demi-Glace Sauce in Pouches

A gourmet demi-glace from Le Sauce Co., this sauce is a rich and flavorful reduction made from veal bones, vegetables, spices, and red wine. Unlike other sauces on this list, this demi-glace comes in a pouch rather than a bottle. Customers often enjoy the way the thick consistency and intense flavor complement a variety of meats, thus demonstrating how it can be used in various culinary applications beyond steak.
Serving Size2.12 oz.
Servings per Container2 Servings
Package TypeIndividual Packets
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.5

Golden West Specialty Foods
Shemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce

Lowest price
$22.99
High Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
unknown
Added Sugars
unknown
Calories
unknown

Steak Sauce With Whiskey and Hot Peppers

This steak sauce offers a unique combination of bold, smoky flavor from the whiskey and a touch of heat from jalapenos and black pepper. This distinctive flavor has drawn praise from many customers, who appreciate the way this sauce's thick consistency helps make it a perfect finishing touch for grilled or pan-seared steak.
Serving Size10 oz.
Servings per Containerunknown
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.6

365 by Whole Foods Market
365 Organic Steak Sauce

Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
1g
Added Sugars
1g
Calories
10 Calories

Organic Steak Sauce From Whole Foods

Another organic option on this list, 365 Organic Steak Sauce has the quality you would expect from Whole Foods. It offers a balanced flavor profile with a hint of sweetness and tanginess thanks to simple ingredients and a base of tomato puree. Customers enjoy the value this sauce provides as well as its commitment to organic ingredients.
Serving Size10 oz.
Servings per Container19 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.7

Badia Spices
Chimichurri Steak Sauce

Lowest price
$8.71
Low
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
0g
Added Sugars
0g
Calories
60 Calories

A Chimichurri Sauce That Gets Its Tanginess From Red Wine Vinegar

As a chimichurri-style steak sauce, this product offers a different twist on adding tangy flavor to your steak. Being a unique and flavorful condiment, customer opinions are a bit mixed. Although many customers appreciate its bright, refreshing taste, others feel that it’s too acidic
Serving Size8 oz.
Servings per Container16 Servings
Package TypeGlass Jar
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.8

Braswell's
Vidalia Onion Steak Sauce 13.5 oz

Lowest price
$12.90
Low Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
5g
Added Sugars
4g
Calories
20 Calories

Made With Vidalia Onion and Mustard Seeds for a Unique Flavor

This steak sauce has a sweet and savory flavor thanks to the inclusion of Vidalia onions and mustard seed. Thanks to the onions, reviewers appreciate its unique flavor profile and its ability to add a touch of sweetness to their steak. The most common complaint is the poor durability of the glass bottles.
Serving Size13.5 oz.
Servings per Container22 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.9

Pendennis Club
The Original Henry Bain’s Sauce

Lowest price
$14.99
Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
unknown
Added Sugars
unknown
Calories
unknown

Steak Sauce With a Century of History

A classic steak sauce with a rich history and named after its creator, this product is known for its bold, tangy, and savory flavor. Bain intended for this sauce to be paired with a variety of meats including beef and local game. More than anything else, customers appreciate its versatility and flavor.
Serving Size8 oz.
Servings per Containerunknown
Package TypeGlass Jar
Organic
Gluten Free
View all
No.10

London Pub
Steak & Chop Sauce

Lowest price
$22.95
High Mid
Garlic
Tangy
Spicy
Sweet
Total Sugars
2g
Added Sugars
0g
Calories
15 Calories

Traditional British Pub Flavor

This steak sauce is inspired by the classic British pub fare and offers a hearty, savory flavor with a hint of sweetness. While the majority of customers enjoy the flavor, common complaints include the durability of the glass bottles and trouble sourcing the sauce locally. 
Serving Size10 oz.
Servings per Container18 Servings
Package TypeGlass Bottle
Organic
Gluten Free
View all

Extra Steak Sauce Tips

If you've already exhausted our list of sauces, you may want to know how to upgrade your steak routine. Once you know what type of sauce you like you can use these tips to further pinpoint new favorites.

Look for a Thicker Sauce for Dipping

A thicker sauce will typically work better for those who prefer to dip things into their steak sauce, rather than adding the sauce on top of the dish. The additional viscosity will help the sauce stick to whatever you're dipping in it better than a thinner sauce. Furthermore, the thicker sauce will be less likely to soak into things that you may not want to get soggy like fries. 

Look for a Chutney to Add Texture and Flavor to Your Steak

While not a traditional steak sauce, chutney is a sweet, tangy condiment that is often associated with Indian cuisine that has become a popular steak topping. It allows you to retain the tanginess that steak sauces tend to have while exploring different textures and flavors.

Check Out More Sauces for Your Kitchen

We've curated other lists of excellent sauces just for sauce lovers. There's something for everybody, whether you're cutting back on sodium or need some extra spice in your life.

Top 5 Steak Sauce

No. 1: A.1.A.1.Original Sauce

No. 2: Peter Luger Steak HousePeter Luger Steak HouseOld Fashioned Steak Sauce

No. 3: Primal KitchenPrimal KitchenOrganic Steak Sauce

No. 4: Le Sauce & Co.Classic Demi Glace Gourmet Finishing Sauce

No. 5: Golden West Specialty FoodsShemp's Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Steak Sauces

Low-Sodium Soy Sauce

10 Best

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.